Contributor Ssdg on Unity
There should be a clear distinction between applications and settings.
Written by david4dev the 1 May 11 at 19:53.
Not an idea
Currently, there isn't really a way to tell the difference between an application program and a configuration program when launching from the dash.
The configuration programs are jumbled together with the application programs in the applications lens. This is inconvenient when trying to launch applications and confusing when trying to change settings.
Most users won't really think of settings as being applications so it makes no sense for them to be in the applications lens.
There is no easy-to-use Force Quit application in Ubuntu.
Written by Jebeld17 the 3 Nov 11 at 21:55.
New
There is no easy-to-use Force Quit application in Ubuntu. The closest thing we have now in the latest release, 11.10, is the "Processes" section in the System Monitor. Finding the application that you want to force quit can be frustrating at times using this method, as you have to search for the System Monitor app by default in the first place and the program you are trying to close may very well have a code name that no new user can figure out easily. Also, there is no keyboard shortcut to quickly access the System Monitor, anyways.
Solution #1:
Create a Force Quit app similar to the one you will find on Mac OS X
Written by
Jebeld17 the 3 Nov 11 at 21:55.
Create a Force Quit app similar to the one you will find on Mac OS X. Apple is well known for easy product usability, and the Force Quit app on Mac OS X is simple, easy to use, and doesn't take time to learn, unlike Ubuntu's System Monitor app. Implement all the features Apple has in their Force Quit app including the Command+Option+Esc shortcut, and do not forget the ever-so-popular Ctrl+Alt+Del keyboard shortcut for every other keyboard on the planet! Limit the applications list in the new Force Quit app to only noticeable programs, and NOT programs running in the background, like Gnome-shell, etc.. Please add a checkbox at the bottom of the window for more tech-savvy users to view applications running in the background, and options to force quit them, too.
And I do say that the automated detection service works very well, but sometimes it doesn't. We need a simple tool to do the job manually, just in case. Windows has similar automated detecting, but they have the Ctrl+Alt+Del tool for just in case.
This will make the transition to Ubuntu from Mac OS X or Windows easier, less time consuming, and less frustrating for Ubuntu's target audience.
Also, I am suggesting to be put on top of this is a fast, easy-to-use, simple bug-reporting system similar to the one in Windows XP used after forcing an application to close AND having a Force Quit shortcut in the Power/Settings menu on the top right-hand corner of the screen.
Create a Force Quit app similar to the one you will find on Mac OS X. Apple is well known for easy product usability, and the Force Quit app on Mac OS X is simple, easy to use, and doesn't take time to learn, unlike Ubuntu's System Monitor app. Implement all the features Apple has in their Force Quit app including the Command+Option+Esc shortcut, and do not forget the ever-so-popular Ctrl+Alt+Del keyboard shortcut for every other keyboard on the planet! Limit the applications list in the new Force Quit app to only noticeable programs, and NOT programs running in the background, like Gnome-shell, etc.. Please add a checkbox at the bottom of the window for more tech-savvy users to view applications running in the background, and options to force quit them, too.
And I do say that the automated detection service works very well, but sometimes it doesn't. We need a simple tool to do the job manually, just in case. Windows has similar automated detecting, but they have the Ctrl+Alt+Del tool for just in case.
This will make the transition to Ubuntu from Mac OS X or Windows easier, less time consuming, and less frustrating for Ubuntu's target audience.
Also, I am suggesting to be put on top of this is a fast, easy-to-use, simple bug-reporting system similar to the one in Windows XP used after forcing an application to close AND having a Force Quit shortcut in the Power/Settings menu on the top right-hand corner of the screen.
Solution #2:
By default, set popular keybindings to xkill
Written by
Jebeld17 the 5 Nov 11 at 12:23.
As people have said in comments, there is a tool a little like what I wanted in the Solution #1, called "xkill" and I have decided to try to "meet in the middle."
