Ubuntu QA:
Blog
Brainstorm
Package status
Log in
The Ubuntu community has contributed 16602 ideas, 102352 comments, 2137701 votes
All
more
Projects
more
Software
»
AbiWord Word Processor
AcidRip DVD Ripper
Akregator
Alien Arena
Amarok
Amaya
AMSN
Anjuta IDE
Archive Manager
Ardour
Ark
Audacious
Audacity
Azureus
Banshee Music Player
Battle for Wesnoth
Blender 3D modeller
Bluefish Editor
Bluetooth File Sharing (Gnome)
BZFlag
Calculator (Gnome)
CellWriter
Cervisia
Chatzilla
Cheese
Chess (Gnome)
Claws Mail
Comix
Compiz
Compiz Advanced Settings (ccsm)
Deluge BitTorrent Client
DeVeDe
Device Manager (gnome)
Device Manager (kde)
Dia
Dictionary (gnome)
Dictionary (kde)
DigiKam
Dillo
Dolphin
Dvd::rip
Eclipse
Ekiga Softphone
Emacs
Emesene
Epiphany
Eric python IDE
Evince Document Viewer
Evolution Mail and Calendar
Exaile Music Player
Extreme Tux Racer
FileZilla FTP client
Firefox
Flash plugin (macromedia)
FlightGear
Frozen-Bubble
F-Spot Photo Manager
GCompris Educational suite
GDecrypt
GDesklets
GFTP
GIMP Image Editor
Glade Interface Designer
Gnome
GNOME Do
Gnumeric Spreadsheet
Gossip Instant Messenger
GPROFTPD
GStreamer
Gtkam
GTwitter
IDLE
Image Viewer (EoG)
Inkscape Vector Graphics Editor
Istanbul Desktop Session Recorder
Jokosher Audio Editor
JuK
K3b
Kaffeine
KAlarm
Kate
KAudioCreator
KDE
KDevelop
Kino
KMail
KNetworkManager
KNode
KOffice
Konqueror
Konsole
Kontact
Konversation
Kopete
KOrganizer
KPDF
KTorrent
KWord
MeMaker
Miro Internet TV
Mixxx (DJ software)
MonoDevelop
MPlayer Movie Player
Nautilus
NetBeans
Network Manager
OpenArena
OpenOffice.org Database
OpenOffice.org Drawing
OpenOffice.org Formula
OpenOffice.org Presentation
OpenOffice.org Spreadsheet
OpenOffice.org Word Processor
OpenTTD
PgAdmin
Phoronix test suite
Pidgin Internet Messenger
Qt Designer
Scorched 3D
Scribus
Seamonkey
Shrew Soft VPN Access Manager
Sound Juicer
Sunbird
SuperTux
Totem Movie Player
Transmission
Twinkle
Umbrello
Vega Strike
Vinagre Remote Desktop Viewer
VLC media player
Wine
Wireshark
Wormux
XChat-GNOME IRC Chat
Ubuntu software
»
Add/Remove program dialog
Live CD
Live CD installer
Synaptic package manager
Update manager
Wubi Windows installer
Ubuntu derivate
»
Edubuntu
Gobuntu
Kubuntu
Mythbuntu
Sabily
Ubuntu mobile edition
Xubuntu
Ubuntu website
»
brainstorm.ubuntu.com
launchpad.net
ubuntu.com
ubuntuforums.org
wiki.ubuntu.com
Global categories
more
Accessibility
Documentation
Education
Gaming
Graphics
Hardware support
Installation
Internet & Networking
Look and Feel
Marketing
Multimedia
Office
Programming
Quality
Security
Server
System
Usability
Others
Idea sandbox
Popular ideas
Ideas in development
Implemented ideas
Idea #19418: Ubuntu has to be protected against pantents demands
Description
Report duplicate
Help promote this idea!
Written by
diegoj
the 25 Apr 09 at 11:58. Category: Others. Related project:
Nothing/Others
. Status:
New
Rationale
Ubuntu is a great OS, it has to be protected against other companies which claim Ubuntu uses other's intellectual propierty.
Ubuntu must be completely protected against patent infringment demands.
Tags:
demand
intellectual
patent
propierty
9
votes
13
0
4
Solution #1:
Offer Mono as a package in ubuntu-restricted repository, not by default
Written by
diegoj
the 25 Apr 09 at 11:58.
Firstly, I don't want to start a pro/against-Mono flamewar here. In a near future, I'm going to develop .Net on Windows, and I like some Mono applications as GnomeDo (which, in fact, I've helped translating it to Spanish).
Microsoft holds patents for the non-standards .Net libraries like Windows.Forms (and many others), Mono has implemented them, so Microsoft could demand Mono (and every Linux distribution, including Ubuntu) which offer this software.
So, I think that Mono should be treated as a multimedia codec and include Mono in ubuntu-restricted-extras, and not include this kind of software by default in Ubuntu distribution.
Firstly, I don't want to start a pro/against-Mono flamewar here. In a near future, I'm going to develop .Net on Windows, and I like some Mono applications as GnomeDo (which, in fact, I've helped translating it to Spanish). Microsoft holds patents for the non-standards .Net libraries like Windows.Forms (and many others), Mono has implemented them, so Microsoft could demand Mono (and every Linux distribution, including Ubuntu) which offer this software. So, I think that Mono should be treated as a multimedia codec and include Mono in ubuntu-restricted-extras, and not include this kind of software by default in Ubuntu distribution.
10
votes
13
0
3
Solution #2:
Study which software could be demanded and propose alternatives
Written by
diegoj
the 25 Apr 09 at 12:05.
Microsoft demanded TomTom because of a FAT patent.
Ubuntu is the main competitor of Microsoft Windows, so it could be possible that Microsoft sues Canonical (or whatever Linux-company).
This Linux-companies must be prepared against this kind of demands. Classify potential demanded software, and provide an alternative or help rewriting conflictive software modules.
Microsoft demanded TomTom because of a FAT patent. Ubuntu is the main competitor of Microsoft Windows, so it could be possible that Microsoft sues Canonical (or whatever Linux-company). This Linux-companies must be prepared against this kind of demands. Classify potential demanded software, and provide an alternative or help rewriting conflictive software modules.
5
votes
5
1
0
Solution #3:
Canonical should join to the Open Invention Network
Written by
diegoj
the 19 May 09 at 20:59.
Canonical should join the
Open Invention Network
to protect Ubuntu against patent claims, that is to get helped about what of its software could be demanded.
Thus, it could be more legal feedback between big open source developers, making it stronger.
Canonical should join the <a href="http://www.openinventionnetwork.com/">Open Invention Network</a> to protect Ubuntu against patent claims, that is to get helped about what of its software could be demanded. Thus, it could be more legal feedback between big open source developers, making it stronger.
Propose your solution
Attachments
No attachments.
Duplicates
[Report a duplicate and merge its votes to this idea]
Comments
AndrewLuecke
wrote on the 7 Jul 09 at 09:48
Solution #1 is NOW irrelevent. Microsoft has made Mono safe from lawsuits:
http://port25.technet.com/archive/2009/07/06/the-ecma-c-and-cli-standards.aspx?
yay
diegoj
wrote on the 7 Jul 09 at 13:24
Sure?
Post your comment
Keywords
Advanced search »
Tags
Submit your idea