Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 22700 ideas, 138270 comments, 2629576 votes
Idea sandbox Idea sandbox
Popular ideas Popular ideas
Ideas in development Ideas in development
Implemented ideas Implemented ideas

Contributor Incendia

Clean Distro Upgrade/Install [Two problems in one...they are very similar...]]  
Written by Incendia the 4 Jan 11 at 14:09. Related project: Live CD installer. New
When a new Ubuntu version is released you have only three options.

1. Upgrade from inside the system which keeps data.
2. Download .iso and install the new one.
3. Download .iso and replace a previous installation manually to keep data. [This one is differcult to do.]

...but there is no way to run a 'clean upgrade' which upgrades the system like in 1. but would also erase all your data if you want a fresh installation. There is also no way to only save selected data...what if I only want the PPAs?

And inside the .iso there is no easy to see option to replace only the exist Ubuntu installation and import selected data.

Edit:
The installer checks for other Ubuntu installs and asks if you want their /home...their could be a drop down labelled advanced which asks if you want the sources.list and /etc and folders such as that.

The page can be skipped if the user doesn't want to copy anything. It would work similar to how Ubuntu finds pictures and videos from windows.

I personally only want to keep the software sources list and package lists. Selected data would be any user data from the old one.

The natty installer would check for the words 'maverick' in copied PPAs and replace any 'maverick' it finds with 'natty'. Similar thing for newer ubuntu versions.

In the update centre instead of 1 button asking for an upgrade you would get a dropdown menu eg:
New Ubuntu version available-Upgrade >


[....]
4
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Improve the .iso and update manager.
Written by Incendia the 4 Jan 11 at 14:09.
Add an option to write of the existing Ubuntu installation and save only selected things or nothing and add an option in the update manager to 'Clean Upgrade' to simply replace the current installation with a new one.

*Basically what it says in the Edit of the Rationale.

See the 1 comments or propose a solution (latest comment the 8 Jan 11 at 23:46) >>

PPA system can be improved  
Written by Incendia the 8 Jan 11 at 23:32. Related project: launchpad.net. New
I looked at sources.list and I know how many repositories I usually add.

The list gets long and cluttered.

There are also some ppas that are duplicates or rely on others etc.
-7
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: PPAs that link to other PPAs
Written by Incendia the 8 Jan 11 at 23:32.
Allow PPAs to be link to other PPAs.
When synaptic checks for updates it checks the packages in the ppa and if you select and option to do so it will check the packages in linked ppas over the internet without having to add them to source.list.
EG.
Browser:
[http://launchpad.com/ubuntu]

This is the ubuntu PPA.

Packages in PPA:
Awesomeness.deb
ubuntu-desktop.deb
gnome.deb

Linked repositories:
ppa:separateextras

Add a comment or propose a solution >>