Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 21986 ideas, 135057 comments, 2615221 votes
Idea sandbox Idea sandbox
Popular ideas Popular ideas
Ideas in development Ideas in development
Implemented ideas Implemented ideas
Idea #6790: Password asking when you move/copy files to protected folder

Written by gio91ber the 10 Apr 08 at 17:24. Category: Others. Related project: Nothing/Others. Status: New
Rationale
In Mac OS X when you try to copy/move a file in a protected folder appears a pop-up that asks you to insert admin password.

In Ubuntu the same thing become very difficult, especilly copying multiple files: you have to access to the terminal and write a command. This could be really stressing for a new user.

Could you implement the same function seen on Mac?

707
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #6790
Written by gio91ber the 10 Apr 08 at 17:24.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #6790 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!

Propose your solution

Attachments
No attachments.


Duplicates


Comments
Eldmannen wrote on the 10 Apr 08 at 17:36
"Copy a file in a protected folder", you should be more clear.
From or to?

If from, then I disagree.
If to, then I agree.

daisy.code wrote on the 10 Apr 08 at 18:35
I agree with Eldmannen. This is a great idea, it would reduce the amount I use sudo nautilus by 90%.

Matthias wrote on the 10 Apr 08 at 19:17
I agree. This function I'm missing always. +1

knoopx wrote on the 10 Apr 08 at 19:24
Even more, every time you try to do a GUI-based operation without permissions ask for password.

johno wrote on the 10 Apr 08 at 21:28
Being a command-prompt person myself, I haven't tried copying files via the nautilus gui - but I find it surprising that it wouldn't interactively prompt for authentication. Otherwise it kind of defeats the point of having the graphical file mananger in the first place.

bryhoyt wrote on the 10 Apr 08 at 21:46
Eldemannen, sorry if I'm just being dense, but I really don't understand what difference it makes whether you're copying from or to?

Either way, I'd like to be asked for a password (unless of course I already have permission to copy in whatever direction I'm copying), rather than having to load up a command prompt.

I can't see how it would interfere with security, either; it's asking for the password, after all. Presumably this would be the same password it would ask for if you did the operation via the command prompt.

mysticmatrix wrote on the 10 Apr 08 at 21:46
I guess this has been implemented in hardy with new gnome file handling and policykit.

Niedzwiedz wrote on the 11 Apr 08 at 06:11
I hope so. It's really annoying... And opening protected files... I added to "Open with" "gksudo xxx" where xxx is program to open file (ig gedit for text files and so on).

Matthias wrote on the 11 Apr 08 at 13:28
I can't find this function in hardy.

Jadd wrote on the 11 Apr 08 at 15:39
You can do this with just a GUI, sort-of:
Press alt-f2, type
gksu nautilus
That nautilus window and any windows you spawn from it will have root priveleges.
Although I area, it really should be the way you suggested.

johan wrote on the 12 Apr 08 at 23:38
excellent idea.

natureflow wrote on the 16 Apr 08 at 10:43
Could PolicyKit do this?

revzoe wrote on the 16 Apr 08 at 14:50
bryhoyt, the difference is, it's silly to put a password on something you copy from a protected folder, since yau can already do that without password. As for the idea, this is just one of many permission problems with nautilus, and definitely the easiest to fix. This should have been done long ago.

revzoe wrote on the 16 Apr 08 at 14:52
bryhoyt, the difference is, it's silly to put a password on something you copy from a protected folder, since yau can already do that without password. As for the idea, this is just one of many permission problems with nautilus, and definitely the easiest to fix. This should have been done long ago.

brownknight wrote on the 17 Apr 08 at 15:03
Great idea. This feature should be a default functionality.

Koenputer wrote on the 25 Apr 08 at 00:44
Should be default to ask for a password, instead of saying it's impossible to do because of password protection in all cases. Like emptying trash you don't own and other things i can't think of.

Railroadgeek wrote on the 19 May 08 at 23:01
Excellent idea, it would make things much easier.

droetker wrote on the 6 Aug 08 at 07:38
This is no dupe of http://brainstorm.ubuntu.com/idea/4347/,
AFAIK it will be implemented using PolicyKit in Intrepid Ibex.


Post your comment