nand(Brainstorm admin)
wrote on the 25 May 08 at 18:53
This is indeed quite an accomplishment : one million votes in around three months, that's quite something!
But the number of votes is only one of the factors that would make Brainstorm a success. One of the other factors is the usefulness of Brainstorm for the developers. At the moment, it is not optimal: a good portion of the ideas concerns specific piece of software, and there is no easy way to "tag" an idea to a software. That's something we are working on.
The bottom line is, we have reached one of our goals (popularity), but there are still some improvements needed!
Many people suggest ideas, but do nothing to promote or implement it (even if you don't know how to implement it, you should find someone which is interested in implementing your idea).
ofir_k, I don't think that was nand's point. He was just saying that there is no efficient way to channel Brainstorm info to developers on individual projects and that we need improvement there.
There is no reason to think that users who suggest ideas have or should have the ability to get them implemented (either by persuation or own direct efforts).
As nand says we need a way to categorize ideas by applications in cases where that makes sense (some ideas are not application specific, like this one...)
Brainstorm development has progressed so quickly though that I have no doubt they will add this in the near future.