Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 22823 ideas, 138726 comments, 2639112 votes
Idea sandbox Idea sandbox
Popular ideas Popular ideas
Ideas in development Ideas in development
Implemented ideas Implemented ideas

Contributor reverendlinux

ubuntuforums.org may look unofficial for certain users  
Written by wolterh the 27 Jan 09 at 05:58. Related project: ubuntuforums.org. Already implemented
Being the forums site away from the ubuntu.com server, people might get the wrong idea that it is not an official forum. Also, it looks disorganized that some sites like this one, brainstorm.ubuntu.com are hosted as branches of the ubuntu.com site, and others, like the forums already mentioned, are hosted separatedly.

Now, I know that if you browse for http://forums.ubuntu.com/ you will probably get redirected to ubuntuforums.org, but it is not the same thing.
724
votes
closed
Solution #1: Move ubuntuforums.org to forums.ubuntu.com on an 100% basis
Written by wolterh the 27 Jan 09 at 05:58.
The feel of ubuntu would look cleaner. Besides, is it that hard a thing to do?

Imagine if brainstorm.ubuntu.com was hosted as ubuntubrainstorm.com ... Which do you prefer? I prefer brainstorm.ubuntu.com. It gives me a feeling that it is official. It gives me the feeling that ubuntu is an organized OS and that I will find whatever I need at ubuntu.com, by being linked to either the forums section, the brainstorm section, or any other branch I need. Maybe even an irc.ubuntu.com could be made to provide users the excellence of service that the irc channel provides on the comfort of their internet browser.
-173
votes
closed
Solution #2: Direct subdomains of Ubuntu to official websites
Written by andruk the 27 Jan 09 at 08:56.
(Copied from my comment below:)
Direct forums.ubuntu.com, forum.ubuntu.com, help.ubuntu.com, etc. to ubuntuforums.org. That way people can still access ubuntuforums.org via its domain, and converts can access a better domain name (imho). I would also try to get an optional single sign-on going for all of the official websites.

I would also have irc.ubuntu.com be a web-based IRC client that connects to #ubuntu on freenode. Include the links to the support websites (including the wiki) on the default home page for Firefox.

See the 12 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 9 Jul 11 at 15:52) >>

Update Manager is not optimized for low speed Internet.  
Written by ravibuz the 16 Jul 09 at 12:23. Global category: Internet & Networking. In development
Update Manager Is not optimized for people with slow internet connection..For me it nearly takes 2 days to update a version of ubuntu from update manager.
654
votes
inprogress
Selected solution (#1): Add Pause and shutdown button
Written by ravibuz the 16 Jul 09 at 12:23.
If you had a pause button we could pause the download and continue later,We have stop button but it sometimes corrupts the download file.And also add a "Shut down after installation"button to the download manager so that we need no be around when it is updating.
392
votes
inprogress
Selected solution (#2): Limit the bandwidth consumed by update Manager
Written by ravibuz the 16 Jul 09 at 12:25.
Add a button the control the bandwidth used by the update manager while downloading,So that we could browse and do other things.This will help people like me with less bandwidth.
273
votes
inprogress
Selected solution (#3): Allow Timed Update
Written by ravibuz the 16 Jul 09 at 12:32.
Set a clock in update manager where we can tell it to update in a particular period of time and stop in a particular time.This will be helpful for people with limited download.
142
votes
inprogress
Selected solution (#5): Let the Update Manager "feel" the use of the net
Written by Rodrigo the 18 Jul 09 at 08:14.
I remember a few years back a daemon for the SETI project that "felt" the use of the processor, and when it was idle it would make its calculations.
Something similar with the internet would be nice. So it would be downloading, but when you want to see a new web or send an email the net will be free in very little time. Maybe through a "pause" as Solution #1 said.
-34
votes
inprogress
Selected solution (#7): Add Support for SuperDebs
Written by sf_007 the 20 Jul 09 at 14:02.
There is something called SuperDebs that seems useful to users with slow internet (or no internet at all), but is more focused on new installs of software
274
votes
inprogress
Selected solution (#8): Use better compression as much as possible.
Written by yaknowwat the 21 Jul 09 at 05:55.
LZMA has been updated with LZMA2 included in the newer beta's of 7z which is making it into Karmic.

It seems with the new LZMA2 compression using 2 threads and Solid compression it gives better compression than even RAR's upcoming WINRAR64 with comparable speeds.(LZMA2 with 4 or more threads is about 50% faster and 2 or less threads is about 20% slower, though 2 threads has better compression.)
[ Note: This is for compressing LZMA2Solid could easily be far faster at decompressing ]

I know it won't be as big a difference as moving to delta's but it will cause about a 30% reduction compared to the current tar.gz compression used now which is actually very large when you consider some people have to download 200 MB in gunzip compressed updates with LZMA2 it would be around 150 MB. Huge difference if your connection is slow.

Downside is compression is slower with lzma ,but its designed to have decompression speeds like gunzip fortunately.
-53
votes
inprogress
Selected solution (#9): Create a update package file
Written by fernandoc1 the 30 Jul 09 at 15:06.
With an update package file, people can download the most recent updates in a single file and install it.
This solution could help people with slow internet connection, because they can get the file in a Lan House or with a friend that has already downloaded the updates and keep it with him for future use.
It could work like a "service pack" for example, and become available in the ubuntu official site.
I think that with it, there will be even an economy of Ubuntu mirrors bandwidth, because in many places, people put many machines in a same network to update directly from the mirrors and it is not reasonable, because the same download will be done many times.
With the update as a single file package, any download manager can resume a partial download of the file.
-57
votes
inprogress
Selected solution (#10): Blend to background
Written by put4558350 the 30 Jul 09 at 15:52.
By doing this. The update process will look blend to background. User can just using the computer when download of update file is in progress.

- hidden interface as much as possible.
- put QOS (quality of service) over it. so it dosn't take bandwidth too much when user using internet.
- update as much package as it downloaded when user shutdown or startup so no file is in used.

Optional

- sort important update on top of download list. so important update package get update first.
- reusme last package. so long package can finish.
- popup when download compleate or error.
111
votes
inprogress
Selected solution (#11): LAN P2P update
Written by Drebon the 2 Aug 09 at 11:10.
In certain cases, people have got one low bandwidth connection with a bunch of pc in lan behind. If update manager was able to seed it's downloaded update on local networks it would reduce the usage of bandwidth (only one download per arch).

I think Apple has something similar
81
votes
inprogress
Selected solution (#12): Support continuation of terminated download
Written by fukanchik the 3 Aug 09 at 08:33.
I use low bandwidth gprs connection. During updates i very often see that in the middle of downloading a package the process terminates and starts over from zero (!) again downloading what has already been downloaded! And over and over and over. During this process it consumes times more traffic than entire update. It looks like bug.

If update manager will support continuation of terminated download process (like wget or sometimes firefox does) it will be very helpful.

