Ubuntu QA:
BlogBrainstormPackage status
Log in
Ubuntu QA
The Ubuntu community has contributed 21949 ideas, 134905 comments, 2614500 votes
Idea sandbox Idea sandbox
Popular ideas Popular ideas
Ideas in development Ideas in development
Implemented ideas Implemented ideas

Popular ideas Here are the most popular ideas ever about Ubuntu.

Provide a simple interface for labeling partitions and external drives   forum
Written by descentspb the 3 May 08 at 13:18. Related project: Nautilus. New
This becomes especially useful with Hardy, which gives unrecognizable names to the unnamed partitions like "100 GB media" etc.
2703
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Easy and quick label in nautilus
Written by descentspb the 3 May 08 at 13:18.
For example right-click on the partition and bring up it's options, where you can change the label.

See the 8 comments or propose a solution >>

Graphical Interface to format Pen Drives an other Hot Plug devices  
Written by kernel_script the 3 Mar 08 at 13:29. Global category: Accessibility. New
I think Ubuntu needs a proper, pretty, functional, simple and friendly Graphical Interface to format Pen Drives and other Hot Plug devices. Because gParted and others do it really good but are generics, a lay person new on Linux or a lay person newly arrived from Windows™ can do serious data loss if he/she choose the wrong device on the partition table for example. And it only format, don't have any special feature to Pen Drives and other Hot Plugs. A Specific GUI (Graphical User Interface) only to Pen Drives and other Hot Plugs like Cellphones and MP3™ players would be so a great feature and help. With unique features like pass and covert videos - using existing codecs like mencode - to MP4™ players for example.
I think it is easy, just create some Glade, Gambas2 or Gazpacho + GTK, cause the features are already there, ready to become together. Like i said, a GUI that links directly to USB or Bluetooth on the System and identify only these devices, use already existing codecs, and already existing functions/commands like mkfs, lsusb and othes, and pop up it all friendly to the user, to let he/she choose safely what he/she want to do.

Edit: +add christopher_lees suggestion - "Right-click on the device and choose "Format Drive...", give it a name, give it a filesystem, and click Format. An absolute necessity."
kernel_script - Just add a gksu on that action and would be perfect.

Examples:

=Hot Plug Devices Config= (HPDC)

"That tool allow you to easy manage all your Hot Plug Devices like Pen Drives, Cellphones, MP3™ players, MP4™ players, Bluetooth Cellphones and others. You can easily and safely format these devices, convert you favorite videos and music for you MP3™ and MP4™ players, and, rip your CDs direct to these Devices"

And some example of tools that could be used:

mencoder, ffmpeg, some code fork from SoundConverter and Sound Juicer, or ,just click on the option on HPDC and call them, mount and umount options specifically for these devices and format options for these specific devices. (like just put some direct paths like mount or umount /media/sda etc)

[....]
960
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Include GNOME Format by default on Ubuntu; Show option to format on right-click
Written by kernel_script the 3 Mar 08 at 13:29.
Here my Mockup Screenshots:

ubuntu_device_formatter_mockup_by_kernel-script

ubuntu_device_formatter_mockup_by_kernel-script_#2

Would be awesome if we could launch it with a right-click upon a device icon.

- Homepage: http://home.in.tum.de/~kanis/html-data/gnome-format/
- Launchpad: https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+bug/316908
- Ubuntu Packages: http://packages.ubuntu.com/jaunty/gnome-format

ziroday solution suggestion:
"The gnome-format application (http://home.in.tum.de/~kanis/html-data/gnome-format/) appears to do what you want. Its currently still very early in development and could use some help. You can read the Phoronix review about it at http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=gnome_format&num=2"

GNOME Format is available on Ubuntu 9.04 latest Alphas and for Ubuntu 8.10 on GetDeb - http://www.getdeb.net/app/Gnome+Format

See the 16 comments or propose a solution >>

Easy file sharing between local users  
Ubuntu

In :  
Priority : Undefined
Definition : Discussion (Needs guidance)
Implementation : Not started
Assignee :
spec
Written by kamil.paral the 8 Mar 08 at 21:20. Global category: Accessibility. New
Currently there is no way to easily share files between multiple local users. I am talking about full read-write access to particular folder, eg. music folder.

