Here are this month's most popular ideas about Gnome . New to Brainstorm? Learn how it works !
Unify system tray behaviour (drop-down menus)
Written by vectart the 25 Oct 09 at 09:52.
New
In new Ubuntu Karmic release, system tray has a new type of buttons in tray.
So I found 3 different types of behavoiur after clicking on tray applets.
Here is illustration:
Solution #2:
Notification area
Some can think this is silly, but i think it would be a good solution, that Ubuntu make a new notification area fully costumisable and it should be very intuitive, like you could pass all the icons with one click only.
Some can think this is silly, but i think it would be a good solution, that Ubuntu make a new notification area fully costumisable and it should be very intuitive, like you could pass all the icons with one click only.
Solution #3:
Let's live up to our motto: Linux For Human Beings!
Written by
azhar the 31 Oct 09 at 21:33.
I know its a bit long, but, plzzzz do read what I wrote.... i think it's worth....
Well, first of all, kudos for the guy who noticed what I call to be inconsistencies. You see, we should have a standard way to display notifications. i read the comments, and, I can see some explained why the behaviour is such.
Anyway... What I wanted to point out, is, well.... Why is that toolbar sooooo dull??? Why??? Just look at the first illustration/screenshot that Vectart provided....
It's not that I'm saying that brown is ugly, but, truth be told, its not appealing at all. Why can't we use vibrant, cool, fresh, and very lively colours. I know all too well that Ubuntu is somewhat more centered on what I call 'brown themes'. But hey! Who said we cant use brown in an elegant way.
What I'm trying to say is that we must just marry the colours. Like, when having a default brown background, that does not necessarily mean that the notification or button should be brown in colour. Ubuntu's identity isn't limited to the colour brown. Ubuntu is not known for being the most-brown-centric OS! Come'on guys! I'm pretty sure we can replace all this unappealing and dull brown notification/button by cool blue, or green. Moreover, we should consider a glassy or glossy look and feel.
Now! Plz! Don't think I'm one of those who wished Ubuntu resembles a Mac or whatever... What I'm trying to say is that I'm pretty convinced that we have great talents in the Open Community. And, I'm also pretty sure that we could do a much much much better job when it comes to the look and feel of Ubuntu..
Now, maybe some of you will argue that Ubuntu is more concerned with being free, open source, and a stable OS with less bugs that Windows lets say. And, that if some novice users don't know how to use Ubuntu, they just have to learn, and if, even after that, they can't get it, then, well.... just too bad....
But! Hey!
REMEMBER UBUNTU'S MOTTO: Linux For Human beings!!
Let's live up to that! Let's work to achieve that! Let's work together to show to the world that Ubuntu is really a user friendly OS. That linux is not a niche market, as many at Redmond would have us believe! That linux can be great!! That linux is THE WAY softwares should have been! That the open community nurtures great artistic talents! And who knows?? That could encourage mopre people to join in, and bring much more talent!
BTW, why not have Compiz-Fusion integrated into Ubuntu by default, just like in MINT LINUX?? Many people never heard of Compiz because it's just too messy and difficult to setup. I myself, required the help of a linux genius. That said, all my thanks goes to him, for, he was the one who introduced me to Ubuntu....
I hope I was able to convey my thoughts on this issue... And thanks for reading :)
I know its a bit long, but, plzzzz do read what I wrote.... i think it's worth....
Well, first of all, kudos for the guy who noticed what I call to be inconsistencies. You see, we should have a standard way to display notifications. i read the comments, and, I can see some explained why the behaviour is such.
Anyway... What I wanted to point out, is, well.... Why is that toolbar sooooo dull??? Why??? Just look at the first illustration/screenshot that Vectart provided....
It's not that I'm saying that brown is ugly, but, truth be told, its not appealing at all. Why can't we use vibrant, cool, fresh, and very lively colours. I know all too well that Ubuntu is somewhat more centered on what I call 'brown themes'. But hey! Who said we cant use brown in an elegant way.
What I'm trying to say is that we must just marry the colours. Like, when having a default brown background, that does not necessarily mean that the notification or button should be brown in colour. Ubuntu's identity isn't limited to the colour brown. Ubuntu is not known for being the most-brown-centric OS! Come'on guys! I'm pretty sure we can replace all this unappealing and dull brown notification/button by cool blue, or green. Moreover, we should consider a glassy or glossy look and feel.
Now! Plz! Don't think I'm one of those who wished Ubuntu resembles a Mac or whatever... What I'm trying to say is that I'm pretty convinced that we have great talents in the Open Community. And, I'm also pretty sure that we could do a much much much better job when it comes to the look and feel of Ubuntu..
