Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
Live CD installer
Idea sandbox Idea sandbox
Popular ideas Popular ideas
Ideas in development Ideas in development
Implemented ideas Implemented ideas

Contributor ChrisB on Live CD installer

Configure Ubuntu Programs During Installation  
Written by Klau3 the 27 Jan 10 at 20:15. Won't implement
Installation process should give people the choice to select some standard programms.
Someone using Thunderbird as mail client doesn't need Evolution...
It is not about installing all kinds of programms during the installation process, but about selecting the most common programms easily.

The other thing is that a lot of people don't know that ubuntu can play DVD videos, because they just don't know about libdvdcss2, “ubuntu restricted extras” and how to install them.

Example: my parents cannot install libdvdcss2 without my help. This should change!
1068
votes
closed
Solution #3: Configurate Ubuntu Programms During Installation
Written by nhandler the 27 Jan 10 at 23:27.


Integrate one more step into the installation process to enable a 'light weight' program selection and system pre-configuration
685
votes
closed
Solution #4: But hide it under "Advanced" button!
Written by Int_ua the 28 Jan 10 at 00:28.
Because it can make installation process harder to understand for nonexpert users.
34
votes
closed
Solution #5: Put it under Software Configuration
Written by vvfrn2 the 28 Jan 10 at 03:07.
not advanced option
533
votes
closed
Solution #6: Include a 'none' option
Written by alms66 the 28 Jan 10 at 03:29.
A none option at each dropbox for those who will not use torrents, or notes, or those with no cd burners, etc.
-250
votes
closed
Solution #7: Only propose Open Source Software
Written by krs the 28 Jan 10 at 09:22.
For base Installation.
Or using Ubuntu is a non-sense.
287
votes
closed
Solution #8: Name's Category
Written by guigui14100 the 28 Jan 10 at 23:22.
Instead write: Brasero (CD / DVD Burning)
Write this: CD / DVD Burning
414
votes
closed
Solution #9: Video drivers
Written by Zorba the 3 Feb 10 at 09:39.
I think it's a good idea to insert an option "install video card driver"... more or less the idea is to integrate jockey in the installation program, so users can install the system with the right video driver (if they want).
175
votes
closed
Solution #10: Add more stuff to "more information"
Written by tommis the 3 Feb 10 at 19:42.
Add more to information box stuff like:

license
programs homepage
hard drive space needed
homepage
-224
votes
closed
Solution #11: Add install your own software.
Written by tommis the 3 Feb 10 at 19:56.
Theres so many programs at you cannot just but all in such a little list. Add option install your own packapages from ubuntus servers or your chosen ppa.
229
votes
closed
Solution #12: Make it part of Ubuntu Software Center
Written by alexander255 the 5 Feb 10 at 00:17.
Add a new item in the sidebar of the Ubuntu Software Center called "Favorite Applications". The information about the alternatives could be simply added through debtags.
-144
votes
closed
Solution #13: adapt your own software
Written by ergbigred the 8 Feb 10 at 22:11.
We all may have pet programs that worked well under other linux distributions. It'd be nice if they could be automatically configured to play nice with Ubuntu setups or run in protected areas.
-49
votes
closed
Solution #14: Optional Microsoft Application Compatibility
Written by justintime03_2 the 9 Feb 10 at 02:13.
I know this sounds like heresy, but Ubuntu already has this in the repositories. Why not make it easier for new Ubuntu users to run their Windows applications. That's one of the biggest complaints I've heard. A lot of people don't know they can use WINE without digging around on the net. There's a lot who never know they have the option. Have the option to install WINE in the Configure Ubuntu Programs tool at first boot. I think this is crucial.
37
votes
closed
Solution #15: Autorun installation software
Written by diegusohpus the 11 Feb 10 at 11:49.
To include all this software in the ISO will be too big for a CD size. If you don't want to include them into the ISO you have to have a Internet connection enabled during the installation, and it's not always possible, so after you have installad Ubuntu the system will automaticly install them from internet.
-22
votes
closed
Solution #16: not enough space, internet and other problems
Written by Goury the 12 Feb 10 at 10:54.
there is no problems to include this one to DVD
also there is one more thing needed - ability to install more than one app of any type
there is tons of ppls who uses chromium AND firefox because first is fast and second sometimes shows pages more accurate and have more extensions

