Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
Gnome
Idea sandbox Idea sandbox
Popular ideas Popular ideas
Ideas in development Ideas in development
Implemented ideas Implemented ideas

Contributor l.billon on Gnome

I would like to be notified when a large file operation (copy/move) is completed  
Written by martinbrook the 19 Mar 10 at 11:23. New
I often perform moderately large copy/move operations which take more than a few minutes. I like to leave these running in the background and get on with some other work in the meantime, and return to the task I was dealing with once the file operation is complete.

I usually close (i.e. hide) the 'file operations' dialog so that it doesn't distract me while I'm working.

The problem is that I don't have an easy way to know when the copy/move is done. The only thing I can really do is keep checking the notification area to see if the 'file operations' icon has vanished.
766
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Provide a libnotify popup when a file operation is complete
Written by martinbrook the 19 Mar 10 at 11:23.
A simple message such as 'Moving 342 files from /home/martin to /media/disk completed successfully' would suffice.

Sample:

138
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Notify only if the operation's time is higher than a customized time.
Written by Ssdg the 20 Mar 10 at 12:56.
All in the title.
112
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Notify when user indicates lessened immediacy
Written by Dataphile the 21 Mar 10 at 18:36.
As the submitter noted, putting things in the background is the issue here, as their status updates aren't apparent. If the file operation window is focused, then it doesn't make sense to notify the user, so I believe Solution #1 is overkill.

Adding a new setting to customize the time interval (Solution #2) also seems like overkill from this perspective.

So, I'm wondering, why not just fire up the libnotify popup when the file transfer completes and the file operation window is not focused, as that indicates the user has focused on other priorities?
328
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: As #1, but user enables the feature via a checkbox
Written by martinbrook the 30 Mar 10 at 14:08.
As in the image below. The checkbox would be unchecked by default.


-63
votes
up equal down
Solution #5: As #4, but only notify when ALL file operations are complete
Written by martinbrook the 30 Mar 10 at 14:16.
Have a single checkbox at the bottom of the File Operations window saying "Notify me when all file operations are complete".
24
votes
up equal down
Solution #6: Create a Process Manager
Written by Penguin Guy the 31 Mar 10 at 19:00.
Create a daemon that will manage processes. Add support for not only copying files, but also things like downloading and installing files.


-10
votes
up equal down
Solution #7: expanding on #1 and #4
Written by Snow Keld the 5 Apr 10 at 05:27.
both solutions, #1, and #4, are great, but i often miss the libnotify bubbles.

i think that it should be set to always announce with libnotify, but also have the check box and raise/prioritize what window when its finished instead of closing it auto.

which means on a file transfer, if you do not click the box then when the transfer completes it will be sent to libnotify and the window will close (and the bubble will pop up for a moment)

when you click the check box and the transfer finishes the libnotify bubbly will still pop up for a moment, but the transfer window will stay open and be raised to the top saying your transfer is done, in this way you'll be notified for sure.
-21
votes
up equal down
Solution #8: Let the user decide when the popup should appear
Written by man0riaX the 6 Apr 10 at 16:20.
Create a simple and easy-to-use configuration dialogue to configure in what situations a popup should appear, e.g.:

Notification when
- single file operation done (yes/no)
- all file operations done (yes/no)
- file operation gave an error message (yes/no)
[you can extend this list on your wishes]
e.g.
- Firefox download complete (yes/no) [deactivate the built-in firefox notification then]

You can also extend this and disable the default-notifications, such as
- Rhythmbox notification (yes/no)
- Empathy notification (yes/no)

Also, to come back to that file-operation-notification, in that control panel you can decide what exactly a "large file operation" is; means you can tell the system that you want to see a notification if the file(s) is/are larger than 10GB (let the user decide about a value here), but not to show a notification if the file(s) is/are smaller, for example.
-43
votes
up equal down
Solution #9: Have a timer running on a panel that starts blinking once the job's done.
Written by SuNk8 the 6 Apr 10 at 19:44.
This solution's very similar to the alarm/timer applet on a panel.
Also we could have a warning sound for the same.
-26
votes
up equal down
Solution #10: make it windows7-like
Written by Goury the 14 Apr 10 at 08:05.
coz not only mac have good ui
mergin progressbar with button background is perfect idea
16
votes
up equal down
Solution #11: Make an AppIndicator for file transfers & downloads
Written by spocky the 28 Apr 10 at 19:05.
I think the current move of Ubuntu to use Indicators to interact to different typ of applications like MessagingMenu would perfectly fit to an appIndicator for FileTransfers and Downloads

