Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
Live CD
Idea sandbox Idea sandbox
Popular ideas Popular ideas
Ideas in development Ideas in development
Implemented ideas Implemented ideas

Popular ideas Here are the latest commented ideas about Live CD.

Simplify management of ecryptfs protected directories  
Written by komputes the 26 Sep 09 at 13:06. New
Simplify management of ecryptfs protected directories to be able to:

-Easily mount an encrypted directory in recovery mode
-Easily transport an encrypted directory easily (like saving/mounting the encrypted dir to a single image file)
-Have the ability to tell nautilus to mount the encrypted directory with "archive mounter" and creatively find a simple way to decrypt it.
-Have the ability to graphically manage keys and passphrases
8
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Developers, developers, developers.
Written by komputes the 26 Sep 09 at 13:06.
No but in all seriousness, we need to throw code monkeys at the problem. Eep!

From what is listed the following will be needed:
-Script to mount home dir from recovery mode
-Modification of ecryptfs to be able to save to iso
-nautilus extension that manages ecryptfs image auth
-key and passphrase manager for ecryptfs (seahorse integration would be a big plus)

The portability and accessibility of ecryptfs encrypted data is very important and needs to be simplified.

Add a comment or propose a solution >>

Bare Metal Default Desktop ( C/GTK+ ) [ before the 12.04 LTS ]  
Written by yaknowwat the 8 Jul 09 at 04:47. New
Sorry I can't get an a better title than that, but I'll explain what I'm talking about.

The Desktop's performance is a huge figure in the feel. We all know this.
Now the issue we have here is that Ubuntu's default desktop is just far to separated in its code base. The default code base of Ubuntu should be unified it should as be fast. As of now what we have is horribly inefficient and on a path to get worse from what I've seen with project surrounding. If you want to see for yourself just use a bare Xfce 4.6 desktop no Ubuntu/Python/Mono tools and compare it against Ubuntu/GNOME's performance.

Now there are some heavy advantages we can get with code unification. One is that code can easily be shared between API's, without heavy use of "gluing" things together like what we do with Python and such. Sharing code is what open source is about and we should not be making this harder.

We also want speed. GTK+ made a bold and strong choice by building around C. C is blazingly fast, and C is also the most portable language. Sadly C's design is so general and low level that programmers only want it for drivers, because drivers designed in C are normally the best. Thankfully the GTK+ crowd took another strong step and designed the GObject library, an object like C library for GTK, from which we have easier languages. Like Vala, a C# syntax language, and Genie, a Python syntax language, which are built on C/GTK+ because they in fact mid compile become clean C/GObject/GTK+ code, with comments placed correct might I add, meaning no glue is needed.

So for what we have available this task isn't as hard as one might think. Though just because it's easier now than its been before we shouldn't wait around and we should begin immediately. Beginning with the heavy weights Python/Mono, C++ on the other hand I know isn't something to mess with, example getting Webkit ported from C++ to C is an insane idea on another note we can always have an alternative basic C built html viewer made if a system cant have C++.


Quick note summary :
Advantages to the default install:
More portability. ( Some know the pluses in this. )

[....]
33
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Porting the default desktop to C/GTK+ ( C++ code can stay )
Written by yaknowwat the 8 Jul 09 at 04:47.

Vala and Genie reduce a huge part of the burden in such a port.
Python may already need effort because of v 3.0 why not go full C/GTK+ with Genie.
Theres enough time to accomplish this too.
-Easy ideal process.
-> By mid 2010 have scripts and notes how to convert Mono/GTK# apps to Vala and PyGTK apps to Genie apps.
-> Piece by piece move each application in the default desktop to this native C/GTK+ architecture.

