Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 21986 ideas, 135057 comments, 2615221 votes
Idea sandbox Idea sandbox
Popular ideas Popular ideas
Ideas in development Ideas in development
Implemented ideas Implemented ideas

Contributor Penguin Guy

Fix Suspend and Hibernate   forum
Written by tighem the 28 Feb 08 at 17:22. Global category: System. Not an idea
Suspend and hibernate still seems to be a big issue based on forum posts.

Developer comments
“Fix suspend and hibernate” is not an idea; it is not something that a developer could ever mark as “Implemented”. Suspend and hibernate work for many machines, and making them work for more machines is a matter of fixing individual bugs, not of implementing an idea.

This page has (as shown by the “Mix of improvements” suggestion, and the highly varied “duplicate” ideas) become a vortex for many unrelated ideas. Some of these ideas are good, and some are not so good. They should be separated out and voted on individually.

—mpt
7476
votes
closed
Solution #1: With proprietary drivers
Written by tighem the 28 Feb 08 at 17:22.
Really focus on fixing it, even with proprietary drivers.
78
votes
closed
Solution #3: Mix of improvements + Solution #1 (letting the user choose)
Written by franco.valoppi the 26 Aug 09 at 03:47.
I think that even using proprietary driver may make it more compatible, always let the user to choose.

On the other hand I have some other ideas to improve performance (probably already implemented):
- Memory trim and garbage collection, before hitbernating.
- Memory Defrag.
- Exclude System Prefetched data from hibernate files. I mean memory used with programs already closed but still in memory in the case you want to open them again.
-31
votes
closed
Solution #4: Add an idle option
Written by qwerty800 the 19 Sep 09 at 14:54.
As a temporary solution, we should add an "idle" option to ubuntu.

Since suspend and hibernate both invole creating a system image and storing it in the ram/in the swap, until we fix this, we need to find another alternative to this.

The only alternative remaining is to leave your computer open during all the night!

Well, my idea is to add an "Idle" option, that would:
-Suspend most of the programs
-Lower the CPU clocking (If possible)
-Lower the fan speed (If possible, trying to emit the less noise possible)
-Lower the HDD speed (If possible)
-Lock the screen

That way, we could still avoid energy wasting, while waiting for a working sleep mode.
136
votes
closed
Solution #5: we should have a progress hibernating bar in lucid lynx
Written by slsolaris the 5 Nov 09 at 22:45.
a progress bar is more intuitive than a black screen, nothing else to add
99
votes
closed
Solution #6: don't ask for password after wake up (optionally)
Written by yzarc the 9 Nov 09 at 20:33.
don't ask for password after wake up (optionally).
I'd like to open the lit and have my system ready to use.
-32
votes
closed
Solution #7: Create solid aternative for laptops where suspend/hibernate doens't work.
Written by FeraTech the 21 Mar 10 at 04:47.
For those laptops where suspend and hibernate do not work Ubuntu should automatically default to an alternative.

A good solution would be to simply have the previous state stored onto the hard drive including all running applications. The laptop would boot normally and all of the previous state would just be stored and controlled by the operating system.
30
votes
closed
Solution #8: Don't allow suspend/sleep on Laptops where it doesn't work!
Written by DrWig the 23 Apr 10 at 08:48.
If hibernate/suspend doesn't work, have Ubuntu disable the option, so it doesn't try until a new version/potential fix is released.
-27
votes
closed
Solution #9: Disable suspend/hibernate by default
Written by decumanus the 3 Aug 10 at 19:02.
This is a solution of despair. Function that fails on half of all computers should not be enabled by default. Do not pretend we are able to do what we cannot.
I lost many minutes of work just by accidental pressing sleep button. Sorry.
10
votes
closed
Solution #10: investigate why suspend works in other distros and not ubuntu
Written by DonnyDonNothin the 22 Nov 10 at 15:36.
investigate why suspend works in other distros and not ubuntu. 's2ram -f' in another distro works flawlessly, but what ever ubuntu uses causes my touchpad to freeze. ask the community to contribute to a list of what hardware and applications work in suspend. much like the voting system here. for example:
XXX touchpads freezing after suspend +6 votes
window contents lost on ati drivers +X votes
0
votes
closed
Solution #12: Hibernate light
Written by xer0 the 23 Mar 11 at 17:56.
Boot as normal and just restore the state of the X desktop.
Saving the state is already supported in X but not present as an option in the Ubuntu menus (at least i cant find it).

