Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 21986 ideas, 135057 comments, 2615221 votes
Idea sandbox Idea sandbox
Popular ideas Popular ideas
Ideas in development Ideas in development
Implemented ideas Implemented ideas

Ideas in development Here are ideas about Ubuntu that have been marked as already implemented by the moderators.

Run thorough User Test  
Written by Allards the 20 May 12 at 17:50. Related project: Unity. Already implemented
I'm a Mac OS and was a Windows user. I'm trying Ubuntu 12.04 on my iMac a lot to love, but also so much to be disturbed about.

I'm keeping a list with annoying issues, (things that are broken in the interface) in 3 days the list filled up with over 50 issues and inconsistencies.

This makes me wonder, does Canonical run user test? And if they do with whom DEVS? "They'd better bring me in" because obviously it's not being pointed out where Ubuntu falls short in the Interface and user interaction. Even it might be 500 to 1000 things that needs to be fixed, this Ubuntu version is closer then ever to be usable by i wider audience.

Please Canonical run professional usability tests and explicitly EXLUDE DEVS and Ubuntu Gurus from those test!
0
votes
closed
Solution #1: Run test with non devs
Written by Allards the 20 May 12 at 17:50.
Test usability with a wide audience (seniors,random people, Windows / Mac user from all walks of life) Make it independent from development.

See the 7 comments or propose a solution >>

New users need to download release ISO then 150+Mbytes of updates  
Written by IanWatters the 20 May 12 at 17:39. Related project: Live CD. Already implemented
Particularly when you have a slow internet connection or limited disc space, the current situation of having to download an out of date release ISO and then all the subsequent updates is far from optimal.

A week ago, I needed to install Ubuntu 12.04 LTS on a PC with a slow internet connection for someone. It took a while for the .ISO file to download.

When it did, a problem with the installer meant I could not get past the partition and user setup screens. The error reporting program complained various packages were not up to date and so was unable to submit a report.

I noticed there were updates, and went to download all 150M bytes or so of them. Most had been downloaded when the file system space when running the live CD ran out.

So I needed to get the alternative .ISO. That took a while to download. It worked. But then I needed to download 150M bytes or so of updates. Again.

As the months go by, this problem will get worse as more updates are released. 12.04.1 et seq will be a partial solution, but this is not usually done for non-LTS releases.

0
votes
closed
Solution #1: Have latest.iso available to download
Written by IanWatters the 20 May 12 at 17:39.
What I should have been able to do: download an up to date ISO with all packages no older than 24 hours old.

Proposal: in addition to the standard ISOs, one which includes the updates to the included packages is built (automatically?) at least once each day. Users will then be able to download it and be reasonably sure that it will be up to date as downloaded and they will not need to download another few hundred megabytes of updates immediately after installation.

Because these ISOs will not have the amount of testing that the standard release ISOs have, they may fail in some way. But people should have the choice between going for the thoroughly tested but known to be out of date (and sometimes known to contain versions of packages with security issues) official release ISO and a less tested but (almost) up to date one.

As a side effect, it will also lessen the bandwidth requirements on the Ubuntu servers and their mirrors: 700 < 700+150.

See the 5 comments or propose a solution >>

Uramdisk  
Written by NomadDemon the 17 Apr 12 at 12:29. Global category: System. Already implemented
HDD I/O is slow, on old computers [mostly found in small bussines companies] needs to be speeded up.


Nowadays we have tons of free ram like 6 gb 8 gb, why dont use part of it like ramdisk/"swap"

just need to add litle program to ubuntu default instalation, to build a ramdisk and then ability to prefetch full program what user use.

ramdisk-> create
prepopulate on every boot -> select a app name/ folder with files

it will greatly reduce load time of programs, but increase boot time a bit.

in corporations users use like 2-3 programs so preloaded to ram would be nice

in case of security maybe add auto checking the content of folder and backup it every 5 minutes to original folder on HDD [diff backup]

after "preloading" folder or programm, make a symlink to ramdisk, not the normal disk.

0
votes
closed
Solution #1: preloading using ramdisk
Written by NomadDemon the 17 Apr 12 at 12:29.
preloading using ramdisk with userfrieldly wizard, for every user on system
http://i.imgur.com/uKEvn.png

See the 4 comments or propose a solution >>

Out of Date Ubuntu Games  
Ubuntu

In :  
Priority : Undefined
Definition : New (Needs guidance)
Implementation : Unknown
Assignee :
spec
forum
Written by MighMoS the 28 Feb 08 at 16:35. Global category: Gaming. Already implemented
Many games feature the ability to play with other people. However, the first thing the game will check for is to see if it is currently up to date.