Porting like this will also give Vala/Genie probably the best documentation any language could ever have to programmers. Which is huge in an overall advancement to GTK/Xfce/GNOME/OpenSource as a whole.
10
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Profile all default apps and either rewrite or replace slow ones.
Written by staticsan the 15 Jul 09 at 00:48.
Older versions of GNOME run much faster because they were designed for older, slower hardware. Perhaps the solution is to re-target minimum hardware requirements to a (much) lower standard and revisit all the current apps' inclusion in the default desktop.

This will also encourage programmers of libraries and interpreted languages to fix slow, bloated code.

See the 3 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 23 Oct 09 at 06:23) >>

Ubuntu Netbook Remix needs to be Easier  
Written by hboyhh the 9 Oct 09 at 05:30. New
Ubuntu Netbook Remix (UNR) came along with some netbooks, but most of these netbook users have not ever used a linux based OS. Some terminology such as Add/Remove... and The Terminal, sudo: , packages, repositories, etc.. made really hard for them to use URN. In consequence URN has lost a very important opportunity to enter establish himself as a more popular OS. When UNR fisrt came out, it was came pre-installed in almost 13% of the netbooks, now a days this number has reduced to near 5%.

(When I talk about "the netbook users", i mean the people who bought a netbook with UNR, but were not really familiar with it)

Ubuntu offers us a very secure, highly configurable environment, but when we move to the netbooks the situation this is really different. The netbook users want a OS which is fast, stable and easy to use. The terminal; for example; for most of us is really helpful as it let as do all kind of tasks. But if someone who has never used this OS try to use it, he will don't know how to use(at least not completely well). This is the first issue, in order to the UNR to be widely accepted, int needs to be much easier to use. Some users has already posted similar ideas, as the use of universal package format. Another important problem is that the netbook users does not know the Ubuntu strengths, as the security against intruders or viruses, in which we are far superior to Windows.
With UNR 9.04 much of the netbook users did not figured out how to use it correctly and most of them were seemed forced to return their netbook or change it for another one with Windows. That is why we need to make UNR much easier.
0
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: UNR explanation, simplification and promotion
Written by hboyhh the 9 Oct 09 at 05:30.
1. WindowsXP has a tutorial for the first time users. We can implement such thing to explain to the users who has never used Ubuntu the basics of its working.

2. Commonly there are some instructions or message boxes that show information that involve the knowing of some advance use of Ubuntu for understanding. We can edit those texts in order to make it easier for the new users to understand.

3. Some features and programs can be removed, because are not really popular between netbook users(this idea has already been posted).

4. Some programs can be included in UNR in a Lite edition, so the performance can be improved.

5. The use of the Terminal can be minimized in UNR and can be replaced with some GUI applications that works as a background process.

6. Improve the compatibility with some external devices such as Apple products, printers and cameras.

7. A video-bank must be available(on the web) so that new users can not only read; but also watch(which is always more didactic); how to use Ubuntu.

8. Ubuntu must show off its capabilities, as is it security, stability and the options to customize it, which are some factors that users are looking for.

See the 1 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 9 Oct 09 at 06:52) >>

System beep is deeply irritating on most systems.  
Written by r0g the 10 Feb 09 at 14:47. New
I have it physically disabled on my desktop but the beep on my g/f's work laptop would put most sonar's to shame! It doesn't have a bios option to disable it and I don't think her boss would appreciate me taking a screwdriver to it either so, every time tab won't complete a line or backspace doesn't have a character to delete we're subjected to a this stupid 100 dB sonic weapon.

Naturally this is even more of a problem at night or in the library.

