Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstorm
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 12232 ideas, 57574 comments, 1174524 votes

Idea #6158: Ask Authors To Approve Duplicate Ideas!



up
18
down
Written by batonac the 31 Mar 08 at 12:52. Category: Brainstorm.
Related to: Nothing/Others. Status: New
Description
It seems that any new idea which is reported as a duplicate can be quickly removed and merged into another, even if the original author thought that his idea was similar, but had very important differences from the older idea.

I very recently reported a new and exciting idea for ubuntu which was becoming popular very fast (for its short lifetime). My idea has been removed from brainstorm searches because someone reported it as a duplicate of a lesser idea, and, although the other idea had a similar theme, my idea was far more specific and better documented.

I wish that members here still had the option of voting for my idea, since voting for other idea won't accomplish what I was proposing, but I seem to have no power over this process.

To get a feel for the problem, look here:

My Original idea:
http://brainstorm.ubuntu.com/idea/5848/

Other Idea:
http://brainstorm.ubuntu.com/idea/5362/

If the author doesn't respond in the time appointed, then the merge should go ahead, but otherwise, our free speech should be better protected on this site.

Attachments
No attachments.


Duplicates


Comments
Auzy wrote on the 31 Mar 08 at 13:23
Who honestly though would actually vote to have their idea merged into another? Not me..

I suggested meta moderation to help fix the admins, so we can rate various moderators and see what they are doing (better transparency), but it seems all of these ideas don't get voted for. The system is failing us because there aren't enough people voting, so all of the new ideas to fix the system, never get enough votes to get noticed

macros wrote on the 31 Mar 08 at 14:37
But something has to be done against this.
Watch these 3 Ideas (don't miss the comments of the 3rd)
#3975 http://brainstorm.ubuntu.com/idea/3975/
#65 http://brainstorm.ubuntu.com/idea/65/
#3982 http://brainstorm.ubuntu.com/idea/3982/

Please also notice that #3975 got its 22 Votes
in a very short time (2 days) while the other one,
which was posted at nearly the same time, has only 18 Votes

(Of course I would remove the quote from the Moderator
guidelines from my idea if it is restored)

greetings
Macros

batonac wrote on the 31 Mar 08 at 21:27
Auzy, I honestly believe that many authors would be willing to merge their ideas, it seems to make alot of sense. If the ideas are really the same, then the votes get added together which furthers the cause of the both authors.

Auzy wrote on the 1 Apr 08 at 02:40
I agree with this, but I don't think its the right way to approach the problem.. I'd rather a community vote or something AS WELL!!!

Because that way, the author may not agree, butt the community may

batonac wrote on the 2 Apr 08 at 14:35
Hey Auzy, come up with a practical technique and I'll vote for it.

DanRabbit wrote on the 4 Apr 08 at 23:29
I'm voting for this and the ability to vote down Auzy.

I'm sorry, but some people are just negative for no reason at all.

batonac wrote on the 5 Apr 08 at 01:40
i think ur right danrabbit


Post your comment