also: do not include opera and chrome. include chromium and some other free (as freedom, not as beer) browsers
70
votes
closed
Solution #17: Optional Install updated system and/or packages
Written by ing.gonzo the 13 Feb 10 at 00:47.
Add also during installation, the capability to install updated system and/or software packages (so we don't have to do an apt-get update && apt-get dist-upgrade as first thing to do after the first boot and then we have to do another reboot...). So the system is updated out of the box
73
votes
closed
Solution #18: add network-manager plugins here
Written by Goury the 13 Feb 10 at 08:17.
90% russian internets is pptp vpn so option pptp must include needed packages to pptp-vpn plugin works in network manager (its stable enough)
many ppl in europes uses some oter vpn (i am not sure) so option to install oter vpn type is needed too

a lot of peoples uses wifis or something else to interneting
and we all know that ubuntu without internet is 99% dualbooting to windows or uninstalling - ubuntu MUST HAVE internet after installation so all interneting packages must be included at least to dvd, but on cd is good too AND thete must be option to install them - its very difficult task to noobs to install vpn or something else packages
-102
votes
closed
Solution #19: will hard from the new experience user
Written by taufiksu the 14 Feb 10 at 12:09.
i think it is not important to implement because it will hard to choose the app when new ubuntu user install the ubuntu.
-55
votes
closed
Solution #20: Choose kernel type
Written by pkslot the 16 Feb 10 at 15:46.
Why not let people choose what kernel to install, vanilla, rt or what their prefrences are.
54
votes
closed
Solution #21: Solution #3, but also include option to choose Office suite
Written by magallucas the 16 Feb 10 at 20:53.
Some people (including me) have a personal preference for certain Office suites. Include a chance to choose the preferred suite (OpenOffice by default) would also be interesting. The options could be KOffice, Lotus Symphony, etc..

Integrated to Solution #12, the idea is even more complete: Accessing "Favorite Applications", the User can change your kit software more easily after you install the OS. For example, to change the option favorite browser "Firefox" to "Google Chrome", the Software Center automatically uninstall Firefox and install Chrome, making it the default browser. Happen the same way with the other favorite applications.

In case if the User wants to keep the two browsers (Firefox and Chrome), usually just select the Software Center - as is currently done - so both will be installed. Then just go to "Favorite Applications" and switch to Chrome, which is already installed - Firefox would remain, but the Chrome would be the primary browser.
26
votes
closed
Solution #22: Provide net isntall cd
Written by tommis the 18 Feb 10 at 19:05.
Also provide option to net isntall wich don`t have programs includet. This would prevent users from downloading packpages what they do not conna use.
26
votes
closed
Solution #23: That menu suits "prefered applications"
Written by pererik87 the 20 Feb 10 at 06:35.
That menu should meet the eye in "preferred applications". simple for noobs, when selecting an option not currently installed, user should be prompted replace(remove a install b) or side-by install(install b).

