Contributor MagicFab
Easy way of backing up/moving your documents and settings
Written by stgraber the 28 Feb 08 at 12:10.
Global category: System.
Implemented
At the moment, if someone wants to backup his documents or prepare a migration from a computer to another there isn't much more than file-roller to create a backup.
Ideally, the user should be able to run a graphic software which would ask what the user wants to backup and where (tape/usb key/remote).
Then the same tool would be able to restore the backup.
It would be useful for both backups and migration from a computer to another.
Update : See duplicates ideas which contain even more great ideas about that idea.
3619
votes
4264
4
645
39
votes
46
13
7
Selected solution (#2):
Use existing incremental backup utility and some additional scripts
Written by
mudd1 the 2 Feb 09 at 10:53.
There are already great utilities like backup2l. All that'd be needed were a good default configuration, perhaps a GUI and a couple of scripts that prevent rendering your system unusable and even unbootable after a restore: Something to fix /etc/fstab (UUIDs, I love them), /boot/grub/menu.lst (same reason) and permissions (random UIDs/GIDs on package installation), all of which is a real PITA at the moment and probably breaks every newbie's neck.
There are already great utilities like backup2l. All that'd be needed were a good default configuration, perhaps a GUI and a couple of scripts that prevent rendering your system unusable and even unbootable after a restore: Something to fix /etc/fstab (UUIDs, I love them), /boot/grub/menu.lst (same reason) and permissions (random UIDs/GIDs on package installation), all of which is a real PITA at the moment and probably breaks every newbie's neck.
305
votes
321
21
16
Selected solution (#3):
Write a GUI for rsnapshot
rsnapshot is an excellent piece of software that (much like Apple's Time Machine) allows a user to take "snapshots" of his or her system. Using rsnapshot, a user can create snapshots at any interval he wants: hourly, weekly, monthly, every 6 hours, or anything else that cron supports. Restoring from a previous snapshot is as easy as copy and paste.
The problem is that rsnapshot is not the easiest software to use, even for people who are comfortable with the command line. I suggest that Canonical write a GUI for rsnapshot and ship it with Ubuntu.
rsnapshot:
http://rsnapshot.org/
rsnapshot is an excellent piece of software that (much like Apple's Time Machine) allows a user to take "snapshots" of his or her system. Using rsnapshot, a user can create snapshots at any interval he wants: hourly, weekly, monthly, every 6 hours, or anything else that cron supports. Restoring from a previous snapshot is as easy as copy and paste.
The problem is that rsnapshot is not the easiest software to use, even for people who are comfortable with the command line. I suggest that Canonical write a GUI for rsnapshot and ship it with Ubuntu.
rsnapshot: http://rsnapshot.org/
181
votes
215
25
34
Selected solution (#4):
Wait for TimeVault to go stable
Currently in alpha, TimeVault is a snapshot backup solution integrated into Nautilus. https://wiki.ubuntu.com/TimeVault
-27
votes
30
39
57
Selected solution (#5):
Use duplicity and create a GUI for it, or use duplicati
Duplicity is an excellent piece of backup software and allows one to easily do cheap offsite backups using Amazon's S3 service.
Duplicati (
http://code.google.com/p/duplicati/ ) seems to be the only GUI front-end for it, and it seems to be in early development.
Duplicity is an excellent piece of backup software and allows one to easily do cheap offsite backups using Amazon's S3 service.
Duplicati ( http://code.google.com/p/duplicati/ ) seems to be the only GUI front-end for it, and it seems to be in early development.
-73
votes
41
30
114
Selected solution (#6):
integrate Dropbox
Written by
stefano the 16 Mar 09 at 18:42.
Dropbox is an easy [1] [2], secure [3], cheap [4] [5], based on Amazon S3 [6] and, last but not least, the nautilus client is GPL [7] !!!
and, but it's only an idea, Canonical colud be compensated for paying Dropbox Ubuntu users.