I am proposing that the popular Ctrl+Alt+Del and Command+Opt+Esc keybindings be tied to the xkill tool BY DEFAULT, and (if possible) have a small window pop up the first time using it to explain to newbies how to properly use xkill.
This plan is simple, effective, and already works. All I want is to have the popular keybindings attached to xkill BY DEFAULT, like said. This will make transitioning to Ubuntu from other operating systems simpler and easier for Ubuntu's target audience.
As people have said in comments, there is a tool a little like what I wanted in the Solution #1, called "xkill" and I have decided to try to "meet in the middle."
I am proposing that the popular Ctrl+Alt+Del and Command+Opt+Esc keybindings be tied to the xkill tool BY DEFAULT, and (if possible) have a small window pop up the first time using it to explain to newbies how to properly use xkill.
This plan is simple, effective, and already works. All I want is to have the popular keybindings attached to xkill BY DEFAULT, like said. This will make transitioning to Ubuntu from other operating systems simpler and easier for Ubuntu's target audience.
Solution #4:
Combine Solution #1 with current Ctrl+Alt+Del keybindings
Written by
Jebeld17 the 17 Nov 11 at 02:31.
Currently, Ctrl+Alt+Del is a default command to show the log out prompt. I am suggesting for Solution #4 that the current log out prompt and the proposal in Solution #1 be combined to create a whole new prompt when Ctrl+Alt+Del is pressed, very much like in Windows 7, where the user is given the option to either Log Out, Shut Down, Switch Users, or go to the Task Manager. From there, the Force Quit app will behave exactly the same as suggested in Solution #1.
Currently, Ctrl+Alt+Del is a default command to show the log out prompt. I am suggesting for Solution #4 that the current log out prompt and the proposal in Solution #1 be combined to create a whole new prompt when Ctrl+Alt+Del is pressed, very much like in Windows 7, where the user is given the option to either Log Out, Shut Down, Switch Users, or go to the Task Manager. From there, the Force Quit app will behave exactly the same as suggested in Solution #1.
Quicker access to 'show desktop'
Written by smerz the 30 May 12 at 19:23.
New
Right now (12.04) to show the desktop using Unity I need to press CTRL + SUPER + D
Or I ALT + TAB till I am at the beginning on the "show desktop" tab.
Or I click on the workspace switcher to switch to another workspace to see the desktop.
I would like to have easier and quicker access to this feature.
Open multiple windows in unity
Written by SpyMasterMatt the 4 Apr 11 at 02:22.
Already implemented
Using unity in 11.04 beta 1, the user cannot open multiple windows using the unity launcher (A new window can be opened using the ubuntu button in the top left corner). If the user clicks an icon the application opens. Clicking the icon a second time switches to the application.
-13
votes
8
9
21
Solution #1:
Double clicking opens a new instance
Double click to open a new application window, single click to switch to the application.
Double click to open a new application window, single click to switch to the application.
40
votes
45
6
5
Solution #2:
Shift + click opens new instance
Although a quick way to opening a new window of the same application is helpful, there isn't many things it is needed for. Nevertheless, I still think a double click is too simple for users to bring up new instances, as it is very easy to make a mistake double-clicking by accident, which can be confusing when something else pops up. If we want Unity to be solid, these actions have to be intended, which is why I propose a Shift + click. It's much much less likely a new user can make a mistake this way.
Although a quick way to opening a new window of the same application is helpful, there isn't many things it is needed for. Nevertheless, I still think a double click is too simple for users to bring up new instances, as it is very easy to make a mistake double-clicking by accident, which can be confusing when something else pops up. If we want Unity to be solid, these actions have to be intended, which is why I propose a Shift + click. It's much much less likely a new user can make a mistake this way.
-7
votes
8
10
15
Solution #3:
Agree with shift-click, AND make middle-click CLOSE not open new instance
Written by
Zorgoth the 4 Apr 11 at 16:09.
