Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 12357 ideas, 58479 comments, 1187050 votes

Contributor mcglnx




up
1743
down
Tabbed Nautilus  
tabbed file browsing needed (#154059)

In : nautilus (ubuntu)
Status : Fix Released
Importance : Wishlist
Assignee : Ubuntu Desktop Bugs
3 comments, 2 subscribers and 0 duplicates
bug
forum
Written by einalex the 28 Feb 08 at 17:16. Category: Look and Feel. Related to: Nothing/Others. In development
Enable Nautilus to use tabs.

Nautilus is Ubuntu's default file management software. There is no reason why you should need to open countless Nautilus windows to manage your files. It is time to bring tabs from your web browser to your file browser.

Developer comments
This is being worked on in upstream GNOME: http://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=48034

See the 69 comments >>

up
1842
down
Warning about low disk space  
No information about this blueprint
Information is updated every 5 minutes.
Please wait till the next update.
spec
forum
Written by luohan the 28 Feb 08 at 15:55. Category: System. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
Provide this warning with possibility to solve the problem.

See the 31 comments >>

up
669
down
Easy file sharing between local users  
Ubuntu

In :  
Priority : Undefined
Definition : Discussion (Needs guidance)
Implementation : Not started
Assignee :
spec
Written by kamil.paral the 8 Mar 08 at 21:20. Category: Accessibility. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
Currently there is no way to easily share files between multiple local users. I am talking about full read-write access to particular folder, eg. music folder.

Example: Alice and Bob uses the same computer. Alice has read access to Bob's home folder. Bob has read access to Alice's home folder. They want to fully share (read/write) their music. So they should ideally create /home/music folder, put all the music there and use it. Everything Bob puts into there, Alice should be able to read and remove, and vice versa. This is currently impossible in Ubuntu. Bob has to manually fix permissions every time Alice wants to delete something Bob's (Bob creates /home/music/Britney, but Alice can't delete /home/music/Britney/song1.mp3).

I have discussed this issue with several linux gurus and there is currently no easy nor difficult way to achieve this in Linux on the same (ext3) partition. With every proposed solution I can give you counterexample (group permissions, ACLs, local Samba, local NFS, etc - there is always problem when moving files). There would have to be created utility to set shared folders and some daemon would have to monitor changes and modify permissions.

Currently the easiest solution known for me is to share files on separate (ironically) NTFS partition, because when mounting NTFS you can force user/group/permissions on file access. What a shame, we use Microsoft technologies just to share files between Ubuntu users.

This problem is quite serious, give it a thought or two. Everyone who is not using Ubuntu computer alone and wants to share music/films/etc between multiple users knows what I am talking about.

//New info:
Atany has proposed in the comment that BindFS project can be used to achieve this functinality:
http://code.google.com/p/bindfs/
I have tried it and it works very well. Developers which would like to implement this idea should have a look on BindFS, it's very promising tool, it could provide all necessary background for this.

Developer comments
The proposed inotify/chmod hack in https://wiki.ubuntu.com/LocalFileShare would probably work to some degree, but I think it is subject to race conditions, and also not very flexible.

A slightly better solution would IMHO be to provide the shared directory through FUSE; then we can impose dynamic size limitations (at most use 2/3 of the available space in /home, etc.), fine-grained dynamic permissions, and avoid a lot of inotifying and permission race conditions.

Once this is solved and provided by default, we should reconsider "#6106: Make so other people cant access your home directory", which we didn't do yet in order for people to be able to share files r/o.

See the 37 comments >>

up
151
down
Talk with FSF.org to legitimate translated GPL/LGPL  
Written by Andrei Zhekov the 9 Mar 08 at 11:17. Category: Others. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
There is a problem with GPL/LGPL in my country (Russia) and may be in others. Our law dictate to approve only licenses written in the native language but FSF admits only the English variant. So, this problem is slowing down in some manner the convertation of the market to open source in my country. Please fix it!

See the 14 comments >>

implemented
Done!
(371)
Show me ideas I've voted for  
Written by MDC1 the 8 Mar 08 at 20:24. Category: Brainstorm. Related to: Nothing/Others. Implemented
I've voted for ~40-50 good ideas at this point. Give me a link below "My ideas" that says "My votes" so that I can see all the ideas that I've voted for. That will help users remember ideas that they might want to help with or donate time on in the future.

See the 7 comments >>

up
1233
down
ATI (now AMD) video card drivers that actually work  
Written by mp3phish the 4 Mar 08 at 03:48. Category: Graphics. Related to: Nothing/Others. In development
I know that the Ubuntu volunteers don't have any power over this, but I think that the parent company Canonical maybe could get some pull here. Maybe they could leverage the Dell partnership to force AMD's hands.

