Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 22700 ideas, 138270 comments, 2629576 votes
Idea sandbox Idea sandbox
Popular ideas Popular ideas
Ideas in development Ideas in development
Implemented ideas Implemented ideas

Ideas in development Here are ideas about Ubuntu that have been marked as not following the guidelines by the moderators.

Remove PulseAudio from Ubuntu  
Written by premamotion the 1 Jan 10 at 12:07. Global category: Multimedia. Not an idea
PulseAudio is not working out of the box... what is so hard to understand here? More and more people are complaining about it, and about the problems that PulseAudio is creating to other programs ex. Skype...

PulseAudio makes Ubuntu, and Linux new users go away, and return to MS Windows... That`s not possible, friends...
-14
votes
closed
Solution #1: Remove PulseAudio as the default sound manager
Written by premamotion the 1 Jan 10 at 12:07.
Remove PulseAudio as the default sound manager and go with Alsa.
8
votes
closed
Solution #2: Fix PulseAudio problems
Written by Haku the 1 Jan 10 at 21:19.
As a title.
-1
votes
closed
Solution #3: Allow to disabling/enabling PulseAudio.
Written by Lachu the 1 Jan 10 at 22:11.
Simple allow to enabling/disabling PulseAudio for alsa(pulseaudio as backend).
5
votes
closed
Solution #4: Package PulseAudio the right way
Written by jeypeyy the 1 Jan 10 at 23:55.
One of the PulseAudio developers, Lennart Poettering, is accusing Ubuntu for not packaging PulseAudio the right way, making people think it's his fault. You can read about that here: http://0pointer.de/blog/projects/pa-in-ubuntu.html

So, just listen to Lennart Poettering and use the patch.

(Note that this is just a more detailed solution of #2)

See the 6 comments or propose a solution >>

Listen mic and line in  
Written by DINAMIK the 20 Mar 12 at 18:55. Related project: Gnome. Not an idea
I think that ubuntu should provide an easy way to listen your devices, for example a mic and all line in devices. I have tried to do that in pangolin and it was imposible. many users suggest to download jackd and make a connection. that's unnaceptable.
0
votes
closed
Solution #1: add more options in the audio panel
Written by DINAMIK the 20 Mar 12 at 18:55.
add some options in the audio panel in order to listen this device or someting like that.

See the 1 comments or propose a solution >>

equalizer for rhythmbox  
Written by roemer2201 the 12 Mar 08 at 06:41. Global category: Multimedia. Not an idea
There should be an equalizer in ryhthmbox music player so that everyone can set the sound-output for his personal needs.

Maybe create some default-settings like rock, metal, jazz, classic ...
134
votes
closed
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #4341
Written by roemer2201 the 12 Mar 08 at 06:41.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #4341 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!

See the 29 comments or propose a solution >>

Maintain Nightingale or Songbird  
Written by Pander the 6 Sep 11 at 08:16. Global category: Multimedia. Not an idea
Songbird http://getsongbird.com/ is for me and many more the preferred audio player in Ubuntu. It is build upon Mozilla's XUL framework and offers plenty of useful add-ons. Because it is cross platform, one can also use it on Windows, Mac OS-X, Android, etc. Perfect when you have or want to work on multiple platforms.

However, Songbird has terminated official support for the Linux build http://blog.songbirdnest.com/2010/04/02/songbird-singing-a-new-tune/ Nevertheless it is possible to install and use it on Linux via this package http://www.getdeb.net/updates/Ubuntu/10.10/?q=songbird or by building it yourself from source.

Also a port was made especially for Linux called Nightingale http://getnightingale.com/ but that project has stalled.

Thus, many users are stuck with an old version or Songbird with an uncertain future. Do they have to start looking at (yet) another audio player? Will they be able to migrate ratings, album art, play lists and play history which are not stored in ID3 tags? Will they loose their precious collection that took so long to organise?

The latter being non-trivial and task for experienced programmers as I experienced migrating from Amarok to Songbird. PS I due like Amarok but don't want KDE... no offence intended.

