Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 22700 ideas, 138270 comments, 2629576 votes
Idea sandbox Idea sandbox
Popular ideas Popular ideas
Ideas in development Ideas in development
Implemented ideas Implemented ideas

Contributor MsG

Kernel updates are frequent but most users have no idea if it affects them.  
Written by zoubidoo the 4 Jan 11 at 13:29. Related project: Update manager. New
If a new kernel is released with bug fixes for various drivers but none of the hardware is in your computer, then why bother with the update? How many kernel updates have you done that made absolutely no difference to your platform? And each kernel update forces a reboot.

This is a kernel-related issue but would improve ubuntu.
6
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Machine-readable kernel changelog to check if the updates are relevant
Written by zoubidoo the 4 Jan 11 at 13:29.
The kernel changelog should be machine-readable. Knowing what hardware you have, update-manager/apt could check whether the kernel update is relevant and only install if necessary.

Of course some updates affect all hardware, so of course the update is relevant in this case.

But a kernel update because of a fix to isdn drivers is of no relevance to most users. Since we know our platform's hardware it should be possible to determine relevance.

See the 4 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 30 Nov 12 at 03:55) >>

Change Language In Time and Date Applet  
Written by yniranjanp the 3 Aug 11 at 07:53. Global category: Usability. New
I want to display the date and time in my local language. Rest of all in English or the default language set.
1
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Add language settings tab to Time and Date applet
Written by yniranjanp the 3 Aug 11 at 07:53.
Add a language tab to date and time tab and allow the user to choose the language he/she wants to display the time and date.

See the 2 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 17 Sep 11 at 23:40) >>

Ubuntu needs some kind of regional settings to distinct settings with a language  
Written by MsG the 5 Aug 11 at 11:47. Global category: Quality. Not an idea
When I install Ubuntu, I always choose English like many of us. But this also assumes the 12-hour system instead of the 24-hour system which is default here in Holland.

I need to manually change this everywhere which is pretty annoying.
37
votes
closed
Solution #1: Some kind of Regional Settings
Written by MsG the 5 Aug 11 at 11:47.
Make some kind of regional settings at installation, or to setup later on which uses regional notations and stuf, like 24-hour system, thousand seperator, month day notation order and stuff, so you can have English as a language, but still use your regional notations.

This should be system wide, so I need to be able to use 100,50 in LibreOffice as the English 100.5

Same for 5-6-2010 which means 5 June here. And in English notation it means 6 may.
5
votes
closed
Solution #2: Just Right click it.
Written by dramspringfeald the 10 Aug 11 at 21:58.
Military system also runs on the 24 hour clock however most users are not use to that kind of setting.

so just right click the clock > Preferences > click 24 hour format.
12
votes
closed
Solution #3: System-wide date & time formatting independent of region & language
Written by ester4 the 15 Aug 11 at 14:04.
Create a "date & time settings dialog" that lets users format the display of the time & date (et. al., decimal points) to their choosing. Then manifest this chosen format system-wide.

Regardless of the region or language set on the system, using the proposed "date & time settings dialog," if a user selects 24-hour-time and Day/Month/Year and 100.50 format, then these formats should institute EVERYWHERE: for the date & time in the top panel (e.g., so the date would show "6 June" and not "June 6,"), the date & time at the ubuntu login screen, the date & time of e-mails within Thunderbird, on the headers/footers when printing stuff from the internet with Firefox, within LibreOffice, etc.

Wherever the time or date is displayed in ubuntu, the display format should correspond to what is set by the user within the "date & time settings dialog."

I live in the United States and use English language. All my ubuntu settings default to 12-hour time and Month/Day/Year, yet I ALWAYS use 24-hour time and Day/Month/Year everywhere else in my life. I should be able to set Ubuntu to display date & time how it is displayed everywhere else in my home and work environment.

See the 8 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 17 Sep 11 at 23:36) >>

Connecting manually to your wifi network is not user friendly  
Written by MsG the 28 Jul 11 at 23:53. Related project: Gnome. Already implemented
Many people I know which are new to Ubuntu are annoyed by the fact that they need to manually click on their SSID in the list everytime to connect. This is indeed so stupid, because the majority of the users wants to connect to their wifi connection when it is available.

They don't even think that this is configurable, because they are normal human beings who do not change settings, so they end up ranting on Ubuntu and find it not user friendly.
0
votes
closed
Solution #1: Check the checkbox "connect automatically" in the SSID option screen by default
Written by MsG the 28 Jul 11 at 23:53.
The option "connect automatically" should be checked by default. This is in line with "For human beings". The one weird guy who doesn't want to connect to their wifi connection when available is handy enough to uncheck it, while the noob users aren't handy enough to check it.

