Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstorm
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 12252 ideas, 57766 comments, 1176667 votes

Contributor Ralf.Nieuwenhuijsen




implemented
Done!
(-137)
Yahoo Messenger and Gtalk  
Written by tshrinivasan the 29 Feb 08 at 09:30. Category: Internet & Networking. Related to: Nothing/Others. Implemented
There is not Yahoo messenger and Gtalk in linux. So I can not use linux in our browsing center.

It would be better if they both available for linux. I heard some projects are going.

But, we need them as soon as possible.

See the 17 comments (latest comment the 28 Aug 08 at 19:06) >>

up
227
down
Put creative commons education books in a repository  
Written by matthekc the 17 Mar 08 at 09:57. Category: Education. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
It would be nice to have a one stop place to look for the many available education books available. I think lack of awareness that free books exist is slowing their advance and it would nice for Ubuntu too.

See the 11 comments (latest comment the 28 Aug 08 at 19:04) >>

up
317
down
Use packagekit to improve standardization  
Ubuntu

In :  
Priority : Low
Definition : Approved
Implementation : Not started
Assignee : Sebastian Heinlein
spec
Written by rainforest12 the 28 Feb 08 at 16:16. Category: System. Related to: Nothing/Others. In development
Hi guys!
packagekit gets more and more attraction, i don't think that i have to explain it here, someone who knows this page knows also packagekit and its possibilities i.e. share package discribtions & news, openoffice.org can use it for the installation from additional packages/art; automatic printer driver download from lsb-site and so on...

more here:
http://packagekit.org/
and a really hot presentation from fosdem08:
http://people.freedesktop.org/~hughsient/public/introduction-to-packagekit.pdf


Developer comments
The use of PackageKit for Ubuntu is targeted for the Intrepid Ibex! See the attached blueprint for more informations.

See the 26 comments (latest comment the 28 Aug 08 at 19:02) >>

up
1263
down
Make the System default to Metric Units  
Written by ll the 5 Mar 08 at 15:06. Category: Others. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
Most of the planet uses the Metric System. So why does the system default to imperial units? Make A4 the default paper size for printing, only two countries don't use it. Most people don't know what inches are so cm or mm should be the default.

See the 51 comments (latest comment the 27 Aug 08 at 17:35) >>

up
2694
down
Improve file/folder sharing experience (Samba)  
[shares-admin] Shared folders requires a login (#14774)

In : gnome-system-tools (ubuntu)
Status : Fix Released
Importance : High
Assignee :
31 comments, 17 subscribers and 8 duplicates
bug
Written by bartong the 29 Feb 08 at 01:35. Category: Internet & Networking. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
Currently it is very difficult to setup and control access to shared folders without editing conf files and reading detailed instructions on all the variables. I propose that sharing (specifically Samba) be given a well worked GUI and some real TLC to bring it up to standard with the experience on Windows or OS X.

For example, by default a share should be accessible as Read Only by anyone on the network without a username or password (guest access). While guest access should be turned on by default, it should also be easy to turn it off, and if desired to give guests read/write access to the folder.

You should also be able to specify local users who will have read/write access, and these local users should sync with smb users invisibly (ie: the user doesn't need to know that there are two password databases being used).

I propose the Properties window for a folder should contain a Sharing tab with all the options available to choose. I also propose a Shared Folders option in the Preferences menu should list the currently shared folders along with their settings, and provide a button to take you into the dialogue where you can set the options.

See the 34 comments (latest comment the 26 Aug 08 at 15:39) >>

up
882
down
work on printer drivers  
Ubuntu

In :  
Priority : Medium
Definition : Approved
Implementation : Good progress
Assignee : Till Kamppeter
spec
Written by grashdur the 28 Feb 08 at 20:15. Category: Hardware support. Related to: Nothing/Others. In development
My printer, a Laserjet 1200, is pretty common and is supported by Ubuntu automatically. But I rarely print from it because it stretches my print output, vertically. For example, I have a table in OpenOffice Calc, as a to-do list organized by both importance and urgency, set up to print exactly in a certain way from OpenOffice on Windows XP. But when I open the same document on my Ubuntu computer, it prints stretched out more vertically, so that it doesn't all fit on one sheet. This is printing to the same exact printer. This seems to be the same with other programs.

