Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 16602 ideas, 102352 comments, 2137701 votes
Idea sandbox Idea sandbox
Popular ideas Popular ideas
Ideas in development Ideas in development
Implemented ideas Implemented ideas
Idea #12664: Seamless Shutdown

Written by sparky11 the 29 Aug 08 at 21:07. Category: System. Related project: Nothing/Others. Status: New
Rationale
Shutdown needs to be as seamless as the fade to screensaver effect. This is what should happen:
- You click on shut down

- If there is a unsaved file open, then

-Show a notice explaining this at the corner of the screen have a button on the notice to "Force Quit" the program. (Guifications esque) Use Compiz, if enabled, to focus that app, but have everything else darkened, sort of like the Alt-Tab effect. Then the users saves and closes, and the shutdown process continues. (Notice that no apps have actually started being turned off yet)

- If another user is logged in, and that user has unsaved files, then:

- Show a notice window stating what the problem is. The window should have two options: "Switch to the other account to save files" and "Force Quit the applications"

- If the first option is chosen, then present a password box, which will accept either an administrative password or the users password. Once the user has entered one of the correct passwords, fade to the other account, and do the same window focus effect described previously. After that, continue the shutdown process.

- If the second option is chosen, ask for either the user or administrative password, and then terminate the programs. Then continue.

- Show a black screen with a spinner. (like the firefox progress spinner) while processes are being shut down.

- use compiz, if enabled, (It hasn't been shut down yet) to fade the transition to the usplash. Shut down all remaining processes (The processes compiz needs to run) and finally shut down the computer.

As you can see, this proposition is clearly better than the current one. I'm not sure if this can be implemented, but Mac OSX can do it, so why can't we? I know about the similar ideas, but a search didn't turn up something that proposes what I do. The other ideas make up this more consolidated idea.

If you vote down, please comment on why you voted down.

213
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #12664
Written by sparky11 the 29 Aug 08 at 21:07.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #12664 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!

Propose your solution

Attachments
No attachments.


Duplicates


Comments
Ssdg wrote on the 29 Aug 08 at 21:46
I'd like to add a "cancel" option to every "save/force" prompts. +1

loonyphoenix wrote on the 29 Aug 08 at 22:16
I agree!

Can compiz be shut down so late, though? I think it needs a horde of other programs to run.

Eldmannen wrote on the 29 Aug 08 at 22:19
More importantly a fast booting with smooth login.

emytaylor164 wrote on the 29 Aug 08 at 22:53
^ i agree, it takes forever for ubuntu to start on my older machine, i am going to download xubuntu on the 10th before my downloads re-set

cheesehead (Brainstorm moderator) wrote on the 30 Aug 08 at 01:11
Integrated, smooth shutdown for usability, getting rid of the legacy dangles and jolts?

Man, I need my sunglasses. That's a cool one.

artir wrote on the 30 Aug 08 at 11:33
Agree with Eldmannen and sparky11. But we can have a fast smooth shutdown and a fast smooth boot

edm1 wrote on the 30 Aug 08 at 18:44
I want to be able to press shutdown and walk away knowing it WILL shutdown without any further actions, so -1.

RaVeR VaNc3 wrote on the 30 Aug 08 at 20:55
i dont see why you want to put so much into just a simple shut down sequence this is something that should not be requested for an add on but something someone should do them selves

seriously thats just that much more code that you have to write and take up on your hard drive
i mean sure it could be an option but its just too much

Xero Xenith wrote on the 31 Aug 08 at 13:55
Perhaps have all this happen, on a timer. "Would you like to save? (Ubuntu will automatically save this under a different filename in 60 seconds.)" That way, you can press Shut Down and then walk away, and everything will be saved. Or, you can be there to do it as in the description.

arvindkumarc wrote on the 1 Sep 08 at 11:14
I would go with having the save option as a dialog that shows all the unsaved files. When the shutdown process starts, the first lines of the files were used as fileNames and saved in a temporary location [may be a setting or /tmp by default].
Then the user selects the files s/he likes to save[as a form of checkboxes] and proceeds with shutdown.

+1

maxim99 wrote on the 6 Sep 08 at 16:24
Well thought out idea. +1

snowniak wrote on the 16 Sep 08 at 23:29
I disagree with the "ask root password" thing.

Man! You are having two clicks to hang the PC!

You will not shutdown by a mistake, and cmon, ask password because of open apps, sounds like Microsoft thing.

No way.

sparky11 wrote on the 1 Oct 08 at 21:33
@snowniak
The root password is only for having windows open that aren't on your user.


Post your comment