Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 21545 ideas, 132412 comments, 2606687 votes
Idea sandbox Idea sandbox
Popular ideas Popular ideas
Ideas in development Ideas in development
Implemented ideas Implemented ideas

Popular ideas Here are the last 6 months most popular ideas about Ubuntu.

Copy process pauses/interrupts on file conflict  
Written by komputes the 8 Oct 11 at 17:59. Related project: Nautilus. New
Copy process pauses/interrupts on file conflict. Ideally we would want all file conflicts would be managed before the copy starts and not during the copy.
203
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Continue copying the files that doesn't need confirmation
Written by komputes the 8 Oct 11 at 19:12.
Solution #17: Continue copying the files that doesn't need confirmation

Written by pgdx the 31 Jul 09 at 08:09.
The copying of the rest of the files should continue and the files in question should be queued until the user decides what to do with this.

Need brainstorm admin help with import solution 17 from here:
http://brainstorm.ubuntu.com/idea/15427/
-15
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Before copy start batch process list of conflict need to be displayed
Written by benoyanthony the 11 Oct 11 at 12:57.
Before copy start batch process list of conflict need to be fisplayed in the box and then user can be given option agains each file for overwrite, duplicate, skip , etc.
-6
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: Before copy start batch process, choices can be made
Written by ianp5a the 28 Oct 11 at 06:46.
(similar to #3)
An 'option' to let the user set what should be done for each conflict at the 'start' of the process.
The user intends to leave a long copy process unattended, and expects it to be finished upon their return. In this case the user 'knows' there will be overwrite errors and 'knows' what they want to be done in those cases.
This is important by long copies. Eg slow Networks and hundreds of files and folders.
This option could be on a button on the correct part of the "File Operations" Dialog. That means the copy is already running when the choices are made. Regardless of if an error have already occurred.
This solution solves this common case and does not conflict with other solutions that may be required.

See the 4 comments or propose a solution >>

To extend the capabalities of the calendar applet  
Written by Jimmydoug the 8 Oct 11 at 12:07. Related project: Gnome. New
The calendar in the top panel is pretty but can't actually do very much in its present state other than show you what day such and such a date will fall on. If you want to add an event, you'll have to close the calendar applet and start another, separate calendar.
120
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Incorporate some more functions into the calendar applet
Written by Jimmydoug the 8 Oct 11 at 12:07.
In previous versions of Ubuntu this was achieved with Evolution. With the adoption of Thunderbird as the default email client, it might seem logical to incorporate Lightning into the calendar applet. However, I wonder whether something more configurable and better integrated with Ubuntu could be written. This application could sync via Ubuntu One to the other calendar applets on all the other Ubuntu computers the user works on. So long as it could sync with Google Calendar, and could read ical etc, I think people would appreciate this feature.
57
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Integrate Lightning with Ubuntu
Written by julientroploin the 12 Oct 11 at 11:52.
Lightning even has lots of qualities in the targeted functionalities, it could be a good idea to work with mozilla on this integration or to fork lighning (keeping compatibility with it) if no common work is possible.
10
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Create an event-lens for Unity
Written by julientroploin the 12 Oct 11 at 12:28.
Lightning or an other calendar utility could be used as a scope transmiting information to an event-lens in the dash.
50
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: Integrate with Google Calendar
Written by RobinJ1995 the 14 Oct 11 at 12:08.
The new "Online accounts" option doesn't actually have many uses yet. Wouldn't it be nice to use it to intergrate the Google services into your desktop? Having Google Calendar integrated right into your calendar applet would be a very helpful feature! It could notify you about events and stuff like that.
36
votes
up equal down
Solution #6: Make a generic API like the sound and messaging menu
Written by MsG the 20 Oct 11 at 11:05.
Make a generic API where applications can hook in. So Thunderbird can be made compatible as well as Evolution, or other plugins for online services like Google Calendar.
2
votes
up equal down
Solution #7: A big panel calendar with simple events/notes
Written by petko10 the 23 Jan 12 at 13:08.
Now , I envision it as being one of the super handy things that Ubuntu has , so bare with me . I've always had trouble keeping track of my daily notes, but I'm frequently around the computer .So when I'm on the computer I want to be able to easily check what the notes/events for the day are and to check them or add more (for any of the upcoming days) .The most handy thing to have is to click on the calendar , which will drop a two-thirds-of-the-screen type of panel (picture : http://dl.dropbox.com/u/42681910/Calendar%20blueprint.png ) , that has the calendar , and in each cell (representing a day) there could be events/notes , that are readable as soon as you expand the applet (and everything hides on Esc or click on the indicator) . I think no other OS has anything similar . So to add an event or to edit one - just click on the cell .
An addition to the idea is to have the cell ,that's clicked on, expand (makes it more usable when there's many events/notes) as shown in the picture.