Developer comments
I'll take this idea as a general request for better support on printer drivers.
Please look at this upcoming feature:
https://blueprints.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+spec/printerdriverautodownload
With this system, printer drivers would be downloaded from internet. The big advantage is that we would be able to support printers launched after our release, and provide fixes for current printer drivers.

See the 21 comments (latest comment the 26 Aug 08 at 00:00) >>

up
-31
down
SwitchOS  
Written by tecwhizz the 21 Mar 08 at 10:17. Category: Others. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
Just an Idea. Maybe you could develop a program called SwitchOS which allows users to switch between different OS's seamlessly. For example, you could have Fedora, Ubuntu and Standard Linux on a PC. When you boot into Ubuntu (Which would share the software between the OS's) or any of the other ones there will be, on the programs menu under 'Utilities', SwitchOS. When you boot the software would, in the background, start all of the OS's so you can switch! Basically like your Desktop Switching but with OS's!

A Reply to Eldmannen's comment: Standard Linux is basically Red Hat and stuff like that! It is not lets say Fedora or Debian!

See the 6 comments (latest comment the 25 Aug 08 at 17:54) >>

up
131
down
Finder-like column view in Nautilus  
Written by claudiodsf the 13 Mar 08 at 15:24. Category: System. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
In Mac OSX Finder, this view displays the hierarchy of the file system in a series of left-to-right panes: http://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Mac_OS_X_Tiger/Using_the_Finder#Column_View

I find it terribly useful when you have a deep structured directory hierarchy, especially when you want to move a file several levels up.

See the 13 comments (latest comment the 25 Aug 08 at 06:33) >>

closed
Closed
(371)
Kernel 2.6.25 for Hardy  
Written by flounder the 24 Mar 08 at 15:26. Category: System. Related to: Nothing/Others. Won't implement
1. There are deeply invasive performance/scalability/latency fixes for CFS regressions (vs. 2.6.24) in the 2.6.25 tree. These fixes are too invasive to be ported to the 2.6.24 kernel without significant risk.

2. Many of the driver updates/new drivers in the kernel-ubuntu package are merged into upstream as of 2.6.25. (This is always true, but the smaller the delta against upstream the better on release day).

3. Fedora 9 is based on 2.6.25 which means that key RH kernel developers are aggressively working to get the feature and performance/scalability regressions vs. 2.6.18 & 22 fixed.

4. The kgdb patch will probably be merged at the start of the 2.6.26 cycle which means the delta vs. 2.6.25 kernel should be pretty manageable. This would be really valuable from an LTS ongoing perspective.

5. The RT patch will be better maintained (and smaller) against 2.6.25. (see #3)

6. Better virtualization and SELinux support (see #3).

Given the life-cycle of an LTS release (especially this one which will finally have a meaningful chance to enter the data center) these considerations are especially important.

Obviously 2.6.25 would have to be in addition to 2.6.24 for the Hardy 8.04 LTS release time-frame, but it does allow the aforementioned benefits to be propagated forward.

See the 34 comments (latest comment the 25 Aug 08 at 06:25) >>

up
3132
down
Ubuntu should recognize hardware changes  
Written by nxvl the 28 Feb 08 at 19:11. Category: System. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
When i change some hardware pieces i need to configure them manually, ubuntu should recognize there has been a hardware change and configure it.

See the 29 comments (latest comment the 24 Aug 08 at 11:35) >>

up
185
down
Anti-Duplicate system needs improvement  
Written by Auzy the 31 Mar 08 at 11:08. Category: Brainstorm. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
6 out of 10 ideas on the latest ideas yesterday I noticed were duplicates.

Its obvious the anti-duplicates system is not working AT ALL!!! Obviously it is incorrectly using generic terms like "the" or "a" as keywords.

Unless this is somehow fixed better, moderating ideas on brainstorm will become impossible . Because if almost every idea is a dupe, things become painful

The anti-duplicates system found these duplicates for this idea:
* Make ubuntu more responsive
* Avoid Fsck Forced Irritation
* Disk Manager by default
* LiveUSB
* Push for partnerships with other hardware vendors
* Codec Manager
* Offer to create a separate /home partition and use existing ones
* Professional-looking bootloader
* Speed Up Ubuntu-Gnome boot time
* Clean up Preferences and Administration.