Upd: delta updates alone will not fix the problem. Such update can itself be of large size.
20
votes
inprogress
Selected solution (#13): Integrate Ksplice Uptracker
Written by spocky the 3 Aug 09 at 20:21.
At least for the updating of the kernel the uptracker (ksplice.com) can apply diff updates (at least this is what i understood).
-23
votes
inprogress
Selected solution (#14): Add a "help a buddy" feature to Synaptic
Written by mdhunn the 4 Aug 09 at 19:49.
Actually this would be two features. Add the ability to export a list of the installed packages and their versions installed on one machine along with any apps desired onto a thumb drive. And of course the corresponding feature to download and update the drive.

Basically just an update to the download / add packages feature that's all ready there. After all an update done in Synaptic is just as valid as one done in Update Manager or by using apt on the command line. Having both a laptop and a desktop, I might even get some use out of that when my home connection goes down.
-46
votes
inprogress
Selected solution (#15): Split it
Written by Afroman10496 the 5 Aug 09 at 22:09.
Split it into two parts:

Part one- download the file to one big file

Part two- then, when it is finished downloading, install it with absolutely no need for the Internet.

That way, nothing can screw up the update due to Internet connection failure.
33
votes
inprogress
Selected solution (#16): Generate a download script.
Written by Darwin Survivor the 9 Aug 09 at 22:13.
The package manager is capable of generating a download script, so why not the update manager?

The user could then take that download script to a friend's house, a library or their school and download the files to USB, CD, etc. Then simply insert the media in their computer and BOOM, updated!

It may also be an idea to make the script and OS agnostic as possible (many libraries only have windows) or allow the user to select what OS they will be using to do the download (windows can do ftp via CLI, so it should be possible).
833
votes
inprogress
Selected solution (#17): Show download rate and add pause option
Written by sirish.gauni the 1 Nov 09 at 18:00.
You could just add a pause option to the software center and also show the download rates. Further more if the software center can be made such a way that when the network/internet goes off the download doesn't stop completely and starts from where it left of when the internet is back.

This idea can also be applied to Update manager.
237
votes
inprogress
Selected solution (#18): Allow multiple Downloads
Written by Sebin Benjamin the 5 Nov 09 at 16:47.
Allow multiple downloads to take place using all of the bandwidth Or limit usage. Sometimes some files/servers have very low speed. So simultaneous downloads would be helpful

Anyway why would anyone waste time for each file to get downloaded, whereas you could let it download 2 or 3 files depending on the bandwidth and finish the updates faster.
66
votes
inprogress
Selected solution (#19): support download by torrent
Written by _sebastian_ the 24 Nov 09 at 12:12.
why not support downloads by torrents to ease load on the servers...

See the 17 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 9 Jul 11 at 15:29) >>

Making the GNOME panel better  
Written by baldurpet the 14 Feb 09 at 18:11. Related project: Gnome. Won't implement
There are a couple of things related to the panel which could/should be improved. Keep in mind that this isn't some huge problem, but rather something which could be made better: (I'm going to add the problems as solutions)
567
votes
closed
Solution #1: Improve transparency of the panel
Written by baldurpet the 14 Feb 09 at 18:11.
When you make the panel transparent (Properties > Background > Solid colour, and then making the "style" transparent) the little things at each end of the panel don't become transparent (when the panel isn't expanded), nor does the background of the Workspace switcher).

A simple solution would just be to make the things at the end and the workspace switcher transparent as well.
410
votes
closed
Solution #2: Round the edges
Written by baldurpet the 14 Feb 09 at 18:28.
Why isn't there a simple option to "round the edges" of the panel?

There shouldn't be that hard adding a small option into the properties where it could include something like:

Round edges
Radius: 20
398
votes
closed
Solution #3: Adding a small gloss to the panel
Written by baldurpet the 14 Feb 09 at 18:35.
Adding a small gloss feature to the panel?
An effect like this would be too resource heavy, and could really add some 'bling' I guess. Just something as simple as this; a really classy ivory white panel.

Again, this would be something you could enable and disable from the properties window.

Edit: I noticed something really cool by accident. I looked at my lower panel, saw this and thought "wow, gnome has that effect?" (I'm talking about the real subtle glow on the top), but then I saw that it was just the watermark of my wallpaper (the screenshot of my desktop also shows the problem in solution one). I don't see why this couldn't be added without making GNOME bloated.
346
votes
closed
Solution #4: Adding a few simple themes to the panel
Written by baldurpet the 15 Feb 09 at 05:21.
I think the panel looks (and especially) feels way too boxy. It's like in bad animations, you don't expect the animation to become flashy because it doesn't give you a reason to. When ever I think of the GNOME panel I think of a monotonous box, because quite frankly that's what it is.

You can change between themes in the appearance preferences, well why isn't there an option like that for the panel? Themes could include something like this, this, akin to the KDE kicker (something like a less childish version of this) or even this (yaya Vista, I dislike the company Microsoft for a lot of reasons, and I think Vista looks way too gaudy in general but I do like the way the panel looks).
273
votes
closed
Solution #5: Allowing extra options for the menu button
Written by baldurpet the 15 Feb 09 at 05:32.
Seriously, I don't know why changing something as simple as the picture of the menu button isn't possible (well, of course it's possible- but John Doe can't do neither do it easily nor from the panel's properties screen).

What I was thinking about would be to both allow a simple change of the picture in the menu button, and also to add ways to change it's look (again like Vista, and both these and this one look particularly sleek).

Also something like this, damn that looks good.
186
votes
closed
Solution #6: Saving preferences
Written by baldurpet the 15 Feb 09 at 05:58.
I'm sorry for posting so many solutions, only each time I'm thinking about a problem I keep thinking about new things which could be implemented.

I was just thinking about something straight forward like being able to save the settings for your panel (they could even be included in the appearance preferences?

I'm maybe thinking about if you want to change your computer's theme to "winter-snow white" then you would want your panel to be white, and glossy- maybe with round edges. And then when you want to try the snow panel again you could just select it from a list with pictures.
91
votes
closed
Solution #7: Prepare moving to gnome-do
Written by yzarc the 15 Feb 09 at 19:12.
Gnome-do is not ready yet. But I believe that is more interesting to spend time finishing it than putting lip stick in the gnome-panel.
News features of gnome-do need compositing but improving gnome-panel without compositing is useless too.
121
votes
closed
Solution #8: Move keyboard shortcuts listening to separate daemon
Written by Psycho_zs the 18 Feb 09 at 11:34.
Right now keyboard shortcuts in GNOME are being processed by gnome-panel. Move this function to a separate daemon, so removing gnome-panel wouldn't disable the use of keyboard shortcuts.
195
votes
closed
Solution #9: Setting icon size
Written by erikkll the 18 Feb 09 at 11:41.
Right now, if you resize the panel to let's say 48px, the icons grow too.

