Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 22700 ideas, 138270 comments, 2629576 votes
Idea sandbox Idea sandbox
Popular ideas Popular ideas
Ideas in development Ideas in development
Implemented ideas Implemented ideas

Contributor globinXX

Awkward visual transition from login to desktop  
Written by erikannen the 31 Mar 11 at 17:41. Global category: Graphics. Not an idea
The transition from login screen (with its specific background) is visually awkward for those who do not use the default Ubuntu background on their desktop, have a custom theme, etc.

Beyond a difference in appearance, the transition is also awkward because it is a straight cut (from login immediately to desktop), as opposed to a fade or animation of some kind.
225
votes
closed
Solution #1: Transition from login background to desktop background
Written by erikannen the 31 Mar 11 at 17:41.
A simple transition (fading, dissolving or wiping, lasting no more than a second or so) from login to desktop would reduce the visual contrast between the two.

Idea #7188 addresses this in a somewhat different way. I feel that it still deserves mention, however.

http://brainstorm.ubuntu.com/idea/7188/
-26
votes
closed
Solution #2: Transition background after selecting user
Written by MeanEYE the 1 Apr 11 at 20:00.
Same as solution #1 but with a different behavior. Upon selecting user from login dialog background should fade into user selected background that moment.

This provides user with visual feedback of selection. Also, background transition would occur before session loading ensuring transition is done smoothly.
-75
votes
closed
Solution #3: Transition background with the users pictures
Written by Anjar the 5 Apr 11 at 13:01.
Same as solution #2, but using the users login-picture (?) as background. When login in, fade into the users background.
44
votes
closed
Solution #4: Allow users to choose what their login screen looks like
Written by Townley89 the 7 Apr 11 at 15:37.
If they can change the back image of the background screen, they can either set it to be the same as their desktop (seemless transition) or if their desktop wouldn't make an appealing login screen, they can set it for similar colors that would then, in conjunction with solution 1, allow for a perfect transition.
-12
votes
closed
Solution #5: As soon as you select a user, his/her background will appear
Written by th3pr0ph3t the 25 Apr 11 at 02:44.
For example, in the login screen you click or select user Anna, by the time you're prompted for the password, her desktop background is already visible.

If you don't want this to happen, access to the file should be only for the owner, for example:
-rw------- hotchick.png


See the 6 comments or propose a solution >>

Superuser windows should differ from user windows  
Written by woodroof the 12 Mar 11 at 16:54. Global category: Usability. New
It quite hard to determine if application already have superuser rights.
181
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Add different style to such windows
Written by woodroof the 12 Mar 11 at 16:54.
Maybe different title color or different picture instead of circle in left side.
-63
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Solution #2: Change the title as "Sudo ..."
Written by PaoloRotolo the 21 Mar 11 at 15:35.
Change the title of the window as "Sudo desktop" or "Sudo home".
32
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Change the title bar color and label it 'Priveledged'
Written by rockachu2 the 2 Apr 11 at 19:01.
You cold change the color of the window title, and add a tag to the end of the window : ' -- Priveledged'
22
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: Different color for window border
Written by clonejo the 7 Apr 11 at 18:22.
Recolor the window borders (including title bar) to red or a black-yellow striped texture.
-15
votes
up equal down
Solution #5: Watermark
Written by EdSantilli the 8 Apr 11 at 22:08.
Perhaps a watermark in the windows content would do the trick. For example, it can be placed in the top right corner of the window's content so that it is easily noticeable by the user yet less obtrusive than a complete change in the theme's color.

For the nerds: Unless the user likes using #888888 for their workspace (which can be handled as a special case), a watermark made with a 90% identity + 10% XOR map of the original colors would work using any theme at all.

See the 4 comments or propose a solution >>

No easy place for new users to see Ubuntu version.  
Written by turbolad the 24 Mar 11 at 18:02. Related project: Unity. Implemented
There's no "About Ubuntu" item that gives the user enough basic information about the Ubuntu version they are using.

If new users are asked by technical support "which version of Ubuntu are you using" AND if it's 32-bit or 64-bit, it would be easier for them if there were a one-click option to reveal the Ubuntu version and other useful information e.g. kernel version etc.

I'm aware that users can look within the first tab of the System Monitor, but it's not an obvious place for new users.