Not even close..

See the 4 comments (latest comment the 22 Aug 08 at 22:34) >>

up
190
down
Make people aware brainstorm isn't for bug reporting  
Written by YSH the 15 Mar 08 at 16:06. Category: Brainstorm. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
Many ideas on brainstorm are just bugs, and brainstorm is not for bugs, its for ideas. If you got a bug, go to launchpad. Obviously not everyone new to ubuntu knows that, so they post it here as an idea. There should be some warning, most likely when you're submitting a new idea, that that's the way it is.

See the 13 comments (latest comment the 22 Aug 08 at 22:31) >>

up
1355
down
Integrate prefetch into Ubuntu  
Ubuntu

In :  
Priority : Medium
Definition : Pending Approval (Needs guidance)
Implementation : Deferred
Assignee : Scott James Remnant
spec
Written by Ubuwu the 28 Feb 08 at 15:04. Category: System. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
In todays computer systems the main bottleneck is not CPU but disk access which is several orders of magnitude slower than CPU and memory. In such circumstances the way to improve application performance is to prefetch data it needs from disk before it even requests it and it is the point of prefetching techniques. This speeds up boot and decreases the time needed to start programs. This replaces and it is faster than the currently used readahead.

See the 27 comments (latest comment the 22 Aug 08 at 05:59) >>

up
227
down
Remove Ebay from default search engines list in firefox  
Written by Auzy the 22 Mar 08 at 01:06. Category: Internet & Networking. Related to: Firefox. New
Based on idea 5321, by Eldmannen (about removing yahoo).

We should remove ebay from the default installed searches, because:
- It reduces competition with other auction sites.
- Recently there was a uproar about changes in ebay which make in some case make it unfair. I agree!
- Ebay VERY heavily pushes Paypal, which is acknowledged by many to be very dodgy. A lot of people know someone who has been screwed by ebay. And here in aus, I had to upgrade my account because they had a bug which prevented me accessing my money (which is very unprofessional). The freenet Project owner was also screwed by ebay (and it demonstrated they don't research at all claims made against customers), and another friend of mine was charged 2x the amount he was supposed to be receiving because someone used a stolen credit card against him (so seems they profit from illegal credit cards).
- If ebay was a bank, they would have a 24/7 riot outside their building by customers who were screwed.
- Ebay doesn't exactly listen to feedback. If are a typical large company, where you have no way of providing feedback (if you scream at them over the phone, maybe they will let you speak to a manager). But they clearly dont care much (no forums).

Its to our advantage to promote competition within the auction sites. More competition means lower costs for us, and better payment methods. We should try to encourage the development of a world wide auction site that is more consumer/seller friendly, that actually promotes active feedback and improvement.

There is nothing stopping a patch being applied to the firefox code to prevent ebay being a default search engine (and it shouldn't be hard to do).

See the 28 comments (latest comment the 21 Aug 08 at 00:24) >>

up
-28
down
Visual Studio clone  
Written by taron the 13 Mar 08 at 14:51. Category: Programming. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
Maybe you know Microsoft's Visual Studio, a very nice program especially for programmer beginners.

We should clone this program (or make a similiar) to write Linux GTK/Qt apps with it.

I know this is a big work, but it's worth it I think.

See the 8 comments (latest comment the 16 Aug 08 at 02:50) >>

up
226
down
Ubuntu shouldn't be like Windows or OSX!  
Written by k.y the 1 Mar 08 at 20:39. Category: System. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
Many ideas posted here suggest that Ubuntu should look and|or feel like WindowsXP|Vista|OSX arguing that if so more Windows|OSX users would switch to Ubuntu. Often the suggested methods to achieve this are simplifying and|or even modifying Ubuntu in such a way that functionality, customization or adaptation get removed or limited. I don't think that this is the direction the Ubuntu development should follow. Because:

1. Creating a fool-proof system too often results in creating a systems for fools only. I personally think that Vista is the best example for this. By trying to make Vista more secure they made Vista more annoying. Starting to protect the system and the user's files from the user himself brought the system one step closer to foolproofness but also tends to be most irritating to the rest of us. Also by making everything as easy as possible alternatives, customization possibilities and adaptation are often eradicated.
2. By imitating Windows you most likely will attract Windows users. They will work with Ubuntu for a while then change back to Windows because you can't work on Ubuntu like on Windows and it also doesn't behave like Windows.