It would be useful to have an option to keep them the same (small) size, thus making it possible to group them together (make rows/columns) so that instead of having 4 icons next to each other, you can have a group of four icons in a 2x2 group.
-62
votes
closed
Solution #10: Scroll panel if there are a lot of items on it and resolution is decreased
Written by Psycho_zs the 18 Feb 09 at 11:42.
If desktop is switched to resolution insufficient to hold all items in panel, when resolution is restored, items arrangement becomes a mess. Either right away or after another start of DE.
The solution would be: scroll panel on low resolutions, so items would be in their places when resolution is restored.
70
votes
closed
Solution #11: Add an option to the panel that lets it appear below windows
Written by sambaloelek the 18 Feb 09 at 13:40.
Some people may not want the panel to be above the windows, so if you only use it for notifications or whatever.
There should be given a possibility to keep it below other windows.
70
votes
closed
Solution #12: Effects in bottom panel
Written by justy the 21 Feb 09 at 10:03.
Make the background a nice gradient and enlarge the icon on the active program, like this:
http://img158.imageshack.us/img158/6992/down.png



123
votes
closed
Solution #13: Hide panel completely on autohide
Written by manishmahabir the 21 Feb 09 at 18:19.
Currently to hide the panel completely, I have to set it from gconf-editor. It should hide completely by default.
47
votes
closed
Solution #14: Provide an option to disable some tooltips
Written by codeslicer the 21 Feb 09 at 22:27.
Sometimes the tooltips that show over the window list when Window Previews are enabled, or that "Click to view your appointments and tasks" tooltip is annoying.

We should have an option to disable some of these tooltips if we don't want them.
251
votes
closed
Solution #15: Get rid of all the oldschool GNOME themes
Written by 311005901 the 22 Feb 09 at 14:04.
Whenever I show my friends how cool Ubuntu is, the first thing they want to see is the themes. Then, they see such gems as "Aging Gorilla," "Crux," and "High Contrast."

Delete the ugly ones, make "High Contrast" available in an Accessibility package.
29
votes
closed
Solution #16: Add an animated colored background to the panel
Written by wouter215 the 21 Feb 09 at 14:56.
Add an animated colored background to the panel.
Like smooth slow moving ribbon like color themes.
167
votes
closed
Solution #17: New panel background diferent from Windows and Mac Os X
Written by twocool the 21 Feb 09 at 13:05.
I agree that Ubuntu should have a better default panel background, but it should be diferent from the windows and mac os toolbars
-95
votes
closed
Solution #18: Black or shiny white toolbar
Written by you-buntu the 20 Feb 09 at 22:36.
like mac or windows
91
votes
closed
Solution #19: Add support for multi-row applets
Written by stetzen the 1 Mar 09 at 01:21.
At the moment, panel applets can be placed only in one row (with extremely rare exceptions, like window list applet), so that changing the size of the panel changes only the size of the applet (if doing anything at all). It will be great to add possibility of putting applets in more than one row.

Possible way of doing in is to create an applet called container, which has customizable size and can be divided in a few lines. Other applets can be added to these lines like they are added to the regular panel.
82
votes
closed
Solution #20: System Tray Applet loads in background.
Written by coder543 the 3 Mar 09 at 01:01.
When you login the System Tray Applet takes a long time to load... until then, the whole panel is frozen (along with basically everything else.)
-17
votes
closed
Solution #21: Hide unused/inactive system tray icons in Gnome - notification area
Written by slsolaris the 12 Mar 09 at 02:56.
When we have a lot of icons in the notification area they should automatically be hidden, like in windows and KDE, with an arrow as you can see in the screen shot:
http://cybernetnews.com/wp-content/uploads/2007/01/SystemTrayCalendar.jpg
23
votes
closed
Solution #22: Better Applets Alignment
Written by Shady3D the 28 Mar 09 at 08:42.
i want to be able to specify some applets to be in the middle of the panel and some in the left and some in the right but the problem is that some time when applet expands some empty spaces appear and it requires reorganizing.
0
votes
closed
Solution #23: Panels recognize order
Written by Shady3D the 28 Mar 09 at 08:48.
i like to put panels one one the top and the other underneath it but what i restart panels or computer sometimes the lower panel becomes up so i have to switch them and i can't put the lower panel to the bottom as i have gnome-do dock.
105
votes
closed
Solution #24: Dynamic Applet Spacing
Written by chappell101 the 28 Mar 09 at 23:42.
The mock up shown below is from Hylke's Home Blog and shows how just by perfectly sorting the spacing of the applet icons to match a grid and using a more typographic date/time a more professional appearance can be achieved. The icons spacing dynamically increases as the taskbar is increased in size to match visually! The subtle colour pallet grid also helps separate the content for legibility!



http://www.bomahy.nl/hylke/blog/ugly-notification-area-in-gnome/
20
votes
closed
Solution #25: Change font and font color easier
Written by snooooopy8 the 8 May 09 at 08:47.
When you change background (color or image ) and you make a black panel you can't read the text anymore because it is black too.
If you want to change the font color... you have to create file in home or download special programs.

Why not add some customization option in the properties option like "font color"?
27
votes
closed
Solution #26: Option to "Lock All" / "Unlock All" Applets on the Panel
Written by phoenix the 21 May 09 at 10:21.
When I want to rearrange the applets on the panel, I find myself having to unlock each applet (including separators), move things around and then lock everything again.

With a default of 5-7 applets on the standard panel this is a bit cumbersome.

It would be convenient to right-click on any empty space on the panel and get an option to "Unlock All Applets" / "Lock All Applets".
8
votes
closed
Solution #28: more independent and innovative applet behavior.
Written by yzarc the 10 Jun 09 at 15:05.
The only reason for I still need a panel fixed on my desktop is because i need put gnome applets there. There are some applet that I need to have always on my view (clock, system monitor, notification area, launchers, network, etc).

I'm suggest to a totally new behavior for gnome applet, they should be tread as gadgets that can be fix on a panel, on the desktop and ON THE BOARDS.

In the fist case they will work like they already work today. in the second case, they should work like gadgets. But in the last case they should work in an innovative way. Due my English limitation I will try to explain by mockups.

once on board is used to store an applet, one tine space of that board is reserved to show the miniaturization of that applet. As shown the mini-applet should be composed by only icons in such way that the user can get some information just look at it. the reserved space should be customizable.

Photobucket
here some idea of how the clock and system monitor could look like in the mini form.

Photobucket
on mouse hover or click the get the expanded form. the dimensions could be customized determining the amount of information display for some applet.

Photobucket
Here the system monitor, also the possibility to fix the applet in the expanded form could be gave.
11
votes
closed
Solution #29: Launchers aligned grids
Written by Dragonfly the 22 Jul 09 at 10:13.
Add an option that allows launchers only be placed in the grid.
6
votes
closed
Solution #30: Add an option in preferences that allows for a dock like the one in Mac OS X
Written by Dragonfly the 25 Jul 09 at 20:58.
Add an option in preferences that allows switching classics launchers to the desktop there is a dock like the one in Mac OS X.
0
votes
closed
Solution #31: 1 Panel instead of 2
Written by _khAttAm_ the 21 Dec 09 at 15:41.
Two panels are not good. 2 panels takes up space and the upper panel is truoblesome. I have seen people having hard time with panels who just moved from Windows.