Middle-click being used to open a new instance is inconsistent with firefox, cairo-dock, and many other tabbed systems and taskbars. Middle-click traditionally QUITS programs. Shift-click is more common as an opener of new instances, so agree with Sol-n #2 and further propose that middle-click close windows.
Middle-click being used to open a new instance is inconsistent with firefox, cairo-dock, and many other tabbed systems and taskbars. Middle-click traditionally QUITS programs. Shift-click is more common as an opener of new instances, so agree with Sol-n #2 and further propose that middle-click close windows.
-6
votes
3
11
9
Solution #4:
Shift-super-1, ..., shift-super-0
Written by
Zorgoth the 5 Apr 11 at 16:11.
In addition to solution #2, shift-super-1, shift-super2, ..., shift-super-0 should open new instances of a launcher. Currently super-1, ..., super-0 can open only one instance of any launcher on the dock, and there is not keyboard shortcut to open multiple instances.
In addition to solution #2, shift-super-1, shift-super2, ..., shift-super-0 should open new instances of a launcher. Currently super-1, ..., super-0 can open only one instance of any launcher on the dock, and there is not keyboard shortcut to open multiple instances.
5
votes
5
2
0
Solution #5:
Launch New Window on the context menu
Written by
daltux the 26 Apr 11 at 00:12.
In addition to solution #2, a context menu (right click on the icon) item to open a new window is an easy, consistent and user friendly option.
In addition to solution #2, a context menu (right click on the icon) item to open a new window is an easy, consistent and user friendly option.
Fast windows switcher
Written by bigo86 the 28 Dec 11 at 09:42.
Not an idea
I saw that there was already a lot of discussion about a better way of switching windows belonging to the same application, but I think that the implemented solution in 11.10 falls short to the task. It is nice to have a quick preview of the opened windows, but sometimes it's not really handy, in particular if you are working with a pc that is not exactly new. Another situation when it is not recommendable to use the preview function is when you have a lot of windows open. For example, I use MatLab at work and I can have more than 20 windows open with a lot of figures. Looking at previews of the windows is not handy because I can't see what is in there.
9
votes
16
4
7
Solution #1:
Right-click switcher
Written by
bigo86 the 28 Dec 11 at 09:42.
When I right click on the evolution application in the dock bar, I can see a lot of options listed, in order to quickly open the Contacts or the Calendar. The same thing could be applied for the windows switcher and, for example, if I have multiple Firefox windows opened, they would be all listed there.
When I right click on the evolution application in the dock bar, I can see a lot of options listed, in order to quickly open the Contacts or the Calendar. The same thing could be applied for the windows switcher and, for example, if I have multiple Firefox windows opened, they would be all listed there.
39
votes
39
2
0
Solution #2:
Slide-out "squares" when a program has more than 1 window open (read below)
Written by
turbolad the 29 Dec 11 at 12:36.
When the same program has more than 1 window open, why not display these horizontally in the Unity "squares" - when clicked on - so each window can be opened instantly with one click?
Here's how: when the user left-clicks on the program's "square" in Unity, a number of squares could slide-out to the right, which show the number of windows open in that program. When the mouse pointer is on each square, a preview of its window shows instantly.
This would mean that if you wanted to open lots of windows belonging to that program quickly, you can click on the squares and the windows would appear instantly.
When it's no longer needed, these squares slide back to the left and disappear until next time. A few seconds' delay is obviously needed before sliding these squares out of view.
When the same program has more than 1 window open, why not display these horizontally in the Unity "squares" - when clicked on - so each window can be opened instantly with one click?
Here's how: when the user left-clicks on the program's "square" in Unity, a number of squares could slide-out to the right, which show the number of windows open in that program. When the mouse pointer is on each square, a preview of its window shows instantly.
This would mean that if you wanted to open lots of windows belonging to that program quickly, you can click on the squares and the windows would appear instantly.