[1] http://www.getdropbox.com/tour
[2] http://www.getdropbox.com/screencast
[3] http://www.getdropbox.com/help/27
[4] http://www.getdropbox.com/help/47
[5] http://www.getdropbox.com/help/15
[6] http://www.techcrunch.com/2008/03/11/dropbox-the-online-storage-solution-weve-been-waiting-for/
[7] http://www.getdropbox.com/downloading?os=lnx
42
votes
96
28
54
Selected solution (#7):
LuckyBackup, a GUI for rsync
Recently a new GUI was developed for the most known and reliable backup technology :rsync
luckyBackup is an application for data back-up and synchronization powered by the rsync tool.
It is simple to use, fast (transfers over only changes made and not all data), safe (keeps your data safe by checking all declared directories before proceeding in any data manipulation ), reliable and fully customizable.
Just take a look at this screenshots:
http://luckybackup.sourceforge.net/screenshots.html
Recently a new GUI was developed for the most known and reliable backup technology :rsync
luckyBackup is an application for data back-up and synchronization powered by the rsync tool.
It is simple to use, fast (transfers over only changes made and not all data), safe (keeps your data safe by checking all declared directories before proceeding in any data manipulation ), reliable and fully customizable.
Just take a look at this screenshots:
http://luckybackup.sourceforge.net/screenshots.html
-42
votes
15
5
57
Selected solution (#9):
Partner with an existing online backup provider for seamless backups
Many users do not make back-ups because you need multiple harddrives or more space for that, plus it takes time to set up. Backup should be as low-entry as possible. Online backup systems are a (partial) solution to that problem.
Adding a one-click-to-enable option for free (& cheap to expand) online storage through partnership with an existing vendor would be a major innovation and "selling" point. Yes, space might be limited, but just backing up certain default directories such as documents might do the trick.
Many users do not make back-ups because you need multiple harddrives or more space for that, plus it takes time to set up. Backup should be as low-entry as possible. Online backup systems are a (partial) solution to that problem.
Adding a one-click-to-enable option for free (& cheap to expand) online storage through partnership with an existing vendor would be a major innovation and "selling" point. Yes, space might be limited, but just backing up certain default directories such as documents might do the trick.
50
votes
60
12
10
Selected solution (#10):
support btrfs filesystem for native snapshots and data integrity
Written by
stefano the 20 Mar 09 at 22:17.
For local (not-online) backups btrfs 'll simplify files versioning (with native snapshot support) and data integrity (with native data chesumming).
btrfs is currently supported by 2.6.29 kernel.
as stated in the home page "Btrfs is under heavy development, and is not suitable for any uses other than benchmarking and review. The Btrfs disk format is not yet finalized, but it will only be changed if a critical bug is found and no workarounds are possible.". Ubuntu should support it as soon as possible after the 1.0 release (Q408).
this idea is complementary to #6 and #8 for local backups with rsync (with btrfs and rsync we'll not need other time-something solutions) but for online offsite backups we'll need ALSO one or more solution as #4, #5, #9.
references:
http://btrfs.wiki.kernel.org/index.php/Main_Page
http://btrfs.wiki.kernel.org/index.php/Development_timeline
For local (not-online) backups btrfs 'll simplify files versioning (with native snapshot support) and data integrity (with native data chesumming).
btrfs is currently supported by 2.6.29 kernel.
as stated in the home page "Btrfs is under heavy development, and is not suitable for any uses other than benchmarking and review. The Btrfs disk format is not yet finalized, but it will only be changed if a critical bug is found and no workarounds are possible.". Ubuntu should support it as soon as possible after the 1.0 release (Q408).
this idea is complementary to #6 and #8 for local backups with rsync (with btrfs and rsync we'll not need other time-something solutions) but for online offsite backups we'll need ALSO one or more solution as #4, #5, #9.
references:
http://btrfs.wiki.kernel.org/index.php/Main_Page
http://btrfs.wiki.kernel.org/index.php/Development_timeline
12
votes
29
10
17
Selected solution (#11):
Support backup PLUG-INs
Written by
Craig73 the 21 Mar 09 at 14:45.