ATI Video card drivers are very poor. The thing just plain doesn't work, and I don't see this changing any time soon. This is probably the #1 thing holding Ubuntu back to the mass population where their laptops and desktops came with ATI motherboard chipsets and absolutely NO support for video, compiz, etc from AMD.

While I am not praising nvidia's effort (closed source only) at least their drivers work.

I propose that Canonical use their leverage in any way they feel possible to convince AMD to deliver high quality (and preferably open source) drivers for Ubuntu. They are not only holding back gaming on linux, but also adoption for every day users.

Developer comments
I am marking this as "In development" because now AMD has made the specifications for their cards available so this will likely improve as the open source drivers become more mature.

The closed source drivers are available post-install via jockey.

UPDATE: X.org maintainer Bryce Harrington responds: http://blog.qa.ubuntu.com/node/10

See the 24 comments >>

implemented
Done!
(1303)
Avoid Fsck Forced Irritation  
Ubuntu

In :  
Priority : Low
Definition : Approved (Needs guidance)
Implementation : Unknown
Assignee : Dennis Kaarsemaker
spec
Written by amar the 28 Feb 08 at 14:28. Category: System. Related to: Nothing/Others. Implemented
It is very frustrating when you get caught out after 30 boots and the system does a full check. Especially if you are about to give a presentation or you just need to read one bit of information. The Ubuntu team have done a great job of speeding up the boot time but this irritation undoes all the good work.

Possible solutions and further explanation:
http://micrux.net/?p=52

Developer comments

This is implemented in Hardy Heron.
You can press the escape key to cancel the disk check.



This change was part of a more global set of changes to usplash, you can read more about it here : https://wiki.ubuntu.com/UsplashPolishSpec


See the 61 comments >>

implemented
Already done!
(3253)
Codec Manager  
Written by intarwub the 29 Feb 08 at 00:32. Category: Multimedia. Related to: Nothing/Others. Already implemented
As a user I want to be able to listen to audio or watch videos with the least amount of setup. I would like to have a single interface (Codec Manager) that lists all of the most common audio and video formats and shows me if I am missing the necessary codec for playback.

Use Case: Enable MP3 playback.
Precondition: MP3s are not currently playable.
1. User logs into the system.
2. User opens the Codec Manager.
3. System displays a list of common audio/video formats.
4. User selects MP3s.
5. System displays some info about MP3s.
6. System displays a list of available codecs.
7. User selects a codec and clicks Apply.
8. System downloads and installs the selected codec.
9. System informs the user when completed.

Other possible features:
- Display a list of audio/video types that are missing codecs.
- An auto-setup function, that grabs the recommended codec for all formats.

Audio and Video formats that should be supported:

Audio:
- MP3
- OGG
- AAC
- FLAC
- Real Audio

Video:
- MP4

[....]

Developer comments
Attacks the problem from the wrong angle. I don't think many users would care about a "codec manager", that sounds very much like a geek tool. Heck, *I* wouldn't care about a codec manager. I care about watching my videos. :-)

To me this already seems solved very elegantly with the existing easy-codec-installation.

See the 65 comments >>

up
4518
down
Speed Up Ubuntu-Gnome boot time   forum
Written by Arioch the 28 Feb 08 at 15:26. Category: System. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
I guess everybody has experienced the rather long boot up times in Ubuntu (particularly with laptops). I know they are already working on it, but the change from feisty to gutsy was a pain in the ass in terms of boot up speed.
A default WinXP installation beats Ubuntu's boot up time by far!! That shouldn't be allowed fellas!!

I therefore propose to the development team (both Ubuntu and by extension Gnome)to work on the improvement of boot up times in Ubuntu systems.

See the 90 comments >>

up
4052
down
Unmount resolution  
Cannot unmount volume: show which application(s)
still use the drive (#81239)


In : gnome-mount (ubuntu)
Status : Triaged
Importance : Wishlist
Assignee : Martin Pitt
22 comments, 10 subscribers and 0 duplicates
bug
Written by Vivien the 28 Feb 08 at 16:35. Category: System. Related to: Nothing/Others. In development
When someone wants to unmount a volume and the mount point is used, he gets a message telling him that the volume can't be unmounted because an application uses it. The user has no idea which application is actually using it and can't remove the device.

I propose that the popup tells him which application(s) is(are) using the device and propose to terminate them (that list should be kept up to date when the app. dies).

Developer comments
Upstream bug (GNOME #528559) has a patch in discussion. Volunteering to work on it.

See the 35 comments >>

up
3861
down
Start taking advantage of Upstart  
Ubuntu

In :  
Priority : Medium
Definition : Approved (Needs guidance)
Implementation : Deferred
Assignee : Scott James Remnant
spec
Written by Ubuwu the 28 Feb 08 at 15:12. Category: System. Related to: Nothing/Others. In development
Replace initscripts with upstart events. Our boot sequence is currently slow, full of race conditions and poor interactions, especially with competition between the series of tasks run by sysv-rc, udev and sometimes just with the kernel. We developed upstart so that we could have a truly event driven boot sequence that would be fast, reliable and flexible; we should take advantage of it.