Example: Alice and Bob uses the same computer. Alice has read access to Bob's home folder. Bob has read access to Alice's home folder. They want to fully share (read/write) their music. So they should ideally create /home/music folder, put all the music there and use it. Everything Bob puts into there, Alice should be able to read and remove, and vice versa. This is currently impossible in Ubuntu. Bob has to manually fix permissions every time Alice wants to delete something Bob's (Bob creates /home/music/Britney, but Alice can't delete /home/music/Britney/song1.mp3).

I have discussed this issue with several linux gurus and there is currently no easy nor difficult way to achieve this in Linux on the same (ext3) partition. With every proposed solution I can give you counterexample (group permissions, ACLs, local Samba, local NFS, etc - there is always problem when moving files). There would have to be created utility to set shared folders and some daemon would have to monitor changes and modify permissions.

Currently the easiest solution known for me is to share files on separate (ironically) NTFS partition, because when mounting NTFS you can force user/group/permissions on file access. What a shame, we use Microsoft technologies just to share files between Ubuntu users.

This problem is quite serious, give it a thought or two. Everyone who is not using Ubuntu computer alone and wants to share music/films/etc between multiple users knows what I am talking about.

//New info:
Atany has proposed in the comment that BindFS project can be used to achieve this functinality:
http://code.google.com/p/bindfs/
I have tried it and it works very well. Developers which would like to implement this idea should have a look on BindFS, it's very promising tool, it could provide all necessary background for this.

Developer comments
The proposed inotify/chmod hack in https://wiki.ubuntu.com/LocalFileShare would probably work to some degree, but I think it is subject to race conditions, and also not very flexible.

A slightly better solution would IMHO be to provide the shared directory through FUSE; then we can impose dynamic size limitations (at most use 2/3 of the available space in /home, etc.), fine-grained dynamic permissions, and avoid a lot of inotifying and permission race conditions.

Once this is solved and provided by default, we should reconsider "#6106: Make so other people cant access your home directory", which we didn't do yet in order for people to be able to share files r/o.
948
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #3916
Written by kamil.paral the 8 Mar 08 at 21:20.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #3916 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!
-9
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: No reinventing the wheel.
Written by eduardoassis the 19 Mar 09 at 14:41.
Just make NFS easier to use with a GUI integrated in Nautilus and Dolphin, with a easy way to choose who can or cannot access it.
5
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Use giver
Written by pegasus0378 the 20 Jun 09 at 12:40.
Giver can do the job.
6
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: Use bindfs
Written by bcelary the 8 Nov 09 at 22:46.
The solution has been already proposed, but was not added to solutions list.

Using bindfs works for me and is a possible solution.

See the 48 comments or propose a solution >>

People forget to empty their trash and get problems with space  
Written by sucotronic the 18 Feb 09 at 17:00. Global category: Accessibility. New
I've observed in my job that most of the users forgets to empty their trashes regularly, and suddenly one day they start to have problems due space limitations, or they don't know where is used their hard drive space.
805
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Add a configurable reminder
Written by sucotronic the 18 Feb 09 at 17:00.
It would be useful to add a kind of reminders that prevents the users about their files in the trash or the occupation in the hard drive. And also it could be configured with an option under the System>Preferences menu.




-477
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Clean trash automatically
Written by snizovtsev the 18 Feb 09 at 17:43.
Add the "Trash size" option (percent or absolute value) and automatically clean oldest files from the trash to fit this limit.
-378
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Compress old files
Written by vlo the 19 Feb 09 at 20:05.
The operating system should silently compress some of the files. Perhaps this could be done when the system is not being used, or before shutdown.