This would provide an alternative for people who has hardware related problems with hibernate.

See the 280 comments or propose a solution >>

Disk usage for all mounted disks should be easily findable  
Written by kazade the 5 May 09 at 10:24. Related project: Nautilus. New
One of the things that I liked from playing with Vista was the way that I could see the disk space available for all disks just going to My Computer.

The current equivalent in Jaunty, Nautilus' "Computer" only shows the filesystem and pluggable media. It doesn't (for example) show my mounted /home partition. It would be nice to easily see the disk space available for all mounted disks at a glance.

1061
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Show all mount points, and free space in "Computer"
Written by kazade the 5 May 09 at 10:24.
What I propose is that "Computer" should show all mounted disks and their mount paths and also show a small indicator which displays the used/free space for that disk.

Here is a (crappy..) image explaining what I mean:


217
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Write a plugin for Nautilus
Written by aadityabhatia the 5 May 09 at 20:52.
baobab, also known as "Disk Usage Analyzer", is an excellent tool for this purpose.

Write a plug-in to add baobab's features to Gnome's default file manager Nautilus. This plugin could be optionally enabled.

PS: Disk Usage Analyzer is located in Gnome under Applications > Accessories by default.
-187
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: #1, but with the icon itself as the indicator.
Written by egasimus the 11 May 09 at 16:33.
Free Image Hosting at www.ImageShack.us

Also included: red border for read-only drives such as a write-once CD.
50
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: In the sidebar
Written by chareos the 12 May 09 at 14:48.
I don't like #1 because it requires a click (to go to computer) and leave the place user was before.

I'd prefer a thin usage meter in the sidebar, on the volume icons:
- always visible
- easier to read than a recoloured icon
194
votes
up equal down
Solution #5: By hovering
Written by Cupido.87 the 12 May 09 at 16:43.
It should be like the preview for audio-files.
While hovering the icon it should show the used/free space like solution #1.
-48
votes
up equal down
Solution #6: Offer a system monitor launcher
Written by bryonak the 15 May 09 at 13:48.
Since we already have this in the System Monitor, why not offer a launcher icon for it in the "computer:/" folder, calling it "System Overview".
This way, one has additional easy access to CPU/RAM/network overviews as well.

Reimplementing this in via the folder icons might be duplication of effort here...
-25
votes
up equal down
Solution #8: show all mount points in computer, show disk usage when selecting folder
Written by lievenmoors the 27 May 09 at 15:09.
As it is now, you can see the free space available in the status bar when you are inside a folder. But when you select a folder, only the number of items in that folder is shown. It would be possible to show the amount of space used, and the free space left for a folder, whenever you select that folder. If you select multiple folders, you would get the total sum. When nothing is selected, you can still show the information for the folder you're in.

It would be nice to see all mount points in "Computer", and they could be treated as regular folders. You would see the disk usage information in the status bar whenever you select them. And when nothing is selected in "Computer", you would see the grand total of all mount points.
8
votes
up equal down
Solution #9: Integrate df with Ubuntu file explorer
Written by junk the 18 Jul 09 at 07:55.
Read values from the command df and show a summary of each mounted device together with a bar showing occupied space in Ubuntu file explorer (something like the Vista Computer view).

Just noticed, what I'm looking for is actually the File Systems tab in System Monitor integrated in Ubuntu file explorer for a simple and quick view.
1
votes
up equal down
Solution #10: A visual indicator for HDD/USB media/etc space usage.
Written by lifesf the 14 Jan 11 at 19:26.
Adding a visual, bar of some sort to let users quickly know the current space usage of the HDDs, USB keys, and letting know with text the exact usage information.

See the 23 comments or propose a solution >>

I would like to be notified when a large file operation (copy/move) is completed  
Written by martinbrook the 19 Mar 10 at 11:23. Related project: Gnome. New
I often perform moderately large copy/move operations which take more than a few minutes. I like to leave these running in the background and get on with some other work in the meantime, and return to the task I was dealing with once the file operation is complete.

I usually close (i.e. hide) the 'file operations' dialog so that it doesn't distract me while I'm working.