Developer comments
John Lea, user experience architect on the Unity team, responds that in Ubuntu 11.10 the new LightDM greeter shows the Ubuntu version number, making that basic information very easily visible. For more detail, System Settings -> System Info provides a simple summary.
64
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#1): One-click option to see Ubuntu version, kernel version, 32-bit or 64-bit etc.
Written by turbolad the 24 Mar 11 at 18:02.
A menu option or an entry next to Ubuntu Software Centre/Center that reads "About Ubuntu..." and when it's clicked on, a window appears with the Ubuntu version and basic system information (not in-depth), e.g. 32-bit or 64-bit, Linux kernel version, number of CPU's, total amount of RAM, computer name and free disk space.

That would give users enough basic information, but without being superfluous.
-38
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#2): Enrich uname
Written by Akerbos the 25 Mar 11 at 01:19.
`uname -a` already outputs that the running Linux is a Ubuntu. Version number should be included.
165
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#3): Use already present "About Ubuntu" menu item
Written by Dojan the 25 Mar 11 at 08:54.
There is already a System>About Ubuntu menu item, use and expand that for more comprehensive display of version number, 32/64 bit, desktop/notebook, maybe even Ubuntu/Kubuntu/Xubuntu/Edubutnu, last uptate, kernel version etc.

Newbies should not have to use the terminal more than necessary! This could also be convenient for more experienced users if you get to an unfamiliar computer at a university/internet café/friends/whatever and just quickly want to check the computer out without opening/without access to a terminal.
-33
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#4): Put it on the Unity Dash
Written by ginjaninja405 the 25 Mar 11 at 13:43.
Make it more obvious, but putting it as a button option at the bottom of the Unity Dash, having system settings and the shutdown/restart/log out/lock screen buttons there could be beneficial too.
-51
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#6): Print the version number on the desktop background
Written by warddr the 3 Apr 11 at 00:23.
The title is explaining it all.
-26
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#7): Update "About Ubuntu" to ask users to check "System Monitor"
Written by raghaven the 6 Apr 11 at 06:56.
The SystemMonitor utility under
System->Administration->System Monitor(the "System" tab) does this part.

So, we can just ask users to check it.
3
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#8): tooltip on ubuntu logo
Written by hexatron the 7 Apr 11 at 01:14.
when someone puts their mouse over the ubuntu logo on the unity panel you could have a tooltip pop up and say "Ubuntu [version]" like "Ubuntu 11.04".
-3
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#9): put version in plymouth screen
Written by hexatron the 7 Apr 11 at 01:19.
title says it all. just dont be obnoxious about it.
-4
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#10): Place a link in the Applications launcher
Written by anyedge the 18 Apr 11 at 02:39.
When you go into the Applications launcher in Unity, you can type "ab" and immediately "About Me" pops up as one of the search results.

Why not allow "About Ubuntu" to pop up as one of the results if someone types in "about" or "ubuntu"?

That would be the easiest/least intrusive of all the methods.
-6
votes
implemented
Selected solution (#11): create an application shortcut "About Ubuntu" tht runs "gnome-system-monitor -s"
Written by KuriKai the 21 Apr 11 at 21:47.
the shortcut "gnome-system-monitor -s"
will open the system monitor on the system tab, which will show the version of ubuntu all someone needsto do is create an application shortcut called "about Ubuntu that runs the command "gnome-system-monitor -s"

See the 12 comments or propose a solution >>

Volume slider should not be deactivated when sound is muted  
Written by benjamin.schaefer the 14 Mar 11 at 20:23. Global category: Multimedia. Not an idea
When using Ubuntu on a notebook (as I do) it is often plugged into various soundsystems (headphones, stereo, in my case mixer, etc.) that require different volumes. Sometimes Ubuntu must be muted (e.g. when being in an office or in university). Then you forgot to adjust the volume, plugging it at home to your stereo. You can't turn the volume down while Ubuntu is muted. And if you unmute it, while being so loud, you might damage your speakers, ears or neighbours :-)
Apparently there is no reason for the volume slider to be deactivated, while sound is muted.
131
votes
closed
Solution #1: Don't grey out the volume slider while sound is muted
Written by benjamin.schaefer the 14 Mar 11 at 20:23.
as simple as it can be...
22
votes
closed
Solution #2: Change the color
Written by lilezek the 3 Apr 11 at 01:56.
Just change color of the slider, but let it enabled.

