Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 22700 ideas, 138270 comments, 2629576 votes
Idea sandbox Idea sandbox
Popular ideas Popular ideas
Ideas in development Ideas in development
Implemented ideas Implemented ideas

Contributor wladston

"Post comment and vote yes / no" buttons  
Written by frandavid100 the 19 May 08 at 10:30. Related project: brainstorm.ubuntu.com. New
Sometimes I post a comment on an idea I strongly agree / disagree with, and forget to vote it. I'm just like that.

I think that, when you comment on an idea you still haven't voted, there should be two buttons:

-Post and vote YES
-Post and vote NO

That way votes wouldn't be lost by accident, like in my case.
-23
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #8806
Written by frandavid100 the 19 May 08 at 10:30.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #8806 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!

Add a comment or propose a solution >>

refine nautilus   forum
Written by mangar the 26 Mar 08 at 11:40. Global category: System. Not an idea
1. add a filter bar (similar to finder/ explorer)
2. add tab support (optional)
3. convert the zoom button to a slider, move to buttom left
4. move view mode to the left of the slider, convert to buttons.
5. add "eject" button next to removable media.
6. see ubuntuforums url for mock-up
348
votes
closed
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #5765
Written by mangar the 26 Mar 08 at 11:40.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #5765 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!

See the 22 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 15 May 12 at 07:19) >>

No Mono by default in Ubuntu  
Ubuntu

In :  
Priority : Undefined
Definition : Review (Needs guidance)
Implementation : Not started
Assignee :
spec
Written by Ubuwu the 28 Feb 08 at 17:50. Global category: System. Implemented
Remove Mono and dependent applications from default Ubuntu Desktop CD. Mono occupies a significant amount of the valuable space on the live cd that could be used for translations and other things. Applications using mono use much more memory than their non-mono counterparts. Functionality can be provided by other applications that are just as good.

This will NOT remove Mono or any of the applications from the Ubuntu repositories, just the default Desktop CD. (Although removing them from the CD may mean they don't need to be in Main anymore)

This affects two applications included by default: tomboy and f-spot. Tomboy can be replaced by either sticky notes or zim and f-spot by gthumb.
204
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#1): Auto-generated solution of idea #110
Written by Ubuwu the 28 Feb 08 at 17:50.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #110 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!
85
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#2): No Mono by default
Written by rmh the 2 Jun 09 at 21:57.
Remove Mono from the default package selection
75
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#3): Replace Tomboy with Gnote and remove Mono package
Written by diegoj the 8 Jun 09 at 18:34.
That's all. Save space from liveCD as Fedora Core Team is doing: replace Tomboy with Gnote and avoid patent problems.
32
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#4): Promote Vala as a Gnome enviroment programming language
Written by diegoj the 25 Jun 09 at 21:27.
Vala is a modern language for programming in the Gnome desktop enviroment.

Its code is compiled to C and this is compiled to machine code.

Vala has got all the features that C# has, thus Vala doesn't rely on a virtual machine and isn't patented by anybody like many parts of the Mono machine (Winforms library, for example).

Promote its development and the development of applications based in Vala compiler (like Lucruri) and stop wasting resources in Mono-based projects.
62
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#5): Replace Mono-based applications with Mono-free ones
Written by diegoj the 25 Jun 09 at 21:47.
Replace every Mono applications with its direct C++ port (or similar). That is:

- Tomboy must be replaced with Gnote.
- F-spot must be replaced with Solang.
- Banshee must NOT replace Rythmbox.

Why should Canonical do that? It will...
- Avoid patent demands. Winforms library is patented by Microsoft.
- Make Ubuntu applications faster. Mono is slower than machine code.
- Save live CD space.
23
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#6): Shotwell instead of F-spot
Written by jeypeyy the 25 Dec 09 at 00:15.
Same as Solution #5, but instead of using solang as a replacement for F-spot we should use Shotwell. Shotwell is an application written in Vala, the language Solution #4 wants to promote.

It's better than Solang because you can remove red eyes. Since it's written in Vala it's easy developing for GNOME, which means the development probably will be faster than for other applications.
16
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#7): Remove the package "mono-runtime" in the live-cd.
Written by ubuntosaure the 11 Feb 10 at 19:46.
Remove the package "mono-runtime" in the live-cd and replace Tomboy by Gnote and Fspot by gThumb or similar.