OK - well we might get tired of the word plugins... but I see the request for a timevault style backup system, the underlying technology (file system or backup library), and the destination as being 3 separate part of the solution.
But whatever tool is selected - people should be able to add the options they want
1) Option to backup online. Make it easy to add different online services whether it is some random FTP site, S3, a free cloud service, or some other future solution (bit-torrent backups or replication with other machines?)
2) Allow encryption of data. Whether online or offline, we should optionally allow encryption of data. [I see opportunity here to leverage GPU or multiple core processing for stupidly high levels of encryption no?]
OK - well we might get tired of the word plugins... but I see the request for a timevault style backup system, the underlying technology (file system or backup library), and the destination as being 3 separate part of the solution.
But whatever tool is selected - people should be able to add the options they want
1) Option to backup online. Make it easy to add different online services whether it is some random FTP site, S3, a free cloud service, or some other future solution (bit-torrent backups or replication with other machines?)
2) Allow encryption of data. Whether online or offline, we should optionally allow encryption of data. [I see opportunity here to leverage GPU or multiple core processing for stupidly high levels of encryption no?]
-17
votes
14
11
31
Selected solution (#12):
partimage for partition images
Written by
daddo the 22 Mar 09 at 09:54.
Partimage for making complete images of partitions.
Partimage for making complete images of partitions.
-8
votes
17
14
25
Selected solution (#13):
Incorporate SimpleBackup
Simplebackup has pretty much everything needed:
Different schedules for the backup.
Specify which folders, files, etc are backed up.
Incremental backup.
Backups saved locally or remotely (ssh or ftp)
Simplebackup has pretty much everything needed:
Different schedules for the backup.
Specify which folders, files, etc are backed up.
Incremental backup.
Backups saved locally or remotely (ssh or ftp)
12
votes
22
13
10
Selected solution (#14):
Add Remastersys as extra option for backing up the installed system setup to DVD
I'm not suggesting having only Remastersys or using it for a whole system back up of your files, but as another option to go alongside one of the above for files. It would be just imaging your choice of applications and desktop appearance preferences ect. To enable very easy system restore installation exactly to your liking from a worst case scenario that the HD fail and had to be replaced. The application is also very user friendly for new users to use.
I'm not suggesting having only Remastersys or using it for a whole system back up of your files, but as another option to go alongside one of the above for files. It would be just imaging your choice of applications and desktop appearance preferences ect. To enable very easy system restore installation exactly to your liking from a worst case scenario that the HD fail and had to be replaced. The application is also very user friendly for new users to use.
26
votes
35
7
9
Selected solution (#15):
Include "Back In Time" as default backup tool
Written by
sajmon75 the 7 Apr 09 at 12:17.
A simple and smart solution:
http://backintime.le-web.org/
From web site:
Back In Time is a simple backup system for Linux inspired from “flyback project” and “TimeVault”. The backup is done by taking snapshots of a specified set of directories.
Currently there are two GUI available: Gnome and KDE 4 (>= 4.1).
All you have to do is configure:
* Where to save snapshot
* What directories to backup
* When backup should be done (manual, every hour, every day, every week, every month)
A simple and smart solution:
http://backintime.le-web.org/
From web site:
Back In Time is a simple backup system for Linux inspired from “flyback project” and “TimeVault”. The backup is done by taking snapshots of a specified set of directories.
Currently there are two GUI available: Gnome and KDE 4 (>= 4.1).
All you have to do is configure:
* Where to save snapshot
* What directories to backup
* When backup should be done (manual, every hour, every day, every week, every month)
23
votes
29
5
6
Selected solution (#16):
Use Déjà Dup
Written by
mterry the 6 May 09 at 16:47.
This solution is a little self-serving, since I'm the maintainer of Déjà Dup, but I think it fits the bill. At least, my aim is to fit this bill.
A quick description: A simple GUI that makes backing up the 'right way' (off-site, regular, incremental, encrypted) easy. It's based on the command-line tool duplicity.
https://launchpad.net/deja-dup
As robbiew mentions in the comments, this was added to Ubuntu for Jaunty (go to Add/Remove and search for it). There is also a PPA supporting as far back as Hardy in the link above.
