Different icon for .deb packages
Written by mydoghasworms the 22 Jun 10 at 18:32.
Global category: Look and Feel.
In development
The icon for a .deb package looks too much like an ordinary archive.
Developer comments
Thanks for the suggestion. Making .deb icons more distinctive is a great idea.
I have reviewed the proposed solutions with Michael Vogt, our packaging expert. Solution #1 is straightforward, but we particularly like solutions #5 and #10, using a thumbnailer to show the application icon from inside each package.
Deb Thumbnailer is a good start, but it needs a bit of code cleanup. We will work with the Deb Thumbnailer developers to see if it can be made suitable for the default Ubuntu installation.
If you would like to help out, the next step is to get it packaged:
http://launchpad.net/bugs/685851
— mpt
426
votes
457
17
31
-40
votes
94
30
134
Selected solution (#2):
Allow package to optionally include its own icon
It would be nice if every package could include its own icon, which would display in Nautilus, and if it has no icon, then some default must be displayed. This would be especially nice for third-party vendors providing software (e.g. Google, Skype, VirtualBox, etc.)
This is of course an optional specification, and if the package includes it, and the file manager supports it, it would show the icon.
-- UPDATE --
As per comment below, this is now a reality:
https://launchpad.net/deb-thumbnailer
It would be nice if every package could include its own icon, which would display in Nautilus, and if it has no icon, then some default must be displayed. This would be especially nice for third-party vendors providing software (e.g. Google, Skype, VirtualBox, etc.)
This is of course an optional specification, and if the package includes it, and the file manager supports it, it would show the icon.
-- UPDATE --
As per comment below, this is now a reality: https://launchpad.net/deb-thumbnailer
78
votes
128
37
50
Selected solution (#3):
Use icon similar to Software Center icon
Written by
stoffel the 24 Jun 10 at 19:48.
The icon should be similar to the Software Center icon. This will hint the user that this is a software package that will install a new application.
Maybe it can be the Software Center icon with a (big) green arrow.
The icon should be similar to the Software Center icon. This will hint the user that this is a software package that will install a new application.
Maybe it can be the Software Center icon with a (big) green arrow.
-19
votes
23
23
42
Selected solution (#4):
Solution #1 + mockup icon with a concept
Written by
lvxferre the 1 Jul 10 at 19:56.
Mockup icon:
http://img812.imageshack.us/img812/218/debinstpack.png
The mockup I made is horrible, I know - please, look at the concept behind it.
The icon is still a package, somewhat similar to the old icons. The Debian logo is still there (it's .deb after all), but it should be bigger and with a more contrasting color.
The package is open. Inside it's a floppy - while few of us still use floppy disks, most associate it with "install". The green arrow in the floppy hints "download".
So, an icon like this tells us: "You downloaded this file, There's a program inside. You can install the program if you want." Exactly what we expect from a .deb .
Mockup icon: http://img812.imageshack.us/img812/218/debinstpack.png
The mockup I made is horrible, I know - please, look at the concept behind it.
The icon is still a package, somewhat similar to the old icons. The Debian logo is still there (it's .deb after all), but it should be bigger and with a more contrasting color.
The package is open. Inside it's a floppy - while few of us still use floppy disks, most associate it with "install". The green arrow in the floppy hints "download".
So, an icon like this tells us: "You downloaded this file, There's a program inside. You can install the program if you want." Exactly what we expect from a .deb .
13
votes
41
11
28
Selected solution (#5):
Different icons for software packages and for type of content
Written by
eld1e6o the 4 Jul 10 at 03:31.
Use different icons for software packages
Also use debthumbnailer which puts different icons for different type of software
See https://launchpad.net/~deb-thumbnailer-team/+archive/ppa
See images here: http://www.omgubuntu.co.uk/2010/06/that-was-quick-new-deb-thumbnailer.html
-4
votes
17
11
21
Selected solution (#6):
Have a different icon for archives
That looks like a box. So it is perfect for software packages. The metaphor is great, it is like the package that comes in the box that you order and you open it up.
Archives, like zip files, have often been shown in other OS as a folder with a zipper on it. You could also use a filing cabinet for the icon. But my point is, if anything needs to change, it's the archive icons.
That looks like a box. So it is perfect for software packages. The metaphor is great, it is like the package that comes in the box that you order and you open it up.
Archives, like zip files, have often been shown in other OS as a folder with a zipper on it. You could also use a filing cabinet for the icon. But my point is, if anything needs to change, it's the archive icons.
-13
votes
4
12
17
Selected solution (#7):
emblems #1
Written by
cfg the 11 Jul 10 at 10:45.
Add a emblems on deb(rmp) package denoting installation.
Add a emblems on deb(rmp) package denoting installation.
-16
votes
4
9
20
Selected solution (#8):
emblems #2
Written by
cfg the 11 Jul 10 at 10:52.
Add a emblems on deb(rmp) package denoting depending on what packages are not included in standard ubuntu, and maybe need download other packages.
Add a emblems on deb(rmp) package denoting depending on what packages are not included in standard ubuntu, and maybe need download other packages.
-31
votes
6
6
37
Selected solution (#9):
Use Ubuntu logo on icon rather than Debian logo
The current package has the Debian logo on it. Replace it with the Ubuntu logo (and then make it look less like a box).
The current package has the Debian logo on it. Replace it with the Ubuntu logo (and then make it look less like a box).
51
votes
54
4
3
Selected solution (#10):
Make the Deb Thumbnailer a default app
Written by
lotif the 21 Jul 10 at 16:37.
Deb Thumbnailer (
https://launchpad.net/deb-thumbnailer ) is a great solution. Why not make it a default app? It needs some improvement, but once it becomes default, more eyes will turn to it and it will certainly look better.
Deb Thumbnailer ( https://launchpad.net/deb-thumbnailer ) is a great solution. Why not make it a default app? It needs some improvement, but once it becomes default, more eyes will turn to it and it will certainly look better.
<a href="http://img839.imageshack.us/img839/4395/capturadetelaarchivesna.png"> <img src="http://img839.imageshack.us/img839/4395/capturadetelaarchivesna.png" /> </a>