Now, maybe some of you will argue that Ubuntu is more concerned with being free, open source, and a stable OS with less bugs that Windows lets say. And, that if some novice users don't know how to use Ubuntu, they just have to learn, and if, even after that, they can't get it, then, well.... just too bad....
But! Hey!
REMEMBER UBUNTU'S MOTTO: Linux For Human beings!!
Let's live up to that! Let's work to achieve that! Let's work together to show to the world that Ubuntu is really a user friendly OS. That linux is not a niche market, as many at Redmond would have us believe! That linux can be great!! That linux is THE WAY softwares should have been! That the open community nurtures great artistic talents! And who knows?? That could encourage mopre people to join in, and bring much more talent!
BTW, why not have Compiz-Fusion integrated into Ubuntu by default, just like in MINT LINUX?? Many people never heard of Compiz because it's just too messy and difficult to setup. I myself, required the help of a linux genius. That said, all my thanks goes to him, for, he was the one who introduced me to Ubuntu....
I hope I was able to convey my thoughts on this issue... And thanks for reading :)
Solution #4:
Leave Button Style
I like button style more than changing icon background. And it should require less testing for the icons.
I like button style more than changing icon background. And it should require less testing for the icons.
Solution #5:
Raise this issue to the Ayatana team
Written by
rrnwexec the 5 Nov 09 at 23:31.
The Ayatana project is an effort to make Ubuntu more "human". This thread is a perfect candidate for inclusion. Can someone from the team adopt/nominate it, or can someone here track down an Ayatana member and have them participate in the discussion?
The Ayatana project is an effort to make Ubuntu more "human". This thread is a perfect candidate for inclusion. Can someone from the team adopt/nominate it, or can someone here track down an Ayatana member and have them participate in the discussion?
Solution #6:
aw, come on!!!
Written by
alkx4444 the 7 Nov 09 at 02:37.
I know that we all have to nit pick a lot in order for the ubuntu operating system to be better than it is already but in my opinion this is just nit picking to the extreme., what the hell is really at fault with the ubuntu task-bar, it's okay as it is!!!, apart from a few small minor bugs of-course, and that's besides the point because bug reports is a domain for launchpad and bugzilla.
I know that we all have to nit pick a lot in order for the ubuntu operating system to be better than it is already but in my opinion this is just nit picking to the extreme., what the hell is really at fault with the ubuntu task-bar, it's okay as it is!!!, apart from a few small minor bugs of-course, and that's besides the point because bug reports is a domain for launchpad and bugzilla.
Notify for Daylight Savingtime
Written by xeniac the 25 Oct 09 at 10:35.
New
Today Daylight Saving Time switched back to GMT +1 in my region. As a long term Linux User i always trust my PC clock, but my girlfriend is new to Ubuntu and was confused, her nolonger-Windows PC does't bug her that he changed the Time automaticly and she should check if the changes are correct.
It also happend to me that my GNU/Linux PC changed the Timezone and i didn't realize it. So i didn't changed my Alarm-Clock per hand and overslept the next day.
Solution #1:
Add DST Notification to the Clock Applet
Written by
xeniac the 25 Oct 09 at 10:35.
For each User the standard clock-applet could show an explanation mark when the time has been changed to DST, or back.
Mockup:
http://dl.getdropbox.com/u/1816843/DST-statusbar.png
If the user expands the clock-applet he sees an additional Message explaining to him that the clock has been set forward/backward, and why this had happend.
Mockup:
http://dl.getdropbox.com/u/1816843/DST-Clock.png
This notification stay for each user the whole day, or as long as he clicked on the applet to see the message.
For each User the standard clock-applet could show an explanation mark when the time has been changed to DST, or back.
Mockup: http://dl.getdropbox.com/u/1816843/DST-statusbar.png
If the user expands the clock-applet he sees an additional Message explaining to him that the clock has been set forward/backward, and why this had happend.
Mockup: http://dl.getdropbox.com/u/1816843/DST-Clock.png
This notification stay for each user the whole day, or as long as he clicked on the applet to see the message.
Solution #2:
And make it optionnal
Written by
Ssdg the 25 Oct 09 at 22:58.
I understand xeniac... but I'm part of the people who don't really bother this (especially because I'm not working on sunday, nor praying in the morning) but I understand it's easy to forget switching to winter's time and miss apointments.
So make it enabled by default and allow people to easily turn it off.
I understand xeniac... but I'm part of the people who don't really bother this (especially because I'm not working on sunday, nor praying in the morning) but I understand it's easy to forget switching to winter's time and miss apointments.
So make it enabled by default and allow people to easily turn it off.
Solution #3:
Use Notify-OSD to inform the user
Written by
Elkimo the 1 Nov 09 at 18:17.