The problem is that I don't have an easy way to know when the copy/move is done. The only thing I can really do is keep checking the notification area to see if the 'file operations' icon has vanished.
763
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Provide a libnotify popup when a file operation is complete
Written by martinbrook the 19 Mar 10 at 11:23.
A simple message such as 'Moving 342 files from /home/martin to /media/disk completed successfully' would suffice.

Sample:

138
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Notify only if the operation's time is higher than a customized time.
Written by Ssdg the 20 Mar 10 at 12:56.
All in the title.
111
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Notify when user indicates lessened immediacy
Written by Dataphile the 21 Mar 10 at 18:36.
As the submitter noted, putting things in the background is the issue here, as their status updates aren't apparent. If the file operation window is focused, then it doesn't make sense to notify the user, so I believe Solution #1 is overkill.

Adding a new setting to customize the time interval (Solution #2) also seems like overkill from this perspective.

So, I'm wondering, why not just fire up the libnotify popup when the file transfer completes and the file operation window is not focused, as that indicates the user has focused on other priorities?
324
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: As #1, but user enables the feature via a checkbox
Written by martinbrook the 30 Mar 10 at 14:08.
As in the image below. The checkbox would be unchecked by default.


-62
votes
up equal down
Solution #5: As #4, but only notify when ALL file operations are complete
Written by martinbrook the 30 Mar 10 at 14:16.
Have a single checkbox at the bottom of the File Operations window saying "Notify me when all file operations are complete".
23
votes
up equal down
Solution #6: Create a Process Manager
Written by Penguin Guy the 31 Mar 10 at 19:00.
Create a daemon that will manage processes. Add support for not only copying files, but also things like downloading and installing files.


-10
votes
up equal down
Solution #7: expanding on #1 and #4
Written by Snow Keld the 5 Apr 10 at 05:27.
both solutions, #1, and #4, are great, but i often miss the libnotify bubbles.

i think that it should be set to always announce with libnotify, but also have the check box and raise/prioritize what window when its finished instead of closing it auto.

which means on a file transfer, if you do not click the box then when the transfer completes it will be sent to libnotify and the window will close (and the bubble will pop up for a moment)

when you click the check box and the transfer finishes the libnotify bubbly will still pop up for a moment, but the transfer window will stay open and be raised to the top saying your transfer is done, in this way you'll be notified for sure.
-21
votes
up equal down
Solution #8: Let the user decide when the popup should appear
Written by man0riaX the 6 Apr 10 at 16:20.
Create a simple and easy-to-use configuration dialogue to configure in what situations a popup should appear, e.g.:

Notification when
- single file operation done (yes/no)
- all file operations done (yes/no)
- file operation gave an error message (yes/no)
[you can extend this list on your wishes]
e.g.
- Firefox download complete (yes/no) [deactivate the built-in firefox notification then]

You can also extend this and disable the default-notifications, such as
- Rhythmbox notification (yes/no)
- Empathy notification (yes/no)

Also, to come back to that file-operation-notification, in that control panel you can decide what exactly a "large file operation" is; means you can tell the system that you want to see a notification if the file(s) is/are larger than 10GB (let the user decide about a value here), but not to show a notification if the file(s) is/are smaller, for example.
-42
votes
up equal down
Solution #9: Have a timer running on a panel that starts blinking once the job's done.
Written by SuNk8 the 6 Apr 10 at 19:44.
This solution's very similar to the alarm/timer applet on a panel.
Also we could have a warning sound for the same.
-25
votes
up equal down
Solution #10: make it windows7-like
Written by Goury the 14 Apr 10 at 08:05.
coz not only mac have good ui
mergin progressbar with button background is perfect idea
16
votes
up equal down
Solution #11: Make an AppIndicator for file transfers & downloads
Written by spocky the 28 Apr 10 at 19:05.
I think the current move of Ubuntu to use Indicators to interact to different typ of applications like MessagingMenu would perfectly fit to an appIndicator for FileTransfers and Downloads

See the 14 comments or propose a solution >>

Nautilus Standard Permissions Editor is Confusing  
Written by Penguin Guy the 29 Mar 10 at 21:02. Related project: Nautilus. Not an idea
The standard permissions editor is nautilus is confusing and non-standard (a checkbox grid editor being standard).

728
votes
closed
Solution #1: Use Nautilus Advanced Permissions Editor
Written by Penguin Guy the 29 Mar 10 at 21:02.
A checkbox grid editor is both easier to understand and more widely used. Enable Nautilus' advanced permissions editor by default.