It should look something like this:
http://img687.imageshack.us/img687/7643/mockup.png
5
votes
closed
Solution #32: Make gnome-panel support Themes
Written by _khAttAm_ the 21 Dec 09 at 15:46.
Gnome-panel should include support for themes. The themes should define how any panels are there and what kind of menus it contains. It should also define how different parts of panels look.
1
votes
closed
Solution #33: Custom option regarding trancparency, color, animation and gradient
Written by jekristiansen the 22 Jan 10 at 23:13.
The panel should really have some option to choose from.
What i have in mind is multiple gradient color with support for tranparency on each one of them.
It should also have support for animations, and how about support for screensavers?
Glass effects would be something too?
This way, anyone can make their choice in how they want to customize the panel, and it could even overcome the KDE panels
Here is a mockup of how it "could" look
http://www.4shared.com/file/206213772/5fde7b97/Ubuntu_Mockup.html
2
votes
closed
Solution #34: Always align the applet/launcher to one of the edges
Written by etrusco the 4 Feb 10 at 09:50.
Let's stop with the applet positioning madness. Just do what the XFCE launcher do!
Or at least add the option to do so...
-2
votes
closed
Solution #35: Use a simple background
Written by joehms22 the 6 Feb 10 at 16:03.
use a simple background image on the panel.

http://picasaweb.google.com/joehms22/Ubuntu#5435161341042485586

The pictures uses a simple gradient.
1
votes
closed
Solution #36: Options for menus
Written by paradox_twelve the 6 Oct 10 at 03:24.
Maybe at the least an option to change the color of the pop up menu other then the themes default, and maybe allow transparency without having to use custom commands in compiz. Also improve for panel transparency to cancel out the themes default panel.

See the 19 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 7 Jul 11 at 18:19) >>

ubuntu-restricted-extras is essential for many users  
Written by mankelin the 14 Jul 09 at 21:27. Related project: Live CD installer. Implemented
The ubuntu-restricted-extras metapackage includes a JRE, Adobe Flash and various video/audio codecs, among other things. These components are not installed by default due to possible legal problems.

However, for many, if not most desktop users, these componentes are essential and thus they install this metapackage right after the Ubuntu installation, if they know about it. New users don't, and this is bad for the initial user experience. For the more experienced users, having to install it manually feels like a chore.
669
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#1): Offer the user the choice to install the package
Written by mankelin the 14 Jul 09 at 21:27.
Directly after installation, or after first boot, pop up a dialog asking the user whether he/she wants to install the package (in an appropriate way).
It should be worded so that a lay person can understand the benefits, e.g. something like:

"Do you want to install optional support for various audio/video formats and web plugins? Without installing this, you might have problems playing back audio or video files and certain web sites will not work correctly."

The dialog should offer simple "Yes" and "No" buttons. If the user chooses "Yes", the meta package and its dependencies should be downloaded and installed. If the user chooses "No", he should be reminded that he/she can later install the "ubuntu-restricted-extras" package with Synaptic, should he/she decide otherwise.
-149
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#2): Add apturl to a "Start Here" icon on desktop
Written by Clorox the 20 Jul 09 at 02:55.
Add a sentence and a link to "apt:ubuntu-restricted-extras?refresh=yep" to Solution #2 of http://brainstorm.ubuntu.com/idea/8074/.

The solution there is for introduction to Ubuntu by an icon on the desktop that loads a simple HTML window, with simple introductory things such as how to install packages.
-178
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#3): Have it undercover, but ask to delete or keep it
Written by Afroman10496 the 22 Jul 09 at 01:40.
Keep it in the /tmp directory, and when one opens an mp3 file or tries to view flash, ask if they want to keep it or delete it. If they answer yes, show them the legal stuff and if they agree to it, and install it in the directories for a regular installation. If they answer no, tell them what they will not have and how to install it later. Delete it from the /tmp directory if they answer that.

*TO AVOID LEGAL STUFF, IN THE INSTALLER MENU FOR LOCATION, IF THEY SAY THEY ARE IN A COUNTRY WHERE IT IS ILLEGAL TO HAVE IT, DON'T INSTALL IT IN THE /tmp directory!*
100
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#4): Integrate the option into the installation process
Written by suit the 3 Aug 09 at 20:25.
This could just be implemented somewhere during installation as

[ ] Install stuff to be able to view flash content right away.
# (Of course rephrased by a more eloquent person!)

The download could start (if eth0 or others are found) during installation or afterwards. Alternatively an icon could show up as with the "restricted hardware drivers" after the first boot.
62
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#5): Integrate this with restricted drivers
Written by cos the 4 Aug 09 at 15:00.
As in solution #1, but also suggest to install restricted drivers, if they are available. e.g. have checkboxes and descriptions of what can be installed.
-30
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#6): Add a Codec Install wizard
Written by CJ Master the 5 Aug 09 at 21:08.
This idea expands on Solution #2. Instead of simply having an apt-url link to install it, the link will run a program. This program will tell the user the standard legal precautions about it, and will link to a website where you may legally buy the Codecs if you live in the U.S. If the user agrees that they live in a location that's legal for them to be installed for free, it'll download/install the codecs and remove the icon from the desktop.
0
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#7): Modification of Solution 1: Have it downloaded
Written by Sebin Benjamin the 10 Aug 09 at 17:40.
Directly after installation, or after first boot, pop up a dialog asking the user whether he/she wants to install the package (in an appropriate way).
It should be worded so that a lay person can understand the benefits.

The dialog should offer simple "Yes" and "No" buttons. If the user chooses "Yes", the meta package and its dependencies should be INSTALLED FROM THE SAME CD OR DOWNLOAD. Ihis this case there wont be a waste of time downloading all the files
26
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#8): Modification of Solution 1: Warn about the risks.
Written by misiu_mp the 21 Aug 09 at 14:08.
Except for informing of the benefits the notification should warn about the drawbacks of using this package (legality, patents, closed source) and the benefits of supporting open standards.
21
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#9): Automaticly download it when the user tries to read one of the formats if cover
Written by qwerty800 the 28 Aug 09 at 20:14.
For exemple, if I try to read an MP3 file, the system would ask me:

"You're trying to read a MPEG Audio Layer3 file, which is unreadable by Ubuntu by default for patent reasons.
Do you want to install the necessary codecs to read this, as well as support for the formats listed under:

+ *Shockwave Flash
*Java Runtime environment
*MPEG-4 Part 14
*etc...

But not only this, it should do that for every restricted formats, like DVDs!

People want to play DVDs on their computer! If a such system was aviable for those formats, that woul be a success!