I love feedback/bug reports!
This solution is a little self-serving, since I'm the maintainer of Déjà Dup, but I think it fits the bill. At least, my aim is to fit this bill.
A quick description: A simple GUI that makes backing up the 'right way' (off-site, regular, incremental, encrypted) easy. It's based on the command-line tool duplicity.
https://launchpad.net/deja-dup
As robbiew mentions in the comments, this was added to Ubuntu for Jaunty (go to Add/Remove and search for it). There is also a PPA supporting as far back as Hardy in the link above.
I love feedback/bug reports!
158
votes
160
5
2
Selected solution (#18):
Add a migration/transfer tool in System->Administration
A migration tool will (1) collect the enviroment (of the user or the computer) including the personal preferences in a machine independent way (e.g. Thunderbird, Mozilla, Pidgin, config files), the personal files (home directory), the list of installed applications, and (2) send them to another computer (via ssh, rexec, ssl, etc.) or create an archive to be transferred and then imported by the same application on the new computer.
A migration tool will (1) collect the enviroment (of the user or the computer) including the personal preferences in a machine independent way (e.g. Thunderbird, Mozilla, Pidgin, config files), the personal files (home directory), the list of installed applications, and (2) send them to another computer (via ssh, rexec, ssl, etc.) or create an archive to be transferred and then imported by the same application on the new computer.
46
votes
49
8
3
Selected solution (#19):
Add a "transfer settings from existing installation" in the installer.
I suggest we have something at the end of the Ubuntu installation process that, like at the end of the Mac OS X installation process, asks the user if he/she would like to transfer his/her files and settings from an existing copy of Ubuntu. If selected, the user can choose to transfer data via the Internet or through a USB or other physical connection. The Ubuntu install will then transfer (most of) the contents of "/home" and "/etc" (depending on what can be reasonably copied from one installation to another), and the new installation will use the apt-get markings of the previous installation to download and install the appropriate packages.
I suggest we have something at the end of the Ubuntu installation process that, like at the end of the Mac OS X installation process, asks the user if he/she would like to transfer his/her files and settings from an existing copy of Ubuntu. If selected, the user can choose to transfer data via the Internet or through a USB or other physical connection. The Ubuntu install will then transfer (most of) the contents of "/home" and "/etc" (depending on what can be reasonably copied from one installation to another), and the new installation will use the apt-get markings of the previous installation to download and install the appropriate packages.
6
votes
11
3
5
Selected solution (#20):
Make a backup system with RAID support for cloning drives
If ubuntu had an integrated SYSTEM BACKUP & RESTORE (compatible with RAID) we could just clone the disk and self not lose all that precious data .
If ubuntu had an integrated SYSTEM BACKUP & RESTORE (compatible with RAID) we could just clone the disk and self not lose all that precious data .
-10
votes
4
3
14
Selected solution (#21):
Here is a simple GUI program for backup written in python
Written by
Zorba the 8 Feb 10 at 08:17.
I realized a simple program with python and Qt4 to make easier backup of files or system configuration. You are totally free to modify this code, and I hope this could be useful for many Ubuntu users. I think it could be a good idea to insert it into system settings (the system settings for KDE and the settings menu for GNOME). If someone can make a porting to GTK+ the integration with GNOME will be better.
You can download the program here: zorbaproject.uuuq.com/upload/easybackupgui.tar.gz
to test it simply open a console, enter the folder where you have unpacked the tar, and type "python easybackupgui.py": some features need sudo.
I realized a simple program with python and Qt4 to make easier backup of files or system configuration. You are totally free to modify this code, and I hope this could be useful for many Ubuntu users. I think it could be a good idea to insert it into system settings (the system settings for KDE and the settings menu for GNOME). If someone can make a porting to GTK+ the integration with GNOME will be better.
You can download the program here: zorbaproject.uuuq.com/upload/easybackupgui.tar.gz
to test it simply open a console, enter the folder where you have unpacked the tar, and type "python easybackupgui.py": some features need sudo.