What I've drawn is pretty bad , but I guess you could imagine a better coloured version with some transparency and some simple open-animation .

Importing/exporting with a mail client and/or Ubuntu One will make the integration complete and enable syncing with other devices through the already existing systems.

See the 7 comments or propose a solution >>

File management isn't as easy as it could be  
Written by Eldmannen the 28 Oct 11 at 14:56. Related project: Nautilus. New
Managing files isn't as easy and straight forward as it could be. The filename is what is most relevant to the user, not other data such as the file extension.
92
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Dim file extensions in Nautilus
Written by Eldmannen the 28 Oct 11 at 14:56.
I would like an option to dim the file extension in Nautilus.
Many web browsers have now began dimming less relevant parts of the URL, such as the protocol, subdomain, path, and query string.
I propose we have an option/setting/feature that does the same Nautilus. Dim the the file extension.


71
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Dim file extensions in Gtk
Written by Eldmannen the 28 Oct 11 at 15:02.
I would like an option to dim the file extension in Gtk file chooser dialogs.


-105
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Hide extension by default.
Written by thehosh the 29 Oct 11 at 23:36.
I propose that the file extensions are hidden by default, if a user needs/wants them, they can enable it in the settings. Maybe even add a dim feature (File extensions: Hidden/Show/Dimmed).
Of course, this would be system wide.
-24
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: Make it optional
Written by jonasPlatte the 31 Oct 11 at 14:24.
I propose to make it an option to show the file extension normally or completely hide it, and set "dimmed" as default.
5
votes
up equal down
Solution #5: Make it optional
Written by ckujau the 31 Oct 11 at 18:35.
If this is wanted at all, I propose to show the file extension by default and provide an option to hide/dim it. The individual user should judge what she considers as "less relevant parts of the URL".
42
votes
up equal down
Solution #6: Linux 101: File extensions mean nothing in Linux.
Written by NictraSavios the 6 Nov 11 at 02:36.
Linux has no concept of a "file extension" like legacy operating systems. You may name files any way you like. The contents/purpose of a file is determined by other means.

This means that a file extension should have no bearing on linux users, a text file is not denoted by .txt, and MPEG layer 3 doesn't have to have .mp3. If a program requires an extension, then the developer should be notified immediately about proper Linux concepts.

This is something that has been a sticking point for Linux users since before Ubuntu was even around, if you are going to give any mention to file extensions, it should be that they mean nothing.

They shouldn't be hidden, they shouldn't be dimmed, they are part of the file name in Linux and should be treated as such, they tell the USER what the file is and the system doesn't care. Its just a name. So if you have problems with them, your in luck.... just ditch them. You do not need them. They are simply there for the user to be able to tell that "this is an image, this is a music file", the system doesn't care. Neither should you.

If this is for compatibility with Windows, then an option to hide them would be sufficient, but please, please, please do not make it default.
-17
votes
up equal down
Solution #7: The default view should depend on the directory.
Written by Gregory the 13 Nov 11 at 23:07.
Nautilus has three views right now: Icons, List, and Compact. Considering the optional extra pane and sidebar, and the combinations possible, you might say we have 36 views. If you're looking for files based on something like access time or permissions, the icon view isn't very helpful, but if you're looking at a small set of well known files related to a project, the list might have too much irrelevant information and the compact view might not have enough. If you're moving lots of files around, you might want an extra pane or tree view sidebar instead of two separate windows.

The filesystem hierarchy can be categorized in many ways. One set of categories might be "a user's files" and "everything else". The user's files category would typically include all non-hidden directories and files in the user's home folder. These are fewer in number and more familiar to the user than everything else. In any directory they are usually more type-heterogeneous than files in standard system directories like "/usr/bin".

The icon view is better suited for a small set of familiar files of different types, while the list view is better suited for large sets of unfamiliar files of the same type. The default view for non-hidden directories in the user's home folder should be the icon view, and the default view for everything else should be the list view.

This simple division (user's files, everything else) and use of just two views (icons, list) is only meant to be an example. This is only for the default view when a user first visits a directory and is not meant to disallow changing the view or having the change remembered by file manager.

