Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 12357 ideas, 58479 comments, 1187050 votes

Contributor pornographer




up
5958
down
Fix Suspend and Hibernate   forum
Written by tighem the 28 Feb 08 at 17:22. Category: System. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
Suspend and hibernate still seems to be a big issue based on forum posts. Really focus on fixing it, even with proprietary drivers.

See the 245 comments (latest comment the 6 Sep 08 at 01:02) >>

up
696
down
Make it possible to mark applications "Disable Compiz when running"  
Written by johan the 3 Mar 08 at 21:54. Category: Graphics. Related to: Nothing/Others. In development
This is what I want:

I want to be able to mark applications "Not Compiz compatible" so that Compiz shuts down when I launch a game or some other 3D-heavy application. This is something I want to improve stability and performance for such applications.

Developer comments
This will be automatically fixed with the arrival of DRI2 and updated drivers. There is no point in adding a plugin or workaround like suggested. The caveat here is that the initial support for DRI2 is only for intel's i915 at the moment... maybe with i965 following shortly thereafter.

When the OpenSource drivers for ATI (radeon,radeonHD) and nVIDIA (nouveau) will support DRI2 is still unknown. But the only way to fix the mentioned bugs is via DRI2. There is not much action that can come from our (Canonical) side as we don't have any experienced upstream Xorg developer in our team.

See the 28 comments (latest comment the 4 Aug 08 at 10:33) >>

implemented
Done!
(506)
Brainstorm: Allow duplicate ideas to merge (sum votes)  
Written by psquared89 the 4 Mar 08 at 03:31. Category: Brainstorm. Related to: Nothing/Others. Implemented
Duplicates happen, and there are already quite a few examples of duplicates that have each accrued a fair number of votes (ie the original has 50 votes and the dupe 100).

This creates confusion for the user, should I vote for both ideas, the original, or the duplicate as it has more votes? This would obviously require some supervision, but a "propose merge" form for two very similar / identical ideas would help ensure that competition doesn't kill good ideas.

The merge process would also have to check to ensure that votes from the same person for each idea are not double counted, but I don't think this would be that hard to implement.

Example from idea 4292 :

One is suggesting to add MBR recovery option in Installation CD.http://brainstorm.ubuntu.com/idea/1242/
One is suggesting that installer should never overwrite MBR.http://brainstorm.ubuntu.com/idea/1957/
One is suggesting to have general application which can recover MBR.http://brainstorm.ubuntu.com/idea/3985/

All these ideas should be merged and a single solution which seems to be good enough should be implemented.

See the 11 comments (latest comment the 2 Aug 08 at 19:41) >>

up
125
down
Calling for The Next Linux Multi- Media Application Suite by Canonical  
Written by amoore the 4 Mar 08 at 19:57. Category: Multimedia. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
Everyone is familiar with Open Office’s office suite or Firefox/Mozzilla’s internet suite of Firefox and Thunderbird. Both suites have found homes in Linux and are a staple in many Linux distros.(IMHO) These two application suites have made Linux a viable OS in desktop computing. Yes, I do know other alternatives to OOO and FF are available and, competition is a good thing.

The time has now come for a multi-media Application Suite for the OSS community. Lets face it, Linux lacks many of the creative and multi-media tools that it needs to be a real desktop OS. Many new users to Ubuntu/ Linux just need a simple way to edit video, audio and pics. I know that many apps already exist for these needs but, most of these apps fall short and do not integrate with one another(IMHO).

Is there a really solid OSS video editor for the home video enthusiast? This is what I see with many OSS video editors: Cinelerra is overkill and it lacks the ability to capture DV video. Kino and Diva are just to basic. Pitivi just combines clips, Kdenlive is still very buggy (in beta) also, getting firewire to work is also a real pain for video editing applications too.

A simple to use video editor is much needed in the home user Ubuntu/ Linux desktop. While were talking about video Apps how about integrating a video editor with a separate DVD Video creation app? Is this starting to sound like iMovie and iDVD?

Image editing in Linux needs work too, Gimp is OK for simple editing but should combine a photo manager and needs some work with some of the core tools and its UI to make it easer for the home user. Once more, the Image app should be able to work with the video editing and DVD creation software.

If these apps were created and worked well, a natural side effect could be a push in the use of free or open source formats for media such as ogg. Having a multimedia application suite for creation that pushes open media formats such as OGG would be huge!

So the BIG question is how do you make money off developing this Application suite? Easy, all of these apps create multimedia files that either have hard copy equivalents or can be uploaded to sharing sites like youtube or flicker.

[....]

See the 11 comments (latest comment the 19 Jul 08 at 05:26) >>

up
88
down
Brainstorm: Don't just delete duplicate ideas -- link to the informative ones  
Written by theosib the 2 Mar 08 at 16:00. Category: Brainstorm. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
I just noticed that an idea that I was looking at before disappeared and then realized that it had been marked a duplicate of another one and hidden. I'm all for collapsing good ideas, but in my opinion, the hidden duplicate was vastly more informative than the one that it was marked a duplicate of.

Don't arbitrarily throw away good ideas.

My suggestion is that a link to the hidden idea should appear as a comment under the winner. This way, people can still get to all of the useful information.


See the 8 comments (latest comment the 16 May 08 at 19:10) >>

up
133
down
Better integration (or migration) between gnome/KDE  
Written by KhaaL the 29 Feb 08 at 17:34. Category: System. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
Some simple things such as bookmarks of my folders and mouse sensitivity settings should be recognised by the DE the user is using / migrated to. Some settings may be hard to migrate, such as keyboard shortcuts or amaroks/rythmboxs ratings , but the more simple settings shouldn't be too hard.

The free desktop enviorments shouldn't lock-in their users.

See the 2 comments >>

up
123
down
Add Cinelerra  
[needs-packaging] cinelerra - Heroine Warrior
version multritrack video editor (#105907)


In : ubuntu
Status : Triaged
Importance : Wishlist
Assignee :
11 comments, 6 subscribers and 1 duplicates
bug
Written by M1r4g3 the 29 Feb 08 at 22:21. Category: Multimedia. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
Make cinelerra available with apt-get.
Very cool non-linear video editor, the only one able to deal with the sound of JVC HDD media files!
OK it's maybe a codec problem, but all the other available non-linear video editors mess it up.

See the 5 comments >>

up
45
down
Another Brainstorming Search Order  
Written by jsatkanpak the 29 Feb 08 at 20:39. Category: Brainstorm. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
"Most Popular Ideas" is not necessarily the most useful search. It could be that these ideas have been around a long time, so have had more votes.

I would rename the current "Most Popular" to "Most Voted For" and make the "Most Popular" list report the order in (# of votes over time listed). This would allow very recent posts that are getting a lot of votes to appear at the top of the list.

Otherwise, the newer posts seem to slide into oblivion on the "Latest Ideas" search, regardless of actual user interest.

See the 3 comments >>

closed
Closed
(-118)
MAP (MySQL-Apache-PHP) installed by default  
Written by vargux the 1 Mar 08 at 02:00. Category: Server. Related to: Nothing/Others. Won't implement
Yeah, 'MySQL, Apache, & PHP' installed by default for servers.




Developer comments
There is already an LAMP option during install.

See the 8 comments >>