Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 22700 ideas, 138270 comments, 2629576 votes
Idea sandbox Idea sandbox
Popular ideas Popular ideas
Ideas in development Ideas in development
Implemented ideas Implemented ideas

Contributor rbn

Print dialog should select connected printer first  
Written by sorryimfrench the 21 Feb 13 at 15:00. Global category: Usability. New
Here's the use case: I have a laptop that I use at the office and at home. At the office I have a Canon IP5000 printer, at home I have a Canon IP3000 printer.

When I want to print a document, the IP3000 printer is always selected, even if it is not connected (and indicated as such), adding an extra step to select the IP5000 printer if I'm at the office.

One of the side effect of that is that I often print a document without noticing the the IP300 printer is selected (but not connected, as I'm at the office). I then have to cancel the job in the job queue, reprint and select the IP5000 printer.

Another side effect is that if I forget to remove it to the queue, the documents that I wanted to print at the office get printed when I dock the laptop at home (the IP3000 being connected, its print queue gets processed).

This would not be necessary if the print dialog was selecting the first online printer instead.
26
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Print dialog should always select an online printer by default
Written by sorryimfrench the 21 Feb 13 at 15:00.
When the currently selected printer is not available, the first available printer should be selected instead.
10
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: printer hitory - select last working pinter
Written by Klau3 the 27 Feb 13 at 00:04.
Create a history of printer hardware IDs that the user has used. If the user connects to a network select the last available printer that the user has used before.

But DONT select the first printer you can find in a network!
12
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Default Printer Can Be A Cascade
Written by chrisxsterling the 6 Mar 13 at 04:56.
Allow individual users to store a history of printers and setup the default printer as a cascade. So if the most preferred printer is not found then the software will walk down the list until it finds one. If no online printer is found then it defaults to "Print to file" or another printer of the user's choosing.
-2
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: Select an online printer and then the last working one
Written by alessandrofac93 the 8 Mar 13 at 21:33.
This is a mix of #1 and #2. In the print dialog, firstly select the online printer if one, and if not, select the last working printer.

See the 4 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 16 Apr 13 at 20:31) >>

Performance options  
Written by Levan the 18 Feb 13 at 18:57. Related project: Compiz Advanced Settings (ccsm). New
ubuntu has really nice effects like minimizing window animation and so on but I think people should get the ability to manage this effects so
I think Visual Effect settings menu should be integrated directly to ubuntu yes some one might say that there is compiz manager but it requires a separate download and plus it is a mess to use I have this problem if I change something I never can make it as it was before

http://ubuntuone.com/7BWDfjIm4Hg3QmVzKNK0nL
25
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Integrate Performance options in settings
Written by Levan the 18 Feb 13 at 18:57.
So I want to disable some effects to make ubuntu faster but sadly I can not do this easy
So why not instagreat it in
settings like this
http://i.imgur.com/kafzSpd.jpg

and

http://i.imgur.com/Oj0Ntfp.jpg
14
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Integrate a simpler Performance options in settings
Written by prakreet the 26 Feb 13 at 07:37.
The proposal by levan will be too complex for new users. Why don't we give just give 3 options in the behaviour tab.
1. No animations
2. Some animations are shown
3. All animations

Similar to how android does it. A user who wants to tweak individual animations would know about ccsm and will surely go that way.
9
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Combine Solution #1 and #2
Written by blob626 the 5 Mar 13 at 17:26.
Have the 3 options from solution #2 and an "advanced" button to take the user to the full list of effects.

This way new users don't need to worry about a complex effects list, but those who do want to can still enable or disable specific effects easily

See the 3 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 28 Mar 13 at 15:05) >>

Inform user to use Shift+Ins when they enter Ctrl+V in the terminal.  
Written by JLeon85 the 25 Feb 13 at 18:16. Global category: Usability. New
I believe this would prevent many first-time users from being discouraged when they first use the terminal.
3
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: A GUI pop-up that can be disabled.
Written by JLeon85 the 25 Feb 13 at 18:16.
A simple message with a check box to disable future prompts. I suggest a GUI prompt instead of one within the terminal because many users will not hit enter after they see that their paste didn't work.
25
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Allow the setting to be swapped in the Preferences
Written by PaddyLandau the 1 Mar 13 at 16:32.
Add a setting in the Preferences to allow the user to swap the meaning of Ctrl+V (verbatim insert) and Ctrl+Shift+V (paste).