117
votes
closed
Solution #2: Use "easy" words and complex ones between ()
Written by Ssdg the 30 Mar 10 at 09:46.
As you can see on #1 the interface uses words like: "set user ID"

It's a bit complex for low level users. We need them to get as quickly as possible what a checkbox means. For exemple:

Set user ID will become : "the program will have same rights as the owner has(set user ID)"
394
votes
closed
Solution #3: Add "Become root" button
Written by la_serpe the 31 Mar 10 at 09:29.
It's impossible to change some options in this menu, unless you are root. There is no way to become root through GUI. This should change.
134
votes
closed
Solution #4: 'set default rights' button
Written by m.lettner the 31 Mar 10 at 19:18.
Add a button which assigns the most useful and common rights to the selected item (recursively if it's a directory).
that would be rw-r--r-- for files and rwxr-xr-x for folders.

this would be very useful for example if you copy files from lesser advanced filesystems like the ones used in windows which don't have rights management (they are often set to wrong values like 777 then)

just one button - one click - which sets the default rights. so the user is safe and doesn't even have to know anything about rights management.
189
votes
closed
Solution #5: Add the actual owner/group names for clarity.
Written by Darwin Survivor the 31 Mar 10 at 22:21.
Instead of using
Owner: Read, etc
Group: Read, etc
Others: Read, etc

Why not list the actual owner/group of the file?
Owner (Joe): Read, etc
Group (users): Read, etc
Others: Read, etc.
-98
votes
closed
Solution #6: Like Solution #1, but Remove 'Special Flags'
Written by Penguin Guy the 1 Apr 10 at 16:31.
Use the checkbox-grid idea as in solution #1, but remove 'Set user ID', 'Set group ID', and 'Sticky'.
13
votes
closed
Solution #7: adding to solution #5
Written by tommynz1975 the 3 Apr 10 at 05:30.
I am not to sure what the poster ment.

But to be able to edit users in each group when one brings up the properties window shown in solution #1

Maybe having an unlock button on the properties dialog box, like with network settings would be good.

This could solve the other issue some have of, I am the only user but have no access to my usb drive, cant change properties.
145
votes
closed
Solution #8: S1++: Add visual hints for logical grouping
Written by lfaraone the 3 Apr 10 at 17:30.
Building off solution one, we should also add logical grouping, which will allow the user to follow associations between the preferences in the grid more easily.



40
votes
closed
Solution #9: S #1 + #3 + Advance Bottom
Written by braiam the 8 Apr 10 at 06:45.
As in the Solution # 3, we can´t change user right of a file/folder if we are not root, this should change with a Bottom that read "Become root" and reload the box, Solution # 1 are usefully to know current access permitions and with Become Root butoom change it. Set SID and text migth be in a advanced section.
13
votes
closed
Solution #10: A merge of #1, #3,4,5 and #6
Written by Tatsel the 12 Apr 10 at 06:53.
I agree, the default one confused me long time (and still does), so I am proposing the advanced view, the "Become Root" button, the "default permissions" button, for dual(or more)-booters, as example and the current Owner/Group.

About #6, I would rather put it under a button that open a small dialog (or anything similar) because:

1- This is more advanced features that new users should probably not mess with;

2- the permission dialog will be rather big even without those last options. We don't all have 32'', HD computer screens.

See the 10 comments or propose a solution >>

Tiresome Going Through The 'Open With...' Menu  
Written by Penguin Guy the 19 Aug 09 at 16:39. Related project: Nautilus. New
Sometimes I want to view a file, and sometimes I want to edit it. But to do one of these I have to go through the 'Open with Other Application...' menu, which wastes time.
278
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Add 'Edit with Program' Below 'Open with Program'
Written by Penguin Guy the 19 Aug 09 at 16:39.
Possible Uses:

Images
o 'Open' - 'Photo Viewer'
o 'Edit' - 'Gimp'

Sound Files
o 'Open' - 'Rhythmbox'
o 'Edit' - 'Audacity'

HTML
o 'Open' - 'Firefox'
o 'Edit' - 'Bluefish'

---------------

In the 'Properties' -> 'Open With' menu you should add options to disable the Open or Edit buttons for certain files (most people read text files through a text editor so there would be no need for the 'Open' option on them). It would of course, be possible to assign an editor to the open button, but that's up to the user.
-48
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Extend #1 to Include an 'Execute' Option
Written by Darwin Survivor the 20 Aug 09 at 17:56.
I find needing to chose between opening and executing a file *after* clicking it to be annoying. The context menu should have 3 options.
-Open/View
-Edit
-Execute

Of course, each option would only appear if the action were possible such as not having the execute option for a jpeg or any object without +x in the permissions.