<img src="http://zorbaproject.uuuq.com/upload/easybackup.jpeg">
3
votes
7
2
4
Selected solution (#23):
System backup and restore
Ubuntu should come up with MS windows like user interface where in user can backup the sytem and restore point is generated which can be reloaded as and when required. This restore point will include user setting and sytem setting if required by user. Also need to give provision to copy the restore point file to any required location on HDD or any other storage media.
Ubuntu should come up with MS windows like user interface where in user can backup the sytem and restore point is generated which can be reloaded as and when required. This restore point will include user setting and sytem setting if required by user. Also need to give provision to copy the restore point file to any required location on HDD or any other storage media.
7
votes
8
1
1
Selected solution (#25):
Backup Center
I propose a "Backup Center", where you:
* Can choose directories to backup or your whole home directory
* Can create a key to encrypt your backup, if you want
* Can print your key or copy it to an media
* Can select network destinations for your backup like Ubuntu One Storage, Secure FTP, Secure WebDAV, SMB, etc.
* Can select local storage devices like USB storages
* Can select a timetable for the backup on the local USB storage, which might require the user to periodic connect it to the computer when prompted
* and, of course: Can easily play back your backup, when your files are gone
There should be an intelligent daemon in the background which accomplishes the backup. If an backup destination is not available or full, the user should be warned.
I propose a "Backup Center", where you:
* Can choose directories to backup or your whole home directory
* Can create a key to encrypt your backup, if you want
* Can print your key or copy it to an media
* Can select network destinations for your backup like Ubuntu One Storage, Secure FTP, Secure WebDAV, SMB, etc.
* Can select local storage devices like USB storages
* Can select a timetable for the backup on the local USB storage, which might require the user to periodic connect it to the computer when prompted
* and, of course: Can easily play back your backup, when your files are gone
There should be an intelligent daemon in the background which accomplishes the backup. If an backup destination is not available or full, the user should be warned.
6
votes
7
1
1
Selected solution (#26):
Copy filesystem with USB Startup Disk Creator
Written by
tebibyte the 2 Jan 11 at 06:15.
Use the USB Startup Disk Creator to make a mirror image of your system. And add a mechanism to sync it or mirror it back.
Use the USB Startup Disk Creator to make a mirror image of your system. And add a mechanism to sync it or mirror it back.
1
votes
1
0
0
Selected solution (#31):
Option at CD install to recover from UBUNTU ONE programs and settings
Written by
mitcoes the 13 Jun 11 at 10:39.
At USC an option to backup to UBUNTU ONE:
1.- The list of main repository installed/unsinstalled programs and settings
2.- The same with PPAs and PPAs programs and settings
At CD Install an option to recover your list of programs and settings and in a separate option PPAs ones where you can select all or pick some. - Sometimes PPas programs can be the cause of system inestability -
This way you can make installation profiles or make easier the reinstallation when it is necessary.
As well ubuntu would know the program change / install preferences from users with datamining of this backups.
For example I use to install VLC, Qbittorrent, Chromium, Chrome, Opera, & Thunderbird
At USC an option to backup to UBUNTU ONE:
1.- The list of main repository installed/unsinstalled programs and settings
2.- The same with PPAs and PPAs programs and settings
At CD Install an option to recover your list of programs and settings and in a separate option PPAs ones where you can select all or pick some. - Sometimes PPas programs can be the cause of system inestability -
This way you can make installation profiles or make easier the reinstallation when it is necessary.
As well ubuntu would know the program change / install preferences from users with datamining of this backups.
For example I use to install VLC, Qbittorrent, Chromium, Chrome, Opera, & Thunderbird
Create a better hardware database
Ubuntu
In :
Priority : Low
Definition : New (Needs guidance)
Implementation : Unknown
Assignee : Tomas Gustavsson
Written by Ubuwu the 28 Feb 08 at 15:22.
Global category: System.
Implemented
People around the globe that are using/concidering using Ubuntu are afraid that some of their hardware won't work for them. And some are frustrated to buy additional add-on cards to work around unsupportad onboard chips. All this could be avoided with a lookup in an ubuntu Hardware Database Website.
