Idea
#7669: Make Ubuntu perfect and run on all computer
|
| |
160
|
|
|
Written by yekcim the 26 Apr 08 at 18:59.
Category: Brainstorm.
Related to:
Nothing/Others.
Status: New
|
|
|
Description
The title is an example of idea i think Brainstorm have to hide : Some ideas are too logical.
Examples :
- Add software 2.0 and not software 1.9
- Support acpi
- Speed Up boot time
- Better wi-fi support
- ...
In fact, these ideas are good ideas and everyone will vote for. But little ideas but good ideas are hidden because can't obtain same scores.
We can vote "for" or "against" an idea. We could clic on a "too logical" button and if "too logical" have a important score we hide this ideas. A visitor could watch all ideas, but by defaut done and "too logical" should be hides.
Tags:
(none)
Attachments
No attachments.
Duplicates
Comments
|
retj wrote on the 26 Apr 08 at 21:12
| |
isn't this idea a sum of all most voted ideas on brainstorm? makes not much sense to vote for it...
|
|
yekcim wrote on the 26 Apr 08 at 21:24
| |
retj > Read the text, not only the title !
|
|
GuyKPADJIK wrote on the 26 Apr 08 at 21:56
| |
Very good idea
|
|
tromboneman wrote on the 26 Apr 08 at 21:59
|
Do you really think you are the first one to ever even consider this idea? There are an uncountable number of developers working on the GNU project, the Linux kernel, all of the applications included in the repos, and Ubuntu itself. Do you really believe they wouldn't make their respective projects "perfect" if they could?
|
|
wearzeep wrote on the 27 Apr 08 at 01:14
|
Wtf people, read the description..
Although the title is misleading because you think some idiot posted it, even if you later read that it is an example.
Well anyway, good idea.
|
|
jimmux wrote on the 27 Apr 08 at 02:29
|
Yeh, the description pretty much sums up the problem with brainstorm. Too many ideas are not really ideas at all. More like obvious requests which get voted up because they are so obvious that nobody is going to disagree.
So, can we now just mark all those "ideas" as duplicates of this idea? ;)
|
|
glibik wrote on the 27 Apr 08 at 02:34
|
I had to read the description about a dozen times to try to figure out what the idea actually is.
Am pretty sure I have it now, so please indulge me while I summarise; Any ideas that are obvious (as yekcim says "too logical") should hidden. Reasoning is that there is no point having them as candidates for votes because, as tromboneman suggests, all developers are already trying to "make their respective projects perfect".
Must admit I'm getting pretty tired of seeing the same suggestions being made over and over. Don't know haw many times "Speed up booting" and "better wi-fi support" have been suggested. :-( There have also been a tediously large number of "include ver Y instead of ver X" suggestions. :-\
Vote = +1
|
|
_sebastian_ wrote on the 27 Apr 08 at 06:12
|
@glibik: I had to read it as well a couple of times...
@yekcim: maybe you could edit your initial post and clarify on some aspects thus making you idea more puplar by easy reading :-)
If Idea Is
hide ideas which are common sense ideas (like create best OS ever)
then
Vote = +1
else
please explain idea better...
|
|
linbai wrote on the 27 Apr 08 at 07:12
| |
Sweet 8 lbs 7 oz. baby Jesus... I have seen this post up here all day and had no idea what the hell the guy was talking about. Then, in a poof of magic, my third eye opened and I understand. Its beautiful in fact. Yes, I agree, we should hide posts which are too vague. This is just a little too Zen though. +1
|
|
HermanChess wrote on the 27 Apr 08 at 08:08
| |
This idea is too logical!
|
|
freezz wrote on the 27 Apr 08 at 08:18
| |
I kind of agree with this but when you see that the most popular idea ever is "Fix Suspend and Hibernate" you kind of think that is too logical, but it seriously need to be voted for so it gets fixed. Hide those "too logical ideas" would hide a problem that really needs to be addressed.
|
|
Bristow wrote on the 27 Apr 08 at 08:26
| |
Good idea !
|
|
yekcim wrote on the 27 Apr 08 at 09:09
| |
tromboneman > I'm not stupid, you just don't read my idea, only the title.
|
|
gmarketer wrote on the 27 Apr 08 at 09:32
|
voted down
freezz, +500 to you :)
|
|
gmatht wrote on the 27 Apr 08 at 12:13
|
Who gets to hide the "too logical ideas"?
Also, too logical ideas can still be useful. For example if "Speed Up boot time" gets 3000 votes and "Better wi-fi support" gets 3 this might suggest that speeding up boot time should be prioritized over better wi-fi support.
Perhaps instead of having "too logical" ideas, we could have difficulties. We could approximate the priority of an idea as the number of votes divided by the difficulty, so that a semi-popular idea that requires a one line config change is ranked above "make Ubuntu perfect".
|
|
Auzy wrote on the 27 Apr 08 at 12:31
|
Big +1. And I suggest merging with http://brainstorm.ubuntu.com/idea/4730/
Some of these ideas are specific enough though..
like: support wireless better means nothing.
Support Atheros wireless better is ok.
|
|
scamper_22 wrote on the 28 Apr 08 at 02:12
|
While this simplicity of brainstorm is great (just vote up or down), I think we can also have a bunch of advanced tags to redirect the entry.
For example:
Application bug (for application specific bugs)
Application feature
Too Obvious (as per this entry)
...
|
|
Arnaudus wrote on the 28 Apr 08 at 15:43
| |
Nice idea, but next time you'll chose a better title. There are thousands of ideas, it's a matter of respect helping people to understand what you mean as easily as possible. If you don't manage to make it clear, you just deserve a poor score.
|
Post your comment
|
|
|