At least the coding should be easy.
14
votes
closed
Solution #24: Add a theme menu
Written by Niels_ the 22 Feb 10 at 16:29.
Just like the other options, add a menu for themes.
So people can choose their favourite standard theme at instsall.
44
votes
closed
Solution #25: Give some warning for low disk space systems
Written by dreamr the 23 Feb 10 at 12:16.
In addition to the "more information", give some indication of space left after installing all the applications. Can be just passive indicator that the user sees while making choices. Useful for systems with low memory, like netbooks with SSD.
0
votes
closed
Solution #26: Not during installation, but in the Welcome Screen
Written by pazuzuthewise the 3 Apr 10 at 02:55.
I believe that this option for adding software during OS install that cannot possibly fit on a CD medium, and therefore necessitates internet connection, could end up in a failed install process if the connection fails, as could happen with a 3G connection during bad weather conditions.
I certainly agree that the options presented in Solution #3 should be presented to the user in an informative manner - who, especially if new to linux, would otherwise have no clue what to do to be able to watch a DVD, for example - but not during OS install, but integrated in the Welcome Window that appears at the first login, maybe having a link in it to the Add/Remove Software, which, in turn should have these options on a main page.
15
votes
closed
Solution #27: Store Favourite Applications List on Ubuntu One
Written by rugbeeprop the 4 May 10 at 04:03.
'Path' suggested "A list of favorite packages could be useful to put up on ubuntu one?"

https://answers.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+question/109518
-5
votes
closed
Solution #28: Choose the applications from the website before download
Written by thipv the 9 May 10 at 23:12.
It would make the process more flexible letting us to choose the programs before getting the iso, creating a customized image. You would select everything from the system architecture (32, 64, ppc, arm...) to desktop environment (gnome, kde, xfce, lxde...) or special environments (moblin based, netbook remix...), suggesting their default applications for each one, and let you change or remove them and choose additional programs, even restricted ones, informing the restrictions.
This would also be good because you would always be getting the most updated packages.
5
votes
closed
Solution #29: Solution #3, #21, #23 ... + User choise
Written by JasLicno the 12 May 10 at 23:26.
User should decide which program will use.solution is simple:
Configure programs during installation:
1. button - ubuntu suggested
2. button - user defined ... list of all available programs
+ (because is impossible to have that big source of programs)

after installing, program that will give you option to make a clone of your installation, so next instalation of your system will be faster and with 100% personal programs. (this is not my idea, I have read about this as option in one of linux distributions)
7
votes
closed
Solution #30: enable account transfer
Written by switchgirl the 30 Jun 10 at 21:21.
enable a way of saving account details to ubuntu one so that one can transfer all your accounts (yahoo, hotmail,gmail icq... irc... jabber.. everything) to the new machine this will help with setting up of new machines - like if someone has a laptop, web book and other machines, they really down want to have to set up all the different accounts multiple times. i'm not suggesting emails as this is too much data but enabling people to sync account details, and passwords would be good and improve ubuntu installs
0
votes
closed
Solution #31: In advanced installation mode
Written by mackuz the 17 May 11 at 06:55.
If even #4 is too hard for some users, #1 can be added in advanced installation mode.

It's actual again, 'cause even if Thunderbird will become default mail app in Ubuntu, some corporative users will need Evolution anyway.

See the 55 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 29 Mar 12 at 21:01) >>

Fix Damaged Installation Without Losing Data  
Written by lhb1142 the 6 Apr 09 at 15:12. New
Sometimes something goes wrong with my Ubuntu installation. Generally this has occurred when I have added lots of programs which I believe are useful. Later, an update will take place and, when I reboot, something (sometimes many somethings) no longer function, the most important of these being the wireless networking.

In the absence of any other means of repairing my installation, I am thus forced to re-install Ubuntu, thereby losing the configurations I have had. (I do always back up my data so that, thus far, I have never lost any of that.)

I wish there were some sort of "repair" option on the installation CD which could test to see if all necessary programs were functioning as they did originally and automatically fix the Ubuntu installation, perhaps removing or inactivating (or at least identifying them) the program(s) causing the problem, setting all the "defaults" necessary functions back properly, I believe that this would be very useful to Ubuntu users.

In conjunction with this, if the problem program(s) were merely identified by the installation CD, I should hope that there would be some way to deactivate these programs, either temporarily or permanently.
63
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Include Repair Option on Installation CD
Written by lhb1142 the 6 Apr 09 at 15:12.
A "Repair" option should be included on the Live CD installer which would, without losing any programs not causing a problem, maintain the computer as the user has it configured but also ensure that all "default" programs, as configured when effecting a "clean" installation, are functioning completely and normally.

