Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 17459 ideas, 107690 comments, 2263278 votes
Idea sandbox Idea sandbox
Popular ideas Popular ideas
Ideas in development Ideas in development
Implemented ideas Implemented ideas
Idea #18725: Simple relocation of home and personal folders

Written by Kurotenshi the 21 Mar 09 at 22:23. Related project: Gnome. Status: New
Rationale
This is something that is possible in Vista and would come very handy for people that, like me, have a separate partitions to store all their data.

I have a second hard drive where I have a documents, music, pictures, videos, etc folder and that is never formatted with the OS. In vista, you can change the path on the personal folders shortcuts and the system automatically changes every thing related to those folders, including moving files from the current location to the new one, without messing the files already existing.

In Ubuntu, the process is a lot more triky, if it is even possible to do what I just described.
Tags: (none)

13
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Simple way to define personal folders post instalation
Written by Kurotenshi the 21 Mar 09 at 22:23.
Basically the solution was to implement a way to do what I described above about Vista.
-One step redefinition of personal folders location
-auto move existing files to new location
-auto move does not mess with existing files
5
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Easy to use front end to LVM on the Live CD
Written by James_Lochhead the 22 Mar 09 at 05:45.
I believe LVM is probably what Kurotenshi is looking for.

If I remember correctly there is an guided LVM option on the Live CD however I think there are several problems with this:

1) (Blurry on this) I believe there is no option to keep any existing installs with LVM (might of course be wrong).

2) For the new user there is not much information available on LVM, they simply won't know what it is. I started using Ubuntu over a year ago and have just now started using LVM.

3) LVM is probably too difficult of a concept for the new user, especially first timers.

4) Even if the user sets up guided LVM how do they manipulate it. As far as I know there are no graphical tools for manipulation of LVM installed by default in Ubuntu.

Therefore, what I propose is a two part application to help new users/users with less IT skills to install LVM by default.

The first part would be on the Live CD, say an option allowing users to do a "dynamic install" (no sense in throwing jargon like LVM at people who don't understand it) which will install LVM alongside existing partitions for other OSes.

The second part would be a graphical tool for the manipulation of the "dynamic install" installed by default in Ubuntu.

LVM is a great tool and new users really need more exposure to it.
1
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Use UnionFS or AUFS instead of #1.
Written by Lachu the 22 Mar 09 at 11:21.
Allow people to selecting next layer of folder. User go to folder property, click on move all new files to seperate folder/partition and input a path. User can also select option move all existing files to this folder and remove files from old locations.

Some user may use it for mirroring work. We need to deliver our work to our boss? We can select Home > Documents > properties > storage page . Set removeable media where we must place the work as next filesystem layer and modify documents.

It's not about integrated this function for each folders, but some like Documents. If you realize my idea then Documents must be stored in separate folders.

Propose your solution

Attachments
No attachments.


Duplicates


Comments
andrew (Brainstorm moderator) wrote on the 22 Mar 09 at 01:58
Personally, I always set up my /home on a separate partition already. I assume you are looking to easily remap /home at a later point.

Kurotenshi wrote on the 22 Mar 09 at 16:03
It's +- that andrew, the point here is to remap only some folders inside /home but the hole /home wouldn't be bad at all.

aliam13_2 wrote on the 22 Mar 09 at 16:26
I think its best to mount \home on a different partition to archive what you want. The reasons I think this is best are:

1) Its better to have all user data in one place and not scattered about. Remapping of personal folders allows this scattering effect. For instance, may be you remap Documents and Pictures and forget about Desktop. Then you reformat the OS partition and you thought that the Desktop was also remapped and thus you loose all files on your Desktop. This would not happen as easily with mounts \home on a separate partition.

2) With me at least I usually end up having more than one user (even though I am the only person using my computer). So its better to have all new users data automatically on a safe area. So again separate home makes this easy.


Post your comment