Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 21567 ideas, 132490 comments, 2607102 votes
Idea sandbox Idea sandbox
Popular ideas Popular ideas
Ideas in development Ideas in development
Implemented ideas Implemented ideas
Idea #23950: Alt+F2 should propose to install programs not found

Written by huit_six the 10 Mar 10 at 09:07. Related project: Synaptic package manager. Status: New
Rationale
When trying to launch a command with Alt+F2, if the program could not be found, there is only an error message. The user who wants to launch a program which hasn't been installed yet has to :
* Open synaptic or software
* Make a search
* install
* ...

And if it wasn't found, then, the user have to know the right sources of information, for installing a new repo, or a compiling a software.
Tags: AltF2

31
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Dialog box which propose to install the software
Written by huit_six the 10 Mar 10 at 09:07.
There should be a dialog box which would propose to install the software (or possibly one in a list).

For example:
* One hits Alt+F2 and tries to execute the command gimp
* On Lucid, this command has disappeared by default
* A dialog box pops-up and says :
"The program Gimp isn't installed yet on your system, but is provided by the package 'gimp'. Do you want to install and execute it now ?"
* If the user clicks on yes/Ok, a summary of installations is shown.
* Then apt-get installs the package and launches the command gimp.

What's more, if nothing was found on the repository, there should be a message either :
* inviting the user to search on ubuntu documentation sites for an alternative repo or way of installation.
* or listing command names which could have been misspelled.

This would have several benefits on well known softwares :
* No need to launch synaptic, or software store
* No need to perform a search
* A disappeared software from a new release of ubuntu could be quickly installed again.
* In general, a better information given to the user and a better user experience.
* Extend the system in place for codec/drivers/language/ff plug-ins to software and gain in homogeneity.

[PS] Excuse my bad English, I'm French and if I made mistakes, please mention it, thanks !
50
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Dialog box which propose to install the software
Written by Vampireboi the 11 Mar 10 at 02:37.
There should be a dialog box which would propose to install the software (or possibly one in a list).

For example:
* One hits Alt+F2 and tries to execute the command gimp
* On Lucid, this command has disappeared by default
* A dialog box pops-up and says :
"The program Gimp isn't installed yet on your system, but is provided by the package 'gimp'. Do you want to install and execute it now ?"
* If the user clicks on yes/Ok, a summary of installations is shown.
* Then apt-get installs the package and launches the command gimp.

Propose your solution

Attachments
No attachments.


Duplicates


Comments
Akerbos wrote on the 10 Mar 10 at 19:10
An extra dialog for typos? No, thanks.

Darwin Survivor (Brainstorm moderator) wrote on the 10 Mar 10 at 21:41
The solution is kind of 2 solutions stuck together.
-Suggest installing missing software
-Search for software not found in repository.

I would vote for the first one (they obviously know what they want).

I would *not* vote for the second one, due to typos (as Akerbox said).

huit_six wrote on the 12 Mar 10 at 08:17
Hello thanks for your comments,
for typos, maybe, the suggestion could only be added to the error message, and not cause an extra dialog to pop-up.
The fact is that if the command was not found neither on installed softwares nor in the repos, it would be a better user experience to propose an alternative solution.

I think a solution should be :
* simple
* informative


Post your comment