Here are the most popular ideas ever about Banshee Music Player .
Enhance bluetooth manager
Written by benjamimgois the 13 Mar 09 at 17:20.
New
Default bluetooth Gnome applet isn't much user friendly, it do not allow to turn off bluetooth radio with a single click saving battery's life and do not integrate with Network Manager. A solution with a better and powerfull GUI would be great.
Sync Support for Android in Rhythmbox
Written by jbtechguy the 7 Jul 09 at 15:19.
New
I'd really like to see added support for Android-based devices in Ubuntu media players, namely Banshee or Rhythmbox.
I understand why this is difficult to achieve with the iPod/iPhone, but it'd be nice to see some integration with Android-based phones, namely when it comes to podcasts. Ability to sync "3 Most Recent Unlistened To"/"3 Oldest Unlistened To", etc. would be nice to see.
Banshee LIbrary handling ideas.
Written by Rodrigo the 13 Aug 09 at 20:20.
New
When I add a new song to the media directory in banshee I have to rescan the whole library, something that can take a while if I have a few songs.
.is_audio_player needs new features.
Written by b3t0n the 11 Sep 09 at 13:32.
New
If you want to manage the content of your media player in applications like Banshee you either have to get it recognised as media player by default, or create own .is_audio_player file.
Creating file is fairly good solution, but as the pmp advance and now can play not only music, but movies and podcasts, the file doesn't help to manage them. It can only define music directory, cover art, supported media types, but it all comes down to music.
Solution #1:
Define a new .is_media_player file.
Written by
b3t0n the 11 Sep 09 at 13:32.
With devices like PSP or any other PMP we can now watch movies. However, we cannot manage files in Banshee or other program, because .is_audio_player defines only music players.
What we need is a new file that will be describe f.e.
- movie directory
- supported resolutions, codecs, file formats,
- podcast directory
- maybe audiobooks?
- other things that can be put on pmp.
With devices like PSP or any other PMP we can now watch movies. However, we cannot manage files in Banshee or other program, because .is_audio_player defines only music players.
What we need is a new file that will be describe f.e.
- movie directory
- supported resolutions, codecs, file formats,
- podcast directory
- maybe audiobooks?
- other things that can be put on pmp.
increasing the sound buffer, and # of audio channels (5.1, 7.1) is too much work
Written by asuastrophysics the 17 Apr 09 at 03:12.
New
i am sick of stuttering sound. i have 2 GB of RAM and it makes no difference.
editing sound configuration files, such as .asound.conf is very primitive, and it doesn't do anything to fix the problem
ubuntu seems to blatantly ignore any configuration files i make. i have followed guides for hours to no avail.
multitasking makes the audio suck. period. this needs to be fixed.
adding 5.1 support is a nightmare, and it takes too much time to set up
Solution #1:
change sound buffer and # of audio channels with a GUI
a GUI would be so much better.
***remember: "linux for human beings", before suggesting to leave "as-is"
a GUI that lets you:
1. Select the sound driver you are currently using (ALSA, OSS, Pulseaudio) from a drop-down list
2. Various system-wide options for the driver would be shown below:
You can change the audio buffer using a slider (or numerical value in MB)
You can set-up multiple audio outputs (if you have more than one audio out port that you want to use)
You can set up 2,3.1,4,5.1, and 7.1 surround sound by clicking on a button in the GUI, which brings you to a step-by-step configuration (next, previous buttons included)
it would also include a test page towards the end of the configuration that sends sound through each speaker, to make sure they are all working.
a GUI would be so much better.
***remember: "linux for human beings", before suggesting to leave "as-is"
a GUI that lets you:
1. Select the sound driver you are currently using (ALSA, OSS, Pulseaudio) from a drop-down list
2. Various system-wide options for the driver would be shown below:
You can change the audio buffer using a slider (or numerical value in MB)
You can set-up multiple audio outputs (if you have more than one audio out port that you want to use)
You can set up 2,3.1,4,5.1, and 7.1 surround sound by clicking on a button in the GUI, which brings you to a step-by-step configuration (next, previous buttons included)
it would also include a test page towards the end of the configuration that sends sound through each speaker, to make sure they are all working.
Solution #2:
Integrate it into System>Preferences>Sound
Add all the above settings into the existing sound configuration menu, possibly under a tab labeled "Advanced".
Add all the above settings into the existing sound configuration menu, possibly under a tab labeled "Advanced".
Software independent song rating
Written by brx75 the 21 Jan 09 at 08:41.
New
Make a way to have the rating of songs independent from the software being used.
Case 1: I'm hearing a song with Rhythmbox and marking it 4 start. When I open Banshee or Songbird I would have the same song rated 4 start without rating it again.
Case 2: I'm hearing a song from a removable device, I mark that song 4 star. I unplug the device, then plug in again (on the same or other computer). I would like to have the song still marked with 4 star and the "play count" not reset.