See the 11 comments or propose a solution >>

Implement way of telling user that there is a connection but no internet  
Written by tancrackers the 4 Dec 11 at 21:00. Related project: Network Manager. New
Please implement a method of telling the user that there is a wireless connection but not internet like Windows 7 does.

Sometimes my router goes nuts and will give me a wireless connection but I cannot connect to the internet.

All I have to do is unplug the router and plug it back in.

Though, on Ubuntu I only know when I try to go online and my homepages fails to load.

On Windows 7, the wireless icon in the taskbar shows the bars that represent the connection, but there is a yellow "caution" arrow on the wireless icon followed by a message that there is no internet connection.

Can you please implement something similar to this in Ubuntu so I can know right after log in that it is my router failing as opposed to something else?

Thank you!
86
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Perhaps some new icon to represent a connection w/o internet status
Written by tancrackers the 4 Dec 11 at 21:00.
http://pix.share32.org/s-images/wirelessicon.jpg
imagine that with a yellow ! or something
5
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: Ping the DNS server
Written by ross9885 the 24 Dec 11 at 19:18.
Or ping the home page of the default browser, like SpyMasterMatt suggested. Show status in the icon and show a notification when status changes.
-1
votes
up equal down
Solution #5: Try root DNS servers and tooltip message
Written by EduardoR the 2 Jan 12 at 05:04.
Are many and may be tried in Round Robin manner.

But some networks may not "need" to be routed to internet to be connected, then must be *optional*.

Root servers are listed with dig command:
dig
ping a.root-servers.net

I really prefer to have an independent and configurable indicator. There are too many situations and can be very confusing. Best with a one time tooltip message.

The alert may be when no-IP address is offer by DHCP server o manual. Called local o IPv4 169.254.x.x. But is a another idea.

See the 11 comments or propose a solution >>

System Info  
Written by Drak the 20 Oct 11 at 17:16. Global category: Others. New
In KDE there is a handy utility Kinfocenter it shows a lot of information conveniently in one place. Why would in new Ubuntu System Info window also did not display some information? For novice users it will be very useful (after all, not everyone knows the appropriate terminal commands).
That's how I see it:


Also, the button "System Testing" to open Ubuntu System Test app, I think it is very good looking.
81
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Add more categories
Written by Drak the 20 Oct 11 at 17:16.
I think we need to add these categories:

Audio
Shows vendors and models of audio devices.

Disk
Shows disk vendor, mobel, size, and other information about this.

Network
Shows network adapters information (see example on first picture). "Settings" button open "Network" app for charge properties.

USB Devices, shows:
Connected USB devices.

Operation System, shows:
Version (example 11.10)
Codename (example Oneiric Ocelot)
Kernel Version (example 3.0.0-12-generic)
Hostname
Uptime (shows results of comand "uptime")
39
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Add HardInfo to Ubuntu
Written by Drak the 31 Oct 11 at 16:14.
We can add hardinfo app in ubuntu CD, so users can learn all the necessary information in a convenient form, on Live CD and after install, without any additional software.
The program is small, so that it does not take much space on the cd.


HardInfo screenshot.

See the 7 comments or propose a solution >>

Software center "For Purchase" trial version option  
Written by strongdrink the 16 Oct 11 at 02:41. Related project: Ubuntu Software Center. New
Here is one big problem with the purchasing of applications or games with the software center.. there are no trial versions. I would not like to buy an application if I don't know if I would like it.
78
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Add a 'trial edition' when the developers submit the application.
Written by strongdrink the 16 Oct 11 at 02:41.
Add a 'trial edition' when the developers submit the application. It would be nice if the developers could set an option for a trial version of their program. This would give more exposure to the program, and let the user decide if he/she would really want to buy the application.

See the 7 comments or propose a solution >>

Reset Major Ubuntu Configuration to Default  
Written by Liono the 14 Dec 11 at 10:50. Global category: System. New
Many novice Ubuntu users tend to fiddle with various configurations on Ubuntu and end up causing their machines to hardly boot or start the GUI. Common example are things like, changing graphics driver or modifying the display resolution, and so on...

Usually the fix involves only having to run one command such as removing the xorg.conf file or running "dpkg-reconfigure gdm" to rebuild the defaults, but to the mainstream, this is too daunting.

So rather than formatting, reinstalling Ubuntu, creating a new username to login with, or trying to decipher error messages and commands, I propose an easier way to reset the system into a like-new state.