The user only needs to be informed once, so one notification on startup should be enough, this will keep the panel clean (no explanation mark you have to click before it goes away), and will be as unobstructive as possible.
The user only needs to be informed once, so one notification on startup should be enough, this will keep the panel clean (no explanation mark you have to click before it goes away), and will be as unobstructive as possible.
Log-in with fingerprint (set it up easily)
Written by mike.thorton the 19 Oct 09 at 15:03.
New
Many laptops have fingerprint readers included and many of these devices finally work today. However, we can't use them as they are not supported by the software (GDM,GNOME,...).
What we want is to have an option to use our finger(s) and/or our password to log into the system.
Maybe we should extend this later for general authentication of a whole system.
Solution #1:
Just use the fedora's solution
The simplest solution is probably to implement the fedora's one:
http://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Features/Fingerprint
Solution #2:
Enable it only when warning about security risks
Written by
xfuser4 the 19 Oct 09 at 17:25.
Biometric sensors are known to have potential security risks (see comment).
When enabling finger print readers, the user should be informed about it.
Biometric sensors are known to have potential security risks (see comment).
When enabling finger print readers, the user should be informed about it.
Solution #3:
Make it a package file installable like an app.
Written by
Jaksco the 30 Oct 09 at 20:49.
Make it a package file installable like an app.
Make it a package file installable like an app.
Solution #4:
Make sure there is an option for fingerprint + password authentication.
Based on the comments about security risks, it seems like this should naturally be an option.
From
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Authentication#History_and_state-of-the-art : "Hybrid or two-tiered authentication methods offer a compelling solution." Fingerprints can be swiped and used and there are plenty of methods for getting a password (peeking, social engineering, brute force, etc.); getting both would likely prove to be more difficult.
At any rate, a fingerprint on top of a normal password would definitely stop a casual snooper.
Based on the comments about security risks, it seems like this should naturally be an option.
From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Authentication#History_and_state-of-the-art : "Hybrid or two-tiered authentication methods offer a compelling solution." Fingerprints can be swiped and used and there are plenty of methods for getting a password (peeking, social engineering, brute force, etc.); getting both would likely prove to be more difficult.
At any rate, a fingerprint on top of a normal password would definitely stop a casual snooper.
Solution #1:
Display the name instead of the username
Written by
SVT the 10 Oct 09 at 11:21.
As it says above
As it says above
Solution #2:
Make it configureable..
Written by
eumel the 10 Oct 09 at 18:09.
.. whether you wanna show the username the realname, with icon or not with icon,...
.. whether you wanna show the username the realname, with icon or not with icon,...
Solution #3:
#1+#2 in an easy way
displaying the name instead of the username sounds useful.
display the username instead can still be an option in some config file, but i don't see _any_ point in cluttering configuration dialogs with this kind of options. 99% of people don't care about the difference at all.
displaying the name instead of the username sounds useful.
display the username instead can still be an option in some config file, but i don't see _any_ point in cluttering configuration dialogs with this kind of options. 99% of people don't care about the difference at all.
Solution #4:
Bring back FUSA Preferences
Written by
Dazed_75 the 18 Oct 09 at 17:56.
Jaunty (9.04) had a right click option for preferences. One of those preferences was whether to show User Name, "Users", or an Icon. Bring this back and add User ID. Done!
SIDE NOTE: BTW, Preferences had other options like whether to use the Confirmation Dialogs for Shutdown, etc. Those should be retained and an entry added for the duration of those boxes. I will try t add a separate proposal for that if one does not already exist.
Jaunty (9.04) had a right click option for preferences. One of those preferences was whether to show User Name, "Users", or an Icon. Bring this back and add User ID. Done!
SIDE NOTE: BTW, Preferences had other options like whether to use the Confirmation Dialogs for Shutdown, etc. Those should be retained and an entry added for the duration of those boxes. I will try t add a separate proposal for that if one does not already exist.
Solution #5:
Display the real name, but only the first name
Written by
darius the 24 Oct 09 at 13:36.
Displaying the complete full real name on the FUSA will in some cases take up lots of space, displaying the first name only sounds like a reasonable compromise.
Displaying the complete full real name on the FUSA will in some cases take up lots of space, displaying the first name only sounds like a reasonable compromise.
Integrate OpenID support into Ubuntu
Written by daddo the 2 Nov 09 at 21:27.
New
Launchpad.net is one of the many sites, wich offers OpenID login.
Unfortunately are such kind of OpenID-s long and uncomfortable to type on web pages.
At the moment, the OpenID as feature is not to implemented any way into Ubuntu.
Have gnome accept non-rectangular desktops
Written by rpgsimmaster the 9 Oct 09 at 01:39.