If Solution #1 is also implemented, this would automatically stop the GUI pop-up from being displayed.
-3
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: As solution #2, but add an extra checkbox for Solution #1
Written by PaddyLandau the 1 Mar 13 at 16:37.
Implement Solution #1 and Solution #2, but also add a check-box to Solution #1 to swap the settings in the Preferences.

Something like:

[ ] Permanently swap Ctrl+V (currently varbatim insert) and Ctrl+Shift+V (currently paste). This can be reset in the Preferences.

See the 7 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 4 Mar 13 at 15:45) >>

Spread View: Close Windows on Middle-Click  
Written by linuxlisa the 22 Jan 13 at 13:10. Related project: Unity. New
The "Spread" view in 12.10 is nice. But what I really miss is an easy way to close unneeded windows from there. There is the close button for each window. But this button is tiny and you have to aim for it. This is very annoying. On top of that, I didn't even see this function/button until I read about it in a blogpost. I always thought that this is just the window title bar and always overlooked the close button or the very possibility that this is actually a way of closing windows from spread view.

Everytime I am in spread view, I wish I could close unneeded windows by simply clicking in that window. When clicking on a launcher icon with middle-mousebutton, a new windows of that application is being opened. So it would make sense that with a middle-click on such window in spread view, a window will close.
5
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Open spread view and middle-click on unneeded window
Written by linuxlisa the 22 Jan 13 at 13:10.
1. Open the spread view when having multiple windows open
2. Middle-click on unneded window
21
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Open spread view and right click for options
Written by Dazed_75 the 22 Jan 13 at 16:16.
I don't think solution 1 is at all intuitive, but right clicking is universal for a context menu with options that make sense. These could include closing, minimizing, maximizing, or even moving to another workspace (left, right, up, down, or named).
12
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Make the close button big upon mouse proximity
Written by beruic the 30 Jan 13 at 00:50.
Make the close button easier to click on.

I initially imagined that it could be shown all the time, but scaled like the window, and then when the mouse comes near, some kind of zoom effect or magnifying effect could happen, such that it's easy to click. This however might hinder the user in discovering functionality initially, so maybe a normal sized version the close button should just be placed with its centre upon the corner of the window (thus obstructing the real estate of the scaled down version of the window less), and become bigger when the mouse comes near.

This of course does not hinder solution #1 from being implemented as well.

See the 2 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 16 Feb 13 at 06:33) >>

Alternative sources of income  
Written by Faboy the 16 Dec 12 at 18:51. Related project: Unity. New
A lot of users are dissatisfied with the integration of the Amazon shopping lens in Ubuntu due to its many disadvantages such as the privacy issues or the use of the internet connection.
However Canonical need to earn money somehow to pay the developers.
Most likely they will remove the shopping lens or make it optional, if we (the community) suggest other effective sources of income.
83
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Donations for bug fixing
Written by Faboy the 16 Dec 12 at 18:51.
Plenty of users have problems with bugs, but aren't able to fix them on their own. Reasons for this could be the disability to program, a lack of time or the missing money to pay another person to fix the bug.

Canonical could offer a "bug fix team" for non-commercial users. The users donate money for fixing certain bugs in Ubuntu via Lauchpad. In return Canonical's "bug fix team" handles the bugs in the order of the donated money for each bug.
Ancillary effects: Ubuntu becomes more stable; non-programmers can contribute to the project; bugs, which are classified as insifignant by the developers, can be fixed;...