Why would people enable their wifi on their laptop but not want to connect to their known networks? I can't find any usecase for that scenario, so please enable that check by default.

See the 4 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 8 Aug 11 at 18:40) >>

Eye of gnome images order should be the same as nautilus files order in folder  
Written by soyporti the 29 Oct 08 at 15:40. Related project: Gnome. Not an idea
Its confusing when you order your files in nautilus for example by date, and then eye of gnome doesn't show images in that order, you never know what image is next.

Eye of gnome should change that order to order by date, or manually, or by type, or any other order the user choose in nautilus for that folder.
30
votes
closed
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #14953
Written by soyporti the 29 Oct 08 at 15:40.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #14953 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!

See the 2 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 30 Jul 11 at 16:24) >>

Ubuntu One: More Payment Options  
Written by Bubble the 17 May 11 at 13:02. Global category: Others. Not an idea
I'd like to buy more space for my Ubuntu One account, but the only available payment method is by providing credit card information.
68
votes
closed
Solution #1: Add more Payment Options
Written by Bubble the 17 May 11 at 13:02.
Paypal, Google Checkout, Bank transfer, Call2Pay (for monthly payments)

See the 3 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 29 Jul 11 at 02:45) >>

Drives and partitions could be set up to be auto-mounted selectively.  
Written by hirumono the 12 Jan 11 at 11:47. Related project: Nautilus. In development
In recent versions of Ubuntu, non-system partitions (e.g. Windows partitions, Fat32 'exchange' areas, other Linux storage drives or volumes) are correctly detected and left unmounted, ready for use right AFTER the user has mounted them. This is good for volumes which aren't used often, but it creates problems whenever a user decides to organize his data out of his home directory - if, for example, my music is located on an (unmounted) internal HD or non-system partition, my music reader won't find it and clear all my playlists as the files are 'not there'. Wine can't locate any drives associated with unmounted partitions (which is a problem, as a lot of Windows software has to live on a Fat/NTFS volume due to upper/lowercase issues) and generally speaking, any software looking for data on an unmounted volume will fail. So the user has to remember which volumes to mount manually at every boot.
186
votes
inprogress
Selected solution (#1): Add a 'mount at login' flag on volume properties
Written by hirumono the 12 Jan 11 at 11:47.
Older versions of Ubuntu used fstab to mount volumes at boot, but now a more dynamic approach has been chosen to access non-system disks or partitions. So, while going back to fstab entries would be inadequate, a simple 'mount at login' flag on the volume properties tab could help the user choosing to auto-mount volumes intended for frequent access, Wine drives, or containing data which must be readily available.
-14
votes
inprogress
Selected solution (#2): Have a Gtk/GUI fstab editor come installed with Ubuntu
Written by mystro256 the 31 Jan 11 at 20:37.
I know there's a program out there that does it but I can't seem to remember what it's called.

Editing fstab with gedit/generic editor can be intimidating to some users because of the harm they can do to their operating system. I can see users either adding partitions/drives after installing Ubuntu or forgetting to mount a drive during the installation (I've done that before!)

A GTK/GUI program that can add a drive to fstab like the installation screen of Ubuntu (in the set drives manually screen) would work well: automatically set mount options but allow for manual setup if desired by the user.
-4
votes
inprogress
Selected solution (#3): Automount the volume when the software tries to access the file(s)
Written by saimanoj the 10 Feb 11 at 13:01.
Ubuntu should mount(automatically in background) the volume required which is tried to access the file or a folder by software

See the 27 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 20 Jun 11 at 20:24) >>

Frequently you need to update a BIOS with a windows/DOS executable  
Written by hawthornso23 the 16 Jan 11 at 09:25. Global category: Hardware support. New
Installing a new BIOS is a pain because many manufacturers only provide BIOS updates as windows/DOS executables. To update the BIOS natively from within linux is actually quite easy, but to do it you need a copy of the BIOS in suitable form - for example an hdr file. For that we are totally dependent on the goodwill of the manufacturers. Goodwill which we are not getting.

Manufacturers if anything seem to be making it more difficult to obtain hdr files that would allow native linux BIOS updates. Perhaps they are being threatened. The ideal would be to simply update the BIOS via a repositary. That ideal is not achievable without the cooperation of manufacturers. In the interim we need is a simpler method to flash your BIOS using the windows/DOS executable which is often the only BIOS update format that manufacturers provide.