The idea is to have Ubuntu offer a solution for this situation.
0
votes
closed
Solution #1: Package Songbird
Written by Pander the 6 Sep 11 at 08:16.
0
votes
closed
Solution #2: Persuade Songbird to support Linux
Written by Pander the 6 Sep 11 at 08:18.
A dialogue could be started with Songbird to support Linux once again. Perhaps Ubuntu request can make a difference in this. It is a bit sad that Songbird does not support Linux even though it is popular with any Ubuntu users and is build on the cross platform XUL framework and even capable of handling cross application add-ons with Firefox and Thunderbird.
0
votes
closed
Solution #3: Complete Nightingale
Written by Pander the 6 Sep 11 at 08:29.
Support the development and release of Nightingale, which is mainly a Linux port of Songbird code. Keep it in sync and compatible with the Songbird releases.
0
votes
closed
Solution #4: Offer migration script
Written by Pander the 6 Sep 11 at 08:39.
Offer well tested scripts to migrate audio metadata such as ratings, album art, play lists and play history to other open source cross platform audio players. However, not any cross platoform open source audio players are out there with functionality Songbird is offering.

See the 2 comments or propose a solution >>

better audiobook support  
Written by brianbourke75 the 20 Dec 08 at 00:09. Related project: Banshee Music Player. Not an idea
I would like there to be a "special" section in an media player (I don't really care which one) which has some special support for audio books. The features that I am thinking of...

1) A separate section so that they have their own organization as well as not in the shuffle queue of music files.

2) Save the current play location for each of the files so you can return to your location in the book even after listening to something else.

3) Extending Ogg Vorbis media files so they support audio book specific meta-data. For example the time stamp location for each chapter in the book, Read by, etc)

4) Ripping into a single file, or perhaps treating a series of audio files as a single source.

Perhaps some of this applies to audiobooks as well.
18
votes
closed
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #16654
Written by brianbourke75 the 20 Dec 08 at 00:09.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #16654 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!

See the 1 comments or propose a solution >>

Since it is the default audio player, why Totem's name is "movie player" ?  
Written by lalejand the 14 Oct 08 at 23:19. Related project: Totem Movie Player. Not an idea
It should be "multimedia player" or "audio/video player" or "media player" (as mrdoob proposed).
---------------
Puisque Totem est le lecteur audio par défaut, pourquoi s'appelle-t-il "lecteur vidéo" ?
Ça devrait être "lecteur multimédia" ou "lecteur audio/vidéo", ...
195
votes
closed
Solution #1: Name it "Multimedia player"
Written by lalejand the 14 Oct 08 at 23:19.
Name it "Multimedia player"
--------------
L'appeler "Lecteur multimedia"
-9
votes
closed
Solution #2: Name it "Audio/Video Player"
Written by lalejand the 14 Jan 09 at 15:40.
Name it "Audio/Video Player"
-----------
L'appeler "Lecteur Audio/Video"
63
votes
closed
Solution #3: Call it 'Media Player'
Written by ryanli the 8 Jul 09 at 09:29.
Rename "Movie Player" to "Media Player" in menus, and titles.
-23
votes
closed
Solution #4: Solution #2: Call it 'Totem Player'
Written by radi8 the 10 Jul 09 at 07:50.
Rename "Movie Player" to "Totem" or "totem Player" in menus, and titles. The "real" name is fine and I don't understand the reason of changing that anyway....
113
votes
closed
Solution #5: Call it 'Totem Media Player'
Written by mac9416 the 11 Jul 09 at 12:06.
AndrewLuecke mentioned that perhaps just "Totem Player" wouldn't work because many beginners don't know what Totem Player does.
It would be a compromise between calling it the less misleading "Media Player" and using the actual name, "Totem Player".

See the 11 comments or propose a solution >>

Dual sound? (e.g. firefox + vlc)  
Written by Ogar the 27 Sep 08 at 18:55. Global category: Multimedia. Not an idea
Well e.g. if I has watched a video with sound on youtube , and then leaves youtube and then tries to play an audio file in vlc , then it won't play? Only if i kill the firefox process!