General donations could be given for bug #1 („Microsoft has a majority market share“) ;)
12
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Donate, if Ubuntu is helpful for you
Written by rbn the 23 Dec 12 at 20:18.
The developers of Ubuntu (programmers, translators, designers,…) could be supported by users which agree with Ubuntu, which use Ubuntu successfully, which want to help making Ubuntu better…
These users could use micropayment ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micropayment ) to support Ubuntu. There could be discreet suggestions during updatingor installing new software or a dialog, which opens when Ubuntu is used for severals (e.g. ~20) days. Every user only has to donate some cents, and developers would earn money by supporting Ubuntu, which would give them an other reason to improve their work, to improve Ubuntu.
Micropayment is easy and quick, it works, e.g. with a mobile phone.
22
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Serve as intermediary for collecting donations to installed apps
Written by psequeirag the 7 Jan 13 at 13:49.
As Solution #2 to Idea #21212 suggests, Canonical could provide a means for apps & packages to collect donations by including a "Donate" button in the Software Center GUI. Canonical could take a fee from those donations as an intermediary in a simmilar way as SourceForge does for donations to projects made through their site.
14
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: Create a franchise of Ubuntu Stores
Written by psequeirag the 7 Jan 13 at 13:59.
Create a franchise of Ubuntu stores that would sell Ubuntu certified PCs, laptops, tablets, printers, scanners, webcams, WiFi adapters, wireless mice, media boxes, phones... all kinds of accessories and complements to having an Ubuntu box.

Partner with manufacturers so they can get their certified hardware distributed & sold through the stores. I guess Dell and HP would be brands in there for sure, but please, try not to leave the good people from ZaReason, System76 and the like out of the deal.

Put an end to the perception that it is hard to get peripherals that work with Ubuntu Linux. If there were such a store in my area, I would certainly source all my gadgets from it. Heck!, I would even apply to open and operate it myself.
-14
votes
up equal down
Solution #5: Sell Votes on ideas and fixes
Written by psequeirag the 7 Jan 13 at 14:18.
A variation of Solution #1 that for me is more sensible than the "pay for fix" scheme (see my comment below), is to limit the number of votes each person has available on feature requests and bug reports/fixes.

Instead, if the user wants to vote on a particular idea or fix, he would purchase additional votes and spend them there to raise its priority or popularity.
-18
votes
up equal down
Solution #6: Sell credits for posting questions or support requests on premium forums
Written by psequeirag the 7 Jan 13 at 14:36.
What about a watered down support service that consists of purchasing the right to post questions or some limited forms of support requests on premium forums? The deal would be that there would be a better change to get good and timely answers to your pressing questions in those forums than in the community-supported ones.

The idea is to come up with some other form of support service that is cheaper and more affordable than the current commercial support offerings, something that can be offered at half or less of the standard professional desktop support.

This is delicate, though, because Community support is already well stablished and valuable, and these premium forums could disrupt and trash them. Perhaps, we could encourage community participation in the premium forums when contributors earn reputation, and give them somthing in exchange for increasing the quality of the support provided to users.
-13
votes
up equal down
Solution #7: Sell credits for posting priority questions in comunity forums
Written by psequeirag the 7 Jan 13 at 14:51.
A variation of Solution #6: use the exiting and established forums, but allow to post priority questions that are intended to be addressed in a timely manner by qualified forum members.

So, users would purchase credits for being able to post priority questions in the forums and voting on the quality of the answers they get.

Allow only members with certain reputation treshold to address those questions. Give them "contributor" credits to acknowledge their premium contributions when acknowledged by the original poster, perhaps allowing to exchange them with small prizes like items from the Ubuntu Shop or an Amazon giftcard.

This would create incentives for providing good support from the community, but I would also expect Canonical to keep a portion of the proceedings.
0
votes
up equal down
Solution #8: Offer a Bounty
Written by ki4jgt the 14 Jan 13 at 04:04.
Offer a bounty for bug fixes and improvements. Instead of setting up a team, allow users to invest (through donations) in project ideas for Ubuntu (whether bug fixes or improvements). Let users then compete for the best solution to the problem and give a percentage of the donations to the user who best solves the problem. This will keep the open source movement flowing and doesn't limit fixing a problem to just a panel of people.
0
votes
up equal down
Solution #9: Offer premium Canonical-designed apps
Written by RockyC the 11 Mar 13 at 22:57.
Developers need to feed their families too - everyone understands that. So why doesn't Canonical simply offer a set of premium apps on it's own Software Center?