Note: The following fixes should not affect users' files (home directory) or login credentials.
78
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: A One Button Reset
Written by Liono the 14 Dec 11 at 10:50.
Add a system option that deletes all configuration files as if the system was freshly installed and all hardware/drivers and settings have been reset to their defaults.
-19
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: An Option in GRUB
Written by Liono the 14 Dec 11 at 10:51.
Same as Solution #1 except that it is made available in GRUB.
65
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Selective Reset
Written by Liono the 14 Dec 11 at 10:56.
Similar to Solution #1, but allow the user to select which aspects to reset:

* Reset Graphics and Display Settings
* Reset Desktop Environment and Unity (X11, input devices)
* Reset Network (network manager and /etc/network/interfaces)
* Reset Language/Localization
* Reset Audio drivers/settings
* etc...
17
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: Stateless Boot
Written by Liono the 14 Dec 11 at 11:02.
Similar to the concept of Chromebook, allow Ubuntu to boot and detects all hardware without reading previous settings or saving new configurations. The only thing that persists are the users files in their home directory. This is mostly for recovery purposes.
-3
votes
up equal down
Solution #5: Detect Consecutive Restarts
Written by Liono the 14 Dec 11 at 11:09.
Ubuntu should be able to detect that a user has been restarting their machine several times during a very short period and suggest to reset system configurations in an attempt to fix hardware and system misconfiguration.
-36
votes
up equal down
Solution #6: Hotkeys combination
Written by checoimg the 21 Dec 11 at 15:39.
Once Logged.

Spr+Tab: Ctrl+Alt+R, Ctrl+Alt+F, Ctrl+Spr+R

The first is to make sure is not intersected by other programs. Then 3 more combinations because reseting a OS is something serious.


Keep Ubuntuing!
-4
votes
up equal down
Solution #7: Work with File system Layer
Written by AdlerHorst the 29 Dec 11 at 11:28.
After fresh installing setup a new Filesystem Layer who take all changes like Updates and configs. So booting with the Emergency bootoption start Ubuntu with out the file system Layer with the changes. The Layer itself should be mounted as a separate Harddrive. So I could do changes and repairing configs from a Working Ubuntu
15
votes
up equal down
Solution #8: Live Cd Resetting funktion
Written by crazysoldier the 1 Jan 12 at 16:24.
I think there must be a funkction in live cd for choose.
There are so "test ubuntu" "install ubuntu" and new: "restore ubuntu settings" but dont overwrite the userfiles.

See the 6 comments or propose a solution >>

Synchronise desktop settings between computers  
Written by PaddyLandau the 14 Jan 12 at 18:30. Related project: Compiz Advanced Settings (ccsm). New
For years, I have wondered about being able to sign on to any computer (even a library one) and have your own desktop appear.

Imagine my surprise when I loaded the preview version of Windows 8 in Virtual Box to find that Microsoft will be doing exactly that! Well, OK, not quite any computer, but along those lines.

(For interested parties, here is the link to Windows 8 Preview:
http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/apps/br229516
)

Microsoft's method is to let you log in to Windows using your Microsoft Live ID (subject to Administrator approval), and synchronise your desktop settings.

This is, of course, opt-in (imagine the privacy implications if it were not).

I think that Ubuntu would be well placed to do something similar.
75
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Opt-in option to synchronise your desktop settings over Ubuntu One
Written by PaddyLandau the 14 Jan 12 at 18:30.
Allow a user to "link" his desktop settings to his Ubuntu One account. The linking would allow the user to synchronise the following items (each one would have to be opt-in; none would be done by default):

* Wallpaper
* Theme
* The entire set of Compiz Config settings

(I'm open to other ideas as to what to synchronise.)

When linking a new login for the first time, the desktop would ask whether or not to synchronise each of the items (again, for privacy concerns, they would be opt-out by default).

Obviously, there would have to be a "sanity check" when synchronising onto a target machine. Thus:

* Themes would be synchronised only if the target machine supported that particular theme (so, for example, you wouldn't try to sync a 10.04 theme with its panels onto a 12.04 theme with Unity, or an imported theme onto a computer without that theme being available).

* Compiz Config settings would be synchronised only if the target machine had the same version of Ubuntu (so don't try to synchronise (say) Kubuntu with Lubuntu).

EDIT: Communications with Ubuntu One are all encrypted and stored safely. This would, of course, apply to this option.