See the 14 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 28 Jul 10 at 23:29) >>

Terminal should show the name of the application running  
Written by JeongtaeRoh the 26 Mar 10 at 18:55. New
You are running alpine(email client) on terminal. And you open another terminal window, and do some file management. And you open *more* terminal for some other purpose. It happens sometimes.

But you can't see the name of application, or doing of terminal. Because window's nameplace does not show that. It says, just "Terminal". Isn't it unconvienience?

A terminal window should display what it's doing on it's forehead. That's it. It's a simple matter of metacity. It can be fixed easyly, but the trouble is on the way.
109
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: place the name of application on the window panel
Written by JeongtaeRoh the 26 Mar 10 at 18:55.
As I said, that's it.

See the 2 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 27 Mar 10 at 16:34) >>

Allow users to have peace of mind if they lose their laptop  
Written by denis.k the 27 Dec 09 at 01:36. New
There is an 'About Me' in Ubuntu, but where is the information actually beneficially used? Absolutely nowhere.

If a laptop/netbook where to be forgotten or lost, the person who finds the laptop cannot figure out how to get it back to it's rightful owner.

By giving an easy, and secure way to show contact info openly, users can know that they are somewhat safeguarded in case they happen to misplace their laptop.
14
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Show 'About Me' info on login screen and ask info during @ first boot/install
Written by denis.k the 27 Dec 09 at 01:36.
Information from 'About Me' will be shown at the bottom of the login screen (beside the accessibility options, session options (restart/shutdown), etc) and probably will scroll due to the amount of info.

The info can probably start with About: or Contact Info: so that other users will understand that it is the owners info and not info about the operating system, or support, etc.

Or instead of scrolling, a button can be shown and a dialog will popup showing all the info, which would make it easier to make note of the owners info to contact them.

By not letting the user login, if a password exists, this is a secure and easy way for others to gain access to contact information.

Furthermore, the 'About Me' info will be asked for during installation of Ubuntu, or at the first boot up/login of the initially created user, and will be explained to where the info will show up, and why.
42
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Write your contact info on your laptop!
Written by Darwin Survivor the 28 Dec 09 at 00:10.
The best, most secure, easiest and most trustworty way to ensure that you get your hardware back is to physically put your contact information ON the hardware.

A sticker on the inside (above/below keyboard) or on the back (where it doesn't cause irritation to your hands) is a very low-tech and extremely reliable way to inform the finder who's laptop it is.

No software will help you if they battery dies :P
36
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Notifications
Written by DrG the 28 Dec 09 at 07:59.
A.Send an eMail - if the laptop is able to connect to the internet and on any autologin or incorrect password entry - Send an email

The contents of the eMail.
1. Time
2. IP address - Will be in header -Location identification ( Can be used also for remote administration )
3. Hardware IDs - of connected devices
As attachment
4 .Mic Input - (optional)
5 . Web Cam Input -

All these should be configurable.
4
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: Lock
Written by DrG the 28 Dec 09 at 08:05.
Allow user to set a lock (password ), which will -
1.Prevent resetting the password through the LIVE CD
2.Disable Booting from removable media .- Requires BIOS support
3.Disable auto login
4.Enable emergency data encryption , if configured

+ solution 1 & 3

16
votes
up equal down
Solution #5: Call for rescue
Written by DrG the 28 Dec 09 at 08:13.
If password entered x ( predefined ) times is wrong or similar actions -

Automatically activate wifi / Bluetooth / GPS or similar to send a predefined rescue messages ( can contain Owner information ) to nearby devices .
-9
votes
up equal down
Solution #6: Show contact to Canonical lost & found servie.
Written by Lachu the 3 Jan 10 at 09:52.
Allow users to register laptops onto special lost & found service. On login screen shows only contact to Canonical's lost & found service(with special number).

See the 3 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 14 Jan 10 at 06:54) >>