The files that would be compressed would be the files that have been in the trash for a certain amount of time (configurable).
-336
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: Trash with maximum size
Written by blaxter the 19 Feb 09 at 23:41.
Like in solution #2, add a "Trash size" option but instead of automatically clean oldest files form the trash, just say "the trash is full, please clean it up" when the user try to send more files to it
171
votes
up equal down
Solution #5: Notification with "Delete now"-Button
Written by rakudave the 21 Feb 09 at 20:39.
Same as #1, but with a button to empty the trash directly from the notification-bubble
287
votes
up equal down
Solution #6: Don't put unnessecary distractions in the system!
Written by kapipi the 21 Feb 09 at 21:17.
This solution is a response to solution #1. Solution #1 is great, except that as a default the user should not be notified about the size of trash, unless space on the partition is getting critically low.

The rationale:

- We don't want to distract the user's attention unnecessarily
- We don't want to force or lure the user to empty his trash unnecessarily.
353
votes
up equal down
Solution #7: Low disk space notification instead of trash notification
Written by argon the 22 Feb 09 at 00:35.
The rationale of this problem is that sometimes people run out of disk space. So the notification should directly address this issue, and not just target the trash at an arbitary point, which will just lead to more annoying notifications.

Windows also does this when disk space is low...
773
votes
up equal down
Solution #8: Create a System Cleanup widget
Written by 311005901 the 22 Feb 09 at 15:59.
A notification alerts users when the system is running low on free space.


When clicked on, users can use a widget to remove unwanted files.


(Click to see full sized image)
-345
votes
up equal down
Solution #9: auto-remove when disk-space is low
Written by koenfloris the 25 Feb 09 at 14:00.
ubuntu begins to fragment when you've got not enough disk-space. lets say that the limit is about 20%.

when disk space is to full...
ubuntu should auto-remove unnecessary things to free it up. of course, it should ask the user the empty the trash, to prevent data-loss. but other cash-like things should get cleaned up.
173
votes
up equal down
Solution #10: Extend computer-janitor to support low disk space and trash notifications
Written by ziroday the 27 Feb 09 at 12:07.
computer-janitor (only in jaunty) is a small utility to clear up left over packages and left over files that have no use. It could easily be extended to support emptying the trash and notifying the user when disk space is low.
36
votes
up equal down
Solution #11: Use the desktop icon to provide information
Written by Menti the 7 Mar 09 at 12:23.
As proposed in idea #14699. Desktop icons in general are static and do not provide any useful information. Trashcan icon is slightly dinamic: it has an empty state and a full state. Let the icon change to show how much trash there is. There could be a (configurable, with a sane default) max limit to the trash size, and the desktop icon could show what percentage of that limit is already in use.

This way, we could have more information without actually adding anything to the current setup, no more clutter; only better use of an already existing and underused graphic element of the desktop.
-79
votes
up equal down
Solution #12: Put the trash icon on the desktop
Written by dubrict the 10 Mar 09 at 06:19.
The reason people forget is because by default, the trash icon is as tiny as can be and hiding in the corner. Placing it on the desktop instead puts it more directly in the user's conscious, reminding them to empty it while not being obtrusive or complex.

The "running low on free space" reminder is reasonable, because it would solve this problem while taking on another. There's no reason to add any complexity to the system beyond this.
-116
votes
up equal down
Solution #13: Empty Trash On system Shut down
Written by MOSAM the 10 Mar 09 at 20:06.
Have the system ask you if you want to empty the trash when shutting down the as it does when unmounting disk drives.
39
votes
up equal down
Solution #14: make gui to let the user decide
Written by linuxrules the 12 Mar 09 at 23:28.
settings dialog _ +/- X
=============================================================
put trash icon on desktop "on/off"

Empty Trash On system Shut down "on/off/ask/auto"

Use the desktop icon to provide information "on/off"

auto-remove when disk-space is low "on/off/ask/auto"

Notification with "Delete now"-Button "on/off"

Trash with maximum size & if to delete when size limit is exceeded "on -size-/off"

Compress old files "on/off/ask/auto"

Add a configurable reminder "on/off"
|advance..|
211
votes
up equal down
Solution #15: Beyond Icons
Written by trustno1uk the 16 Mar 09 at 20:02.
Icons that represent valuable information at first glance can really save you some time.