See the 4 comments or propose a solution >>

Allow shutting the computer down from the lock screen  
Written by aruseni the 27 Mar 11 at 19:18. Global category: System. Already implemented
When Ubuntu is locked (for example, after resuming from suspend or screensaver), you must enter the password to shut the computer down. If you don't know the password, but have to turn off the computer (for example, you are reported that the electricity in the building will be turned off in 5 minutes), all you can do is to press and hold the power button, until it will be roughly turned off, which is not a really good idea.
-45
votes
closed
Solution #1: Add an option to shut down the computer from the lock screen
Written by aruseni the 27 Mar 11 at 19:18.
For example, add a button for doing it. I think, it is even much more important than a feature to leave a message to the user, as he or she would be much more glad if you shut down the computer correctly when it’s required (and not turn it off using the button).

I also think that this feature won’t decrease the security, because if you have physical access to to the computer, you can turn it off anyway (okay, except some very rare cases — but we can add a feature to hide this button from the lock screen), and the regular shutdown performed from the OS is much better.
-35
votes
closed
Solution #2: Allow shuting down only with the current users or an admin password.
Written by Ssdg the 27 Mar 11 at 21:53.
Because you can always lock your screen with unsaved documents, temporary downloaded files open or anything, a shutdown should never happen without your consent unless the power is cut.
101
votes
closed
Solution #3: Have a "Save State" mode
Written by ginjaninja405 the 27 Mar 11 at 23:16.
Basically, have a mode where you can save the current state of programs behind the password, basically a hibernation, specifically tailored to preserving all programs exactly as they are and having the computer turn off completely. This way you save power, and the documents.
-18
votes
closed
Solution #4: Make it more obvious how to shut the computer down correctly
Written by rockachu2 the 2 Apr 11 at 19:13.
Three things:

1. Ubuntu should warn when turning off if somebody is logged in.
2. Change the 'switch user' button to a large back button that says 'User screen' or whatever
3. give an option in the system preferences to prevent users from forcing anyone else to log out.

See the 14 comments or propose a solution >>

Software Center asks for password too often  
Written by neo_aryan the 21 Mar 11 at 09:49. Related project: Ubuntu Software Center. Not an idea
Software Center asks user to authenticate to install software too often.
-69
votes
closed
Solution #1: Store authentication for length of session
Written by neo_aryan the 21 Mar 11 at 09:49.
Password is entered manually the first time. Password is kept securely throughout session.
84
votes
closed
Solution #2: Store authentication for length that Software Center remains open
Written by komputes the 22 Mar 11 at 22:29.
Password is entered manually the first time. Password is kept securely until Software Center is closed.
13
votes
closed
Solution #3: Create an updated policykit GUI and allow users to decide behavior
Written by komputes the 22 Mar 11 at 22:36.
Not all users are alike and some may have different needs than others. Allowing users to specify their security preferences will allow users to set the software-center behaviour to a password timeout value, entire session or for when software-center is open.

Solution #3 recommends we allow users to specify their policykit authentication preferences. The "Authorizations" utility in previous releases of Ubuntu used give the ability to do just this. It has not been maintained and apparently does not work with current versions of policykit.

No equivalent to polkit-gnome-authorization in policykit-1-gnome
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/policykit-gnome/+bug/443265

See the 3 comments or propose a solution >>

Making thumbnails of big files can slow PC  
Written by crantisz the 21 Mar 11 at 22:32. Related project: Nautilus. Not an idea
Making thumbnails of big files can slow PC if there isn't enough free memory. Standard block by size works always, but it must work only if system overloaded
72
votes
closed
Solution #1: Do not allow making thumbnails if there isn't enough free memory
Written by crantisz the 21 Mar 11 at 22:32.
Do not allow making thumbnails if there isn't enough free memory
52
votes
closed
Solution #2: Do not allow making thumbnails if the CPU is heavily used
Written by komputes the 22 Mar 11 at 21:17.
Do not allow making thumbnails if the CPU is heavily used. A threshold (example 50%) should be configurable.
-25
votes
closed
Solution #3: Only load thumbnails for files in the viewable area of the window
Written by komputes the 22 Mar 11 at 21:23.
Don't create thumbnails for items that are not being viewed in nautilus. Wait until user scrolls down to create those thumbnails.
40
votes
closed
Solution #4: Optimise OS features if specs are low
Written by ginjaninja405 the 25 Mar 11 at 13:12.
Things like Thumbnail loading for large files should be switched off by default for computers with low specifications. The option to turn it on should ALWAYS be available, but not immediately turned on. This could apply to other features too, and can be determined by a smart analysis of the system's hardware.
-1
votes
closed
Solution #5: Turn off thumbnails by defauld in list view, use it by default with nautilus
Written by Felitaur the 28 Mar 11 at 02:34.
Thumbnails are also insecure, because item could contain exploits for thumbnailer. It's not a problem currently, because, particular systems are relatively rare, but it also would make loading list of files faster. And custom icons is not particularly useful in list view, because icons is too small anyway
So, custom icons should be disabled by default for nautilus list view, and also it should be default because, it show more information about files and also more secure if custom icons is turned off for the mode
-9
votes
closed
Solution #6: Add thumnails effect to "Extra" Visual Effects option.
Written by raghaven the 6 Apr 11 at 07:05.
We can add it as effect into the Extra effects in Appearance->Visual Effects.