The pending release of Ubuntu for tablets and smart phones represents a HUGE opportunity to generate revenue. Ubuntu Tablet Edition is going to need some good, quality apps to help it launch. Instead of the usual nonsense of telling people to "wait until something appears in the Software Center" or "learn how to code and develop it yourself," why not simply create some great apps up front and SELL them for a reasonable price? I can get some AMAZING apps on my iPad or Android tablet for anywhere from $.99 to $4.99, and other AMAZING apps on my Mac for $4.99 to $9.99. These aren't bank-breaking prices, and it allows Canonical to continue it's mission. It also allows developers to do things like EAT and PAY RENT so they can go back to doing what they love.

See the 12 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 15 Jan 13 at 04:45) >>

Customizable installation and all desktops in one DVD  
Ubuntu

In :  
Priority : Undefined
Definition : New (Needs guidance)
Implementation : Unknown
Assignee :
spec
Written by l0rdraiden the 28 Feb 08 at 20:12. Global category: Installation. Won't implement
1) A customizable installation (with checkboxes o something similar) you will be able to choose what packages do you want. You will can select or unselect the programs that ubuntu install as a default, if you dont need an email client you will can unselect it...

2) Integrate in 1 DVD unbuntu, kubuntu, xubuntu... you need only select what desktop do you want and what packages (see nº1)

"Ubuntu should be available as a live/install DVD that comes with Gnome, KDE, Xfce, and perhaps other desktop environments. Ideally, it would have equal priority to the CDs that only come with one, which would include being released at the same times. When booting from the disk, users should have an option of which environment to use. When installing, users should be able to chose which environments to install, and have options for installing additional packages designed for those environments (like the gnome and kde packages).

This would allow multiple people who prefer different environments to use the same installation disk. It would be more convenient for people who want to have e.g. both KDE and Gnome. It would make it easier for people new to Linux to learn which environment they prefer. It would make it easier for lesser used environments to gain new users. It would put all supported desktop environments on a more equal ground, rather than sanctioning one as the only "real" and "official" desktop environment for Ubuntu."

http://brainstorm.ubuntu.com/idea/7151/
1544
votes
closed
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #188
Written by l0rdraiden the 28 Feb 08 at 20:12.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #188 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!
221
votes
closed
Solution #2: Produce a DVD with a boot menu, allowing you to install any version
Written by Tom Mann the 14 Apr 09 at 15:08.
Have a boot menu with:

Install Ubuntu (default)
Install Kubuntu
Install Xubuntu
Install Ubuntu Studio
...
15
votes
closed
Solution #3: Boot a plain environment with USB creator
Written by Tom Mann the 14 Apr 09 at 15:16.
This will boot straight into a UI-free environment, apart from the Ubuntu USB Drive tool, modified slightly to give you a option of each Ubuntu variant (rather than ask for a path to an ISO) to create the live usb key of your choosing.
16
votes
closed
Solution #4: Offer to seek out wider packages/drivers
Written by jamesisin the 14 Apr 09 at 18:18.
One problem that I have run into in installing Ubuntu is that sometimes I would like to install the desktop software onto (former) server hardware. That is often not possible due to differing drivers being included on the desktop version and the server version.

Selection between different desktop environments could be part of this process. Kernel selection (desktop/server/older) should also be available.

Could it be possible to have the installer carry a wider array of drivers to cover more installation types and then be able to download other necessary drivers during its installation process?

I think we could still offer a very trim CD which could do all of this, but it may be beneficial to also offer a DVD which contained a lot of the optional packages.

7
votes
closed
Solution #5: cd alternitive
Written by nloewen the 28 Jun 09 at 18:53.
keep a slimed down version of the install with only base features to fit on cds and smaller flash drives for people without a dvd drive. On the first boot it could install the extra unnecessary stuff that didn't fit on the cd. The cd would include enough to keep it functional so that if you didn't have an internet connection you wouldn't have to worry.
25
votes
closed
Solution #6: Multi-buntu DVD
Written by nq6 the 28 Aug 09 at 15:13.
Untitled-1 copy copy

The DVD included with this issue lets you sample a selection of the most popular Ubuntu variants. Boot
the disk to a Live version of Ubuntu 9.04 “Jaunty Jackalope,” or install a permanent version of Jaunty on
your hard drive.