"You just a DVD Video, which is unreadable by Ubuntu by default..."
17
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#10): Also Offer to add the Medibuntu repository
Written by cos the 16 Sep 09 at 11:20.
Medibuntu contains a bunch of restricted multimedia codecs, fonts, drivers etc that are not part of the main repo for licensing reasons. For me, its packages greatly improve support for playback of some formats including wmv and realvideo, and allow my webcam to work -- these are important things for typical desktop users coming from Windows, where these are taken for granted.

I believe it would be greatly beneficial for the majority of users to make this repo easily available, even if it is never merged with the main Ubuntu repos. If Ubuntu offers at any point to install restricted stuff automatically, it should also offer to add Medibuntu to Software Sources. That would save each new user a few hours of Googling and frustration.

For the long-term, perhaps it's more logical that all restricted extras packages be moved into Medibuntu to keep a cleaner separation of what is and isn't restricted. Of course, it doesn't have to be Medibuntu -- any new repo should do.
3
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#11): solutions #1 and #9 but cut the popup box.
Written by tommynz1975 the 10 Nov 09 at 23:08.
maybe others...

but cut this popup box business, this is one thing that infuriated me with windows.

I would think the system was ready for use, I'd go start doing something only for a popup box to take screen/keyboard focus.

having migrated from 6.06 to 9.04 on this system, I have to say having icons appear on the menu panel top of screen is more pleasing, to alert the user of information.

Many times you get that lovely message, Installing this codec may not be legal in your country.

surely by now we have enough loco teams to make a database answering this question and this question could be answered by your location settings and the database, as we all install stuff on the assumption its okay until its forcefully pointed out otherwise
1
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#12): Also inform users of Adobe Flash Player EULA legal problems
Written by Lyfang the 21 Jun 11 at 05:39.
The Adobe Flash Player End User License Agreement prohibits reverse engineering and more. Therefore developers cannot develop a competing Flash player if they've accepted the Adobe Flash Player EULA.

See also
https://answers.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/flashplugin-nonfree/+question/1354 00

See the 20 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 7 Jul 11 at 17:28) >>

Better install experience  
Written by yookoala the 11 Mar 09 at 07:17. Global category: Installation. Implemented
While I was installing Jaunty, I can't help but thinking if we can get a better installation experience. It start with a plain idea, and I think many of you might have your own suggestion.

Developer comments
I accidentally deleted the "make the installation full screen" suggestion. Apologies, that was not intentional. As of Ubuntu 9.04, the desktop installer already goes full screen when the "Install Ubuntu" option is selected from the CD boot menu. We have no plans to make the installer full screen when running the installer from the live CD desktop (when "Try or Install Ubuntu" is selected) because we want to encourage people to use the live system.

Regarding the slideshow suggestions. This has been a feature we've been trying to nail down for a few releases. Unfortunately it would be best accomplished by the desktop experience team, and they were too busy this release to work on it, so it has been deferred to 9.10.

https://wiki.ubuntu.com/UbiquitySlideshow has the 9.04 discussion, and https://wiki.ubuntu.com/Ubiquity/Slideshow has the discussions that occurred before that.
-626
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#1): Play some music during installation
Written by yookoala the 11 Mar 09 at 07:17.
As title. It can be some short, simple melody that can be looped. I think I'd feel better if I have something to listen while watching the progress bar grows.

It would be better if user can mute this music at the installer interface.
892
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#2): Show more about ubuntu
Written by hemanth.hm the 11 Mar 09 at 17:07.
Show more about ubuntu , like what ubuntu means ? How it grew ? What all can be done with it ? so on ...in the background as it is installed , also provide an option to hide the info if the user already knows it and is not interested :)
538
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#4): Add an option to shutdown the PC when done installing
Written by Cé the 13 Mar 09 at 09:45.
So I can start the installation friday at work at 16:45, answer the questions, set the checkbox "shutdown the PC when installation has been finished" and go home for the weekend.

On monday I start the PC, and have a freshly installed PC.
907
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#6): Show a mini tutorial during installation.
Written by kgamer the 15 Mar 09 at 09:08.
This is a feature that Windows has had since 95. All it is is it shows how windows in 'good' and how it improves over the previous version. This way, users know what the advantages are of the version, and how to use it.

It's mainly a solution aimed at new users.
41
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#7): Show a video about Free Software, and the history of GNU/Linux
Written by jamesmcm the 15 Mar 09 at 12:14.
This would be good in educating users about what they are using and why it is important. A tutorial would also be handy. Perhaps see if you can distribute the Ubuntu Pocket Guide and Free Software, Free Society for free with it.
-314
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#9): Asks more question
Written by Lachu the 17 Mar 09 at 16:33.
I now, that probably many people hate this idea.

In my opinion, we should allow user to select wallpaper or theme. It can be done during installation(copying files). When install process was done and user answer to all question, we can close look&fell creator and copying additional files.

The conception looks like: we start copying files, so we open additional dialog.
-131
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#10): Already start using Ubuntu while the system is being installed
Written by adaniels the 18 Mar 09 at 13:39.
You can use the Ubuntu right from the Live CD/USB-drive.

It should be possible to install Ubuntu on the system in the background while the user is simply already using Ubuntu directly from the Live disk.

When the installation completes display the normal request to restart the system. On restart, the data from the temporary home directory is copied to the final home directory of the user.
-108
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#11): Get answers to questions from existing installations
Written by hdhfm the 18 Mar 09 at 21:58.
Offer to get the answers from an existing installation (previous version or other desktop like KDE) on the same machine or from another already perfectly installed machine.

The second one could be like "go to the Ubuntu PC to be cloned, insert a USB stick, click on System/Administration/Get System Configuration, when the the file is created, take the USB stick and insert it in the PC on which Ubuntu should be installed" The rest is done automatically. Maybe even including that the same programs are installed and personal settings and home directory are copied.
312
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#13): Add a menu to enable/disable the programs to install
Written by lqtdc the 20 Mar 09 at 19:49.
Ubuntu comes with a lot of programs. No everybody install all programs.
100
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#14): Offer games for the user to play.
Written by jackmcslay the 21 Mar 09 at 01:03.
Konami has done a lot of this on games that have considerably long load times, so why not?

When it starts copying files, open up a menu with the games that are installed on Ubuntu by default.

This way the user actually HAS something to do while the installation takes place
129
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#16): Extension to #2 and #6
Written by James_Lochhead the 22 Mar 09 at 05:11.
Just to add a little. I think that should be more of a tutorial on Ubuntu and its features rather than information on history.

I do not feel that the user documentation is friendly enough yet for people with low computing ability and this would be an ideal place to teach them some of the basics.

Good things to introduce could be:

1) The basic user interface.

2) Each of the major applications (such as Firefox, OO etc). For example, "By default Ubuntu has the Firefox web browser installed. Firefox is an open source application produced by the Mozilla Corporation." Along with a few slides showing Firefox and its location.

4) Package management. The Add/Remove programs tool would be probably be the best idea here. Although I think some mention of the Synaptic as an alternative should be made.

5) The root user. Many people find this confusing when first switching over. A short explanation of the root user and its benefits would be a good idea.