See the 72 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 29 Apr 12 at 21:50) >>

Longer support for LTS desktop releases  
Written by gutnov the 22 Mar 08 at 23:31. Global category: Security. Implemented
Why not to support LTS desktop releases of Ubuntu for a longer time. For example for 5 years that means as long as server editions are supported currently. This should not be a big problem, as most of updates are identical for both versions. Alternatively it can be full support for the first three years, and only crucial security updates for the last two.
-69
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#1): Auto-generated solution of idea #5455
Written by gutnov the 22 Mar 08 at 23:31.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #5455 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!

See the 6 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 12 Apr 12 at 13:23) >>

New users tell that Ubuntu is slow (live sessions)  
Written by zwyber the 8 Mar 09 at 19:55. Related project: Live CD. Won't implement
I tell my friends and family about Ubuntu and most of them come back telling me that Ubuntu makes their PC run very slow. They didn't know that you had to install Ubuntu to get the true speed.

I think that many people may encounter this problem, because when you run a live session it really just looks like it is installed. Because of the speed these users don't want to use Ubuntu and tell everyone they know that it is very slow.
1318
votes
closed
Solution #1: Show (extra) notification.
Written by zwyber the 8 Mar 09 at 19:55.
Very plain and simple, show a (extra) notification, telling the user that they are running in a live session and that Ubuntu runs very slow now.

Why extra? If Ubuntu developers are going to create a welcome screen where they put this information some people are not going to read this. Just a small dialogue after the welcome screen has been closed would be nice.

OR

Put the message in the default wallpaper, easier but not really the best solution.
-389
votes
closed
Solution #2: Live CD Cloud
Written by kidmodify the 9 Mar 09 at 02:07.
Use a Live CD "Cloud" if the computer is connected to the Internet to help increase speed. That way you have two sources of incoming data, the CD, and the Web.
-431
votes
closed
Solution #3: Use multiple CD Drives if possible
Written by kidmodify the 9 Mar 09 at 02:14.
Some computers have more than one CD drive. Make it possible to use for example two disk drives each with an ubuntu CD. This could (as far as I know) double the speed, depending on the drive speeds.
254
votes
closed
Solution #4: (Pre)cache executables on CD agressively
Written by Cé the 13 Mar 09 at 12:24.
Cache the executable files on the CD very agressively.
Cache the data files a lot less.
If there's a lot of RAM, precache executable files, if possible all of them.
This will make the use of the CD (or a slow HD) a lot faster.
446
votes
closed
Solution #5: Grub option to load into memory
Written by scubanator87 the 13 Mar 09 at 13:45.
Some live CDs (like puppy for instance) have the option to load the OS into memory.

Provided there is enough RAM (2GB?) Allow users the option to load the OS into memory and to continue to boot from there.
-142
votes
closed
Solution #6: Don't run Compiz in LiveCD
Written by sci-fi guy the 16 Mar 09 at 23:08.
Maybe integrate a checkbox to turn it on with Solution #1 above.
259
votes
closed
Solution #7: Notify During OS Boot
Written by Basem the 22 Mar 09 at 08:54.
While booting the OS, add a line that says "Enjoy ubuntu in full speed by installing it"
-52
votes
closed
Solution #8: As #1, keep notification visible
Written by euxneks the 26 Mar 09 at 19:01.
I like the idea of letting them know that they are using a LiveCD on the desktop - we should also have interaction with it so that a user can get an idea of what a LiveCD is and why it's slower than the real system.

Once they close this, allow them the ability to open it again.
-90
votes
closed
Solution #9: Most users don't need all programs in live session
Written by ahsaeed the 29 Mar 09 at 16:11.
When I use Ubuntu in live session i don't wont to play games for example .. and some users do..
So..
i recommend to add another option to the boot menu as an advanced option..
"select programs to load during live sessions " .

-47
votes
closed
Solution #10: Insert USB to improve performance
Written by sanketmedhi the 2 Apr 09 at 11:23.
Everyone might not have 2 GB of RAM but everyone has a USB drive. Live sessions booted from CDs can be cached onto USB storage for improved performance.
173
votes
closed
Solution #11: Promote bootable USB
Written by sanketmedhi the 2 Apr 09 at 11:51.
Bootable USB images should be promoted rather than live CDs. Bootable USB drives can be prepared using software such as the one showed on https://help.ubuntu.com/community/Installation/FromUSBStick . Alternatively, the software that runs on Windows when an Ubuntu live CD is inserted should include such a functionality.
-58
votes
closed
Solution #12: fast live session
Written by Dorje the 2 Apr 09 at 22:10.
like solution #9 add an option to deselect unnecessary programmes and also give the percentage increase each unselection generates .
like for eg.
deselecting games =increase in speed 10%
and so on

