Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 13716 ideas, 65290 comments, 1273844 votes

Idea #3859: Warn on shutdown when multiple users logged in



up
572
down
Written by kamil.paral the 8 Mar 08 at 11:24. Category: Accessibility.
Related to: Nothing/Others. Status: New
Description
Multiple users can be logged in by using the user switching. But when the second user forgets about the first one and tries to shut down the computer, no warning pops up and it kills all the sessions silently. That's really bad, because all the unsaved work of the first user is completely lost. It would be *so easy* just to pop up confirmation dialog saying, that other users are still logged in and the shutdown can lose their unsaved data. In the fast-user-switch-applet we can see users currently logged in, so this is really a matter of few lines of code to implement. It would often save a lot of cursing. Windows have this functionality.

Example: Alice is working with Ubuntu. Bob wants to read his email quickly. Alice fast-switches to Bob account. Bob reads his email, forgets about Alice's running session and shuts down the computer. All Alice's unsaved work is lost. This wouldn't happen with the confirmation dialog.
Tags: (none)


Developer comments
++ for me for being useful, and easy to implement: we just have to look at the current ConsoleKit sessions to get a list of which other users are logged in where. As an added bonus we can look at "who" to see currently established network conditions.

UI-wise this should just be added to the shutdown/reboot dialog. I would like to avoid introducing a separate "Are you sure?" confirmation dialog before getting to the actual shutdown/reboot one.


Attachments
bug Bug #82530 : Wish: Show warning dialog when shutting down PC and another user logged in


Duplicates


Comments
Melchior wrote on the 8 Mar 08 at 12:40
For general information, this is a problem with Gnome rather than Ubuntu itself - Kubuntu does not have this problem. :)

Auzy wrote on the 9 Mar 08 at 01:33
Good idea.. +1


juno eclipse wrote on the 9 Mar 08 at 10:29
Yes, good idea, +10
But it's a gnome/gdm issue I think...

Jadd wrote on the 26 Jun 08 at 11:44
Ubuntu by default ships with GNOME, so a problem with GNOME is a problem for Ubuntu, and an idea improving GNOME is welcome on Ubuntu Brainstorm, Melchior.


Post your comment