6) Links to further information? For example, the Ubuntu forums and that e-book on Ubuntu.

-144
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#17): Video or minimise
Written by Basem the 23 Mar 09 at 05:25.
Either show the video of Mandela talking about Ubuntu, or hide the installer in the notification area and notify the user that he/she can use Ubuntu while the installer is running in the background.
-89
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#19): Kernel selector
Written by afisamuleal the 23 Mar 09 at 23:29.
Similar to solution #13, I would like to have been able to install the rt kernel. A menu or menu you can choose to view that would choose from a couple non-standard kernels or allow you to patch them before install would be cool.
143
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#20): Do all the other things and download updates in the background
Written by t4ggs the 24 Mar 09 at 08:54.
...it's better downloading the updates while the installation...cause u r not using your computer anyway.\

its really annoying that after the installation finished and you want to use your computer, u have to download all the updates.
-56
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#21): One-click install
Written by cousteau the 30 Mar 09 at 20:24.
Show a screen with a default/autodetected config summary, so the future user only needs to check if it's ok, enter a username and a password and click Install.
Options could be individually configured if the user wants to (e.g. change the locales, select which programs will be installed, use manual partitioning, etc... each one with its own config screen).
-65
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#22): Interactive slideshow/presentation
Written by mydoghasworms the 31 Mar 09 at 07:13.
Normally, slideshows are static. It would be nice to provide an interactive presentation for the user to have a choice as to what they can learn about. E.g. present a few points and say "click here to learn more", so they can choose to see what interests them.
44
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#23): Offer to seek out wider packages/drivers
Written by jamesisin the 4 Apr 09 at 19:11.
One problem that I have run into in installing Ubuntu is that sometimes I would like to install the desktop software onto (former) server hardware. That is often not possible due to differing drivers being included on the desktop version and the server version.

Could it be possible to have the installer carry a wider array of drivers to cover more installation types and then be able to download other necessary drivers during its installation process?

(This relates to solution 19 above.)
23
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#24): Add selection of units and paper size.
Written by ll the 6 Apr 09 at 03:15.
Allow the user to select the units (metric vs. imperial) and paper size (A4 vs. that other size) they want to use by default similar to the keyboard. I know that not all software will follow this selection but it would be a start. This could be in an advanced tab like grub install options.

I just hate having it default to imperial units because I select USA as my place of residence. Ordinarily I would say just to force everyone to use metric and be done with it but that is not in the spirit of Linux so I will settle for letting the user choose. But I at least want the choice.
12
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#25): Ability to install applications along with the base-system
Written by André Rantzow the 25 May 09 at 23:43.
I would like to see a step in the installation-process where the user could select packages to install from the repositories. Then just about everything would be ready for them when they log in the first time.
It would also be nice if ubuntu cleaned out packages it don't need. Or let the more advanced users deselect the stuff in the base-system that they don't want. Video-drivers and such could also be searched for during the installation and installed if the user wants to.
There should also be a button that would enable audio and video-codecs from the start, instead of going through the trouble of installing them later on.
8
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#26): Give the user more options: Standard install, minimal install, advanced install
Written by billdotson the 7 Oct 09 at 14:49.
Open Source is all about choice so let the user have as many options as he/she wants.

Have one screen with three options:

Standard install: "This is the default setup."
does what it does now.

Advanced install: "Take full control of your operating system. Choose programs you want, color scheme, or anything that you want" gives the user the choice to install certain programs, choose desktop background, etc. Have a prompt that says "What do you want to do on your operating system?" The user could type in music (or any other keyword) and the installer would bring up a list of available music programs, ranked by popularity. Give the user a choice between window managers, file managers, etc.

Minimal: already implemented but it must be off to the side somewhere, I didn't even know about it. Maybe a minimalist that gives you the CLI version and gives you the option of putting xfce or something else light on top of it. The last time I figured out how to do a minimal install with 6.06 it was a pain to add X window/GUI functionality.
10
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#27): Replace older version with new
Written by zil the 5 Dec 09 at 16:16.
During installation when Ubuntu show all current OS on computer. If it find older version of Ubuntu, there should be option like -> Replace 9.04 with 9.10.

I didnt update system which i do from 7.04 because wanted ext4 and Grub2. So i made clean install.
2
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#28): Have more options
Written by tadcan the 28 Nov 10 at 02:27.
For install over free space put back the functionality to see and install on free space.

Also have a list of all currently installed OS's.

Also install over previous version which has been mentioned here as well.

http://brainstorm.ubuntu.com/idea/18564/

See the 19 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 7 Jul 11 at 05:22) >>

Native Firefox on Ubuntu is even slower than on Wine  
Written by Dinth the 15 Feb 09 at 12:43. Related project: Firefox. Not an idea
This new benchmark shows that native linux version of Firefox is very slow comparing to Windows version, even when run on Wine.
1128
votes
closed
Solution #1: Compile Firefox with PGO by default
Written by Dinth the 15 Feb 09 at 12:43.
One of reasons why Firefox is so slow on Linux, is that Windows version is compiled with PGO - https://developer.mozilla.org/en/Building_with_Profile-Guided_Optimization . Ubuntu devs should compile firefox packages with PGO enabled to speed up Firefox on Ubuntu
125
votes
closed
Solution #2: Compile Firefox with ICC (Intel compiler)
Written by Dinth the 15 Feb 09 at 12:46.
Propably compiling Firefox with ICC would greatly speed up this application.
It is a trouble when user must do compiling with so unusual compiler on his own, but Ubuntu devs can easly do it and put binary packages in repository, or at least PPA.
582
votes
closed
Solution #3: Add native 64bit Java and Flash packages to PPA
Written by Dinth the 15 Feb 09 at 12:52.
There are avalible native 64bit Java and Flash versions on Suns and Adobe websites. ATM they are in beta state, but there are pretty much stable, so why dont package them to repo or at least PPA? This would greatly speed up Firefox on 64bit systems - now, sometimes nspluginwrappers takes 50% of cpu power when playing video from some sites.
944
votes
closed
Solution #5: Work with Mozilla to Ensure Linux version is Perfomance Optimized
Written by lutimdale the 18 Feb 09 at 04:37.
There probably aren't as many developers testing the linux version as this isn't the biggest install base.
-272
votes
closed
Solution #6: Support the development of swiftweasel
Written by JanMalte the 19 Feb 09 at 06:56.
Support the development of the swiftweasel project.
This is an pgo compiled version of firefox.
http://swiftweasel.tuxfamily.org/
-438
votes
closed
Solution #7: Epiphany as default browser
Written by danielrmt the 26 Feb 09 at 20:11.
I have been using Epiphany for the last months, and I really enjoy it. I still miss some Firefox extensions, but it's ok. I think it is a good choice for Ubuntu. Maybe not now, but when it gets a stable webkit support.
-120
votes
closed
Solution #8: Support the development of Google's Chrome
Written by brownbat the 14 Mar 09 at 02:20.
The "support x browser instead" options are tanking, but I wanted to give everyone an option to vote down (or up?) Google's browser too.
-96
votes
closed
Solution #9: Port Firefox to Qt
Written by flammon the 14 Mar 09 at 22:18.
I love GNOME and use it every day, have been since pre 1.0 but I think that its weakest part is GTK/GDK. Qt is faster and GPL so perhaps it is time to start porting. Firefox is mostly written in C++ so using Qt shouldn't be a problem.