Some problematic hardware can be used with more or less work if helping information is available together with the hardware compatabillity data.
The hardware database can be found at
http://hwdb.ubuntu.com/
From
idea #47 : The data should then be available in a format that is simple for users to browse on-line when considering new hardware.
Webcam with Pidgin!
No information about this blueprint
Information is updated every 5 minutes.
Please wait till the next update.
Written by kwixbit the 28 Feb 08 at 19:24.
Global category: Internet & Networking.
Won't implement
Pidgin is a good program to chat on all protocols, but a webcam plugin is still missing.
The developers aren't decided to code webcam support, but having this in Pidgin is very needed.
Or why not code this plugin for emesene? But you can only use the MSN protocol at the moment!
Work with Broadcom for Native wireless drivers
Written by pornographer the 29 Feb 08 at 17:52.
Global category: Internet & Networking.
Won't implement
Broadcom wireless drivers are still common - see Lenovo V100 laptops etc, and having to fight with NDISwrapper or the terrible bcmxxxx driver is a terrible block for new users.
Ubuntu should now have the clout to get these companies to open up specs, especially for legacy hardware (as I believe the newer broadcoms work reasonably).
Replace Pidgin with Empathy by Ubuntu 9.04
No information about this blueprint
Information is updated every 5 minutes.
Please wait till the next update.
Written by DPic the 1 Aug 08 at 09:50.
Related project: Pidgin Internet Messenger .
Implemented
There has been a lot of positive talk in the past about replacing Pidgin with a better client that uses Telepathy but now there's one that looks like it's almost ready to do that! Empathy (
http://live.gnome.org/Empathy ) has much more potential than Pidgin since Empathy uses Telepathy (
http://telepathy.freedesktop.org ). Although i don't think Empathy is quite ready for this in Intrepid, it certainly will be for the next release.
(If you'd like to give it a try, don't use the old version in the Hardy repos, look here:
http://cass.no-ip.com/~cassidy/blog/index.php/post/2008/04/14/Voice-and-video-c alls-with-Empathy )
The fact that Empathy uses Telepathy to manage all the different protocols it supports is what makes it so great. Why is it that Pidgin supports file transfers on AIM but not Jabber? Why can't i use VoIP to talk to my Google Talk friends in Pidgin?
Empathy will enable more desktop integration, better support for multiple protocols, and a happier user :)
The bottom line is that Empathy has been making much more progress and improving much faster than Pidgin thanks to Telepathy and including it in Ubuntu will only help the process along!
Major Update! Empathy is now part of Gnome--
http://blog.ibeentoubuntu.com/2008/08/gnome-has-empathy-for-you.html
233
votes
324
4
91
Selected solution (#1):
Auto-generated solution of idea #11705
Written by
DPic the 1 Aug 08 at 09:50.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the
idea #11705 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!
<i>Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #11705 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution.</i><br /> Thanks!
54
votes
63
4
9
Selected solution (#2):
Wait until Empathy is actually ready before replacing anything
Written by
Endolith the 1 Feb 09 at 21:08.
We're sick of software being pushed on us before it's ready.
When Empathy is actually nicer than Pidgin for *everyone* who's going to use it, when it does everything Pidgin does and more, has an equal or better interface, and almost all the noticeable bugs and incompatibilities have been ironed out, *then* it can become the default.
We're sick of software being pushed on us before it's ready.
When Empathy is actually nicer than Pidgin for *everyone* who's going to use it, when it does everything Pidgin does and more, has an equal or better interface, and almost all the noticeable bugs and incompatibilities have been ironed out, *then* it can become the default.
15
votes
28
4
13
Selected solution (#3):
Wait until Empathy supports OTR encryption
Written by
Gri the 10 May 09 at 09:11.
After reading the terms and conditions of famous instant messaging protocols, many users will recognize, that encrypting their messages should make sense or should be essential, depending on which information they share via these protocols.