When it's no longer needed, these squares slide back to the left and disappear until next time. A few seconds' delay is obviously needed before sliding these squares out of view.
-13
votes
2
9
15
Solution #3:
Quicker Window Switching
Written by
CJC100 the 31 Dec 11 at 03:13.
Have an icon on the window that you click, and it zooms out to a ring of pages you rotate by hovering the mouse over an arrow to the left or right of it, and click the page you want.
Have an icon on the window that you click, and it zooms out to a ring of pages you rotate by hovering the mouse over an arrow to the left or right of it, and click the page you want.
-9
votes
4
5
13
Solution #4:
Show the opened file name list from the dock in unity
Just show the opened file name list when I point the mouse on the button on the dock. For example, when the mouse points on xpdf icon on the dock, the file list shows on its side.
Just show the opened file name list when I point the mouse on the button on the dock. For example, when the mouse points on xpdf icon on the dock, the file list shows on its side.
1
votes
4
2
3
Solution #5:
Use the "windows key + " ;-)
Written by
uaneme the 20 Jan 12 at 02:02.
Make that usless and ugly "windows" key do something for its overpriced money. (= the arrow keys)
Make that usless and ugly "windows" key do something for its overpriced money. (= the arrow keys)
Excessive Titling of Active Application
Written by Daniel Brainard the 30 Nov 11 at 19:54.
New
At a given time when, when my active application is not maximized, I am told in essentially three different places, what application I have open (icon in launcher is highlighted, name open application is on the top bar, and name of application and name of file is displayed on the applications window titlebar). I find this completely excessive because 1) You know what application you are currently using and 2) it is simply a waste of space that could otherwise be potentially given to something else.
Titlebars are very inefficient with their use of space for their only actual purpose, window management.
Solution #1:
Get Rid of Window Titlebars
I would replace the window titlebar with the respective application icon (for unmaximized applications). The icon would be placed on the top left hand corner of the application and be partially underneath the window so the icon would not interfere with the usability of application. The purpose of the icon would simply to be able to single click and hold to move the window around. Window control buttons would be placed in the top bar, and utilize the same functionality as a maximized application would. I would also suggest then, not having the window control buttons in the top bar be automatically hidden by the title of the application. These controls should always be shown simply for usability. The file name could then be placed in the top bar without the application name and could then be toggled with the global menu.
The only issue I see arising with this for usability purposes when you have two windows side by side that take up the whole screen. My solution would then be to have them both act and being maximized at the same time. The top bar would then be split having the left half of the top bar be given the the application on the left and the right half to the application on the right. With respect to the global menu on the right hand side, the indicators are still always shown on the right, but when the mouse is moved to the top to use the global menu, these indicators could be temporarily hidden to give more room to the global menu on the right.
I would replace the window titlebar with the respective application icon (for unmaximized applications). The icon would be placed on the top left hand corner of the application and be partially underneath the window so the icon would not interfere with the usability of application. The purpose of the icon would simply to be able to single click and hold to move the window around. Window control buttons would be placed in the top bar, and utilize the same functionality as a maximized application would. I would also suggest then, not having the window control buttons in the top bar be automatically hidden by the title of the application. These controls should always be shown simply for usability. The file name could then be placed in the top bar without the application name and could then be toggled with the global menu.
The only issue I see arising with this for usability purposes when you have two windows side by side that take up the whole screen. My solution would then be to have them both act and being maximized at the same time. The top bar would then be split having the left half of the top bar be given the the application on the left and the right half to the application on the right. With respect to the global menu on the right hand side, the indicators are still always shown on the right, but when the mouse is moved to the top to use the global menu, these indicators could be temporarily hidden to give more room to the global menu on the right.
Solution #2:
Show the application menu instead of the title
At present, the menu is hidden until the mouse hovers over the top panel, where the title is displayed (11.04 -- I don't know if 11.10 is different).