Now I know it can be disabled by blacklisting and removing a kernel module which is what I now do BUT... I'm certain this damned beep annoys more people than it helps and as such I think something ought to be done about it...
4
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Disable the pcspkr module by default.
Written by r0g the 10 Feb 09 at 14:47.
“blacklist pcspkr”
2
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Modify default inputrc
Written by r0g the 10 Feb 09 at 14:48.
Add "set bell-style none" to the default /etc/inputrc file.
31
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Make the "sonar" beep more pleasant
Written by kidmodify the 14 Feb 09 at 01:09.
The beep is still useful to some people.
Just Change the evil sonar beep to something that sounds better by default.
And since open source is about freedom, also give people the freedom to shut it off if they so desire.
2
votes
up equal down
Solution #5: Create sound profiles
Written by gerrywastaken the 22 Jun 09 at 08:38.
====
This was first posted by Craig73 under http://brainstorm.ubuntu.com/idea/17235/ and had 11 upvotes and 0 down before the idea was closed for being a dupe. I also felt it had many good points so added it here verbatim...
====


System beeps and really any application generated sound should have more contextual control.

Examples
a) Headphones are plugged in, so why are PC Speaker sounds being generated? Re-direct beeps to the headphones.

b) Movie profile - tone down or turn off most other sounds other than those for the video player

c) Entertaining profile - tone down or turn off all sounds. Sounds like incoming VOIP calls or IMs (from certain people) could perhaps be rendered as a background sound (that in a surround sound setup sounds off in the corner / noticeable but no disruptive)

d) Silent - turn off all sounds except the most critical. Perhaps those "beeps" should be showing up as flashing notifications at this point.
-1
votes
up equal down
Solution #6: Convert beep to window tab pulsate, when possible
Written by phyzome the 14 Aug 09 at 03:54.
Instead of emitting a beep, set the "window wants focus" flag on the requesting window (if available.) If the window is already focused, flash it.
1
votes
up equal down
Solution #7: Remove pcspkr kernel module
Written by miohtama the 5 Oct 09 at 10:16.

See the 10 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 5 Oct 09 at 10:47) >>

Remove irrelevant programs in the Netbook Remix  
Written by Frank Roberts the 9 Sep 09 at 22:38. New
Because netbooks are machines that are made for a very specific task that is quite different from 'normal' desktop use, there are several programs installed that 95% or even 100% of the users will not use. For example:
- Brasero. I'm pretty sure that almost nobody uses his netbook to burn cd's.
- XSane Image Scanner.
- Assistive Technologies. The size of the devices doesnt make it very accessable for the less capable.
- PalmOS Tools. Who does even use a palm these days anyway?
310
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Use less preinstalled software for the Netbook Remix
Written by Frank Roberts the 9 Sep 09 at 22:38.
The above programs are just a few examples, my point is: I think the system will work a lot better (and become smaller) if the enormous amount of useless preinstalled software for -most- netbook users will be diminished. The few who want to burn cds anyway can easily find brasero in the repositories.
0
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Include two install options, a 'Full' and 'Minimal' install
Written by Sir Wallsy the 10 Sep 09 at 10:37.
When installing UNR, give the user an option of installing UNR as it currently is, with all default software included, and a 'Minimal' option whereby software such as those mentioned above is not installed by default, but can later be installed if required from the repositries.
80
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Grow UNR into a new metapackage - ubuntu-netbook
Written by cheesehead the 19 Sep 09 at 01:14.
Changing the software mix, and the associated additional administration and testing is much bigger than the current team and 'remix' concept.

The original 'remix' concept was a new-flavor-on-the-cheap, look and feel customized to the smaller-screen environment without creating a whole new (expensive) edition of Ubuntu.

To go beyond the current remix, the UNR team needs many more volunteers, and must publish it's own metapackage, replacing ubuntu-desktop instead of just adding to it. Obviously, it would have many common components with u-d, like Gnome and many applications.

27
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: Gather usage stats for UNR applications. Move "unpopular" ones to repositories
Written by rrnwexec the 29 Sep 09 at 19:39.
Choices on what to include (or not) should not be abitrarily made by developers (or anyone else for that matter).