Pidgin supports encrypting instant messages at least with a plugin: Off-The-Record encryption. Empathy doesn't support OTR, nor any other encryption method. This should be a absolute no-go criteria for making Empathy the standard application for instant messaging in Ubuntu.
After reading the terms and conditions of famous instant messaging protocols, many users will recognize, that encrypting their messages should make sense or should be essential, depending on which information they share via these protocols.
Pidgin supports encrypting instant messages at least with a plugin: Off-The-Record encryption. Empathy doesn't support OTR, nor any other encryption method. This should be a absolute no-go criteria for making Empathy the standard application for instant messaging in Ubuntu.
-10
votes
10
0
20
Selected solution (#4):
Wait until Empathy support Social Networks and Microblogging
Written by
kazuya00 the 22 Jun 09 at 14:50.
Wait until Empathy supports Social Networks and Microblogging
Wait until Empathy supports Social Networks and Microblogging
Fingerprint readers integration
Ubuntu
In :
Priority : Low
Definition : New (Needs guidance)
Implementation : Unknown
Assignee :
Written by stgraber the 28 Feb 08 at 12:13.
Global category: System.
Implemented
Most business laptops and some of the end user ones too now include a fingerprint reader.
Those are perfectly possible to use on Linux either by using thinkfinger (IBM/Lenovo) or fprint (HP).
The various PAM modules for those should be installed by default or at least be easily installable and integrate correctly in the default desktop.
GDM, gksudo and the gnome screensaver would have to be modified in order to correctly support fingerprint readers.
That way the user would be able to login either by entering is password as usual or using his fingerprint.
1667
votes
2328
0
661
Selected solution (#1):
Auto-generated solution of idea #2
Written by
stgraber the 28 Feb 08 at 12:13.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the
idea #2 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!
<i>Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #2 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution.</i><br /> Thanks!
47
votes
53
3
6
Selected solution (#2):
improve GDM with fingerprint reader option
Written by
musikele the 15 Jan 09 at 12:51.
When Ubuntu starts and GDM comes out, you should be able to login only with your fingerprint, without entering any username.
So, the login window should be with all users like always, but with the possibility to login simply passing the fingerprint. If the fingerprint is recognized, a windows telling "user XXX recognized/accessing" should come out and linux should go on.
If the user is not recognized, a window telling "no user recognized - try again" could be an idea.
The normal login option should always be present, in case of an hardware error one should be always capable to enter with his username - password .
When Ubuntu starts and GDM comes out, you should be able to login only with your fingerprint, without entering any username.
So, the login window should be with all users like always, but with the possibility to login simply passing the fingerprint. If the fingerprint is recognized, a windows telling "user XXX recognized/accessing" should come out and linux should go on.
If the user is not recognized, a window telling "no user recognized - try again" could be an idea.
The normal login option should always be present, in case of an hardware error one should be always capable to enter with his username - password .
10
votes
16
3
6
Selected solution (#3):
Fingerprint for Identification not Authorisation
Written by
doctormo the 15 Jan 09 at 22:19.
The inherent security problem with fingerprints is that you can take anyone's laptop and very easily, using high school chemistry. Take the owners fingerprints and feed it to the reader.
When this topic comes up in Ubuntu Development lists, it's pretty much decided that a fingerprint reader can be used for a bad-ass username, but then the computer must still ask for a password to login.
This also includes using the webcam and some facial recognition tech that's in the pipes.
The inherent security problem with fingerprints is that you can take anyone's laptop and very easily, using high school chemistry. Take the owners fingerprints and feed it to the reader.
When this topic comes up in Ubuntu Development lists, it's pretty much decided that a fingerprint reader can be used for a bad-ass username, but then the computer must still ask for a password to login.
This also includes using the webcam and some facial recognition tech that's in the pipes.
264
votes
268
11
4
Selected solution (#4):
Just use the fedora's solution
The simplest solution is probably to implement the fedora's one:
http://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Features/Fingerprint
107
votes
112
19
5
Selected solution (#5):
Enable it only when warning about security risks
Written by
xfuser4 the 19 Oct 09 at 17:25.
