Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 21986 ideas, 135057 comments, 2615221 votes
Idea sandbox Idea sandbox
Popular ideas Popular ideas
Ideas in development Ideas in development
Implemented ideas Implemented ideas
Idea #13230: Proposal for beginner friendly partitioning during install

Written by enbuyukfener the 15 Sep 08 at 06:24. Related project: Live CD installer. Status: New
Rationale
This is a follow up on ideas such as:
http://brainstorm.ubuntu.com/idea/7762/

I propose going one step further and automating the process and doing all the gritty work for the user.

This would be done with two features:
1) initial scan of hard drive and checking of contents to look for existing operating systems, existing /home partitions etc.
2) multiple choice wizard that will get enough info to set the mount points and partitions

Apart from solving the problem of inexperienced users having no idea or at least hesitating at the partitioning stage, it would also prevent headaches in future with smart suggestions, e.g. use a separate data drive which can be used by Windows and Linux, use a separate /home partition, leave room for another OS etc.

Something like this:

(Step 1/2)

To install Ubuntu, you will need a partition (hard drive section) to put it on.

To determine how to best set this up, please describe the current contents of your primary hard drive:

* I have Windows installed on it
* I have something else installed on it
* The hard drive is empty
* None of the above

Need help?

(this step may not be needed if we auto detect the above, maybe confirm with user? Auto detection wouldn't be too problematic, just look for simple scenarios, i.e. look at partition types, maybe stat some files that indicate a certain OS's presence etc. A simple fall back would be that the installer could not determine your current set up and fall back to the menu above)

(maybe follow the prompt above with sub-questions, do you have a shared data partition, do you have more than one OS etc.)

(Step 2/2)

You specified that your hard drive contains a [Windows, other existing OS] installation.

Would you like to:

* Install Ubuntu and keep [Windows, other existing OS]
* Remove [Windows, other existing OS] and install Ubuntu
* Create a custom set up (advanced users only)
* Go back

Need help?

(Step 2/2)

You specified that your hard drive is empty

Would you like to:

* Install Ubuntu
* Create a custom set up (advanced users only)
* Go back

Go Back | Need help?

48
votes
closed
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #13230
Written by enbuyukfener the 15 Sep 08 at 06:24.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #13230 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!

Propose your solution

Attachments
No attachments.


Duplicates


Comments
artir wrote on the 15 Sep 08 at 15:02
OK if you add an option called I AM A FUX0RZ! that enables the advanced mode (the "I AM A FUXORZ" name is needed) right from the beginning. :)

Id2ndR wrote on the 15 Sep 08 at 18:04
I think the custom setup should appears in your "step 1/2".

I also proposed an idea about all this part of partitioning which focus on others aspects : look at http://brainstorm.ubuntu.com/idea/12862/

I don't know how it possible with brainstorm to discuss about several ideas to make a new one that use the interesting points of all ideas. I think the comments are the best solution, so let me know if you want to discuss about that.

enbuyukfener wrote on the 16 Sep 08 at 07:10
Id2ndR, good points in that idea. So it has actually gone downhill in usability or at least in user experience. Surprising as to me, the only advantage besides image and friendliness of a GUI install is that it is beginner friendly and the partitioning step has become a bottle neck.

I might make a mock up of this process as I don't think I made my idea clear enough (judging by the low 44 votes).

jaiber wrote on the 16 Sep 08 at 09:22
Definitely simplifies the partition question for new users..


Post your comment