Any "problem" programs should be deleted, inactivated, or, at least, identified. If possible, these should be repaired so that they do not cause a conflict.
15
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Create Downloadable Recovery CD
Written by jamesisin the 7 Apr 09 at 01:56.
Create an ISO available to Ubuntu users (linked probably in the Help menu &c) which has been set up specifically for repairing version x.y of Ubuntu.

(Part of my "Keep the installer trim" philosophy.)
29
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Automatically Save List of Installed Packages
Written by Thelasko the 9 Apr 09 at 20:41.
Synaptic currently has an option to save a list of installed packages on your system. This should be done automatically to ensure that users will be able to get their system up and running again quickly.

This feature will only work if the user has a separate /home partition.
5
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: 'Recover' everything except /home
Written by dalhamir the 18 Apr 09 at 09:58.
I think the most straight forward way of thinking about this is that there is /home ... and everything else.

Therfore, there should be an option to perform a clean install with the exception of the /home dir, where %95 of 'data' resides. Movies, pictures, etc

also, the 'fix' or 'recover' script should remove "/home/$USERNAME/.*" to make sure you clean up the odd configuration file that is corrupting the user's experience.

Question: to you, does 'data' mean making sure you favorite programs are still there?

See the 9 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 16 Dec 10 at 19:42) >>

Optional MBR backup before installation  
Written by KIAaze the 28 Jun 08 at 09:31. New
Backing up the MBR before installation using the "dd" command can save a lot of trouble in case of boot problems.
Why not offer an optional MBR backup before installation?(would require backup media like a USB key for example of course)

If there are several partitions already, it could backup all start sectors. This is easier for people who have no idea where their boot partition is.

In general, it would be nice to have a GUI utility to backup/restore MBRs.

If you think people would panic and stop installing if they see such an MBR backup dialog, just deactivate it by default.
A simple checkbox or GUI utility on the LiveCD could be used by users that want to play it safe.

edit:
As indicated by Warbo, a very easy solution would be to automatically create the MBR backups and those that care about them would just have to save them on an external device. :)
69
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #10410
Written by KIAaze the 28 Jun 08 at 09:31.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #10410 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!

See the 12 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 1 Dec 10 at 02:48) >>

Too many hardware support issues after new installation.  
Written by SuNk8 the 3 May 10 at 16:05. New
Well, there are a lot of people who try the Live session once or just a few number of times.
And go for the new release directly.
If you have some unsupported hardware, then comes a lot of debugging.

The Ubuntu forums are filled with threads where users installed the new release without checking if all components of their system are supported by it.

Seasoned users easily find solutions to most problems, but the newbies are a bit rattled by the process.
How will new users know if the new release is actually good for their hardware?

Your solutions and comments are greatly appreciated...
342
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Integrate Hardware Testing into the Official Installer
Written by SuNk8 the 3 May 10 at 16:05.
Prevention is better than Cure.
Ubuntu comes with a very cool System Testing app: checkbox-gtk
Let System Testing be one of the (optional) steps in the Live installer.

So, a newbie user can easily check and actually know if his/her PC will work fine after the upgrade.
If not, they can wait till their issues are resolved and then go for the upgrade.

Testers can just skip the step and go for the install.
-29
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Introduce an Advanced Mode of Installation
Written by SuNk8 the 4 May 10 at 02:52.
Introduce an advanced mode where users are asked questions concerning their hardware. A questionnaire will improve the experience of the user and get the correct information from them about the hardware specs.
The installer will then check on the online database and also include drivers for those entries.