Some users don’t care about emptying their thrash and also use it as another folder at times, this will remind them to empty it.

trash

REF: http://www.kumailht.com/blog/linux/10-features-ubuntu-should-implement/
-4
votes
up equal down
Solution #16: Automatically delete after 30 days
Written by OrelEagle the 5 Dec 09 at 20:38.
I'm using a script to delete files permanently after 30 days spent in the trash:

find ~/.local/share/Trash/files -maxdepth 1 -ctime +30 -exec rm -r \;
find ~/.local/share/Trash/info -maxdepth 1 -ctime +30 -exec rm -r \;

This way the user doesn't have to worry about emptying the trash but still has a "second chance" in case a file was deleted by mistake.
1
votes
up equal down
Solution #17: Provide a suite of tools for the user to save/recover disk space
Written by yoda2031 the 28 Mar 11 at 17:26.
Computer Janitor already fulfils the requirement to recover disk space from files which are temporary/cached/etc.

Squashfs more-or-less fulfils the requirement to conserve space, but should be provided as an option on installation ("compress home directory" and "compress system directory" options)

A utility to automatically compress/remove components which have not been used for more than 30 days.

A utility which lists your installed applications in order of size and last used date. Allows the user to remove the bigger, unused packages.

A utility which allows you to "reorganise" your partitioning scheme.

Where applicable, these solutions should be accessible under an umbrella utility, possibly as an extension to the existing Disk Utility, or as a stand-alone utility.

See the 13 comments or propose a solution >>

Windows aren't raised on drag and drop init  
Written by dsargeant the 2 Mar 08 at 20:00. Global category: Accessibility. New
When I click on something to drag and drop (drag-n-drop) it e.g. in Nautilus, the window gains focus and is raised. If the destination of my drag (e.g. another nautilus window) is above the window it is lowered and obscured. This forces me to arrange my windows before starting a drag and drop so that my destination is still visible when the source window is raised. This could be fixed by windows not being raised until mouse release instead of mouse down. Ideally, though, there would be a special case where if drag and drop is initialized the window isn't raised until release, otherwise it is raised on click.
631
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #2567
Written by dsargeant the 2 Mar 08 at 20:00.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #2567 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!

See the 9 comments or propose a solution >>

Gnome-Panel: Do we really need to manually accomodate each item?  
Written by wolterh the 11 Mar 09 at 02:40. Related project: Gnome. New
The gnome-panel, an application which I really like because its ability to be customized and functionality, is sometimes painful to organize. And I say painful because when you want to move an item, or remove one, you have to unlock, move and maybe lock again, every item.
500
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Add a "gravity" feature.
Written by wolterh the 11 Mar 09 at 02:40.
I propose to give every item, on it's properties, an option to gravitate to one of either extremes of the panel. This way, when you remove an item the items will maintain their organization making your panels look clean without an effort.
549
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Give the Panel a global "Unlock" and "Lock" feature
Written by stevemot the 11 Mar 09 at 14:26.
The main reason that re-organizing the Panel is such a pain is that the user has to unlock each of the items on the Panel individually before they can be moved. This solution proposes to add a right-click context menu item to the Panel to unlock all of the objects in the Panel, allowing them to be dragged about at will. When finished, the user just selects a corresponding "Lock all" option. The advantage with this solution is that it should not require any changes to the many objects that can be added to the Panel, only to the Panel itself (it just needs to walk through its list of objects calling "unlock" on each one).
-189
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: Remove the "Lock To Panel" option
Written by kenden the 17 Mar 09 at 23:46.
What is the use of the "Lock To Panel" feature?

Locking a icon into place in the panel? To avoid it moving around?

But why would it move around?

Only because the user would move it!

And if the user wants to move it, why would she unlock it, move it and lock it back?