The project has already begun and I'm anxious to see the results.

http://browser.garage.maemo.org/news/10/
-42
votes
closed
Solution #11: Option to install firefox32 on 64-bit distributions
Written by sanketmedhi the 15 Apr 09 at 09:24.
Edit: I take this back. I upgraded to Janty 9.04 and Firefox works like a charm with the Flash 10 driver!

I have been using Ubuntu 64 bit versions for several years. And what I still don't like is that my system slows down pathetically when the browser tries to load a Flash or Java applet which are used on most pages on the Internet today, not to mention ads.

Although, its not exactly Ubuntu's problem that the sources providing these plugins do not entirely support x86_64 platforms, users should have the freedom to choose whether or not to use these packages and how to use them.

There should be a meta package that installs firefox32 and removes firefox64 on 64 bit versions of Ubuntu. Also, plugins for Firefox like Flash, Java, Adobe Reader, Shockwave, etc. should be replaced with 32 bit versions without any intervention.

See the 22 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 7 Jul 11 at 05:06) >>

Network Manager must have Wireless Refresh (Or Search button)  
Written by Kosimo the 10 May 08 at 13:16. Related project: Network Manager. Not an idea
When a new wireless network is activated, the only way to see it in network manager is waiting 'till the system find it... Why not adding a simple (refresh) button to make a new search and find all Wireless Networks?

1466
votes
closed
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #8326
Written by Kosimo the 10 May 08 at 13:16.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #8326 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!
823
votes
closed
Solution #2: Right Click->"Scan Wireless Networks"
Written by nick.colgan the 29 Jan 09 at 03:51.
Add a "scan wireless networks" option to right click context menu of nm-applet.
-211
votes
closed
Solution #3: Scan on left-click
Written by anabelle the 29 Jan 09 at 15:01.
Since you click to see if you are connected or to connect to a new network it could work similar to OSX.

Once you click it scans for networks and include new results in the lists... no right clicking or anything.
-189
votes
closed
Solution #4: Use wicd instead of network manager
Written by elbel86 the 1 Feb 09 at 04:19.
wicd is a great alternative to network manager and offers many more options in its gui, including a refresh button. Of course, wicd isn't even in the repos yet, so it could take some time to get it in.
357
votes
closed
Solution #5: Automatically show new wireless networks without any user interaction
Written by Endolith the 2 Feb 09 at 07:47.
If there is a problem with Network Manager not showing new networks when they have changed, then fix that problem.

We should not be adding "Refresh" buttons to things that should always be up-to-date. When would you *not* want the list refreshed? Never. If Network Manager were functioning optimally, the button would serve no purpose, so there is no reason to add it.

Let's make things function correctly instead of adding poor workarounds.
70
votes
closed
Solution #6: Solution in place in 0.7.3 or so: Rescan on startup and if the applet is used.
Written by tchalvakspam the 18 Feb 09 at 20:04.
I'm paraphrasing the solution that one of the developers has implemented (I believe in a version slightly after 0.7) for the purpose of clarifying the brainstorm understanding of what the developers have done to solve the problem.

One of the developers has said that more recent patches to NetworkManager will result in the following behavior:

- When a user interacts with the applet, a rescan will occur immediately if one hasn't within the last 20 seconds. For two minutes thereafter, it will do 20 second interval rescans, then drop to 120 second scans.

- When the applet starts up or the wireless card is re-enabled after being disabled, NetworkManager will do 20 second interval scans for two minutes, and drop back down to 120 second interval scans after that.

So by NetworkManager version 0.7.1 or 0.7.3 or so, any other behavior that doesn't get a rescan as fast as that should be some kind of bug.
15
votes
closed
Solution #7: Integrating WifiRadar into network manager
Written by hemanth.hm the 8 Mar 09 at 18:27.
WiFi Radar is a Python/PyGTK2 utility for managing WiFi profiles.It enables you to scan for available networks and create profiles for your preferred networks. At boot time, running WiFi Radar will automatically scan for an available preferred network and connect to it. You can drag and drop your preferred networks to arrange the profile priority.

17
votes
closed
Solution #8: Make it clear that a scan is in progress
Written by korin43 the 28 Oct 09 at 19:43.
#6 is nice, but it leaves users feeling like NetworkManager isn't rescanning at all. It would be better if it had some sort of feedback like "Scanning for Networks".
8
votes
closed
Solution #9: Configurable Intervals and scan optons
Written by tz the 4 Dec 09 at 17:27.
20 seconds is longer than it takes to load most complex web pages, yet that is what everyone is stuck with, but it might actually be 2 minutes.

I would like the option to scan every X seconds when the applet is active, and Y seconds when it is in background. If you constantly change APs, the current settings are too long, but if you are always using the same one they are too short.

Some hardware does bad things (e.g. can't receive or transmit) when you initiate a scan, so you might not want it more frequently, but if I have a good adapter I should be able to unlimit it.
10
votes
closed
Solution #10: Show received AP Beacons immediately without a scan
Written by tz the 4 Dec 09 at 17:48.
Most wireless cards can receive beacons without a scan and most APs ("visible") send them a few times per second. The list returned by the scan includes these - but I think there is a call which returns the result WITHOUT DOING AN ACTUAL SCAN (sending query packets, etc.).

For wireless cards which support this feature, the display list should be updated every second from the list of visible beacons without doing any explicit scan.
5
votes
closed
Solution #11: wireless network connections "enableness check"
Written by kuluizemp.openconscience the 1 Dec 10 at 13:05.
we should have a simple and easy way of enable just one wireless network to prevent unwanted mistaken wireless connections and also perhabes a cheak list where you check and uncheck on the wireless connections menu what connections a user want to allow

See the 16 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 7 Jul 11 at 04:36) >>

Offer to create a separate /home partition and use existing ones  
Written by frandavid100 the 22 Mar 08 at 10:55. Global category: Installation. Won't implement
A separate partition for /home has been proposed for a long time in the forums. It implies some risks, though, so based on disk size Ubiquity should estimate the amount of space that should be left for / or whether a separate partition should be made at all. Then...

-The first time an user installs Ubuntu, he is given the option to set a separate /home. This option is selected by default, with a size for each partition based on a sane guess:

http://img155.imageshack.us/img155/7958/firstinstallaro2.png

-Of course, he can just choose not to set a separate /home. This option will be selected by default if the results of the system test suggest that's the best thing to do.

http://img186.imageshack.us/img186/6498/firstinstallbfs6.png

-Manual install is also possible. Selecting it greys out everything related to separate /home, since it's implied that the user doesn't want to be guided.

http://img177.imageshack.us/img177/7976/firstinstallcvc2.png

-If the user set a separate /home, the next time he installs Ubuntu a new option appears and is selected by default, prompting to use the existing /home partition. All other options are still available, though.

http://img155.imageshack.us/img155/9034/secondinstalliq1.png

[....]