When Ubuntu enters version freeze, the games fall out of date, and it can be harder to play them online without finding a 3rd party update or compiling it yourself (Freeciv, Scorched3D, and Battle for Wesnoth to name a few).

This also creates issues when different distributions freeze at different times, so it can be hard to play with other Linux users.
2180
votes
closed
Solution #1: New Official Ubuntu Gaming Repository
Written by MighMoS the 28 Feb 08 at 16:35.
Ubuntu should provide a repository for up to date games for games that will always need the latest version to play online.
59
votes
closed
Solution #2: Promote Playdeb
Written by Clorox the 21 Jun 09 at 02:46.
Playdeb is a .deb repository of games for Ubuntu. It has some good games and stays up-to-date.

Site: http://www.playdeb.net/
1
votes
closed
Solution #3: Use Backports
Written by ChrisB the 18 Apr 10 at 15:32.
The backports repository is official and contains up to date software. For more info see here: https://help.ubuntu.com/community/UbuntuBackports

See the 32 comments or propose a solution >>

Brainstorm : allowing submiters to edit their post  
Written by Marchombre the 6 Mar 08 at 15:40. Related project: brainstorm.ubuntu.com. Already implemented
As we always do typing error, or remember too late something very important to add, why not allowing us to edit our own ideas, or comments ?
I don't think that it would make too much abuse... as every forum (at least good forums) allow it.

[EDIT] Sry useless, it's already possible...
-24
votes
closed
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #3549
Written by Marchombre the 6 Mar 08 at 15:40.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #3549 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!

See the 5 comments or propose a solution >>

The posibility to add/remove lenses for the dash from the Ubuntu Software Center  
Written by idude.aldunate the 6 May 12 at 20:07. Related project: Unity. Already implemented
On OMGUbuntu i read an article about "adding a wikipedia lens" to the dash. It would be so cool if we could add/remove lenses from the U.S.C. There should be a Lenses Section and also, the ability of enabling/disabling them from the appearance section from the System Settings. Lenses functionalities could go from searching items on gmail to looking info at Wikipedia and updating your facebook/google+ status.
0
votes
closed
Solution #1: Integrate Lenses section at Ubuntu Software Center & customization at settings
Written by idude.aldunate the 6 May 12 at 20:07.
Integrate Lenses section at the Ubuntu Software Center and customization in the Settings section.

See the 2 comments or propose a solution >>

internet intergration in dash enable and disable option  
Written by simpleperopogi the 13 May 12 at 14:23. Related project: Unity. Already implemented
What is Internet Intergration? internet intergration means listing files,applications,etc in the dash from the internet (means its not in the hard drive its in the internet). hard to understand? IN SHORT ABILITY TO REMOVE "APPLICATIONS AVAILABLE FOR DOWNLOAD CATEGORY" in software category and "FOR PURCHASE CATEGORY" in music category. Many people only want to see applications,music,videos,etc in the dash that are in there hard drive and not from the internet.
0
votes
closed
Solution #1: add option in ubuntu settings
Written by simpleperopogi the 13 May 12 at 14:23.
add an option in ubuntu settings in which to enable it or not.

See the 1 comments or propose a solution >>

Ubuntu should warn if your IP is in conflict  
Written by lotif the 20 Aug 10 at 19:51. Related project: Network Manager. Already implemented
Right now, if you manually set an IP in Ubuntu and if this IP is already registered in your network, or if somebody try to pick your IP by mistake or something, Ubuntu simply does nothing and let you without internet and without knowing what's going on. That's not right.
490
votes
closed
Solution #1: Ubuntu should warn that your IP is in conflict in the network
Written by lotif the 20 Aug 10 at 19:51.
A little warning and a red sign next to the connection indicator means a lot in usability.

A picture is worth a 1000 words.


63
votes
closed
Solution #2: Add help link/button to #1 solution with #3
Written by Oxwivi the 24 Aug 10 at 08:16.
A non-technical and standard user will not understand what to do in such a situation. A fix button bay help, but if it doesn't, a help link/button would go a long way to solve the problem.
160
votes
closed
Solution #3: Add Fix button to solution #1
Written by DaedalusPrime the 24 Aug 10 at 11:58.
Clicking the "FIX" button would attempt to change the IP address automatically by 1) if DHCP is enabled, renew the IP, or 2) if not DHCP, perform a search for an IP that appears to be open on the current subnet, using ipwatchd or a similar mechanism.
87
votes
closed
Solution #4: Make IPwatchD a default app
Written by lotif the 24 Aug 10 at 13:27.
As some pointed out, there's already an app out there which makes the job pretty well: IPwatchD. Let's make it a default app!



The only drawback I see is that the warnings aren't any further than this message. It should add an icon below the connection icon, like in Solution #1.