PS:i don't know much about programmes so i dont know how much speed gain every (possible)deselection will generate
47
votes
closed
Solution #13: Use UnionFS to our advantage
Written by deriamis the 4 Apr 09 at 18:40.
Since the majority of load times is in late-linking the libraries, why not have the often-used libraries in a ramdisk and use UnionFS to overlay those files on a path? In combination with pre-caching (#4), this could be a significant speed boost. If we combine it with using a LiveUSB distro (#11), we could be on par with the performance of the computer itself.
43
votes
closed
Solution #14: Add an option to create a live-usb from the autorun menu of the cd
Written by pepperpupper the 5 Apr 09 at 12:47.
Add an option for creating a live-usb to the autorun menu that pops up when mounting or inserting the cd/iso. Many people will use daemon-tool or similar to mount the cd in Windows, and if they see an option to create a live-usb from the popup menu, that would be a way of making it easier for everyone to do so.
39
votes
closed
Solution #15: Offer a tool for creating a live-usb in occasion with the download link
Written by pepperpupper the 5 Apr 09 at 12:54.
The title is self-descriptive. This would be another way of making it easier for people to find out about the possibility of creating a live-usb.
29
votes
closed
Solution #16: Instead of notification write it in the background.
Written by ll the 6 Apr 09 at 03:52.
A modified background that includes a warning can be used instead of a notification. Many computers at universities that are meant for multiple users use the background to communicate a special procedure especially in libraries for catalogue searches. This will decrease confusion and not use as many resources as a notification (I assume).
14
votes
closed
Solution #17: Install Ubuntu natively from within Windows
Written by pepperpupper the 7 Apr 09 at 14:14.
Make it possible to install a native Ubuntu installation from within Windows to another partition than the one running Windows from or to an USB-memory key, making it easier to install Ubuntu without having to boot into live mode.
5
votes
closed
Solution #18: Calc & disp speed-up performance on log-out based on sys's characteristics
Written by lackscr8ivity the 7 Apr 09 at 14:25.
When running the live session I would guess the memory, processor, hard disk read/write speed (maybe not this one), etc. system hardware & performance are evaluated.
As well, when running a program (game, OpenOffice, etc.) the CD read/write & load time could stored. Thus, when the user ends the live session, in the log-out window list some statistics: "These are the 5 programs you used the most:
From the live CD it took X-amount of real-time to load, but based on your system's hardware, if this were installed, we would expect it would X% faster."
58
votes
closed
Solution #19: disabeling unnecessary services for the live-cd
Written by moose the 14 Apr 09 at 08:08.
So the live-cd shouldn't start services which are not neccessary for testing ubuntu (as some people use the live-cd as a secure system, services like cups are neccessary):

# anachron, atd, cron: I never used a live-cd longer than six hours - why should I create a cronjob?
# acpid, acpi-support, apmd, powernowd, powernowd.early: If I use the live-cd, I want to test if my hardware works and if the software fits my expections, not if the sleep option works.
71
votes
closed
Solution #20: Solution #1 but sooner
Written by Ssdg the 29 Apr 09 at 11:25.
My idea would be to tell it on the first screen (the one that offers you to test, install, etc...).

Like:
Try ubuntu without
Install on your hard drive for better performances
...

not by demoting the live CD mode, but by promoting the installation.

I'm not in advertisement, but ubuntu will look much better.
-84
votes
closed
Solution #21: Make user choose when downloading Ubuntu
Written by chareos the 6 May 09 at 14:08.
Make the Ubuntu download to be an EXE file which lets user choose to create a LiveCD (with performance warning here) OR a LiveUSB.

Also, a performance warning on LiveCD boot itself would be great !
-75
votes
closed
Solution #22: Load LiveCD into temporary file
Written by Avantarius the 10 May 09 at 09:42.
For systems with 1 GiB RAM or less, where solution #5 can't be applied, load the content of the CD in a virtual file system which could be located in a file on the computer's harddisk, i.e. create file on a existing ntfs-partition, an unpartitioned space or even use the m$-windows-swapspace.
55
votes
closed
Solution #23: Put a note into the loading screen
Written by Kver the 16 May 09 at 20:51.
When a live cd shows the loading bar, there's plenty of time for a message such as "Loading and running content from this DVD will result in slow performance, and changes or customizations will not be saved."
5
votes
closed
Solution #24: Use the new notification system
Written by aroach31291 the 22 Oct 09 at 17:19.
Firstly, I think that many of the solutions above are solving the wrong problem. People that try out Ubuntu may think that it is installed by just inserting the CD. The user may have no idea that they are using a LiveCD. After they discover that Ubuntu is "slow", they give up and reboot back into Windows. Notifying the user that they haven't installed Ubuntu yet would be the best way to solve this problem.