Developer comments
I have always used a separate /home as well. Keeping /home after reinstallations is one major reason which has been mitigated by ubiquity preserving /home now (I didn't test that yet, though).

Either way ubiquity (the Live CD installer) should point this out clearly.

The other reason is that I want to use it from multiple Linux installations, but that's mostly a geek use case.

I have no idea what size / and /home should have by default,
I always use 6 GB for / and the rest for /home, but if someone wants to use huge databases, that'll break.

Thus I think we should stick to our current partitioning and rather improve the UI for keeping /home. There is always manual partitioning for people who actually care.

--

Preserving the contents of /home during installation has been implemented in the desktop CD installer (ubiquity) since Ubuntu 8.04. This is achieved by deleting the system files and directories that are about to be replaced and then continuing with a normal installation, leaving /home, /opt and others untouched. We decided against creating a separate /home partition as there is no correct answer for a /home partition, / partition size split for all users, and we felt the likelihood that whatever guess we came up with would be a major regression for a large subset of our users was quite high.

In addition to this, partitioning is a complex subject, one that is quite difficult for many non-technical users to understand. This difficulty is further complicated by a lack of safe, online partition resizing in Linux.

Please note that the functionality to preserve the contents of /home exists in Ubuntu, just not via the arguably dangerous implementation suggested here.

-- Evan on behalf of the Installer Team
5360
votes
closed
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #5390
Written by frandavid100 the 22 Mar 08 at 10:55.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #5390 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!
66
votes
closed
Solution #2: Suggest sizes for root partition
Written by boscorillium the 17 Jan 09 at 16:35.
Change installer to provide a separate root and home partitions and give the user options of typical root sizes based on profiles created (like minimal, average desktop user, maximum install, etc.). These would be just guidelines and the user could still define a custom size.
183
votes
closed
Solution #3: Allow clean reinstall without deleting /home
Written by andrewpmk the 23 Jan 09 at 08:24.
Make the Ubuntu installer preserve /home by default when installing on top of an existing Linux partition, while replacing the rest of the filesystem. This avoids the need for a separate /home partition altogether.
15
votes
closed
Solution #4: new automatic partition menu on install
Written by mitcoes the 29 Jul 09 at 14:24.
Add this option:
USE a /home partition,
=> select the (old home) partition to use
=> make a new one => choose size
=> all the free space
=> choose other size

And of course after giving -/- a partition with enough space.
about 10 Gb in my opinion in a modern HDD, and other options in small devices.

And 6 Gb - i prefer 10 Gb - for / and the rest for /home MUST BE THE DEFAULT, for KK, and, of course in EXT4.



This partition - /home - would be partitioned as NTFS or FAT32 inoder to share documents with MS WOS. As an option, of course. But better an EXT4 driver for MS WOS.

7
votes
closed
Solution #6: Introduce a separate /home partition as default.
Written by plutocrat the 8 Jun 10 at 04:17.
The installer should suggest a separate /home partition as default: instead of just / and swap, it should also add a /home partition to the structure.

The algorithm for this may be complicated: from my experience its only generally worth it if you can allocate at least 10Gb to the OS. Some suggested schemes:

10 Gb HDD - No separate /home partition
15 Gb HDD - No separate /home partition
20 Gb HDD - 10Gb each to / and /home. Swap depends on memory
30 Gb HDD - 13Gb to OS, 17 to /home
40 Gb HDD - 15Gb to OS, 25 to /home
60 Gb HDD - 20Gb to OS, 40 to /home
... and then no further increase in the size of the OS partition - it caps out at 20Gb.

The installer should try to detect a partition previously used as a /home partition, and should ask the user whether or not to re-use that partition, keeping the data, or whether to erase that partition.

As work on this progressed, the installer might even be able to make modifications to the settings files on the existing /home partition, to ensure that they're compatible with the applications being installed. eg. upgrading OpenOffice 2.x settings files to OpenOffice 3.x settings.
eg. upgrading Thunderbird 2.x settings to 3.x settings.



5
votes
closed
Solution #7: Why not give the user a choice?
Written by atomicblue the 24 Jun 10 at 21:02.
I had a much longer first draft to this message, but found I was saying exactly the same that the original submitter proposed. This should be part of the guided partitioning process. Most users I know only do the manual partitioning because that is the only way to create a separate /home partition.

The installer should try to give the user enough information to make an informed decision for their particular setup instead of hiding behind the digital curtain. They could also chose not to use it, but at least they would have the knowledge to make that decision.

Myself, on all of my computers, I use a 20GB / partition and allocate the rest of the data to /home. Granted, I only use about 1/3 of that but it is enough space to grow that I usually don't miss.
-6
votes
closed
Solution #8: Make a seperate btrfs subvolume
Written by jv13613 the 13 Oct 10 at 01:01.
If btrfs is used in ubuntu by default, then a separate subvolume (from root) could be created and used as /home. This would eliminate the problem of determining how much space to give /home and /.

See the 61 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 31 May 11 at 16:17) >>

Enable OpenID for Ubuntu Sites  
Launchpad itself

In :  
Priority : Essential
Definition : Approved (Needs guidance)
Implementation : Implemented
Assignee : Francis J. Lacoste
spec
Written by redyaky the 28 Feb 08 at 14:22. Global category: Others. In development
Allow users to log into Ubuntu Forums and other Ubuntu sites (such as ubuntu brainstorm) using their OpenID.

Developer comments
Work is being done along to make that possible (though I don't know an ETA).
First step: the Fridge (http://fridge.ubuntu.com ) is now using Launchpad authentification via OpenID.
2655
votes
inprogress
Selected solution (#1): Auto-generated solution of idea #9
Written by redyaky the 28 Feb 08 at 14:22.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #9 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!

See the 27 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 5 May 11 at 16:11) >>

Fix compatibility with webcams and microphone  
Written by dragonx the 28 Feb 08 at 17:30. Global category: Multimedia. Not an idea
In many cases, I can't configure my webcam or I have problems with the microphone. Now I can use my webcam but only with V4L2 and only 3 programas detect my webcam. It's a good idea can use my webcam in all programs as camorama.

Developer comments
That's pure driver issue in the first place. A big plus is to recommend UVC-based webcams to users, since it takes a lot of work off the shoulders of driver-developers. On the
integration-side proper support for v4l/v4l2 in webcam-related applications needs to be solidified. The ideal application to polish up is cheese of course.
5301
votes
closed
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #97
Written by dragonx the 28 Feb 08 at 17:30.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #97 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!

See the 42 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 28 Apr 11 at 00:17) >>

<< Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... Next >>