See the 11 comments or propose a solution >>

Battery notifier could be more complete  
Written by pascalio the 16 Dec 11 at 15:58. Related project: Unity. New
On a laptop, the battery notifier is not elaborate enough since it only shows the current prognostics for the remaining time on battery power when you click on it, which does tell the actual current status of the battery.
71
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Show percentage as well
Written by pascalio the 16 Dec 11 at 15:58.
Show a more objective indicator as well (perhaps within brackets), such as the percentage of the battery that is remaining, as it can be found if you travel to the history tab of the power statistics.
24
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Show direct readings from sensors in System Monitor
Written by ross9885 the 24 Dec 11 at 19:10.
Graph battery voltage and current draw in the System Monitor and it's applet. Allow the user the opportunity to figure out clever ways of conserving power based on real data from their machine.

See the 2 comments or propose a solution >>

New users need a simple default option that will set up a separate /home  
Written by fabricator4 the 23 Dec 11 at 18:59. Related project: Live CD installer. New
Experienced users will usually set up a separate /home partition because it makes re-installation and recovery of the root system partition so much easier. New users however need a simple option that will do the same thing for them the first time they install Ubuntu.

Anyone providing support on forums such as Launchpad Questions and Ubuntu Forums knows that a common problem is inexperienced or careless users not doing sufficient backups before attempting an on-line upgrade or other modification of their system. Damaged file systems where /home is on the / partition can make recovery of data quite difficult, especially when trying to coach someone through the forums. Having a separate /home partition would reduce the risk to the user's data and would in most cases reduce the system recovery to a re-installation of the system on the / partition.

While this idea has been proposed in years past, the proposed implementations have been elaborate and the objections to the them don't do justice to either the needs of new users or the abilities of experienced users. While a new user won't have any idea themselves about the best way to set up / and /home partitions, all that is really required (for the average new desktop user) is a 15Gb / partition and the rest allocated for /home. We don't need to over think this but the need for it to be implemented is quite desperate since it will give new Linux users a more robust system that is easier to maintain in the long term, and will reduce the burden on volunteers providing support in forums such as Launchpad Questions and Ubuntu Forums.

In the past objections have included things like concerns over the configuration not being suitable for large database users. Such users would not be considered inexperienced since the use of large databases, server setups or other dedicated systems is really the requirement of an experienced user and they will set the system up manually to suit the task requirements. Inexperienced users attempting such configurations would be setting up test systems first to explore the possibilities, and would quickly gain experience in this aspect of system configuration. In short, they are not what anyone would consider a 'normal' desktop user.

Another objection to this idea has been that it would be too difficult for users to change the partition sizes if that needed to. 15Gb would be quite sufficient for a new user to install Ubuntu and a great many programs from the repositories, while at the same time being a rather insignificant amount of space to use on modern hard drives. In addition to this, providing that both partitions are next to each other and either both primary partitions or on the same extended partition resizing is a simple matter with Gparted: this is much easier than deciding after installation that a separate /home is required and (1) Resizing and moving partitions to make space (2) Creating a new partition for /home, (3)setting up the new home to be recognized by Ubuntu (fstab) and (4) migrating all the user's data to the new partition.

[....]
62
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Have an option in the installer to set up a separate /home
Written by fabricator4 the 23 Dec 11 at 18:59.
For systems where there is already an operating system, give the option to install alongside with a separate /home partition where the total space that can allocated is greater than 30Gb+swap. The partitions would therefore be set up with 15Gb for the / partition and the rest for /home.

For systems where the user will select "Use entire disk", set up the root partition as 15Gb and use the rest of the disk for /home.
36
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Ask the user if they want a separate /home
Written by fabricator4 the 23 Dec 11 at 19:06.
Leave the 'install alongside' and 'use entire disk' options as they currently are, but subsequently ask the user if they want to set up a separate /home partition and suggest the relevant size (ie 15Gb / and the rest for /home). This question could be in the form of asking the user how big to make the / partition (15Gb suggested).
5
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Default option during Ubuntu install: setup /home partition when it's not there
Written by turbolad the 26 Dec 11 at 16:25.
The default settings are created in mind for newbies and less experienced users.

There are so many benefits of using a separate /home partition and this would keep the users personal files (and every program's settings for each user) intact regardless of installing Ubuntu cleanly.

Advanced users can choose not to have a separate /home partition (but then again, I'm sure most advanced users DO have a separate /home partition!).

See the 15 comments or propose a solution >>

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... Next >>