See the 11 comments or propose a solution >>

PPA can thret security risk - no way to find out which is trusted PPA  
Written by grofaty the 18 Mar 11 at 07:24. Related project: launchpad.net. Not an idea
When someone likes to add new software that is not available in official repositories like new version of software then PPA needs to be added. You never know who is behind a PPA unless you know developer/package maintainer behind PPA. Newbies don't know anyone and see no point of knowing them. They only want to install software from trusted source.
-15
votes
closed
Solution #1: Add hotel like stars at trusted PPAs
Written by grofaty the 18 Mar 11 at 07:24.
It would be nice if there is something like hotel stars for PPAs. This statuses should be added by trusted people.
67
votes
closed
Solution #2: Add status "trusted" / "not verified"
Written by grofaty the 18 Mar 11 at 07:26.
Instead of adding stars just add "trusted" or "not verified" statuses for PPAs. This statuses should also be done by trusted people.
-11
votes
closed
Solution #3: mandatory for PPA keeper to give easy to find and verify information
Written by punch the 20 Mar 11 at 09:25.
At least it should be mandatory for PPA repository keeper to provide information about who she/he is. I mean a link to a program's site where user can find and verify information about the authors of the program and about who maintains their PPA repository. It would prevent third party unauthorized persons from running PPA repository.
For example there is no information about Rickard Närström on Clemetine web site and I don't know this person. Why should I trust him? Anyway, it should be easy to find and verify information.
https://launchpad.net/~riccetn/+archive/clementine
And Launchpad team should check if this information is provided before giving PPA key.

There should also be a clear information on every launchpad repository site about what its status really mean and what is the danger. I mean there should be a better description.
For example here is really clear explanation what untrusted PPA - really mean.
https://answers.launchpad.net/launchpad/+question/141780
18
votes
closed
Solution #4: provide better description about security level
Written by punch the 20 Mar 11 at 09:34.
There should also be a clear information on every launchpad repository site about what its status really mean and what is the danger. I mean there should be a better description.
For example here is really clear explanation what untrusted PPA - really mean.
https://answers.launchpad.net/launchpad/+question/141780

I've just thought it should be additional (separate) solution and I could edit Solution #3.

See the 4 comments or propose a solution >>

Web-based Ubuntu Software Center!  
Written by ivo000 the 7 Mar 11 at 21:07. Related project: Ubuntu Software Center. Already implemented
Many people who use Windows to ask:

1.What programs exist in the Ubuntu Software Center?
2.What programs and games are on the Ubuntu Software Center?
3.What is the price of X to Ubuntu Software Center?
-21
votes
closed
Solution #1: Add web-based Ubuntu Software Center!
Written by ivo000 the 7 Mar 11 at 21:07.
By adding a web-based Ubuntu Software Center provides Windows users more choices if he is really worth it to migrate to Ubuntu!

By publishing a Web-based Software Center Ubuntu objavljivaju the information that the software is added to the Ubuntu Software Center.

Web-based Ubuntu Software Center provides information only about the added software, but no download link, because if it wants to install software, you will install Ubuntu!
67
votes
closed
Solution #2: Advertise more available applications on Ubuntu's website
Written by mystro256 the 8 Mar 11 at 01:06.
Advertise more available applications on Ubuntu's website to entice more people to download/buy/use it, because it's the all the applications that make Linux so good, not just the operating system itself.
10
votes
closed
Solution #3: Solution #2 + Link Application summary to documentation on the Ubuntu Wiki
Written by komputes the 16 Mar 11 at 22:37.
Solution #2 + Link Application summary to documentation on the Ubuntu Wiki
21
votes
closed
Solution #4: Integrate Software Center with Launchad PPA
Written by punch the 20 Mar 11 at 09:41.
Integrating Software Center with Launchpad(Mockup)
www.techdrivein.com/2011/03/integrating-software-center-with.html

See the 4 comments or propose a solution >>

Counter Microsoft's Marketing Campaigns  
Written by mydoghasworms the 26 Mar 11 at 08:44. Global category: Marketing. Won't implement
I always refer back to Ubuntu bug #1 on Launchpad ("Microsoft has a majority market share"), and I believe one of the areas to take Microsoft on would definitely be their marketing.