Every file has 3 permission levels (rwx), why not have 3 ways of opening it via context-menu?
167
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Switch 'Open' and 'Edit' for More Descriptive Words
Written by Penguin Guy the 21 Aug 09 at 13:19.
Possible uses:

Images
o 'View' - 'Photo Viewer'
o 'Edit' - 'Gimp'

Sound Files
o 'Play' - 'Rhythmbox'
o 'Edit' - 'Audacity'

Scripts
o 'Execute' - 'Sh'
o 'Edit' - 'Vim'

Archives
o 'Extract' - 'Archive Manager'
o 'Browse' - 'Archive Mounter'

---------------

Simply switch 'Open' and 'Edit' for more descriptive words (such as the above) if needed. Although this has no practical effect, it will certainly add to the depth of the user experience. Inspired by michele74.
54
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: Configurable 'Open With' Options
Written by Wim the 24 Aug 09 at 15:06.
Why limit the user to predefined 'Open With' options? Allow the user to rename and add alternatives. It would probably be nice to have some reasonable defaults though (such as in idea #3). For example:

Default HTML
o 'Open' - 'Firefox'
o 'Edit' - 'Bluefish'

User-Configured HTML
o 'Open' - 'Epiphany'
o 'Edit' - 'Emacs'
o '2Text' - 'html2text'
-34
votes
up equal down
Solution #5: Extend #1 to no changes by default, and Allow to use Open/Edit for advanced user
Written by RomanIvanov the 24 Aug 09 at 19:12.
Iy is great idea to have few applications to use for one type of the file. But It should be triggered by Advanced settings items. No changes by default.
-14
votes
up equal down
Solution #9: Define Default App Based on Last Choice
Written by mrpitchfork the 7 Sep 09 at 22:55.
The default app for opening a file should change based on the last choice used to open the file from the context menu.

See the 7 comments or propose a solution >>

Verify Integrity after burning CD/DVD  
Written by unknown2 the 30 Apr 10 at 13:10. Related project: Gnome. Already implemented
CD/DVD is quite unreliable storage medium, user will want to ensure correctness of important data in the disk
272
votes
closed
Solution #1: Provide an option to "Verify Disc upon completion"
Written by unknown2 the 30 Apr 10 at 13:10.
Provide an option to "Verify Disc upon completion"

The program will automatically verify the content of the disk with the source iso after buring

Windows software "Nero Burning Rom" provide this option long long ago
39
votes
closed
Solution #2: Create checking mechanism
Written by Lachu the 1 May 10 at 15:14.
Add to Ubuntu CD's menu new entry called: check checksums(cd integrity). The checksums should been written at the medium. By this option, there should been possible to use this feature without dependency on burning program.
7
votes
closed
Solution #3: iso image checksum calculator
Written by dinar the 18 May 10 at 10:49.
iso image checksum calculator is needed, because it is hard to use md5sum command. this is needed to check cd taken from somebody that you do not trust so much, whether it is same as in ubuntu site, also can be used to check cd-rw, whether it has been modified.

See the 7 comments or propose a solution >>

E-mail notification in bugs.launchpad.net shows everyone's e-mail address.  
Written by Jarige the 30 Apr 10 at 11:37. Related project: launchpad.net. New
e-mail addresses are private information. If you've subscribed to a bug report in Launchpad, and someone replies to that bug, you'll get that person's e-mail address. Large bug reports with a lot of subscribers and replying persons might feed spambots.
222
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Do not show e-mail addresses
Written by Jarige the 30 Apr 10 at 11:37.
Instead, show the normal bug e-mail address as sender, which is unique to that bug report (445852@bugs.launchpad.net for instance). Those e-mail addresses already exist, the only thing that needs to be done is removing the private e-mail adresses from the notification mail.

See the 6 comments or propose a solution >>

Make gedit be able to open any files  
Written by Eldmannen the 23 May 08 at 18:50. Global category: Others. New
Make gedit (the primary text editor in Ubuntu) be able to open any type of file.

