Contributor spiderpig
Support kubuntu and kde the way you support ubuntu and gnome
No information about this blueprint
Information is updated every 5 minutes.
Please wait till the next update.
Written by quenturi the 29 Feb 08 at 02:09.
Global category: System.
Implemented
Ubuntu is the name chosen for a global project and a distro based on Gnome. Kubuntu is another distro based on kde from the very same project.
I believe they deserve the same support from the project since Gnome and Kde are the most popular desktop manager out there.
It seems quite obvious to me, the project is very much focused on one and only distro, its first baby : ubuntu.
And it shows. Kubuntu web site looks quite poor and unprofessional compared to ubuntu. Most graphic choices like the kdm default theme (even if it's supposed to be a matter of taste) look, again, unprofessional. And finally the whole distro doesn't seem to have the same amount of attention when it comes to details (one example among others: the little thing on ubuntu warning the user about the existence of proprietary drivers for display which does not exist on kubuntu).
I've been told once, like a year ago, by an ubuntu dev that the situation is such because the project doesn't feel like fragmenting its market share.
Whatever is the official position of the project, I don't think you should do things half way.
The Kde project is itself in full evolution with Kde 4. It does deserve full support from ubuntu.
Thank you for reading.
1225
votes
2007
0
782
Fingerprint readers integration
Ubuntu
In :
Priority : Low
Definition : New (Needs guidance)
Implementation : Unknown
Assignee :
Written by stgraber the 28 Feb 08 at 12:13.
Global category: System.
Implemented
Most business laptops and some of the end user ones too now include a fingerprint reader.
Those are perfectly possible to use on Linux either by using thinkfinger (IBM/Lenovo) or fprint (HP).
The various PAM modules for those should be installed by default or at least be easily installable and integrate correctly in the default desktop.
GDM, gksudo and the gnome screensaver would have to be modified in order to correctly support fingerprint readers.
That way the user would be able to login either by entering is password as usual or using his fingerprint.
1667
votes
2328
0
661
Selected solution (#1):
Auto-generated solution of idea #2
Written by
stgraber the 28 Feb 08 at 12:13.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the
idea #2 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!
<i>Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #2 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution.</i><br /> Thanks!
47
votes
53
3
6
Selected solution (#2):
improve GDM with fingerprint reader option
Written by
musikele the 15 Jan 09 at 12:51.
When Ubuntu starts and GDM comes out, you should be able to login only with your fingerprint, without entering any username.
So, the login window should be with all users like always, but with the possibility to login simply passing the fingerprint. If the fingerprint is recognized, a windows telling "user XXX recognized/accessing" should come out and linux should go on.
If the user is not recognized, a window telling "no user recognized - try again" could be an idea.
The normal login option should always be present, in case of an hardware error one should be always capable to enter with his username - password .
When Ubuntu starts and GDM comes out, you should be able to login only with your fingerprint, without entering any username.
So, the login window should be with all users like always, but with the possibility to login simply passing the fingerprint. If the fingerprint is recognized, a windows telling "user XXX recognized/accessing" should come out and linux should go on.
If the user is not recognized, a window telling "no user recognized - try again" could be an idea.
The normal login option should always be present, in case of an hardware error one should be always capable to enter with his username - password .
10
votes
16
3
6
Selected solution (#3):
Fingerprint for Identification not Authorisation
Written by
doctormo the 15 Jan 09 at 22:19.
The inherent security problem with fingerprints is that you can take anyone's laptop and very easily, using high school chemistry. Take the owners fingerprints and feed it to the reader.
When this topic comes up in Ubuntu Development lists, it's pretty much decided that a fingerprint reader can be used for a bad-ass username, but then the computer must still ask for a password to login.
This also includes using the webcam and some facial recognition tech that's in the pipes.
The inherent security problem with fingerprints is that you can take anyone's laptop and very easily, using high school chemistry. Take the owners fingerprints and feed it to the reader.
When this topic comes up in Ubuntu Development lists, it's pretty much decided that a fingerprint reader can be used for a bad-ass username, but then the computer must still ask for a password to login.
This also includes using the webcam and some facial recognition tech that's in the pipes.
264
votes
268
11
4
Selected solution (#4):
Just use the fedora's solution
The simplest solution is probably to implement the fedora's one:
http://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Features/Fingerprint
107
votes
112
19
5
Selected solution (#5):
Enable it only when warning about security risks
Written by
xfuser4 the 19 Oct 09 at 17:25.
Biometric sensors are known to have potential security risks (see comment).
When enabling finger print readers, the user should be informed about it.
Biometric sensors are known to have potential security risks (see comment).
When enabling finger print readers, the user should be informed about it.
27
votes
34
9
7
Selected solution (#6):
Make it a package file installable like an app.
Written by
Jaksco the 30 Oct 09 at 20:49.
Make it a package file installable like an app.
Make it a package file installable like an app.
35
votes
36
0
1
Selected solution (#7):
Make sure there is an option for fingerprint + password authentication.
Based on the comments about security risks, it seems like this should naturally be an option.
From
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Authentication#History_and_state-of-the-art : "Hybrid or two-tiered authentication methods offer a compelling solution." Fingerprints can be swiped and used and there are plenty of methods for getting a password (peeking, social engineering, brute force, etc.); getting both would likely prove to be more difficult.
At any rate, a fingerprint on top of a normal password would definitely stop a casual snooper.
Based on the comments about security risks, it seems like this should naturally be an option.
From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Authentication#History_and_state-of-the-art : "Hybrid or two-tiered authentication methods offer a compelling solution." Fingerprints can be swiped and used and there are plenty of methods for getting a password (peeking, social engineering, brute force, etc.); getting both would likely prove to be more difficult.
At any rate, a fingerprint on top of a normal password would definitely stop a casual snooper.
12
votes
17
4
5
Selected solution (#8):
show captured fingerprint graphically to demonstrate the device adequacy
Written by
daddo the 8 Nov 09 at 21:43.
Show live the fingerprint reader output graphically and let the users to decide, is it secure enough or not.
At the moment, users don't realize at which quality are their fingerprints captured. Show it them!
It could be also solution for showing how good is the the fingerprint reader which is in use.
Show live the fingerprint reader output graphically and let the users to decide, is it secure enough or not.
At the moment, users don't realize at which quality are their fingerprints captured. Show it them!
It could be also solution for showing how good is the the fingerprint reader which is in use.
2
votes
2
0
0
Selected solution (#9):
make sure at you can login with fingerprint via terminal
Written by
tommis the 22 Nov 09 at 18:10.
If you can login via figerprint in gdm terminal should support it too.
If you can login via figerprint in gdm terminal should support it too.