Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 15664 ideas, 77393 comments, 1416168 votes

Contributor rca123




up
862
down
Trash folder on diskette, USB, hard disk  
Shouldn't put .Trash-$USER on removable devices (#12893)

In : nautilus (ubuntu)
Status : Triaged
Importance : Low
Assignee : Ubuntu Desktop Bugs
76 comments, 49 subscribers and 0 duplicates
bug
Written by cybermanolin the 28 Feb 08 at 15:56. Category: System. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
I dislike a lot that the system makes a hidden folder "/trash" in the USB, floppy and others ... The erasure should be direct in these elements because it is very confusing to have this hidden folder storing it erases not even know it

See the 17 comments >>

implemented
Done!
(1505)
Fix Hard Drive Load Cycle Problem in Laptops  
High frequency of load/unload cycles on some hard
disks may shorten lifetime (#59695)


In : acpi-support (ubuntu)
Status : In Progress
Importance : Critical
Assignee : Ubuntu Kernel ACPI Team
625 comments, 234 subscribers and 0 duplicates
bug
forum
Written by SpamBadger the 29 Feb 08 at 00:17. Category: System. Related to: Nothing/Others. Implemented
Advanced power management currently cycles the hard drive once every few seconds even during activity on most laptops. This severely shortens the life of hard drives.

Developer comments
This *bug* is now fixed, see the bug report.
But remember : keep bug reports on Launchpad, the Ubuntu bug tracker; Ubuntu Brainstorm is only for ideas.
This bug, submitted at the launch of Brainstorm in feb 2008, was not closed since the guidelines were not set at this time.

See the 38 comments >>

up
480
down
Ubuntu Brainstorm should make it possible to vote for idea deletion  
Written by Eproxus the 28 Feb 08 at 16:29. Category: Brainstorm. Related to: Nothing/Others. In development
The reason for this is to unclutter Ubuntu Brainstorm.

Some ideas submitted are not applicable, or are already existing although the poster didn't know about them.

It should be possible mark an idea for deletion instead of just voting it down, but it should be well distinguished from voting down an idea. Perhaps users must click on the idea to be able to mark it for deletion.

See the 20 comments >>

up
983
down
Mount removable storage synchronously  
Written by jez9999 the 28 Feb 08 at 23:50. Category: System. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
When you plug in something like a USB dongle, it should be mounted synchronously (-o sync) instead of in buffered mode.

For me, this is far preferable to the minute performance gain gotten by mounting the device in buffered mode. You're very unlikely to be using such devices for anything except data storage/retreival, in which case mounting synchronously is a major benefit. Expecting new users (or those used to Windows XP's behaviour) to know you have to right-click, 'unmount', before removing the drive is not a good idea, as well as just being unnecessary if the device is mounted synchronously. It's also irritating for people like me who know you need to do it, but either occasionally forget or don't want to bother.

Mount the thing synchronously by default. This is what Windows XP does, and it allows you to just remove the drive after any file transfers have finished. Yes, problems will occur if you remove it durung a file transfer, but that's gonna happen in ANY mount mode. It's far more obvious to the user that this will cause a problem than removal of the drive before unmounting. Also stop displaying that 'unsafe device removal' message for devices mounted synchronously.

See the 35 comments >>

closed
Closed
(666)
Take care of the little details  
Written by AnRa the 28 Feb 08 at 16:46. Category: Look and Feel. Related to: Nothing/Others. Won't implement
It is important that Ubuntu is polished up to the little details.

LOOK AT THIS: https://wiki.ubuntu.com/LittleDetails

Developer comments
While the point is valid in principle, the idea doesn't have enough detail to be implemented ;)

Seriously, that is in part what this site is for, but posting actual suggestions for concrete issues is more helpful.

See the 17 comments >>

implemented
Already done!
(3253)
Codec Manager  
Written by intarwub the 29 Feb 08 at 00:32. Category: Multimedia. Related to: Nothing/Others. Already implemented
As a user I want to be able to listen to audio or watch videos with the least amount of setup. I would like to have a single interface (Codec Manager) that lists all of the most common audio and video formats and shows me if I am missing the necessary codec for playback.

Use Case: Enable MP3 playback.
Precondition: MP3s are not currently playable.
1. User logs into the system.
2. User opens the Codec Manager.
3. System displays a list of common audio/video formats.
4. User selects MP3s.
5. System displays some info about MP3s.
6. System displays a list of available codecs.
7. User selects a codec and clicks Apply.
8. System downloads and installs the selected codec.
9. System informs the user when completed.

Other possible features:
- Display a list of audio/video types that are missing codecs.
- An auto-setup function, that grabs the recommended codec for all formats.

Audio and Video formats that should be supported:

Audio:
- MP3
- OGG
- AAC
- FLAC
- Real Audio

Video:
- MP4

[....]

Developer comments
Attacks the problem from the wrong angle. I don't think many users would care about a "codec manager", that sounds very much like a geek tool. Heck, *I* wouldn't care about a codec manager. I care about watching my videos. :-)

To me this already seems solved very elegantly with the existing easy-codec-installation.

See the 67 comments >>

up
1252
down
Delta (patch based) updates  
Binary patch updating (#21837)

In : apt (ubuntu)
Status : Triaged
Importance : Wishlist
Assignee : Michael Vogt
9 comments, 12 subscribers and 0 duplicates
bug
Ubuntu

In :  
Priority : Undefined
Definition : New (Needs guidance)
Implementation : Unknown
Assignee :
spec
forum
Written by ravirdv the 28 Feb 08 at 14:31. Category: System. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
Summary:
Ability to download only changed bits of files and use much less bandwidth.
Scope and Use Cases:
Ann has slow internet connection. She sees that there are 150MB of updates and decides not to update at all leaving her with vulnerable and buggy system.
Implementation Plan:
Adopt it from Debian?

Previously discussed here, but still not implemented: http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=409916

See the 41 comments >>

implemented
Done!
(2349)
Brainstorm: Don't start with most popular, and hide grades until requested  
Improve the model for default idea listing order (#197019)

In : ubuntu-qa-website
Status : Fix Released
Importance : Medium
Assignee :
8 comments, 2 subscribers and 0 duplicates
bug
Written by speakman the 28 Feb 08 at 20:28. Category: Brainstorm. Related to: Nothing/Others. Implemented
Change start page of Brainstorm to show latest ideas or something, else people will probably push for the already high-graded ideas and won't care of other newer ideas.

Maybe a page with random ideas?

And remove the grades if not specifically requested, since it will affect peoples voting.

Developer comments
New front page, with a descending (nb of votes)/(time since creation) sorting.
This way, the newest ideas have their chance to stand up!

See the 52 comments >>