Biometric sensors are known to have potential security risks (see comment).
When enabling finger print readers, the user should be informed about it.
Biometric sensors are known to have potential security risks (see comment).
When enabling finger print readers, the user should be informed about it.
27
votes
34
9
7
Selected solution (#6):
Make it a package file installable like an app.
Written by
Jaksco the 30 Oct 09 at 20:49.
Make it a package file installable like an app.
Make it a package file installable like an app.
35
votes
36
0
1
Selected solution (#7):
Make sure there is an option for fingerprint + password authentication.
Based on the comments about security risks, it seems like this should naturally be an option.
From
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Authentication#History_and_state-of-the-art : "Hybrid or two-tiered authentication methods offer a compelling solution." Fingerprints can be swiped and used and there are plenty of methods for getting a password (peeking, social engineering, brute force, etc.); getting both would likely prove to be more difficult.
At any rate, a fingerprint on top of a normal password would definitely stop a casual snooper.
Based on the comments about security risks, it seems like this should naturally be an option.
From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Authentication#History_and_state-of-the-art : "Hybrid or two-tiered authentication methods offer a compelling solution." Fingerprints can be swiped and used and there are plenty of methods for getting a password (peeking, social engineering, brute force, etc.); getting both would likely prove to be more difficult.
At any rate, a fingerprint on top of a normal password would definitely stop a casual snooper.
12
votes
17
4
5
Selected solution (#8):
show captured fingerprint graphically to demonstrate the device adequacy
Written by
daddo the 8 Nov 09 at 21:43.
Show live the fingerprint reader output graphically and let the users to decide, is it secure enough or not.
At the moment, users don't realize at which quality are their fingerprints captured. Show it them!
It could be also solution for showing how good is the the fingerprint reader which is in use.
Show live the fingerprint reader output graphically and let the users to decide, is it secure enough or not.
At the moment, users don't realize at which quality are their fingerprints captured. Show it them!
It could be also solution for showing how good is the the fingerprint reader which is in use.
2
votes
2
0
0
Selected solution (#9):
make sure at you can login with fingerprint via terminal
Written by
tommis the 22 Nov 09 at 18:10.
If you can login via figerprint in gdm terminal should support it too.
If you can login via figerprint in gdm terminal should support it too.
Easy way of join a Ubuntu workstation to a Active Directory
Ubuntu
In :
Priority : Essential
Definition : Approved
Implementation : Implemented
Assignee : Rick Clark
Mentorship is available if you want to fix this bug.
Written by hmgp the 28 Feb 08 at 15:06.
Global category: System.
In development
Make it easy to join a Ubuntu Workstation to a Active Directory Domain. Like Windows does for instance.
Add Webmin Please!
Written by gdrouillard the 4 Mar 08 at 18:03.
Global category: Server.
New
One of the greatest applications for managing servers via a web browser.
Support extra keys on advanced USB keyboards
Written by muecker the 4 Mar 08 at 17:22.
Global category: Hardware support.
Not an idea
I have a Logitech LX-710 keyboard with a bunch of extra function keys, most of which I cannot program. I had a different keyboard before this one and the same was true. I can program the audio keys (which work by default) and the calculator key, but most others do not work. It would be great if Linux would generate scan codes for those extra keys so I could assign commands to them. The same is true of special mouse buttons.
One program I tried works with non-USB keyboards but claimed that kernel support was required for USB keyboards. Strangely, Enlightment recognizes quite a few more of the extra keys than Gnome does.
Developer comments
Some of the extra keys can be mapped in xkeyboard-config, but the more exotic ones produce scancodes which are over the limit that X can use, so they need to be quirked in the kernel. Just file bugs instead. If xev shows the keycode, the keycode can be added to xkeyboard-config. If not, the kernel needs to be fixed first.
ndiswrapper (gtk) detect chipset
Written by Kreuger the 1 Mar 08 at 14:51.
Global category: Internet & Networking.
New
Alright now that we finally have a GUI tool for ndiswrapper, it should be able to detect the chipset used and if there are drivers available, automatically download and install them.