What's the point of having it locked?
The icons are not going to move by themselves!
84
votes
up equal down
Solution #5: Sticky panel
Written by axayg the 18 Mar 09 at 02:25.
Solution#2 is definitely great. However, this is the simplest to implement and is, at the face of it, a simple copy-paste from M$ Windows. We should do something better than that. eg.
Graviate to one of the sides or make the icon panel slightly sticky. That way when you want to move icons in/out, drag/drop anywhere else on the panel, it does not come off just like that. It makes some sound like "pluck" and is clearly shows that its coming out of a sticky panel. That way, a firm lock is not necessarily needed - a firm lock could be an add-on to enable/disable moving around of icons.
24
votes
up equal down
Solution #6: Visual splits in the panels.
Written by tchalvakspam the 19 Mar 09 at 16:16.
The problem is that the panel is a line, and it's hard to keep stuff organized on that line.

So: Allow the panel to be "broken" visually, whether by separators that are transparent or the converse, by allowing grouping the elements on the panel in groups and then letting the space in-between groups become transparent.

So instead of 1 long panel, you could visually split the panel into left and right, or left middle right, or other user-specified organizations.

The key here is that instead of looking like one long worm panel, it should essentially look like multiple sections, each appearing as an independent part of the user interface, even while the underlying system remains intact.
54
votes
up equal down
Solution #7: Allow slide-out panel "stacks".
Written by tchalvakspam the 19 Mar 09 at 16:28.
Another approach to allow better organization of the panel is to provide slide-out sections of panel that can contain multiple icons within them. Like a more robust version of the "Drawer" panel applet that integrates with the panel better. In essence, different sections of the panel could be clicked to slide out a larger section of panel space which would contain more icons, or could just slide out with a stack of the icons it contains themselves. So if you wanted to add links to a number of websites, you could add the drawer-stack and stick all the icons inside it, then when you wanted to launch one site or another, you would click the part of the drawer-stack, it would slide open to show all the icons inside it, and then you would launch the one you wanted.

One ideal implementation of this can be seen in the "stacks" of the dock in OSX Leopard and the "stack" applet of the Cairo-dock app for ubuntu.
-15
votes
up equal down
Solution #8: Allow icons to be organized in "frames"
Written by jyaan the 21 Mar 09 at 19:20.
One of the most basic elements of organization on computers is the frame. We use it in GTK+, and of course it has been used on web pages.

I propose that icons can be placed (at the user's option) in a rectangular area. This will not affect the visible appearance of the panel; it is only for organization. It should also allow empty space between icons.

This would allow groups of icons to be treated as a whole (although still movable within the frame, and able to be dragged in and out of the frame), and therefore each frame's contents will never end up mixed with each other.

Typically, I keep certain types of icons/applets together, and being able to drag several at the same time, and not losing their order (on screen resize, for example) would be great.

The user should be able to move the frame from the left edge just as we already do with the notification area and window list.

The problem with most of the solutions is that you'll still need to micro-manage your icons and move them one at a time. If I want to move my launcher icons from one side to the other, I'd like to just drag them as a group. Won't be a problem with Multi-monitor setups, either.
26
votes
up equal down
Solution #9: Move them holding alt
Written by kiersie the 31 Mar 09 at 22:10.
Just like the panels dont move without holding alt-button down since gnome 2.26 do also withe applet/icons
10
votes
up equal down
Solution #10: "Book Shelf" Approach
Written by MestreLion the 11 Jun 09 at 23:42.
This brainstorm has so many ideas because we are trying to address several issues in 1 solution: avoid icon micro-management, ordering icons, grouping icons, avoid accidental changes. A consistent, coherent way would be the "Bookshelf Approach":

- Special separators (SPLITERS) would now divide panel in SECTIONS

- Each section would have its own "gravity" or "orientation" - either left, right, center, or none (=just like today). Like Solution #1, but should be applied to a SECTION, not individual icons, so no need set individual icon properties (no micromanagement).