Also, we might move some other entries like bootloader configuration in this mode.
130
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Report HW that's w/o drivers
Written by snadrus the 5 May 10 at 19:29.
'lsusb' and 'lspci' list all the hardware Linux can touch. devicekit loads drivers for these items or defers it (for scanners, printers, etc). Once done, if we have hardware that we couldn't use, lets report that hardware back to Ubuntu.
78
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: Add option to report hardware deficiencies to Ubuntu
Written by LCollins the 10 May 10 at 04:21.
Same as #1, but have the option the report the lack of hardware capabilities to Ubuntu, to help self-improvement. Also check with Ubuntu that the problems have not already been sorted (in case installation CD is out of date.
5
votes
up equal down
Solution #5: Make use of existing Debian device driver check & report homepage
Written by Richard.Kolodziej the 31 May 10 at 12:06.
3
votes
up equal down
Solution #6: Hardware manufactorer partnership for Ubuntu PC's
Written by Bubble the 13 Jun 11 at 10:39.
Ubuntu should search for a hardware manufacturer, to manufacture Ubuntu-"All-in-One" PCs that just work and distribute them via store.ubuntu.com.

Do it like Apple (or Google ChromeOS), provide a few basic systems (for example Ubuntu Notebook, Ubuntu Netbook, Ubuntu Cube PC, Ubuntu Workstation) with Simple Names (Not like Manufacturer X ELGX-423544ES) and good design.

Example:

http://usrnametaken.deviantart.com/art/UbuntuBOX-211559873

So please Ubuntu, be a non-DRM-fanatic, free and OpenSource Apple.

See the 9 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 27 May 10 at 22:28) >>

Have to wipe all hard drives before install.  
Written by leprkhn the 6 Apr 10 at 17:14. New
I, like many others these days, run an small organization that accept donations of old computers for the purpose of refurbishing and donating to those who are without. We wipe every hard drive that comes through our doors with DBAN; mostly for the ease of mind given to folks who donate a computer; but also because we have, in the past, found ourselves holding a hard drive with questionable content on it.
46
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Add a disk wiping option to the LiveCD boot menu or installer.
Written by leprkhn the 6 Apr 10 at 17:14.
It would be an amazing time saver if the Ubuntu install disk came with an option to wipe a hard drive. Ability to overwrite with 1-pass, 3-pass, and 7-pass options would be great.
Having this option appear in the initial boot menu, right behind memtest, would be optimal. This way you won't have to go all the way into the installer. May not be the easiest way to inform users of it's purpose.
Having this option as a part of the installer or partitioner seems to be where *I* would expect to see such a thing and would also give ability to explain it's use from the comfort of a GUI.
Assuming that neither of these options are viable, including an icon on the LiveCD's Desktop that opens a wiping dialogue would be my final suggestion.

See the 7 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 25 Apr 10 at 22:05) >>

Installation Slide Show Should Loop  
Written by lexen the 20 Mar 10 at 19:16. New
I think that the slide show on install is great, and I would love to see more slides in it, but on some slower machines the install will take longer then the slide show.
104
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Loop the Slide Show
Written by lexen the 20 Mar 10 at 19:16.
When the last slide is finished, the first one should pop back up again. They might not have read it yet, but if they had, it's still something to keep their mind occupied in those situations where they need to be there for the full install.
92
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: And allow user to navigate.
Written by Ssdg the 21 Mar 10 at 22:46.
Add on sides of the slides arrows like addons.mozilla.org does with addons' screenshots.


PS: example here https://addons.mozilla.org/fr/firefox/addon/4287
26
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: They have no slides left. Then let them play Games!
Written by LukeM33P the 25 Mar 10 at 01:45.
Seriously, OpenSuse can do it! It might take a lot of work, though.
4
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: Show more exiting slides
Written by uaneme the 16 Apr 10 at 18:25.
People already know what an OS can do.

Show slides that encourage people to more with their pc then 'just the obvious'

the repository has much more to offer.

0
votes
up equal down
Solution #5: Make it depend.
Written by Nate_the_Ace the 4 May 10 at 09:32.
You could limit the amount of time the slide is shown to the percentage of the progress bar. Space the slides out evenly along an equal amount of the progress bar. I would give the last slide at least twice as much time up as the rest. So say you have 9 slides of info to display then the first 8 slides would get the amount of 10% to display, while the final slide would get the last 20% to display. Just a thought.