When I try to open a binary file or a .png file or something, it whines and says;
* "gedit has not been able to detect the character coding.
Please check that you are not trying to open a binary file."

Well, I would like to be able to open a binary file.
160
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #9010
Written by Eldmannen the 23 May 08 at 18:50.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #9010 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!
11
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Add the option to skip unreadable bytes.
Written by misiu_mp the 21 Aug 09 at 13:09.

In the error pop-up in gedit, add the option to skip unreadable bytes or replace them with a replacement character.
22
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Add Built-In Hex Editor
Written by Penguin Guy the 29 Aug 09 at 19:10.
Add a built in hex editor and when opening a non-text file let the user select if they want to open it as a text file or a hexadecimal file. Also have a radio list under View -> Format including 'Plain Text', 'Hexadecimal', and 'Binary'.
9
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: Display characters not part of the encoding
Written by arkmundi the 28 Jul 10 at 13:27.
Open the file anyway with a warning that it may not be a text file. Display all characters not part of the encoding set visibly with some special character.
-2
votes
up equal down
Solution #5: Use the power of gedit...
Written by flint the 27 Sep 10 at 11:38.
Write a filter to include in the "tools" section of gedit which would filter non-ascii text. Additionally, this filter would be available when invoked (e.g. "gedit --encoding=failsafe ), and the filter could be invoked to save an adulterated version of the binary - or not.
3
votes
up equal down
Solution #6: Make gedit more tolerant of encoding
Written by geoff07 the 30 Oct 10 at 20:43.
When I open a text file from Windows, gedit often blanks the screen and in a big red banner says it can't open the file.

Yet notepad/Wine in Ubuntu can open these files.

Therefore the files are perfectly open-able by a simple program. So it isn't a problem of unreadable bytes or binary data. So why not by gedit, which is supposed to be the premier editor in Ubuntu?

And please don't expect me as a user to know or want to know anything about character encoding, that is the job of the developers.
5
votes
up equal down
Solution #7: Display anyway, providing options.
Written by orbatos the 13 Feb 11 at 02:57.
gedit should simply display available ASCII characters and perhaps (optionally?) detect newlines and spaces, while blocking out unprintable characters using their control or hex codes like other technical editors (SciTE, VIM).

In addition, if any banner is to be displayed, the document should be visible and the banner should have options like "Ignore" and "Read As:", followed by the encoding menu.

In the event that a hex editor plugin is developed, an encoding option of "Read as Hex" could be added to the encoding menu.

See the 25 comments or propose a solution >>

Allow easy download of archive file formats.  
Written by arckeda the 20 Dec 08 at 22:55. Related project: Archive Manager. New
When I download a .rar file or a .7z file and double click it, I am told that the "Archive Type is not supported." there should be a download button under that that allows me to quickly and easily download the required programs, such as rar / unrar. If the program is proprietary, the EULA should pop up. Doing this would make it easier for newbies to use Ubuntu, and save time for me.

---Extra---
After reading comments, it would also make sense to do this with most file formats, though I think it might already do this with certain media formats. Ex: Does it do this with .mp3s?
125
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #16690
Written by arckeda the 20 Dec 08 at 22:55.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #16690 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!

See the 2 comments or propose a solution >>

Hotkey Collisions Lead to Unpredictable Behavior  
Written by brownbat the 1 Apr 09 at 09:43. Global category: Usability. New
Changing keyboard shortcuts involves either a lot of expended effort trying to find unused key combinations, or involves risking collisions and unpredictable behavior.

I have seen more than one post on UbuntuForums complaining about Hotkey or Keyboard Shortcut Collisions.
103
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Create a Universal Hotkey Registry App
Written by brownbat the 1 Apr 09 at 09:43.
Maybe a program could consolidate all your hotkeys from across all your programs, so you could quickly cross reference which hotkeys were used or unused.

If this info were machine readable, it might even inspire third parties to write useful warning scripts to help you manage your shortcuts.

The difficulty might be in gathering the shortcut info from such a huge variety of apps...
-17
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Use KDE
Written by phxx the 14 Apr 09 at 20:40.
KDE already has this ability. Ofcourse using KDE is not possible/prefered by GNOME users, but maybe the GNOME Developers can take some ideas from the KDE hotkey system.

See the 2 comments or propose a solution >>

2 Next >>