Note that these cases should work "just for me", not for other users of the same music files (User dependant rating).
Solution #1:
Rate songs rather than files
Written by
brx75 the 21 Jan 09 at 08:41.
The solution should be to have a portable way to rate songs and not files. Right now most of the software stores rating into an internal DB and the primary key for that DB is the location or full path of the music file.
A portable rating system should bind the rating with the song and the user.
Even the "play count", "last played" and "skip count" properties should be "song properties" rather than "file properties".
The song can be characterized in a loose way by values like "Title", "Author" or in a strict way by adding more criteria like "Album" or "Version".
The solution should be to have a portable way to rate songs and not files. Right now most of the software stores rating into an internal DB and the primary key for that DB is the location or full path of the music file.
A portable rating system should bind the rating with the song and the user.
Even the "play count", "last played" and "skip count" properties should be "song properties" rather than "file properties".
The song can be characterized in a loose way by values like "Title", "Author" or in a strict way by adding more criteria like "Album" or "Version".
Solution #2:
Use Filesystem Extended Attributes
By storing ratings using extended attributes on the filesystem, all players can read the ratings (with a patch), they can be backed up locally, and also probably per-user too.
Finally, they wont persist if you distribute the files over the internet, or non-local drives (as this generally strips the extended attributes), or modify the ID3 tags and hence the MD5 checksum of the file (ie, they don't break bittorrent).
When the ratings get sent to a portable device, the ratings can get added to the files via their compatible rating system (either ID3, or however they do it), and possibly they could add a file path so that the ratings can be resynced back into extended attributes.
Everyone wins.. People get cross software compatible, MD5 checksums don't change, ratings don't get lost when backing up files, but they will be lost if upload the music to the internet (which is ideal, as other people don't want your ratings).
By storing ratings using extended attributes on the filesystem, all players can read the ratings (with a patch), they can be backed up locally, and also probably per-user too.
Finally, they wont persist if you distribute the files over the internet, or non-local drives (as this generally strips the extended attributes), or modify the ID3 tags and hence the MD5 checksum of the file (ie, they don't break bittorrent).
When the ratings get sent to a portable device, the ratings can get added to the files via their compatible rating system (either ID3, or however they do it), and possibly they could add a file path so that the ratings can be resynced back into extended attributes.
Everyone wins.. People get cross software compatible, MD5 checksums don't change, ratings don't get lost when backing up files, but they will be lost if upload the music to the internet (which is ideal, as other people don't want your ratings).
Solution #3:
Use Nepomuk
Written by
Warbo the 21 Jan 09 at 22:54.
Nepomuk is a generic desktop database which can store any information about anything. It can keep track of files using a XESAM-capable search engine (eg. Strigi, Tracker, Beagle) and is accessible over DBus (ie. from any application in any programming language). It's already being used by Amarok and other parts of KDE (but is not KDE-specific at all, it's actually an EU-funded initiative across many areas).
Nepomuk uses RDF at its core, which can be used to serialise bits of the database into a file, which can be uploaded somewhere (imagine an ultra last.fm :P )
Nepomuk is a generic desktop database which can store any information about anything. It can keep track of files using a XESAM-capable search engine (eg. Strigi, Tracker, Beagle) and is accessible over DBus (ie. from any application in any programming language). It's already being used by Amarok and other parts of KDE (but is not KDE-specific at all, it's actually an EU-funded initiative across many areas).
Nepomuk uses RDF at its core, which can be used to serialise bits of the database into a file, which can be uploaded somewhere (imagine an ultra last.fm :P )
Solution #4:
Use Musicbrainz collections and rating
Written by
brx75 the 2 Mar 09 at 09:50.
A cross-platform solution could be to use musicbrainz. In Musicbrainz a registered user can mark a song or album as part of his own collection and rate songs, albums and artists.
A cross-platform solution could be to use musicbrainz. In Musicbrainz a registered user can mark a song or album as part of his own collection and rate songs, albums and artists.
Simplify the text of the "Now Playing" notification in Banshee
Written by zach4618 the 22 Oct 09 at 07:27.
New
When a new song starts playing in Banshee, a notification pops up to tell you the name of the new song/artist. The top line tells you that the song is "Now Playing" however this is redundant, since it is pretty obvious that a new song has started. My suggestion is to delete the top line and bold the song title instead. Rhythmbox notifications already appear this way.
Ideas for Improvements in Banshee
Written by Rodrigo the 26 Jul 09 at 23:50.
New
Banshee is quite good but some ideas could make it even better, lets write a few, and let the developers know we like what they do but we want it to be better.
Solution #1:
Play "Top Tracks" if they are in your library
Written by
Rodrigo the 26 Jul 09 at 23:50.
