Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
Live CD
Idea sandbox Idea sandbox
Popular ideas Popular ideas
Ideas in development Ideas in development
Implemented ideas Implemented ideas

Contributor KurtKraut on Live CD

Remove irrelevant programs in the Netbook Remix  
Written by Frank Roberts the 9 Sep 09 at 22:38. New
Because netbooks are machines that are made for a very specific task that is quite different from 'normal' desktop use, there are several programs installed that 95% or even 100% of the users will not use. For example:
- Brasero. I'm pretty sure that almost nobody uses his netbook to burn cd's.
- XSane Image Scanner.
- Assistive Technologies. The size of the devices doesnt make it very accessable for the less capable.
- PalmOS Tools. Who does even use a palm these days anyway?
310
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Use less preinstalled software for the Netbook Remix
Written by Frank Roberts the 9 Sep 09 at 22:38.
The above programs are just a few examples, my point is: I think the system will work a lot better (and become smaller) if the enormous amount of useless preinstalled software for -most- netbook users will be diminished. The few who want to burn cds anyway can easily find brasero in the repositories.
0
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Include two install options, a 'Full' and 'Minimal' install
Written by Sir Wallsy the 10 Sep 09 at 10:37.
When installing UNR, give the user an option of installing UNR as it currently is, with all default software included, and a 'Minimal' option whereby software such as those mentioned above is not installed by default, but can later be installed if required from the repositries.
80
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Grow UNR into a new metapackage - ubuntu-netbook
Written by cheesehead the 19 Sep 09 at 01:14.
Changing the software mix, and the associated additional administration and testing is much bigger than the current team and 'remix' concept.

The original 'remix' concept was a new-flavor-on-the-cheap, look and feel customized to the smaller-screen environment without creating a whole new (expensive) edition of Ubuntu.

To go beyond the current remix, the UNR team needs many more volunteers, and must publish it's own metapackage, replacing ubuntu-desktop instead of just adding to it. Obviously, it would have many common components with u-d, like Gnome and many applications.

27
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: Gather usage stats for UNR applications. Move "unpopular" ones to repositories
Written by rrnwexec the 29 Sep 09 at 19:39.
Choices on what to include (or not) should not be abitrarily made by developers (or anyone else for that matter).

One way to make a choice is to use the 80/20 rule. If an application/package is used by 80% or more of the installed base, then keep it in the default install. Otherwise, make it optional.
20
votes
up equal down
Solution #5: Install hardware dependent tools when device is detected
Written by saftaplan the 30 Sep 09 at 18:36.
Just install xsane when a scanner is first attached, bluetooth tools when a bluetooth device is found, etc. If these devices are present at install time, install them right away.
This can even be used for general Ubuntu. It removes clutter (why do I need Bluetooth preferences and even a daemon starting up if I have no such device?) and saves hard disk space and memory. The only disadvantage is that you'll need an internet connection the moment you attach such a device.

See the 7 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 22 Sep 09 at 01:02) >>