- Every icon within a section would automatically stack according to its section orientation. So if you delete an icon in the middle of a "left-oriented" section, all icons to the right of it would shift left. In a section with no orientation, icons wouldnt shift.

- To arrange the icons, solution #9 is perfect. No need of lock / unlock. A key combination like the proposed ALT+mouse drag would prevent accidental moving while clicking. You could drag icons to different sections as well.

- Besides ALT+drag for 1-item movement, CTRL+ALT+drag could be used to move all icons in a section (useful for re-arranging groups, as #18 suggests).*

- The Splitters could be moved this way too, to set the width of each section

- Right clicking ANY icon would allow to set its panel and section settings: simply add a "Panel > " and "Section > " item to their context menus. No need to hunt down a blank area of the panel anymore, no need to increase section width just to have a blank area to set its properties.

- Splitters would have 3 context menus added: "Panel >", "Left Section > ", "Right Section >".

- Besides the separators we have today, we could also have "SPACERS" to create invisible spaces between icons we want (like suggested in #8). If the user presses ALT while the mouse is over the panel, the spacers become visible (otherwise would be difficult to find and move them)

- If you delete a splitter, a popup would ask if the newly merged section would inherit the properties of the right or of the left section.

* The ALT and CTRL+ALT is just a suggestion, actual keys would be what gnome developers find most consistent with current interface.

Summing it up, no need of lock/unlock, no need to micromanage icons, no need to hunt blank areas to set up options. And, IMHO, highly friendly and intuitive while still fully customizable.
-1
votes
up equal down
Solution #11: Allow multiple selection
Written by panta1978 the 22 Jun 09 at 21:30.
Allow multiple icons selection, simply by clicking with the mouse's left button and selecting the desired area.
3
votes
up equal down
Solution #12: selection with [Alt] key which allows multi move/lock/unlock/remove
Written by xubaj the 26 Aug 09 at 22:31.
just like #11 but with an [Alt] key which prevents accidental rearrangment. by right-clicking the selected icons you can apply multiple preferences (lock/unlock/remove etc.) at once.
1
votes
up equal down
Solution #13: Option to automatic arrange Icons
Written by bliss the 20 Oct 10 at 06:54.
A new option in the (right click) panel menu to auto-arrange icons like the Mac OSX dock or the Windows quickstart.
3
votes
up equal down
Solution #14: No space between items unless spacer is used.
Written by James Haigh the 26 Oct 10 at 17:15.
In KDE items in panels are all next to each other, a spacer can be used to push them apart.

The spacer expands to use all space. So you can have some items on the left, spacer in the middle, and some items on the right.


Panel spacer

1
votes
up equal down
Solution #15: Group Items together
Written by antiGatesGuy the 6 Apr 11 at 14:08.
In Window$ Vista and 7, All open windows of a certain category are grouped together and there are controls so you can do something to the whole group. (Close group, maximize all, cascade, etc.)

See the 17 comments or propose a solution >>

Automatically start virtual keyboard or virtual mouse when one is not detected  
No information about this blueprint
Information is updated every 5 minutes.
Please wait till the next update.
spec
Written by gQuigs the 20 Mar 08 at 19:11. Global category: Accessibility. New
When I start the Ubuntu LiveCD and my keyboard or mouse isn't detected that is very annoying. We cannot expect people to know shortcut keys to start a mouse, or how to turn the on-screen keyboard on.
520
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: "No input" Recovery
Written by gQuigs the 20 Mar 08 at 19:11.
No Keyboard, but mouse: ask if user wants to start on-screen keyboard

No Mouse, but keyboard: ask if user wants to enable mousekeys (numlock keys as mouse), alert user of how to turn on and off