The same problem occurs if i go the other way around (first vlc = ok, then firefox wont play if i dont kill vlc)

Fix this!
7
votes
closed
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #13791
Written by Ogar the 27 Sep 08 at 18:55.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #13791 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!

See the 5 comments or propose a solution >>

Abadie.jo  
Written by temps the 21 Jun 11 at 13:42. Related project: Audacity. Not an idea
Abadie.jo is an audio format who models the sound.
My work is here :
http://www.letime.net/legere/
This format can be read by Audio linux a electronics card audio to make.
0
votes
closed
Solution #1: why and how
Written by temps the 21 Jun 11 at 13:42.
Actually the sound is How !!!
This is not good.
I make why and I have a better sound much lighter
Sorry I speak only french, so I can not say it better

See the 2 comments or propose a solution >>

Audio subsystem is a mess!  
Written by r0g the 27 Jul 09 at 17:00. Global category: Quality. Not an idea
It's the year 2009, why are we still troubleshooting audio recording problems!? For nearly 15 years, assuming you have the right driver installed, recording some audio in Windows has been as simple as firing up sndrec32.exe and hitting record. There's little to no messing around with config to get it working, no ALSA vs Pulse, no choice of 3 different mixers, it just works.

While I'm sure many of you record audio out of the box I have had nothing but trouble getting audacity (the main open source audio editor) to record and edit sound without crashing in Ubuntu, on several machines, on both HArdy and Jaunty. It seems from a brief google hundreds of other people also struggle with this on a daily basis. This is something I had no problem doing back on Windows 98 over a decade ago, it makes the Ubuntu desktop look really bad that we haven't got this together on the cusp of the second decade of the 21st century!
0
votes
closed
Solution #1: Simplifying the audio subsystem and making it rock solid should be top priority.
Written by r0g the 27 Jul 09 at 17:00.
I think far more work and testing needs to be done on the audio subsystem, something as pivotal as this shouldn't be so flaky and hard to use these days, it needs to be simple (one single mixer!) and 'forget it exists' stable.

It seems to me that Linux desktops have a 'good enough' philosophy e.g. if it's good enough to playback sound on Youtube clips then no more work needs to be done because that's what 95% of people want. I think this is one of the biggest reasons serious audio/video software doesn't get made for Linux. We haven't got a single professional grade Audio/Video editor available to buy today, let alone a decent open source one, because wise men don't build their houses on sand!


See the 4 comments or propose a solution >>

Keep Rhythmbox don't move to worse alternatives  
Written by vexorian the 27 May 09 at 13:11. Related project: Gnome. Not an idea
It has come to my attention ( so called blockers can be found at http://pastebin.com/m39042b41 ) that there are plans to move from Rhythmbox to Banshee in either "Karmic Koala" or "Lame Llama"

Let me show strong opposition. Regardless of the arguable yet significant issues both legal and practical with the mere inclusion of Mono apps in the default (I personally think the best path is to get rid of these apps from the default, not to add more) There's also another issue... I like Rhythmbox .

It is not just for technical issues such as "Banshee uses twice as much memory as Rhythmbox" It is also because of the cleaner interface and that in many ways it follows the ubuntu philosophy much better. Regardless, I do not think I a am alone, as noticeable in Idea #18932 There's strong opposition to switching from this app. Instead, what the community wants is that ubuntu sticks to rhythmbox and keep improving it.

It is a little frightening that these decisions are being taken out of artificial advantages such as theorically saving 6.1 MB, The Mono runtime itself adds to much heavier space requirements than Rhythmbox.

PS: What's the message Canonical would be giving to the world if we need MS technology even for basic apps such as music libraries? I mean, really...

Developer comments
This is not an idea. If you want Ubuntu to ship Rhythmbox as its default jukebox, contribute to Rhythmbox and make it better than the alternatives. —mpt
46
votes
closed
Solution #5: Offer Banshee in repositories, Rythmbox by default
Written by diegoj the 9 Jun 09 at 15:56.
Keep Rythmbox and improve it, instead replacing it with a heavier application.

See the 29 comments or propose a solution >>

2 3 Next >>