To install it, go to http://ipwatchd.sourceforge.net/ or just search for ipwatch on synaptic.
-44
votes
closed
Solution #5: Just fix it (and report it)
Written by ivanpd the 30 Aug 10 at 14:42.
I think part of the Ubuntu philosophy is that the user will be provided with a reasonable solution that works in most cases by default. Instead of complaining and allowing the user to fix it, I think the right approach would be:
- If DHCP is enabled, request a new IP with no user intervention.
- If DHCP is not enabled, allow the user to fix it automatically (as described in #3, no-dhcp) or to change the configuration by hand.

I don't have the time to draw anything (help is welcome to show this idea), but something similar to the pic in #1 with the text "Enable automatic fix or change settings by hand" would do.

Regarding the design, I think "Enable automatic fix" and "change settings by hand" could both have the appearance of web links (instead of buttons).
-51
votes
closed
Solution #6: Display "network misconfiguration" message + disable networking
Written by amay82 the 1 Sep 10 at 14:23.
If someone picks an IP address manually, (s)he should know what (s)he is doing, so a generalised "network misconfiguration" message + disabling the network should be enough. The rest can be seen in the system logs.

See the 22 comments or propose a solution >>

When you voted by mistake you can't withdraw your vote  
Written by t4ggs the 22 Feb 09 at 19:06. Related project: brainstorm.ubuntu.com. Category: Ideas/comments moderation. Already implemented
I voted in one idea bye mistake, and then I read again the idea and found that I didn't meant to vote, and not against, i'm not for, and im not indifferent, I just didn't understand the idea so i think the best to do is to withdraw the vote instead of clicking on the orange square...
-7
votes
closed
Solution #1: Clicking back in the same icon should withdraw yout vote
Written by t4ggs the 22 Feb 09 at 19:06.
...have said.
13
votes
closed
Solution #2: Vote unclear
Written by kidmodify the 24 Feb 09 at 04:16.
You should be able to vote "reword" or "unclear".
This is a good way for the writer of the solution to know if his or her solution is being understood by his fellow brainstormers. Then the solution can be changed to be more clear.

However this should only be used in cases when the solution is unclear in what it is asking and not in cases where the person doesn't understand the subject.
For example, if the solution is about using case statements as appose to using if statements, anyone doesn't know about programming languages should not vote unclear because they don't understand the subject. They should just scroll down to the next solution.

Yes I know that the author of the solution could just read the comments and and see if anyone has posted anything, but not everyone who votes comments, and it would also be nice to see how confused the public is about your solutions on your dashboard graph.
It also would be easier for moderators to keep an eye on what needs correcting if the author doesn't see it or care. This also helps eliminate those who vote solutions down because they don't understand.

How it should be handled visually.
1. Another bar under the green red and orange one (recommended)
2. Percent of people that do understand under the green red orange bar.(base on a ratio of how many have voted up,down, don't care and how many voted unclear)
3. Something else
6
votes
closed
Solution #3: Change "I don't care" to blank vote
Written by Primož Papič the 24 Feb 09 at 21:29.
I believe that "I don't care" is harsh and mostly dosen't represent the vote 0. I vote many things 0 not because I don't care mostly because I cant really decide or it's ambiguous.
So I would rather see that 0 would represent blank vote.
As most voting systems know it in some form...
Lets say you're on elections of some sort or on referenda.
You can either vote yes, no or just cast a blank ballot which represents that you agree with neither...
So 0 would represent blank vote and if a voter felt that he or she needs to explain it it can be done in comments.
I personally think that this is the best way.

See the 7 comments or propose a solution >>

The name "Kubuntu" & logo detracts from the image of the distro  
Written by James_Lochhead the 22 Apr 09 at 11:59. Related project: Kubuntu. Already implemented
The name Ubuntu actually means something ("Humanity to others"), there is a point to its name.


The name Kubuntu and the Kubuntu logo (a variation on Ubuntu's) gives an image that Kubuntu is the not quite so well liked/popular version of Ubuntu. This infers that Kubuntu comes second to Ubuntu.

Kubuntu needs an image of its own.
0
votes
closed
Solution #1: Change Kubuntu's name
Written by James_Lochhead the 22 Apr 09 at 11:59.
Change Kubuntu's name to something with meaning, something with an African theme and a similar meaning to Ubuntu.

The name "Kubuntu" would not have to be completely deprecated. It should remain as a non-official name.
0
votes
closed
Solution #2: Change Kubuntu's logo
Written by James_Lochhead the 22 Apr 09 at 12:05.
Dramatically change the Kubuntu logo to be significantly different from Ubuntu's. I think it should remain as some kind of muti-coloured shape though.

See the 5 comments or propose a solution >>

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... Next >>