Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 13716 ideas, 65290 comments, 1273844 votes

Contributor blueglow




up
320
down
Prioritise developers for 9.04   forum
Written by Auzy the 23 Sep 08 at 12:41. Category: Programming. Related to: Nothing/Others. In development
Canonical currently has a big problem. It needs developers. Its a vicious cycle, developers are needed to improve development, yet to increase the number of developers, we need better development programs.

The sad reality is that whilst Canonical has a wealth of development tools available, they are barely officially supported, out of date, or have no easy way of using them (like systemtap).

We need Canonical to step up and make the development environment for 9.04 a priority, so that first time linux developers, and long time developers have a powerful environment, that is officially supported by Canonical. By improving the development environment to be easy to setup, and more updated, developers are more likely to jump on board. In fact, whilst many developers consider coding on OSX to be a privilage, I have never heard the same said of Ubuntu.

Current areas we are severely lacking include:
- Eclipse is out of date in the repos and has been for ages.. Why?
- Sun and Apple have Dtrace officially supported, with a GUI frontend that really makes things easy. We don't have any support for systemtap nor have we got any comparable profiling gui.
- Windows and OSX has a fully supported out of the box development environment with the most popular languages in 2 clicks. With ubuntu, we have to manually work out which gui's we want, which tools, etc
- Debugging? Ha.. its actually quicker to port the code to OSX and use OSX's development tools in some cases then debug currently, because it supports step-backs and such.
- QT can compete against Cocoa. GTK even with Glade is a joke still. I'm not asking you to fix this, but if you want to encourage GTK development, at least have glade/eclipse integration in a developers metapackage
- Developers centre. Ubuntu has none, so developers aren't given a simple list of changes that might affect them next release, such as the change from Alsa as backend, to Pulse, so we can prepare in time. We don't even have a centralised way of really working together with other ubuntu developers.

Some may say developers can help themselves, but first impressions count. If it takes 3000 clicks to get your development environment to the standard provided by Apple in 5, whilst requiring you to also search for equivilent tools (such as dtrace which are considered standard for many OS's now) by yourself, you certainly wont prioritise the OS. By rewarding developers, with a better development environment, the end result will be a higher quality linux environment.

[....]

Developer comments
This has already been discussed somewhat at:

https://lists.ubuntu.com/archives/ubuntu-devel/2008-August/025984.html

As for a particular IDE, I would point at David Futcher's mail, where he writes:
"I think it would probably be a good idea to not include an IDE in these seeds. There are enough IDE flamewars throughout the community when people are just installing the packages themselves. Including an IDE will make 30%
of users happy, but annoy the other 70%. (I can just see the bugs: "Please change default IDE to Geany, Please change default IDE to Eclipse etc.")"

See the 43 comments (latest comment the 7 Oct 08 at 00:30) >>

up
2828
down
Enhance mobile devices sync  
please merge 0.22 from debian unstable (#81831)

In : opensync (ubuntu)
Status : Fix Released
Importance : Wishlist
Assignee : Debian Opensync Team
43 comments, 28 subscribers and 0 duplicates
bug
Ubuntu

In :  
Priority : Undefined
Definition : New (Needs guidance)
Implementation : Unknown
Assignee :
spec
forum
Written by jherran the 28 Feb 08 at 15:01. Category: Hardware support. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
There are lot of people having troubles syncing their devices (pda, smartphones, etc.) with ubuntu. At this poing there is only one solution available, multisync, and works for only a few devices, and it's very limited on their functions.

And I think, this is a very important point for lots of people.

**Suggestions from duplicate idea 397 work on that idea :

1) Clean up the Opensync and SyncML plugin packages to work properly with Evolution by default.

2) Set up an official Ubuntu SyncML server for Ubuntu users.

3) Possibly clean up open source SyncML clients for the different mobile platforms.