New
When working with multiple monitors of different resolutions, and when not working with panels above/below the smaller of the monitors, the desktop icons can spill into areas of the desktop not visible to the user. It is also possible to lose the mouse in this area because the mouse boundaries are specified by the desktop, not the screens.
When in multi-head mode on Windows using different resolutions, Windows restricts the movement of the mouse to stay within the area of the desktop, which may be non-rectangular. Gnome (or even X) needs to do something like this.
Solution #1:
Have gnome restrict mouse movement and desktop icons
Have gnome restrict mouse movement and desktop icons to within the visible monitor area, not just the virtual desktop.
Have gnome restrict mouse movement and desktop icons to within the visible monitor area, not just the virtual desktop.
Solution #2:
Teach gnome "the end of a screen"
This option contains more, than just "restrict mouse movement".
Gnome should be able to know, which screen has which resolution.
E.g. If the main monitor has a resolution of 1280x800 and the 2nd 1680x1050 - AWNs feature "Maximized windows cannot overlap the bar" does not work, because AWN gets the distance to the bottom from the whole resolution (which is 2960x1050) instead of the active screen. So A maximized window covers the AWN Bar, but doesn't use the lower space on the 2nd monitor.
This option contains more, than just "restrict mouse movement".
Gnome should be able to know, which screen has which resolution.
E.g. If the main monitor has a resolution of 1280x800 and the 2nd 1680x1050 - AWNs feature "Maximized windows cannot overlap the bar" does not work, because AWN gets the distance to the bottom from the whole resolution (which is 2960x1050) instead of the active screen. So A maximized window covers the AWN Bar, but doesn't use the lower space on the 2nd monitor.
Allow users to use both side scroll and two finger scroll
Written by taofd the 4 Nov 09 at 08:12.
New
Personally, I use both side scroll and two finger scroll. I use side scroll for long scrolls or when I need to scroll quickly (imprecise scrolling). I use two finger scroll generally when reading long articles that I actually have to pay attention to (precise scrolling).
In Karmic 9.10, the default scroll functionality is set to NO SCROLL and must be enabled via the touchpad options menu. Even then, the two features are now separated and it not possible to enable both. As a user who has grown use the "feature" of using both, I am frustrated at this feature regression.
Sticky window for utilities
Written by vectart the 31 Oct 09 at 18:24.
New
Some often using utilities (like calculator or color picker) have the own window.
By default, that windows hasn't own behaviour.
It's simple window, which hide under other windows and takes place in panel with windows list.
Content of small utilities must have own window type.
More usable for often opening and transfering data to other programs.
Solution #1:
Sticky container
Written by
vectart the 31 Oct 09 at 18:24.
That solution all Gnome users are seen:
The date window still placed over all windows, don't showing in windows list, looks like small tool.
For example, how it's maybe looks for calculator:
* i hate always set 'on top' option for calculator window
Or for color chooser:
* i also hate search that window after picking color from picture and pasting to editor
That solution all Gnome users are seen:
<img src="http://www.xamp.ru/stickywindow1.png" />
The date window still placed over all windows, don't showing in windows list, looks like small tool.
For example, how it's maybe looks for calculator:
<img src="http://www.xamp.ru/stickywindow2.png" />
<i>* i hate always set 'on top' option for calculator window</i>
Or for color chooser:
<img src="http://www.xamp.ru/stickywindow3.png" />
<i>* i also hate search that window after picking color from picture and pasting to editor</i>
Solution #2:
Make the window type modifiable by window's menu (alt+space)
Written by
Ssdg the 1 Nov 09 at 11:01.
Like always on top this behavior could be enabled by an option of the window"s menu and the window manager should remember the window's las behavior when you run the program after closing it.
Like always on top this behavior could be enabled by an option of the window"s menu and the window manager should remember the window's las behavior when you run the program after closing it.
Solution #3:
Solution 1, but in the Window list.
Written by
Mirek2 the 7 Nov 09 at 14:07.
If I open calculator or Songbird or Pidgin, I'm going to want it in the window list, even if I do use the "Container" mode instead of the "Window" mode.
The Container mode should be always optional, never forced on the user. I'm thinking it should be presented as an option in the application's drop-down menu (a click on the application icon) or, less ideally, the placement and inclusion should be left up to the programmer. (Or perhaps Ubuntu should have a mode-changing/ideal-size "+" window button, like Mac OS X has?).
If I open calculator or Songbird or Pidgin, I'm going to want it in the window list, even if I do use the "Container" mode instead of the "Window" mode.
The Container mode should be always optional, never forced on the user. I'm thinking it should be presented as an option in the application's drop-down menu (a click on the application icon) or, less ideally, the placement and inclusion should be left up to the programmer. (Or perhaps Ubuntu should have a mode-changing/ideal-size "+" window button, like Mac OS X has?).