See the 2 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 22 Mar 10 at 03:32) >>

installation without splash  
Written by conradoat the 12 Nov 09 at 19:48. New
I think that splash is just to make linux, ubuntu in particular, more attractive to beginners. But it does not allow the user to read the kernel messages during boot up.

The first thing I do after installing linux/ubuntu is to get rid of it.

I would love to be asked if I want this piece of software to be installed in my computer during the setting up of the OS.
-42
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: just ask the user!
Written by conradoat the 12 Nov 09 at 19:48.
Just add a question and a tick-box in step seven of the installation process, below the popularity contest, asking whether we want it or not.

93
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Add a button or key-stroke to usplash
Written by Darwin Survivor the 15 Nov 09 at 21:59.
Fedora has (or had last I used it) a button you could hit that would show/hide the kernel messages.

A simpley button, or even keystroke, that switched between usplash and text mode would probably be enough.
-1
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Show relevant messages only.
Written by sosurrey the 30 Nov 09 at 10:11.
Just show error messages, or messages that are different from the last boot in an informative and non alarming way.

That's really all you need to know unless you are messing with stuff, but then if you need that you've probably already disabled the splash anyway.
-9
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: Just remove grub options...
Written by hmb1 the 2 Dec 09 at 20:26.
...since you're not a beginner?
-6
votes
up equal down
Solution #5: Be too fast to matter
Written by snadrus the 3 Dec 09 at 21:20.
If pre-X is 2-3s then just a black screen will do as most BIOSes take more than that.

See the 4 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 22 Nov 09 at 14:47) >>

There is no complete install to USB  
Written by ki4jgt the 17 Oct 09 at 08:54. New
The live-USB-creator allows the user to create a flashdrive with Ubuntu as the default system admin (no password) If you create another user, the system doesn't allow you to force login when Ubuntu starts. There are several other issues like this with the live USB (Persistant install), there is no encryption, even if you want to install on one of those external hard drives, so you can carry Ubuntu around from computer to computer.
11
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Allow full USB install without affecting MBR
Written by ki4jgt the 17 Oct 09 at 08:54.
Allow the user a choice, or advanced options in the usb creator program to go through the (entire) install process with a usb drive, without affecting the users computer.

See the 2 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 18 Oct 09 at 18:27) >>

Speed up installation with ready locale settings  
Written by kopo the 23 Jun 09 at 18:48. New
It is frustrating to set up keyboard settings, language settings, location etc..
-38
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Check your location with IP address
Written by kopo the 23 Jun 09 at 18:48.
It would be nice, if installer could check wan ip-address, and set locales, language and keyboard settings based on that information.

MaxMind's GeoIP Country is a solution for this! Check this
http://www.maxmind.com/app/geoip_country
http://blogama.org/node/56

Just integrate this with the installer!
126
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Protect privacy and choice : make it an option.
Written by Ssdg the 24 Jun 09 at 08:12.
What if you just don't want to advertise you're installing your OS?

What if you're an indian/chinese/japanese/... living in the US/UK/France/Germany/... and who loves to use his computer in his mother tongue?

What of large companies behind a proxy (and sometimes behind a VPN that leads to another country)

The old way must be still availlable and the be the default.
-50
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Custom config Linux CD
Written by tolga9009 the 24 Jun 09 at 12:13.
What should people do, who are living in other countries, but want to use english?