Windows and OSX might have some nice|useful features. And most of them are implemented into Gnome|KDE by now. So I think that we should stop with copying but start creating. Of course useful features should still be made available to Linux but the creation of new features should be more important. And by implementing new features, copied or created, functionality, customization and adaptation should never be limited. Also if it means that that particular feature might not be that "easy" to handle. e.g. providing a simpler GUI for apt is okay but replacing the package manager with a setup.exe like system would limit functionality.

Ubuntu should attract users with innovation, stability and possibility and not by providing "just an alternative". Constantly coping from Windows|OSX also demonstrates a certain inferiority. And Linux|Ubuntu are no more inferior. We slowly but surely caught up by now, so now we should start to overtake.

I don't want Ubuntu to be like Windows or OSX!
I want Windows and OSX to be like Ubuntu!

[....]

See the 33 comments (latest comment the 15 Aug 08 at 17:16) >>

up
31
down
Game Coding Optimisation for GCC  
Written by Auzy the 13 Apr 08 at 13:17. Category: Gaming. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
The needs for Application coders and game coders are completely different. For applications, its more about stability, extendable maintainable code that just needs to run well enough, as in most cases, waiting is acceptable. For game coding however, it HAS to run as well as possible in realtime, or nobody will be able to run it.

One thing I learnt while learning game programming, is that there are dozens of tricks windows programmers use to improve the speed of their code (such as pragma's and the likes). However, these books are all written for windows.

A team should be started which maintains an up to date development series on tricks that linux developers can use to speed up their code (such as using template enums to unroll code). It doesn't need to get into generic algorithms like octrees, just simple tricks to get the most out of the compiler (like macros which you can use that may help at a large expense of ram).

Preferably, it should be maintained in a text that is included with the gcc documentation, and is written by someone with good knowledge of GCC, and good experience with game coding. This way, we can increase the quality and speed of our games.

See the 5 comments (latest comment the 15 Aug 08 at 17:09) >>

up
-54
down
Partenrship with Yahoo...?  
Written by bogdan_5844 the 29 Mar 08 at 12:55. Category: Internet & Networking. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
I don't know if this is possible/worth it,but at least here in Romania,Yahoo Messenger is being used by absolutely everyone.It's a big pain in the *** to use Pidgin.Sure,it can send (and recieve!)files now,but webcam,photo share and other features are missing.GYachI looks promising,but it's interface scares the user out.

Can't Canonical make a partnership with Yahoo to at least get part of the code,in order to make a compatible Yahoo messenger client for Linux/Unix?

I don't really care if the final product(if it will exist) will be GPL'ed or not,I just want to use it(as I use Skype,but unfortunately that's not so popular,only 3 contacts in my list)

Sorry for my preety crappy english

See the 11 comments (latest comment the 15 Aug 08 at 16:49) >>

up
34
down
placement of yes/no buttons in gnome  
Written by KhaaL the 25 Mar 08 at 10:25. Category: Look and Feel. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
When you're represented with a yes / no / cancel buttons in KDE, it's presented as:

Yes, no, cancel.

In windows these buttons are displayed in the same order as KDE.

In gnome, the placement is no, cancel, yes.

Now this is *quite* confusing for those who're used to diffrent placement, not to mention the times they'll press the wrong buttons by old habit. I suggest to offer a choice to the users of which placement they'd rather have.

See the 16 comments (latest comment the 14 Aug 08 at 11:59) >>

up
570
down
install 7zip with default  
Written by vinutux the 6 Mar 08 at 11:43. Category: Others. Related to: Nothing/Others. New
7-Zip is open source software. Source code is under the GNU LGPL license. it is nice to install it default.

1. Install 7zip with other copression methodes like zip, tar, gzip

2. It automatically integrated with file-roller. So no need any other gui program or user don't want to know complex comand lines for compressing their data in 7zip.

See the 19 comments (latest comment the 13 Aug 08 at 12:46) >>

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Next >>