When you play a song in your library, in the bottom you see the "top tracks" of that group. If you click on one, you will go to last.fm to see the track.
My idea is, if you have it, it should play.
look at the screenshot:
From
ubuntu
When you play a song in your library, in the bottom you see the "top tracks" of that group. If you click on one, you will go to last.fm to see the track.
My idea is, if you have it, it should play.
look at the screenshot:
<table style="width:auto;"><tr><td><a href="http://picasaweb.google.com/lh/photo/xl4mGU_i341C6J9FwgRBhA?feat=embedwebsite"><img src="http://lh4.ggpht.com/_nve8T1z0v-4/SnWOTU3t71I/AAAAAAAAAfw/Qf7RLCubKgY/s400/banshee.jpg" /></a></td></tr><tr><td style="font-family:arial,sans-serif; font-size:11px; text-align:right">From <a href="http://picasaweb.google.com/rodrigodonado/Ubuntu?feat=embedwebsite">ubuntu</a></td></tr></table>
Solution #2:
Notify me I have the track in "Top Tracks" if I have them in the library
Written by
Rodrigo the 26 Jul 09 at 23:51.
Sort of the idea #1 but it tells you you have the song, maybe with an arrow like the "play arrow" so you know you have the song, and you can play it.
(As in the above screenshot)
Sort of the idea #1 but it tells you you have the song, maybe with an arrow like the "play arrow" so you know you have the song, and you can play it.
(As in the above screenshot)
Solution #3:
Add a CD cover "manually"
Written by
Rodrigo the 26 Jul 09 at 23:56.
Right now there is no way to add a CD cover to a track, and sometime the engine doesn't find it, or finds the "wrong" one.
It could be useful to add manually.
Right now there is no way to add a CD cover to a track, and sometime the engine doesn't find it, or finds the "wrong" one.
It could be useful to add manually.
Solution #4:
Modern notifications support
Written by
gotham48 the 27 Jul 09 at 14:50.
Make banshee supporting new ubuntu notification system.
Make banshee supporting new ubuntu notification system.
Solution #5:
Add the functionality of "playing it" if you have it
Written by
Rodrigo the 2 Aug 09 at 17:16.
A different approach to solution #1 and #2.
In my mock up, I put a green dot, maybe pressing the dot will play the song, while pressing on the name will send you to the last.fm web, just as it did before.
From
ubuntu
A different approach to solution #1 and #2.
In my mock up, I put a green dot, maybe pressing the dot will play the song, while pressing on the name will send you to the last.fm web, just as it did before.
<table style="width:auto;"><tr><td><a href="http://picasaweb.google.com/lh/photo/TOTA-zUTmcEy1PIfRAW1yQ?feat=embedwebsite"><img src="http://lh4.ggpht.com/_nve8T1z0v-4/SnXJwthwLwI/AAAAAAAAAf0/kAB4z9hAiJA/s800/banshee_1.jpg" /></a></td></tr><tr><td style="font-family:arial,sans-serif; font-size:11px; text-align:right">From <a href="http://picasaweb.google.com/rodrigodonado/Ubuntu?feat=embedwebsite">ubuntu</a></td></tr></table>
Solution #6:
Play the Song or add it to the Play Queue
I like the idea very much to play the local file but I would prefer dragging it to the play queue.
Additionally I could think of making whole playlists out of these sugestions like the Mirage Automatic Playlist Generator does. Also dragging it onto Mirage should work.
I like the idea very much to play the local file but I would prefer dragging it to the play queue.
Additionally I could think of making whole playlists out of these sugestions like the Mirage Automatic Playlist Generator does. Also dragging it onto Mirage should work.
Solution #7:
Audiobook Support
I would like to see support for audiobooks.
Just add an Audiobook Library.
Add two checkboxes to the properties
- Music
- Audiobook
Benefits:
- Those marked as Audiobook don't show up in music.
- When playing random files Audiobooks would be skipped.
- Abillity to copy them to iPod's Audiobook category.
I would like to see support for audiobooks.
Just add an Audiobook Library.
Add two checkboxes to the properties
- Music
- Audiobook
Benefits:
- Those marked as Audiobook don't show up in music.
- When playing random files Audiobooks would be skipped.
- Abillity to copy them to iPod's Audiobook category.
Solution #8:
Fullscreen Mode: Click on Time Progress Bar
When clicking on the time progress bar it should skip to this position not only moving the slider.
When clicking on the time progress bar it should skip to this position not only moving the slider.
Solution #9:
auto-tag
like in Winamp and TrackID by Sony Ericsson
like in Winamp and TrackID by Sony Ericsson
Solution #10:
Multi Track ID3 Editing
for interpret, album, genre,...
for interpret, album, genre,...
Solution #11:
maintain track order in playlists
under all circumstances.
under all circumstances.