Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 15804 ideas, 78175 comments, 1425990 votes

Idea #8737: Provide a web service to convert files to open formats



up
31
down
Written by SchwarzeKrause the 17 May 08 at 22:21. Category: Marketing.
Related to: Nothing/Others. Status: New
Description
As I understand, using closed codecs literally means breaking the law even while playing legal media in some countries. So, the current situation with Ubuntu is full of hypocrisy. Ubuntu's CD doesn't include illegal software, but every user would likely download and install it right after the installation is through. Fluendo codecs are an alternative, but a weak one.
Another point, is that the user is forced to use OpenOffice just because other products can't work with MS formats well. This is also inconvenient, since there are some lightweight solutions that can work with OASIS ODF and thus allow user to do all the basic tasks. And, after all, Office 2003 formats aren't supported even by OpenOffice at the moment.
Finally, the archive formats - rar, ace, arj, which also could be converted to zip or tar.gz2 or whatever.
So here is my suggestion on how to promote open technologies.
At the moment, there are already some web services to convert documents (or even music) from one format to another. For example, http://koolwire.com
So, what I am talking about, is a web-service, that would allow to convert audio files to OGG Vorbis and FLAC, video to OGG Theora, Microsoft Office files to OASIS ODF (and PDF, in case the conversion cannot be done well for some files). And it would be very nice, if the service would be integrated into the user's environment. So the software necessary for conversion would be installed only on those servers, which can be located in countries where patent issues are not a problem.
Probably, this initiative requires some really mighty servers, but I guess that this can be done on behalf of the Open Source community on the whole, not just Ubuntu/Canonical, so the funds necessary would be raised and the service will be free of charge. After all it's a real opprotunity to promote free standarts.
Tags: (none)

Attachments
No attachments.


Duplicates


Comments
Eldmannen wrote on the 18 May 08 at 01:25
Converting should only be done from a lossless source.

Transcoding from a lossy source sucks.

pimlottc wrote on the 18 May 08 at 04:51
This would likely require enormous resources and could open up some legal issues.

derubermensch wrote on the 18 May 08 at 05:34
Transcoding from compressed source to compressed source lowers end result quality. Also, as much as I like the notion of open formats, Theora is a terrible alternative to MPEG-4 ASP.

SchwarzeKrause wrote on the 18 May 08 at 10:15
Well, if one wants to have superior quality, he can spend 28 euros on Fluendo codecs pack, which works only with gstreamer-based apps. Again, it's absolutely incovenient for KDE users and more.
Besides, no one noticed the other points - Office, and (which I updated a bit later), archive formats.
BTW, derubermensch, what's so bad about Theora?


Post your comment