For example, I see many ads on e.g. Sourceforge for Microsoft (currently it is the "Genuine Windows 7" campaign).
60
votes
closed
Solution #1: Use advertising space e.g. on Sourceforge, Google ads
Written by mydoghasworms the 26 Mar 11 at 08:44.
Canonical can buy some advertising space and use the same channels as Microsoft does to try and reach the same segment of the market.
33
votes
closed
Solution #2: Target Microsoft's ad campaigns directly
Written by mydoghasworms the 26 Mar 11 at 18:02.
Wouldn't it be great if we could counter the current "Genuine Windows 7" campaign with something like "Genuine Linux" or "Genuine Linux - 100% Free"?

They could use ads that take on or address slogans by Microsoft, e.g. the current "Genuine Windows 7" campaign with something like "Genuine Linux - 100% Free". The Ubuntu logo should of course be prominently featured.
27
votes
closed
Solution #3: Write why Free Software is better.
Written by Felitaur the 28 Mar 11 at 02:15.
There is some campaigns about «why legal software is better».
It mostly contain from false statements, like about it's more protected from virii, while it's still same proprietary system with all their bugs and misfeatures.

It can be opposed by campaigns about software which is still legal, but Free, which is really better than proprietary. e.g. "With Free software, you control your computer, with proprietary software, big brother controls you", about security and so on.
35
votes
closed
Solution #4: Motivate the Community
Written by bawlaw the 30 Mar 11 at 03:23.
motivate the community through competitions to develop good publicity. We can use some tool like Brainstorm and canonical could reward the winner and publish the advertisement.
31
votes
closed
Solution #5: Google Chrome like advertising
Written by krisdouglas the 4 Apr 11 at 12:41.
Simple advertising which generates curiosity about Ubuntu, no point blasting them full of information.
24
votes
closed
Solution #6: Improve Ubuntu more
Written by konradmb the 8 Apr 11 at 17:25.
Improve it by doing [Month|Week|Day] of [bug fixing|fixing bugs that lasts for more than x years|implementing x|etc]. It is not ready for primetime. For example delta deb (like Fedora presto) "implementation" lasts from 2008.
15
votes
closed
Solution #7: Improve Vendor Relations and Competiveness, Close Vendor Lock in.
Written by bigthinker the 14 Apr 11 at 05:12.
First we must evaluate the claimed issue

"Counter Microsoft's Marketing Campaigns"

The original poster didn't address why they want to counter the marketing campaigns so we must assume they are wanting to increase the user base of ubuntu linux.

I would like to see some marketing and advertisements regarding ubuntu and linux in general. But to truly compete we should be working for strong relationships with business's that can push linux to the top. This is were M$ beats us, and is why we struggle to obtain the mass user base you and the other corporate interests desire.

Where should we start. There are two pathways to success here.

1.Students. Currently the majority of students use laptops, but their class's require M$ based software, most of the cd's included in the textbooks require M$, and there is very little knowledge of linux from the faculty. So we need to focus not really on the students, but the material that is being taught and the text books that include the cd's of proprietary software requiring M$.

2.Manufacturer's. We need some large pc manufacturers to include dual boot options by default, and to sell ubuntu based pcs. We also need computer part manufacturers to include information on their packaging related to linux. Currently this is very rare even though the list of compatible equipment is huge. It would also be nice to have just a hand full of major retailers carry Ubuntu install cd's. Walmart and bestbuy would do the trick.
1
votes
closed
Solution #8: Advertise each new release as completely new.
Written by danielerbe the 18 Apr 11 at 15:39.
Advertise each new release as completely new. even if just for the shock value of it being (to a lot of people) a completely new OS, it may only work once because after that it becomes reasonably well known people will know its not new...but now is a good time while unity in comparison to gnome 2, windows and OS X it is a very new idea in OS UI design

See the 21 comments or propose a solution >>

2 3 Next >>