Developer comments
The current status of mobile devices synchronization in Linux is generally is quite shaky. It *can* work but it's a lot of work usually. There are a few efforts around but there's no single project that works in the majority of the situations.

This is also caused by manufacturers not using a single synchronization protocol. The most promising project now is OpenSync[1] which supports basically SyncML 1.1 and the Nokia variation and it works with several degrees of success between phones and desktops but the project itself is in a constant alpha state with a lot of issues, the GUI is simplistic and there are no integrated resources to sync with online contacts/calendars
like Google's. This can be overcome by preparing Evolution and/or Thunderbird to do it.

In short, despite the infrastructure is mostly there, we need work to make it a seamless experience for the user.
Bear in mind that this is a huge effort. Synchronization looks simple but there's a lot of factors and situations that need to be addressed like how to synchronize devices with different capabilities and how to keep 3 way synchronizations (desktop, online and mobile).

See the 67 comments (latest comment the 6 Oct 08 at 15:13) >>

up
6147
down
Fix Suspend and Hibernate  
Nvidia binary driver requires Option "NvAGP"
"1" for reliable suspend/resume (#34043)


In : acpi-support (ubuntu)
Status : In Progress
Importance : Medium
Assignee :
64 comments, 29 subscribers and 4 duplicates
bug
forum
Written by tighem the 28 Feb 08 at 17:22. Category: System. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
Suspend and hibernate still seems to be a big issue based on forum posts. Really focus on fixing it, even with proprietary drivers.

See the 253 comments (latest comment the 6 Oct 08 at 14:17) >>

up
5430
down
Power Management  
Ubuntu

In :  
Priority : Low
Definition : Pending Approval (Needs guidance)
Implementation : Slow progress
Assignee : Amit Kucheria
spec
Written by jsmidt the 28 Feb 08 at 16:49. Category: Others. Related to: Nothing/Others. In development
Ubuntu needs to go green. Powertop, Lesswatts and other tools have finally hit the Linux scene to pave the way for better power management. It needs to be said, "if you want your battery to last longest, or have your energy bill be the lowest, you better use Ubuntu Linux."

See the 73 comments (latest comment the 2 Oct 08 at 01:07) >>

up
4231
down
Professional-looking bootloader  
Ubuntu grub should be deluxe and animated like
OpenSUSE grub (#3339)


In : grub (ubuntu)
Status : New
Importance : Wishlist
Assignee : Chuck Short
24 comments, 19 subscribers and 4 duplicates
bug
Ubuntu

In :  
Priority : Undefined
Definition : New (Needs guidance)
Implementation : Unknown
Assignee :

Mentorship is available if you want to fix this bug.
spec
forum
Written by Murrquan the 28 Feb 08 at 14:42. Category: Look and Feel. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
Ubuntu's bootloader is a stark black and white screen, filled with confusing options. It gives newbies a moment of indecision, as they try to figure out if they are supposed to choose something, and wonder why there are three or four Ubuntus listed. Then the timer finishes counting down (starting from 10), and the newb begins to feel like he's getting in over his head as his PC boots into Ubuntu.

Too much information up front, stark text-only display, painfully long countdown timer. What would be the alternative? Well, when a Fedora PC is booted up, the first thing the user sees is a graphical splash screen, and "Booting into Fedora (kernel version) in 4 seconds ... " The user can press a key to interrupt and select from kernel versions or alternative operating systems, or just let it boot into Fedora.

Can't we create our own attractive bootloader? Or, failing that, copy-and-paste Fedora's?

See the 101 comments (latest comment the 28 Sep 08 at 19:16) >>

up
1190
down
Delta (patch based) updates  
Binary patch updating (#21837)

In : apt (ubuntu)
Status : Triaged
Importance : Wishlist
Assignee : Michael Vogt
5 comments, 8 subscribers and 2 duplicates
bug
Ubuntu

In :  
Priority : Undefined
Definition : New (Needs guidance)
Implementation : Unknown
Assignee :
spec
forum
Written by ravirdv the 28 Feb 08 at 14:31. Category: System. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
Summary:
Ability to download only changed bits of files and use much less bandwidth.
Scope and Use Cases:
Ann has slow internet connection. She sees that there are 150MB of updates and decides not to update at all leaving her with vulnerable and buggy system.
Implementation Plan:
Adopt it from Debian?