Developer comments
The primary reason that we're not taking full advantage of Upstart yet is that it still requires some development to have sufficient features to actually be better than sysvinit. You can follow Upstart development at its homepage.

See the 33 comments >>

up
4702
down
Clean up Preferences and Administration.  
Launchers under "System > Preferences"
and "System > Administration" have
similar names, leads to confusion. (#174277)


In : ubuntu
Status : Confirmed
Importance : Wishlist
Assignee : Oumar Aziz OUATTARA
20 comments, 7 subscribers and 0 duplicates
bug
Ubuntu

In :  
Priority : Undefined
Definition : New (Needs guidance)
Implementation : Unknown
Assignee :
spec
forum
Written by writser the 28 Feb 08 at 16:49. Category: System. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
First of all: What is the difference between Preferences and Administration? For example: why do I see 'Encryption and Keyrings' in Preferences and 'Keyring Manager' in Administration? What is the difference between 'Default Printer' and 'Printing'? Why do I have to disable the Tracker under Sessions and not under Search and Indexing? And why are these menu's so large? I have 24 items in Preferences (they don't even fit on my screen!) and 18 items in Administration. To put all this stuff in a popup menu is bad interface design imho. Besides, the number of option should be much smaller. A few suggestions:

- Merge 'Screensaver', 'Screen Resolution' and 'Screens and Graphics'.
- Merge 'Network', 'Network Proxy' and 'Network Tools'.
- Merge 'Update Manager, Synaptic Package Manager, Software Sources'.
- Merge 'Encryption and Keyrings', 'Authorizations', 'Keyring Manager'.


Below are all settings I can visit via the System menu. This is just way too much.


-- Preferences --
Universal Access
About Me
Appearance
Bluetooth
Default Printer
Encryption and Keyrings
Keyboard
Keyboard Shortcuts
Main Menu
Mouse
Network Proxy
PalmOS Devices (I don't have one)
Power Management

[....]

See the 93 comments >>

up
4887
down
Power Management  
Ubuntu

In :  
Priority : Low
Definition : Pending Approval (Needs guidance)
Implementation : Slow progress
Assignee : Amit Kucheria
spec
Written by jsmidt the 28 Feb 08 at 16:49. Category: Others. Related to: Nothing/Others. In development
Ubuntu needs to go green. Powertop, Lesswatts and other tools have finally hit the Linux scene to pave the way for better power management. It needs to be said, "if you want your battery to last longest, or have your energy bill be the lowest, you better use Ubuntu Linux."

See the 71 comments >>

up
5958
down
Fix Suspend and Hibernate   forum
Written by tighem the 28 Feb 08 at 17:22. Category: System. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
Suspend and hibernate still seems to be a big issue based on forum posts. Really focus on fixing it, even with proprietary drivers.

See the 245 comments >>

closed
Not an idea
(1805)
Fix copy / paste  
MASTER Clipboard gets lost when windows is closed (#106644)

In : ubuntu
Status : Confirmed
Importance : Medium
Assignee :
19 comments, 9 subscribers and 1 duplicates
bug
Written by lubosz the 4 Mar 08 at 16:30. Category: Look and Feel. Related to: Nothing/Others. Not an idea
a lot of times, text is not copied. even if i cut, the selected text disapears in firefox and isn't pasteable in pidgin. sometimes the clipboard is an older version, if i paste.

See the 41 comments >>

implemented
Done!
(559)
Give focus to filename input in gnome File->"Save as" dialog  
gtkfilechooser save/save as dialog misplaces focus (#130224)

In : gtk+2.0 (ubuntu)
Status : Fix Released
Importance : Low
Assignee : Ubuntu Desktop Bugs
16 comments, 5 subscribers and 6 duplicates
bug
Written by oleksiy the 4 Mar 08 at 11:53. Category: System. Related to: Nothing/Others. Implemented
When you click "Save as" menu item in gnome application a dialog windows appears and you naturally start typing new name but that field doesn't have focus and you have to click it. It would be perfect to give focus to the name field automatically.

See the 10 comments >>

up
461
down
Option To Delete Your Own Bad Brainstorm Ideas  
Written by stevec the 4 Mar 08 at 00:13. Category: Brainstorm. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
Because sometimes things don't sound like nearly as good an idea when you've thought on it a while. :-)

See the 21 comments >>

up
247
down
Right-click, "Set as wallpaper" function in Nautilus  
Written by brettalton the 4 Mar 08 at 17:43. Category: Look and Feel. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
Allow users to right-click a photo and left-click "Set as wallpaper" in Nautilus.

This can be implemented by installing 'nautilus-wallpaper'.

Please include this as a default.

See the 9 comments >>