When you are ready for a taste of some other flavors, double-click the VirtualBox icon on your Ubuntu
desktop to launch any of the following:

Kubuntu: Ubuntu for the KDE desktop.

Xubuntu: small and light on resources – optimized for legacy hardware.

Easy Peasy: tooled for netbook systems. Also included on this DVD is a bootable disc image of Ubuntu Studio – an Ubuntu alternative for high-end audio recording studios and multimedia configurations. Plus you’ll find packages for Edubuntu – Ubuntu for schools and other classroom settings. See the Installation guide on page 60 for more on the Ubuntu User multi-buntu DVD.
15
votes
closed
Solution #7: Multibuntu DVD distribition
Written by mitcoes the 5 Sep 09 at 12:20.
Not only a recopilation, a distro where you can install all packages and choose what X to run each time you star o restartX.

All Gnome, KDE, Fluxbox, Xfce and more, are not a lot for actual HDDs.

OPTIONAL: And if it can be implemented a multi Xorg.conf, one for each Desktop Manager, it would be very useful if you have problems with any upgrade or update.

3
votes
closed
Solution #8: Also integrate Server ed.
Written by Dojan the 14 Feb 11 at 23:33.
nt
3
votes
closed
Solution #9: Full DVD version + CD upgreadable via "first launch" screen
Written by teraxas the 10 May 11 at 16:29.
The best way, in my opinion, would be to create two sepparate instalation images:
1)4.5GB DVD with all the features, codecs or anything "Canonical" wants to put inside.
2)700MB CD with basic features. This version should have a "first launch" screen with:
short presentation of Ubuntu's features AND
a button for upgrading to full version. This, when selected, would start downloading all the missing software from the DVD version.

This way, you can forget the size limit of CD and keep people with small USB keys or CD-ROMs interested.

This was already used by Linux Mint team. I think it's the optimal solution.

P.S. sorry for my English. I hope I will be heard.
0
votes
closed
Solution #10: ISO disk available for download with all environments.
Written by sergioii the 18 Jan 12 at 16:31.
Provide a file. ISO disk to download all the environments that can be used by the User to create a disk or flash drive to take on.
1
votes
closed
Solution #11: Appearance
Written by Basem the 1 Apr 09 at 07:19.
Add the ability for the user to swtich Desktop environments from the appearance window.
Also, add a tick box that downloads the apps of the desktop as well. For example, if KDE was chosen, ticking this will install the packages and apps that are found in Kubuntu.
-15
votes
closed
Solution #12: choose which desktop environment to make the program run on it
Written by Shady3D the 2 Apr 09 at 15:31.
when installing any new program and ubuntu detects that u have more than 1 GUI it shows a check-list with the desktop environment available on the PC.

SO WHY DOING THIS????????????????
to make the u choose if u want gnome applications on to be visible on gnome panels only or if u want KDE applications be on KDE menus only, so it removes the clutter that happen when installing application in any of the environments
0
votes
closed
Solution #13: improve usb-creator for more than one iso
Written by Nukama the 20 Jul 09 at 08:29.
Add the function to usb-creator to support several CD/DVD-Images. Like Solution #1 you should choose which image to use at boot.
You can integrate x86, x86-64 images, Ubuntu, Kubuntu, Edubuntu, latest testing, systemrescuecd and many more on your usb-stick as long as space is left over.
The option to add/delete an image to the existing set would be a nice to have feature.
When this improved usb-creator ships, the release team could concentrate on CD/DVD-images and let the user decide which images they want to put on their sticks.
3
votes
closed
Solution #14: A choice into Ubuntu setup, if connected to Internet
Written by alessandrofac93 the 8 Mar 13 at 21:14.
When Ubuntu is installed for the first time, if the computer is connected to a network, the user can choose what DE to install (in addiction to Unity or in place of it).

See the 29 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 25 Sep 11 at 01:48) >>