One way to make a choice is to use the 80/20 rule. If an application/package is used by 80% or more of the installed base, then keep it in the default install. Otherwise, make it optional.
20
votes
up equal down
Solution #5: Install hardware dependent tools when device is detected
Written by saftaplan the 30 Sep 09 at 18:36.
Just install xsane when a scanner is first attached, bluetooth tools when a bluetooth device is found, etc. If these devices are present at install time, install them right away.
This can even be used for general Ubuntu. It removes clutter (why do I need Bluetooth preferences and even a daemon starting up if I have no such device?) and saves hard disk space and memory. The only disadvantage is that you'll need an internet connection the moment you attach such a device.

See the 7 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 22 Sep 09 at 01:02) >>

Make a new Ubuntu distro or flavor, like DSL, Slitaz...  
Written by melwin.a3 the 15 Mar 09 at 04:25. New
hi,
I am using linux past four years by the time i was using various distros. Most of linux operating systems are huge and CPU&RAM hungry.

Most of the people using ubuntu for Internet purpose only.So make a new derivative(like Kubuntu,Xubuntu) and it should be small in size less than 50 MB. IT can be able run in 400 MHZ processor,32 MB RAM(minimum requirement).and better internet connection..

---- All Apps must have GUI interfaces only --

so we can able run in netbook, Mini ITX based PCs... also people who need linux for internet only..

I hope canonical should release an Official version of Ubunti derivative with unlimited support. Because Slitaz, DSL, etc. comes without a good support for end users.
-6
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: My opinion for the ubuntu New derivative
Written by melwin.a3 the 15 Mar 09 at 04:25.
- Latest Ubuntu kernel for 32 bit,64 bit
- JWM (Joe's Window Manager)
- Mozilla Firefox
- Pidgin
- Evince document viewer
- Evoultion or something lght weight email client
- An APT package manager
- Better Drivers Support(Printer,Ethernet,WLAN)

>>>>>> ISO file should be less than 50 MB
-4
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Have a native way to make a custom Live CD
Written by luXy the 21 Mar 09 at 22:10.
I think Ubuntu should have a way to make a custom Live CD. Possibly we can "Ubuntuify" Debian's live-helper, and make a GUI for it.

See the 1 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 24 Aug 09 at 12:45) >>

Easy retrieve a bug report when live-cd fails to load  
Written by dajomu the 31 Jul 09 at 12:28. New
Many times when testing ubuntu in alpha-stages there can be problems with booting/loading the live-cd. I tis difficult for most people to document what is going wrong during boot-up of the live-cd. How do one save and retrieve such data? The big problem is to log and document every bug or error when using the live-cd and it stops before it loads.
7
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: automatically save logs to a thumbdrive
Written by dajomu the 31 Jul 09 at 12:28.
I suggest that there could have been an option in the boot menu that lets you choose to write an extensive verbose of all messages to a file onto a thumbdrive.
This would make it much easier to report bugs with all the necessary info for the developers.

Add a comment or propose a solution >>

live-cd-iso not fully localized, dvd-iso too big for 4 gb usb-memory  
Written by POPrHINO the 11 Jul 09 at 15:38. New
Would be very convenient to have more ready localized installation live-iso-media, but to be able to fit it in 4 gb (or even 2 gb) usb-memory-stick.
dvd-iso is oversized for that and cd-isos don't include all language packs, so they don't offer localization-ready usb-memory live-mediaset.

So the main thing that I suggest is to offer more fully localized installation ISOs. Now there's plenty of unnecessary locales in dvd and not adequate in cd.
Of course I and some other geeks know how to make a more convenient installation media by adding packages and removing unnecessary, but why to force thousands to do that when it could be done more efficiently by offering some more localized installation ISOs.
The ability to run Ubuntu from usb-memory stick is a great advantage compared to Windows, so why not take the full advantage and ease out of it and to offer even better, more fully localized installation ISOs.