Previously discussed here, but still not implemented: http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=409916

See the 34 comments (latest comment the 13 Sep 08 at 12:19) >>

up
3929
down
Start taking advantage of Upstart  
Ubuntu

In :  
Priority : Medium
Definition : Approved (Needs guidance)
Implementation : Deferred
Assignee : Scott James Remnant
spec
Written by Ubuwu the 28 Feb 08 at 15:12. Category: System. Related to: Nothing/Others. In development
Replace initscripts with upstart events. Our boot sequence is currently slow, full of race conditions and poor interactions, especially with competition between the series of tasks run by sysv-rc, udev and sometimes just with the kernel. We developed upstart so that we could have a truly event driven boot sequence that would be fast, reliable and flexible; we should take advantage of it.

Developer comments
The primary reason that we're not taking full advantage of Upstart yet is that it still requires some development to have sufficient features to actually be better than sysvinit. You can follow Upstart development at its homepage.

See the 35 comments (latest comment the 12 Sep 08 at 19:48) >>

up
133
down
Avoid useless reboots with driver installs   forum
Written by markg85 the 11 Jul 08 at 18:08. Category: Hardware support. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
Hey,

Why do i need to restart my pc to get the nvidia driver working?

insmod nvidia and a X restart should be enough right!

So with that knowledge again: Why do i need a restart?
It's not modifying the base kernel which is about the only thing that requires a restart on linux and you can only get it that far if you install a new kernel or compile a new one.

My suggestion:
Kick out the restart demand and just restart X.

Edit//
If you vote this idea down tell me why because i can't think of a reason where a reboot would be better then my suggestion.

See the 16 comments (latest comment the 16 Aug 08 at 00:16) >>

implemented
Done!
(376)
Apply all ideas to improve X startup time  
Integrate Fedora's One Second X fixes (#207246)

In : xorg (ubuntu)
Status : Fix Released
Importance : Wishlist
Assignee :
5 comments, 3 subscribers and 0 duplicates
bug
Written by romu the 14 May 08 at 11:48. Category: Graphics. Related to: Nothing/Others. Implemented
I don't really know if this has already been implemented on Ubuntu, but applying Fedora ideas to boost X startup would be appreciated.

http://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Features/OneSecondX

Developer comments
Ubuntu receives these fixes as they are applied upstream. If for some reason you see a patch upstream that hasn't been applied feel free to file a bug on Launchpad.

See the 21 comments (latest comment the 5 Aug 08 at 22:55) >>

up
1241
down
Quicker, more efficient updates  
Written by bryhoyt the 10 Jul 08 at 20:27. Category: System. Related to: Update manager. New
There should be a more efficient format for apt-get (or the update manager) to download updates. Firstly, it should only need to download the files that have changed in a package (not the whole package), and secondly, it should download a DIFF of those files.

My latest update contains a 34.2 WHOPPING MB update to the linux restricted modules. Here's the changelog:

* Fix broadcom Makefile to get correct objects from split-module.

I'm downloading 34.2Mb just to get a *Makefile update*??? I don't even use any broadcom stuff. Even if I did, I probably wouldn't care enough about a Makefile to make it worthwhile downloading 34.2Mb!

See the 11 comments (latest comment the 16 Jul 08 at 13:46) >>

up
63
down
Show Signal strength for GSM connections  
Written by timnwells the 24 Sep 08 at 01:23. Category: Internet & Networking. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
Show the gsm signal strength in the network manager gsm icon, similar to the wifi signal strength when connected to a gsm network.

No comment yet. Add a comment >>