Utilize the new notification system. Have it simply display a message when the desktop has finished loading similar to:

Ubuntu is not installed yet! Feel free to use Ubuntu before installing it, but beware that it may be a little slow. If you like what you see click the install icon on your desktop!
2
votes
closed
Solution #25: Show notification when system is waiting for CD drive
Written by mikko.rantalainen the 7 Oct 10 at 06:45.
Live session from USB/flash memory should be pretty okay even today but the real problem is accessing files from optical drive. Even there, the problem is latency, usually not the bandwidth.

The live session should run a small background service that displays a notification message when system is waiting for CD drive to access required data. The message could be along the line "Reading data from CD (installing on the hard drive would improve performance)" [however, the label should not claim to be reading CD if one is booting from e.g. usb memory stick]. The notification should be displayed if read command has waited in disk scheduler queue for more than a second.

This could be extended to deal with installed system, too. It would make sense to point out bottlenecks in the system to the user. If the system feels slow and a notification pops up that says "Waiting for disks (installing a fast SSD drive would improve performance)" would give a reasonable hint to the user which hardware upgrade would help the most. This could be even further extended and a similar notification should pop up if all CPU cores have been taken for more than 5 seconds ("Waiting for processor (upgrading the processor would improve performance)").

See the 19 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 19 Feb 12 at 03:08) >>

Transmission auto-close when no file in download queue  
Written by clemdup the 5 Mar 08 at 20:00. Related project: Transmission. Not an idea
I think that Transmission should automatically close itself when there is no file left in the download/seeding queue. For example when we click the "close" titlebar button. Keeping it on the system with no file in the queue is useless.
95
votes
closed
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #3401
Written by clemdup the 5 Mar 08 at 20:00.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #3401 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!
29
votes
closed
Solution #2: Option to start/stop the network connection, too.
Written by cheesehead the 24 Mar 09 at 12:22.
The torrent app can tell Network Manager (using DBus) to start/stop a connection for users who have limited or expensive or scheduled bandwidth.
The criteria (time,seed radio, etc) for start/stop can be set within the application, or by a third-party applet if the torrent app has DBus support for it.
26
votes
closed
Solution #3: Option to turn off the machine once your seed ratio is 1.0
Written by TwistedLincoln the 26 Mar 09 at 21:48.
The whole point of Bittorrent is that the more users in the swarm, the better it is for everyone. If people start setting their machines to automatically shut off when their download is complete (but they haven't seeded 100%), then swarm efficiency will greatly decrease.
28
votes
closed
Solution #4: Stop machine after downloading a certain file
Written by Klau3 the 27 Mar 09 at 12:59.
Have an option in transmission that turns off the machine as soon as a certain file is downloaded (waiting to finish all downloads would take 3 month xD).

See the 2 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 7 Jan 12 at 15:49) >>

Allow banning all or specific users from commenting on your idea(s)  
Written by jhoger the 19 May 08 at 07:28. Related project: brainstorm.ubuntu.com. Won't implement
Some BS'ers are concerned about other users (shudder!) commenting with negative criticism on their idea.

The idea is that users should be allowed to prevent ALL or SPECIFIC others from "unsolicited" comments on their ideas.

Some details:

a) It has to be a priori, not post-hoc. You have to ban a user before you submit the idea. Otherwise, it is plain censorship
b) Obviously, admins would be exempt
c) I think it's OK to ban a specific user from commenting on all your future ideas. They're your ideas, after all.

The point is that some people (and I think reasonably) may want their idea to stand on its own merits, particularly if it is controversial.

For myself, I would never use such a feature except to ban seriously abusive commentors (from my ideas only). I appreciate all constructive comments on the ideas I submit, including disagrees and -1 with Reason.
-50
votes
closed
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #8798
Written by jhoger the 19 May 08 at 07:28.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #8798 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!

See the 5 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 1 Dec 11 at 06:05) >>

downloads should go to $HOME/Downloads   forum
Written by ubuntu_demon the 21 Mar 08 at 10:07. Global category: Accessibility. Implemented
downloads should go to $HOME/Downloads. XDG_DOWNLOAD_DIR should be set to "$HOME/Downloads" instead of "$HOME/Desktop" in the file ~/.config/user-dirs.dirs.

