Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 21545 ideas, 132412 comments, 2606687 votes
Idea sandbox Idea sandbox
Popular ideas Popular ideas
Ideas in development Ideas in development
Implemented ideas Implemented ideas
Idea #14514: Default copy/paste should be more like a clipboard manager

bug This idea was marked as implemented the 27 June 09.
Written by Endolith the 17 Oct 08 at 23:21. Related project: Gnome. Status: Implemented
Rationale
Some ideas for improvements to the default clipboard functionality:

1. When you right-click, instead of just saying "Paste", it should tell you explicitly what is on the clipboard. "Paste 'Here is some text in a ...'"

For non-text content, it might say something like "Paste image from Ubuntu Brainstorm - Mozil..."

2. There should be more than one Paste command, showing the last few things you copied, like a clipboard manager:

Cut
Copy
Paste "Submit the idea you wan..."
Paste "The Ubuntu community ha..."
Paste history                         >

Two or three is probably fine for most people. The top option will be the last thing you copied, so it will still behave like a typical cut and paste. The last "Paste history..." or something similar ("Clipboard history"?) would then pop-out a sub-menu with a much longer list. See the mock-up here.

3. It should be persistent even through reboots.

This way you don't have to worry about data loss through accidentally overwriting the clipboard or otherwise clearing it before you had a chance to paste something that was cut.

I've realized that when I'm doing a lot of things at once, my awareness of what's in the clipboard at any given moment makes me slightly persistently anxious, since I have to mentally keep track of whether I left something in this invisible area of the computer, remember what I put in it, and remember to paste things before overwriting them. :) This should be something that is handled by the computer, not by our brains. It should be impossible to lose data, and the data that's currently in the clipboard should be clearly visible, not left up to our own memory.


Developer comments
glipper already does this on gnome (but is not installed by default).

klipper already does this on KDE, and is installed by default.

43
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#1): Auto-generated solution of idea #14514
Written by Endolith the 17 Oct 08 at 23:21.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #14514 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!

Attachments
No attachments.


Duplicates


Comments
glotz wrote on the 17 Oct 08 at 23:32
I like point 1

cheesehead (Brainstorm admin) wrote on the 18 Oct 08 at 02:30
I can see this functionality as an add-on.
But the default cut/copy/paste should remain simple. Why should all users be forced to wade through all the extra options if they don't want them?

nicoladimaria wrote on the 18 Oct 08 at 06:17
it's ok for glipper advanced features, but why the clipboard should forget data if the application gets closed ?

MKdx wrote on the 18 Oct 08 at 21:11
Another option is Parcellite, which is currently active. It's available in both getdeb and Intrepid.

Endolith wrote on the 20 Oct 08 at 03:35
glipper does nothing but crash, and I don't see a context menu like this in Klipper

Endolith wrote on the 20 Oct 08 at 03:36
"Why should all users be forced to wade through all the extra options if they don't want them?"

What extra options?

Endolith wrote on the 17 Nov 08 at 21:18
Parcellite's nice, but doesn't have the features I'm talking about, like the extra Paste options.

Craig73 wrote on the 6 Dec 08 at 00:53
I agree the bare minimum should be not loosing cut-and-paste data because you choose to close an application.

The annoying thing with glipper (haven't tried Parcellite) is
a) it installed additional packages totalling 10MB (seems like a lot for what it does / perhaps rolling this into gnome core would shrink it)

b) it's not even in add/remove so basic users (who wouldn't know to look for it but would be annoyed without it) aren't going to find it.

travislow wrote on the 27 Jul 10 at 03:39
See #3118 -- http://brainstorm.ubuntu.com/user/reset/42064/1280201584/6c628674dcb9e966d6b39b 853fda8b90

Copy/paste still is a problem for me. System is patched to the latest of the latest.

I did install glipper and klipper as workarounds but they didn't appear in my menus. I'm trying to avoid customizing, especially to fix a fundamental problem like this, but I guess I have no choice.

This would really confound a new Ubuntu user who wasn't comfortable on the command line, so it should be fixed.


Post your comment