Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
Live CD
Idea sandbox Idea sandbox
Popular ideas Popular ideas
Ideas in development Ideas in development
Implemented ideas Implemented ideas

Popular ideas Here are the last 6 months most popular ideas about Live CD.

Make 64-bit CDs available in the Canonical shop  
Written by ekevu the 11 May 12 at 16:56. New
Nowadays people usually prefer a 64-bit system. It's as stable as Ubuntu 32-bit.
However, Canonical only sells the 32-bit variant in the Canonical shop.

I'd like to buy an original Ubuntu CD in 64-bit.
39
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Sell the CD in the Canonical shop
Written by ekevu the 11 May 12 at 16:56.
Sell 64-bit CDs of Ubuntu in Canonical shop.

See the 2 comments or propose a solution >>

A bootloader that loads all .iso files into RAM  
Written by MateoS the 16 Apr 12 at 13:48. New
Iso can be mounted within Ubuntu no problem, and iso emulation works perfectly for a virtual machine, The idea is to pass on iso emulation from the boot strap into the linux kernel, Currently a limited number of iso can be "booted" just because of how the disk is set up, and this takes major customization to set loop-back settings, http://ansi.23-5.eu/2011/10/21/howto-boot-iso-images-via-grub2-with-ubuntu/ . Currently once you emulate the disk, then load the kernel it looses the emulated drive, because the boot-strap simply passes on boot information. The idea is to make iso's as universally accessible, and easy as putting in a CD, to save physical media, and use for small form factor devices that don't use cd's.

Currently there are many types of bootable .iso's *most* linux ones work with the existing tools with careful configuration. but If a system of emulation was set up all iso's work independent of what is on it with no configuration. This would enable any set of tools to be bootable.


Also, a lot of Cd disks are built to specifically to look for a cd drive, so once you boot the cd, it fails to find the contents of the iso, and setting up a memdisk will not work because once the kernel is booted the emulation does not get passed on, http://www.syslinux.org/wiki/index.php/MEMDISK#What_is_MEMDISK.3F , "The majority of Linux based CD images will also fail to work with MEMDISK ISO emulation. Linux distributions require kernel and initrd files to be specified, as soon as these files are loaded the protected mode kernel driver(s) take control and the virtual CD will no longer be accessible. If any other files are required from the CD/DVD they will be missing, resulting in boot error(s)."


And many new users look to unetbootin as if it makes iso's universally bootable, when it has pre-made settings made to work with specific distributions, and I have seen many problems arise from users trying to make windows or other cd's to boot with it.


[....]
-2
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Implment a way for kernel to recieve Cd drive emulation from boot-strap
Written by MateoS the 16 Apr 12 at 13:48.
The boot loader (grub) allread has options to mount iso files, but once a linux kernel is loaded that mount is not passed on to the kernel. If the boot loader could set up emulation, and then pass that emulation to the kernel, Iso's could be used directly with little customization
-2
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Make a Bios Emulation that passes on iso's like cd like bootcamp on mac
Written by MateoS the 26 Apr 12 at 23:18.
Make a nearly transparent "virtural" bios that passes on all other information, but reserves space for iso emulation, can be activated in the circumstance you want to tell grub to boot an iso, configuration would only require defining where the iso located.
-2
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Use thrid party hardware solution
Written by MateoS the 26 Apr 12 at 23:24.
Iso stick, or http://systembash.com/content/zalman-zm-ve200-review-you-need-this-external-har d-drive-enclosure/ , This is a existing hardware solution that does exactly what I want, Boots iso's exactly like a cd drive.
-1
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: automatic findiso on CD's so entrys preserve menus.
Written by MateoS the 1 May 12 at 01:41.

See the 8 comments or propose a solution >>