The usual process is to write the windows/DOS BIOS update file to some sort of bootable media containing a copy of DOS or freeDOS, be it a floppy, CD or USB key. Then reboot and install. I propose a simpler method.
131
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Provide a FREEDOS boot option by default in GRUB.
Written by hawthornso23 the 16 Jan 11 at 09:25.
With the size of modern disks the space taken up by a copy of DOS is miniscule. So lets simply include a copy of FreeDOS and provide a FreeDOS boot option in grub by default. Rather similar to the existing memtest option, this would allow you to boot into a preinstalled copy of FreeDOS specifically in order to faciltate BIOS updates, so you wouldn't have to muck around making special copies of bootable media. The FreeDOS files could be mounted as /FreeDOS in normal ubuntu operation to make it easy to copy stuff across.

To update your BIOS in this setup

1. sudo cp E6510A06.EXE /FreeDOS
2. reboot and select FreeDOS in GRUB
3. Update ( E6510A06.EXE in our example ).

We can't change the policies of manufacturers or do anything about the anticompetitive threats that are causing them to withdraw linux BIOS update options. But we can make updating your BIOS using a windows/DOS BIOS flash utility a painless procedure.
11
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Startup Disk Creator should have "upgrade bios" mode.
Written by daniel311 the 10 Feb 11 at 07:51.
So, as Snc wrote in the comments:

"The Startup Disk Creator should have a "upgrade bios" mode, making the USB a Free DOS booting device, with selected files on it (with selected i mean: zip, decompressed or folder, copied)"

See the 10 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 14 Feb 11 at 17:12) >>

A malware threat for Ubuntu is NOT impossible  
Written by inashdeen the 25 Nov 10 at 18:55. Related project: Add/Remove program dialog. New
We could not deny, now days that, though malware threat for Ubuntu is low, it is not impossible. For years, we had been proud with the root user system as a solid structure that protect Ubuntu from viruses, owever, attacker had found ways to steal these passwords from us, and in short, the threat is coming.
-77
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Captcha as a secondary physical barrier for Ubuntu against malware
Written by inashdeen the 25 Nov 10 at 18:55.
Hence, I suggest that ubuntu used a captcha system, in additional to the default password system used, especially when regarding sensitive filesystem files. A capctha is a simple yet powerful physical firewall that differentiate between a human and non human users, on the other hand, could be given an option to use it or not to use it.
124
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Expand the use of AppArmor and similar technologies
Written by czr114 the 26 Nov 10 at 06:08.
Captchas are a joke. They're annoying, culturally-problematic, and practically useless for hardened purposes. Cybercriminals can subscribe to services using farmed-out human solvers for a few dollars per 1000 solutions. That renders them only partially useful in protecting low-value targets against poorly-coded software. If their goal is deploying bot clients, we can't count on criminal incompetence to save us, and with bank accounts at stake, they're not going to be overly cheap.

Preventing improper automated/invisible access to system files starts with a solid, robust, and secure framework for limiting access permissions by process and purpose. This is where technologies like AppArmor and tripwires come in.

If a user has been fooled by a trojan, and is dead set on sudoing malware, nothing is going to stop it from ravaging the system, short of completely disabling a user's ability to sudo things designed to modify key files for benevolent purposes.
5
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Use Selinux
Written by Lachu the 11 Dec 10 at 21:36.
Use Selinux and modify bash to change current domain, when running command. Only build-in command user could run programs without changing domain. Only programs in the same domain like standard shell could run sudo/su . Bash will change own domain automatically, if it starts in non-interactive mode.

See the 8 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 22 Dec 10 at 13:37) >>

Make method for moving buttons more consistent  
Written by chunkyboy the 1 Dec 10 at 04:23. Global category: Look and Feel. Not an idea
Some icons in Ubuntu 10.10 have both left mouse click AND right mouse click options for dragging. eg: firefox icon, Connect to Remote Server icon; Shutdown Button.
However, other icons have ONLY the right mouse click option for being dragged.eg: Clock; Main Menu and Force Shutdown.

For those buttons which have been assigned only the right click method of being dragged, the left click draging function should also be added.

If all buttons have BOTH dragging functions users will never have to hesitate when they go to drag something because they will know that all buttons work for dragging in the same manner.
0
votes
closed
Solution #1: Give ALL panel buttons BOTH dragging methods
Written by chunkyboy the 1 Dec 10 at 04:23.
Allow ALL panel buttons in Ubuntu 10.10 BOTH dragging methods.

See the 8 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 19 Dec 10 at 01:24) >>

2 Next >>