Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 16602 ideas, 102352 comments, 2137701 votes
Idea sandbox Idea sandbox
Popular ideas Popular ideas
Ideas in development Ideas in development
Implemented ideas Implemented ideas
Idea #14800: Ubuntu switching advisor for windows

Written by manishmahabir the 25 Oct 08 at 12:53. Category: Hardware support. Related project: Nothing/Others. Status: New
Rationale
Today Ubuntu has reached a stage where it can successfully replace windows in home as well as office desktops.
Actually many people are now switching to ubuntu or are now ready to give it a try.

As known to linux community, many hardware vendors have kept their hardware closed source.As a result the open source community has been unable to provide adequate support for the hardware.

usually the hardware we buy has a logo 'certified for windows vista', and similarly for xp.people never know whether it is open or closed hardware or how well the hardware is supported under ubuntu.

i know that there are websites which contain a list of hardware supported under ubuntu.

it would be nice to have a tool for windows which could gather the data about the hardware connected to pc (similar to hardware testing in ubuntu). Based on the data it should generate a friendly report about the current status of support for the available hardware,specially graphics card or wireless card.It would help to prevent any post installation blues.

An additional feature which could suggest the linux counterparts of installed windows applications would be a killer addition.

It wll go a long way in solving bug no. 1 in launchpad!
Tags: (none)

143
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #14800
Written by manishmahabir the 25 Oct 08 at 12:53.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #14800 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!

Propose your solution

Attachments


Duplicates


Comments
granadajose wrote on the 25 Oct 08 at 16:23
I think that a great addition to this switching advisor would be an option to create drivers for Ubuntu based on the existing drivers for Windows.

dino wrote on the 25 Oct 08 at 22:16
and an automatic spam creator to spam the hardware manucatorues with mails saying their hardware does not work under linux :)

Tuxoid wrote on the 25 Oct 08 at 22:51
This would be great +1

While we're on the topic of hardware support, I would like to specify why hardware vendors most presumably do not support their hardware on Linux systems. Simply put, it is because they feel that the market is to small to support, and thusly believe, it is a waste of their money. In this, it would be wrong to place blame in either the Linux developing community, or in hardware vendors.

Hardware vendors operate on money based on the physical goods they sell. The profit allows for the creation of information, and drivers for their products. The drivers for their hardware are free of charge (but it could be presumed that the price of the windows driver is worked in).

In the case of free of charge drivers:

They make no return on the drivers. Therefore, as a business, they will require to cut the drivers down to the most profitable markets. In this case, this is Windows.

In the case of drivers that you pay for somehow:

They make return on the drivers. This is a set return on the drivers that you are receiving with the hardware, though. If you're receiving the Windows drivers (which you probably receiving), They will charge you for only that driver. Therefore, they still do not get any return on a Linux driver. Will they raise the price just to support a driver that they believe most will not use? They'd rather just have you pay for the one driver most will use.

HigH5 wrote on the 26 Oct 08 at 08:34
On other hand, that's what Live CDs are for: you can check compatibility with hardware in real environment. Although some specific tool like Windows Vista Rating tool wouldn't hurt.

thebigbluecan wrote on the 26 Oct 08 at 10:33
Kind of like the Vista Upgrade advisor Microsoft came out with.

+1

Dominik wrote on the 26 Oct 08 at 15:23
OK, you can use the live-CD as upgrade advisor like HigH5 said but an independent programme would be really nice.

Tuxoid wrote on the 26 Oct 08 at 21:30
The thing with a Live CD is that it is manual in terms of testing hardware. The user has to test everything in their system, including, all USB devices, all Bluetooth devices, advanced video card features, if needed. Whereas, with an automated testing program, the user can be assured that every piece of their hardware can be testing thoroughly, and, unlike a Live CD, the hardware can be tested quickly. If the program was capable of providing enough information, the user would not need a Live CD to test.

The matter of a testing utility, is a matter of speeding up the testing process.

manishmahabir wrote on the 28 Oct 08 at 07:32
Well said Tuxoid

boga wrote on the 10 Nov 08 at 23:16
Good idea. Checking installed software for possible open source replacements and Wine compatibility should be helpful as well.

obvio.capitao wrote on the 12 May 09 at 15:04
Microsoft has released the beta version of its Windows 7 Upgrade Advisor, a free utility that tells you if your PC is ready to run Windows 7. It scans your computer, checking internal components, external peripherals, and programs, and alerts you to potential compatibility issues. It also offers upgrade suggestions, such as which drivers to replace, should you make the move to Windows 7.

It's a good idea to run Upgrade Advisor, which takes only a few minutes, if you plan to install Windows 7 Release Candidate, which is also available as a free download.

After downloading and installing Upgrade Advisor, you'll see an opening screen that advises you to connect all of your external devices, such as hard drives, cameras, MP3 players, and so on.

This would be a great step toward the replacement of Windows.

More information about Windows 7 Upgrade Advisor:

http://www.microsoft.com/downloads/details.aspx?displaylang=en&FamilyID=1b544e9 0-7659-4bd9-9e51-2497c146af15

deLi wrote on the 4 Oct 09 at 13:33

|sohbet|
|muhabbet|
sohbet odalari|
kizlarla sohbet|
chat|yonja|sohpet|
chat siteleri|
chat sohbet|
forum siteleri|sohbet|yonja|sohbet|
kizlarla sohbet|dini sohbet|sohbet|sohbet|sohbet|
sohbet sitesi|islami sohbet|
chat odalari|netlog|
islam sohbet|yonja
sohbet chat|Sohbet|sohbet|sohbet|
canlı sohbet|
kameralı sohbet|
sohbet odaları|chat|chatsohbete|sohbet|
chat siteleri|
chat siteleri|netlog|
sohbet odaları
dini sohbet
kızlarla sohbet

digi wrote on the 28 Oct 09 at 11:45
selam hi This sounds fascinating çet sohbet I’m going to read that tracing articlesevda when I have a moment. chat odaları Wow. liseliler sohbet is sıcak sohbet - netlog sohbet sohbet - chat de islami sohbet yy- liseli fer- netlog ger- kızlarla sohbet err dd sohbet gt
liseli sohbet er islami çet ff güzel kızlar
hh çet - bedava chat dd bedava sohbet dd aşk şiirleri cet yap der hikayeler hhkızlarla chat ss
sohbet ~ chat ~ chat siteleri - liseli kız resimleri - kızlar - liseli kızlar - korku filmi izle - dogum günü sözleri GB


Post your comment