My Solution:
1. Install Ubuntu from scratch
2. Configure it to meet your needs
3. Start a program, which creates a Linux Live CD with your current settings, so you can easily install it next time without configuring.
82
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: Adding a button "Try to detect locale settings"
Written by samoul the 25 Jun 09 at 01:19.
If you want to implement such feature you should add some kind of button titled "Try to detect locale settings". Then continue with the standard procedure with the detected settings selected instead of the default ones. That way the user can easily change any settings to fit is needs if the found settings don't. It's simple, flexible and not intrusive.
-49
votes
up equal down
Solution #5: Customize link in the download page( lower )
Written by murdok03 the 25 Jun 09 at 21:20.
When one clicks Customize he gets to something like http://susestudio.com/ Canonical can compete with Novel on this ideea.
In this way you can get your customised ISO first hand and only use that one for burning and install.
Of course language settings and startup programs should be customisable. But maybe should be started as a brand new ideea.
-14
votes
up equal down
Solution #6: Bring a little Wubi into Ubiquity
Written by stickwithjosh the 1 Jul 09 at 00:12.
I get really jealous of Wubi (the Ubuntu installer that installs into a Windows folder through some magic). Check out this screenshot: http://wubi-installer.org/images/wubi.png

Seems like we could have a very similar screen in Ubiquity (the "normal" Ubuntu installer) that guesses all the settings (or tries to get a network connection to help guess), and uses sane defaults, but also lets the user change everything they would like.

I've spoken a few times with Evan Dandrea (co-maintainer of Ubiquity), and there are a lot of things to consider with the installer, but I'd imagine for most installations this process can go from 6 screens to 2 (one like the screenshot linked above, and 1 for user/pass/login details.).
15
votes
up equal down
Solution #7: detect locale and ask to use
Written by josinalvo the 1 Jul 09 at 16:23.
the instaler would automatically find the users probable country and ask to use the settings for the country (one setting at a time)
-10
votes
up equal down
Solution #8: detect locale and ask to use 2
Written by josinalvo the 1 Jul 09 at 16:34.
rather than one at a time (language, time zone, keyboard), just two questions:

what country are you in
keyboard layout

and a details drop-down to set more specifically

See the 3 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 15 Jul 09 at 14:49) >>

Installer for advanced users  
Written by Frantique the 16 May 09 at 06:59. New
We have now this nice installer made in 7 steps. Very nice indeed, and simple to use it, but it installs a system for a simple newbie user, and that is all. We should have an option to switch to a more advanced setup/install procedure.

What I am missing now? Let's see:
1. possibility to create LVM.
2. possibility to create and use encrypted FS.
3. possibility to set up multiple users, with everyone's home on different disk.
4. possibility to set up Raid during the install.
5. possibility to review and eventually override hardware settings. (for ex. for my wireless card intel 4965 I have to use qos_enable=0 option to get reasonable speed...It would be better if we could have a step for setting up the hw options eventually needed. Like this we will not forget to set up things.)

This are the most important things for the moment. What do you say?
64
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Create an advanced installer or extend this one
Written by Frantique the 16 May 09 at 06:59.
On the first step of the actual installer we should have a button to switch to advanced setup. There we could use all these advanced settings.
31
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Alternate CD has advanced installer
Written by chs42 the 18 May 09 at 13:46.
The installer on the live Cd should be kept simple for new users. Advanced users can use the alternate cd which has a way more advanced installer with more options and possibilities.
9
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Do nothing
Written by baldurpet the 20 May 09 at 18:35.
Ubuntu is intended to be simple.
I promise you that some user is going to pick the advanced installer (Solution #1) or download the alternative CD (Solution #2) by mistake, and the average user will get scared once he is asked "would you like to create a LVM?".

When downloading Ubuntu the user can pick Server, Netbook Remix or Desktop, 32bit or 64bit (or even PPC), 9.04 or 8.04, Ubuntu, Kubuntu or Edubuntu.. and then there's the problem of burning an iso image (I've seen people trying to burn iso as an "audio disk"). Adding an "advanced" option sounds like giving the user another possibility of screwing things up.

I would advice intermediate or advanced users to configure these settings themselves or to use distributions that allow for greater customization?

See the 7 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 2 Jun 09 at 11:49) >>

2 Next >>