For example here in Finland (where linux is from btw) with Ubuntu cdISO I have to add missing localization packages to get fully finnish Ubuntu-live-usb-media. Or if I use dvdISO I have to rip off extras to give more free space in live-usb-memorystick to use that space for store space while using live-usb-Ubuntu. So much extra job with every Ubuntu release.
20
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Some more localized live installation ISOs to fit 4 gb usb-memory
Written by POPrHINO the 11 Jul 09 at 15:38.
Would be great to have some specific area fully localized installation ISOs too to fit in 4gb usb-memory stick (or even 2 gb). So smaller than DVD-iso, but better ready localized than CD-iso.
For example Scandinavic installation ISO to include full language support packages of Finnish, Swedish, Norwegian, Danish, Islandic, Saame and maybe Estonian too included in addition to English. And the size less than DVD size to fit in usb-memory-stick to be used better as more fully equiped live-use/installation media.

Others could be for example
Western&Central&South-Europe&Americas,
East-Europe
Africa&Middle-East/Arabic
Asia
18
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Add localization options to usb-creator
Written by Shnatsel the 25 Jul 09 at 15:30.
Add localization options to usb-creator to let user decide which localization packages he needs and which he doesn't need. Missing packages will be downloaded from the Net.
7
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: a web tool as SUSE Studio for easy making your own distro
Written by mitcoes the 29 Jul 09 at 13:39.
Not only locale, package selection, on a ISO maker page.
But I would like a .txt setings save for share with NERDS and NEWBES, and to keep and add good choices.

See the 6 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 27 Jul 09 at 13:51) >>

Uncomplicated 'advanced' install LiveCD, dynamic installation  
Written by Aphoxema the 10 Oct 08 at 18:28. New
It's wonderful that there's Ubuntu for Gnome, Kubuntu for KDE, and Xubuntu for XFCE, and they all do well in supporting their own Desktop Environment, and I won't say it's ridiculous to have them separated the way they are. We do know, however, that all three, including all the 'boxes and FVWM and Enlightenment play very well together in a Debian environment together.

It's also very good that the LiveCD install for Ubuntu is very neat, straightforward, and doesn't offer more options than new users know what to do with.

I've also seen propositions for choosing what packages to install, but I don't think picking out every little package is quite the right idea.

It could be to the benefit for many if there were another 'distribution' put together meant for installs where broadband was readily accessible, one that isn't meant for a streamlined installation of one DE, but instead gave you a simple and descriptive way of choosing DE's, one or many, or even not choosing one at all if someone just wanted pseudoterminals.

Then the user could choose their login manager, if applicable, and be informed the differences between, well, basically GDM and KDM. I don't know of any other login managers that really give users what they need.

The 'roles' of the computer could also be selected since computers have so many different situations.

After the choices have been made, the necessary packages, already up to date, could be downloaded and installed.

This wouldn't interfere with X/K/Ubuntu and give interested users more choices installing Ubuntu without the painful process of sifting through many different applications.

What's even better is this installer could be updated every time the LiveCD is started since it would essentially be expected to. This would make changes in your options independent to the image you download and burn. In fact, you could never need to download another install CD again, the installer would find out every time what it has to do to install the next distribution from files stored on a server.

[....]
15
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #14279
Written by Aphoxema the 10 Oct 08 at 18:28.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #14279 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!

See the 2 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 26 Jul 09 at 15:35) >>

Presentaion of Ubuntu advantages and tips in default screensaver  
Written by deltakilo the 16 Feb 09 at 20:59. New
It´s not easy to switch OS to the experienced users. And for most simple men it´s unbelievable.
9
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Screensaver-presentaion by default
Written by deltakilo the 16 Feb 09 at 20:59.
Let we create and include to (K/Ed)ubuntu screensaver-presentaion of ubuntu. So new users will be able to see what they can and should do in their in much cases new system that named linux, Ubuntu. We should show easy and fun solutions for everyday tasks in ¨did wou know¨ or ¨for Dummies¨ format. Also we can use it on demonstrations from live cd.

Add a comment or propose a solution >>

<< Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... Next >>