Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
Ubuntu Software Center
Idea sandbox Idea sandbox
Popular ideas Popular ideas
Ideas in development Ideas in development
Implemented ideas Implemented ideas

Contributor barrientosa on Ubuntu Software Center

More reliable and thorough information for users, and not diluting Free Software  
Written by rysiek the 9 Jun 12 at 12:12. New
Putting Skype, Opera and Ekiga, Firefox in a single basket of the "Free" category is detrimental both for users and the Free and Open Source Software movement as a whole.

It's detrimental for users, as they do not receive a thorough and full information on what they can and cannot do with the software. I.e. any user can copy Ekiga to an USB stick and give it to their friend; this is however explicitly forbidden in SKype's Terms of Service.

It is detrimental to the whole FLOSS movement because it dilutes the term "Free Software". Skype is NOT Free Software; Opera is NOT Free Software. Ubuntu is doing a great deal of damage to the community and to the whole ecosystem by not differentiating between "libre" and "gratis" - and frankly, should know better than this.
-14
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Split the category to "libre" and "gratis" (or similar)
Written by rysiek the 9 Jun 12 at 12:12.
The solution is easy enough - just split this category into two different categories:

- "libre"/"free software" - holding software that is, in fact, Free Software (i.e. meets DFSG: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DFSG );

- "gratis"/"free-of-charge" - holding software that is free of charge.

Or, even better, make those non-exclusive, so that Skype would only have the "gratis" markings, and Ekiga would have both "libre" and "gratis".
63
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Label Open Source software
Written by Chelloveck314 the 12 Jun 12 at 08:49.
Keep all "free" software in the same categorey, but clearly label software that is Open Source.

See the 14 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 17 Aug 12 at 16:21) >>