As Daniel says, there are two other places that show which application is focused. So, why not just show the menu instead of hiding it? It is quicker to go straight to the menu option you want when you can see it already, than having to move the mouse to the top of the screen before deciding where to put it.
At present, the menu is hidden until the mouse hovers over the top panel, where the title is displayed (11.04 -- I don't know if 11.10 is different).
As Daniel says, there are two other places that show which application is focused. So, why not just show the menu instead of hiding it? It is quicker to go straight to the menu option you want when you can see it already, than having to move the mouse to the top of the screen before deciding where to put it.
Solution #3:
Option to Hide
Written by
joy23 the 9 Dec 11 at 21:07.
AFAIK meddling with titlebars and removing them completely wont be a good idea.
Instead
We could use an option that could autohide itself or show always.
So that we could get that extra space in full screen.
Many people actually like to be inundated with info and many dont so this will appease them all.
AFAIK meddling with titlebars and removing them completely wont be a good idea.
Instead
We could use an option that could autohide itself or show always.
So that we could get that extra space in full screen.
Many people actually like to be inundated with info and many dont so this will appease them all.
Solution #4:
Show the title bar or menus only when the mouse pointer is very near that area
Written by
turbolad the 23 Dec 11 at 10:59.
The title bar is probably used more often for moving the program's window than actually reading the title! Almost everyone is used to moving a program around by using the title bar.
You could choose to only show the title bar or menus in that program's window when the mouse pointer is very near, and hide either away when the mouse pointer is moved away. This means that Unity continues to save that extra line of screen space, which it currently does by putting the menus at the top of the screen.
By keeping the menus and title bars in their familiar places, it saves a *lot* of confusion, especially for newcomers to Ubuntu. Don't break the familiarity of the GUI which users are comfortable with.
The title bar is probably used more often for moving the program's window than actually reading the title! Almost everyone is used to moving a program around by using the title bar.
You could choose to only show the title bar or menus in that program's window when the mouse pointer is very near, and hide either away when the mouse pointer is moved away. This means that Unity continues to save that extra line of screen space, which it currently does by putting the menus at the top of the screen.
By keeping the menus and title bars in their familiar places, it saves a *lot* of confusion, especially for newcomers to Ubuntu. Don't break the familiarity of the GUI which users are comfortable with.
Solution #5:
Combine menu bar into title bar
Written by
nicojpm the 18 Dec 11 at 22:11.
Something similar to this:
«Oxygen Appmenu is an Oxygen style for Kwin that displays the application menu as a button in the titlebar and works with Qt and GTK applications as well as Firefox or Thunderbird»
http://www.webupd8.org/2011/11/oxygen-appmenu-replace-menu-with.html
Solution #6:
Delete or hide the titlebar only when maximized
Written by
nicojpm the 19 Dec 11 at 21:34.
In maximized windows, you don't need the titlebar for move the window. The buttons «close, minimize, restore...» could appear integrated into the menu bar.
Similar to this screen:
http://www.ghacks.net/wp-content/uploads/2008/11/firefox_step_7-500x338.jpg
Ability to pause GUI application execution (job control from bash)
Written by Int_ua the 18 Apr 11 at 18:18.
Already implemented
I often use Ctrl+Z in bash when I need more CPU resources back for some time. Wouldn't it be useful if we could pause GUI applications and then unpause them?
It can theoretically lead to situations where applications will crash, but I have never seen such behaviour in CLI.
specify order of search results in dash
Written by ja4 the 6 Jun 12 at 20:59.
New
The Unity dash search is a great time-saver. For example, I use it to quickly bring up the calculator by typing "calc". However, LibreOfficeCalc is the 1st result returned and I must hit the down, down, right arrow keys and enter to start calculator.
It would be nice to specify the order of search results. (I now realize I can just type "cal" enter and calculator will appear before LibreOfficeCalc, but the idea may still be useful.)