This Downloads folder should be the default download location for firefox and this folder should be bookmarked in nautilus by xdg-user-dirs-gtk (like Music,Videos,Pictures and Documents).

RATIONALE :
* less cluttered desktop and/or homedir
* still easy to access your downloads
714
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#1): Downloads should go to $HOME/Downloads
Written by ubuntu_demon the 21 Mar 08 at 10:07.
downloads should go to $HOME/Downloads. XDG_DOWNLOAD_DIR should be set to "$HOME/Downloads" instead of "$HOME/Desktop" in the file ~/.config/user-dirs.dirs.

See the 31 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 1 Dec 11 at 06:00) >>

keep it simple  
Written by slashdotaccount the 14 May 08 at 21:53. Global category: Others. Not an idea
dont keep adding and adding programs and features.. thats were microsoft went wrong with vista keep it simple so people will want to use it more
-25
votes
closed
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #8572
Written by slashdotaccount the 14 May 08 at 21:53.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #8572 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!

See the 7 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 30 Nov 11 at 23:53) >>

Add "Update from Local Network Server" to Adept package sources list  
Ubuntu

In :  
Priority : Undefined
Definition : New (Needs guidance)
Implementation : Unknown
Assignee : Michael Vogt

Mentorship is available if you want to fix this bug.
spec
Written by apogee the 4 Mar 08 at 14:18. Global category: Internet & Networking. Already implemented
I have 4 Linux machines on my local network: 2 Kubuntu machines, 1 Xubuntu and 1 UbuntuStudio.

They use packages common to all, and they each have specific packages. When an update is available, I have to download the same update 4 times on a single day. That wastes my bandwidth and reduces my productivity.

Via Google I did locate a page that explained how to set-up a server and link networked machines to first update from the network server, if not found then update from web. But that was incredibly difficult for me to follow (kinda newbie / GUI lover.)

Should any of the networked machines download an update first, it stores it and makes it available for the other machines to update without having to download again.

For instance, when I plug my lap-top into the network in the morning, it updates from the already updated desktop machine first instead of directly from the web.

Once all machines are satisfied that they are properly updated, the .deb files can be marked for removal to free up space again.
266
votes
closed
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #3085
Written by apogee the 4 Mar 08 at 14:18.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #3085 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!
9
votes
closed
Solution #2: Use avahi/zeroconf to share package
Written by Id2ndR the 14 Feb 09 at 17:58.
The idea is simple : just publish the packages you've got in your cache to allow other computers in your LAN to download then.

Blueprint : https://blueprints.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+spec/apt-avahi
10
votes
closed
Solution #3: mdns apt repo
Written by sehrgut the 20 Mar 09 at 17:47.
I don't know I want services like this enabled by default (Okay, I do know: I definitely don't!), but a small server that could be enabled in Synaptic along the lines of "Share my packages on the local network" and "Look for packages on the local network" checkboxes would be nice.

The server could register itself with mdns on the local machine, and "Reload" would check published lists on any machines advertising package availability for the appropriate arch.

The main problem I see is with inadvertently grabbing unstable packages from your neighbour. I'm not well versed in apt-get internals, but I'm fairly certain that to avoid such exigencies, additional metadata would need to be kept.
10
votes
closed
Solution #4: Use apt-cacher-ng
Written by tgm4883 the 20 Mar 09 at 18:39.
Just install apt-cacher-ng and tell other computers to use that system as a proxy. Then that system keeps a copy of all the software that gets installed on all the systems, and grabs from the internet anything that it doesn't have.
-20
votes
closed
Solution #5: these are some suggestions
Written by everlasting.puneet the 20 Mar 09 at 07:32.
I can do two things, one is to
apt-get -qq --print-uris install name-of-package
then list is searched on lan using some peer to peer connections(every one is server and every one is client) like dc++
other thing can be done is synaptic can be used to scan lan.
an option in synaptic can be added which will activate the lan sharing option on by which synaptic will search lan first before downloading from internet.
I have made a tool in java but if apt-get has this inbuilt feature this will be good.
and even we can add some other folders where we store other .deb files and all the folders can be cached to search fast.
this will become a great help for users which are beneath some proxies and have limited bandwidth and download limits.

See the 15 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 22 Nov 11 at 22:20) >>

<< Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... Next >>