See the 16 comments or propose a solution >>

Allow file/folder-dragging with right Mouse-Button  
Written by Port_Null the 9 Mar 08 at 18:22. Global category: Accessibility. New
I'd like to see a right-click-and-drag option: you right-click an icon, and after dragging and releasing out pops a context menu with 'create link here', 'move here' and 'copy here'. It's very useful, and one of the few things I like about Windows XP that Ubuntu doesn't have.
463
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Auto-generated solution of idea #4003
Written by Port_Null the 9 Mar 08 at 18:22.
Ubuntu Brainstorm was updated in January 2009. Since the idea #4003 was submitted before this update, its rationale and solution are not separated. Please vote accordingly, and if you have the necessary rights, please separate the rationale from the solution. Thanks!
-62
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Enable Drag and Drop from Right Click
Written by trustno1uk the 11 May 09 at 21:01.
I have a laptop and it only has two buttons as do most laptops. The best solution to this is to enable drag and drop on the right mouse button that brings up a move/copy option amongst others or at the very least have a option where this can be enabled.
9
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Let it work as if you left-dragged while holding ALT
Written by leael the 27 Mar 09 at 23:31.
Title says it.

Maybe you keep the current behaviour, if the mouse wasnt moved far enough.
7
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: another additional feature
Written by comeOnecandy the 27 May 09 at 11:06.
if you click slowly now, nothing happens.
You could for example rename things that way..

See the 12 comments or propose a solution >>

Helping with art in Ubuntu is not accessible  
Written by baldurpet the 10 Apr 09 at 15:35. Related project: wiki.ubuntu.com. New
I'm an artist and I'd really like to help with some of the Ubuntu art projects, problem is I had to visit around 3 different sites clicking on some 8 different links to get there and then I had to subscribe to a mailing list
438
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: Make it easier to submit to Ubuntu
Written by baldurpet the 10 Apr 09 at 15:35.
I understand why a mailing list is important, but what if someone just wants to be issued (for a lack of a better word) commands? I suggest something that's easy to access, a to-do pile if you will.

1. You click "Get Involved" on the Ubuntu front page
2. You click "Design"
3. Then you should see a big button saying "Click here to see projects you can participate with"
4. When you click that button you'd see a table with something like "We need a new icon for the Pidgin Internet Manager" or "A new logo for Kubuntu", and next to it would be a "Submit your idea" button.
The ideas could appear underneath the problem so users can easily see what ideas people have submitted.

You can _still keep the old way_, but this way people that can't be bothered with subscribing to a mailing list can simply submit their pictures.
134
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: point 5. of Solution#1
Written by fred_t the 12 Apr 09 at 06:42.
It would be possible to vote for submitted proposals. Designing the "new Kubuntu logo" would be great, even better if you get a lot of votes. Many designers would see that as a good challenge or an excellent way to contribute to the movement. Most of all, the Ubuntu design would be influenced by users.
77
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Export/import
Written by Basem the 13 Apr 09 at 10:42.
Why not create an export button in the appearance window...A user will be able to create and customise a look. colour, icons, wallpaper, font etc...then he can extract it to a single tarball...other users who wish to use his look can import this tarball and further customise it...
This file can also include extras such as screensaver, transparency, etc...
-29
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: Export to gnome-look
Written by baldurpet the 13 Apr 09 at 13:19.
Why not combine solution #1 and #3 and let users export their look to the theme repository?

The user would simply need to make a custom theme, name it and then click "Submit/export to gnome-look". Then Ubuntu would ask the user for a username and password, and it would be up in no time. The only problem I see with this solution is that gnome-look might be flooded with themes that are either very ugly or themes where someone takes the Human-Clearlooks and implements some minor change (like only changing the colour slightly).
91
votes
up equal down
Solution #5: Constant Artwork Competition
Written by bagano the 19 Apr 09 at 18:59.
Why not have a site like this one, dedicated to the artwork and look/feel of ubuntu.

1. Allow anyone to submit artwork.
2. Allow them to specify a particular use for it, or leave it general.
3. Allow people to vote and comment on the artwork, just like this site.
4. Get Ubuntu developers to look at the most popular artwork, and consider it for ubuntu.
37
votes
up equal down
Solution #6: Use Launchpad
Written by itix the 20 Apr 09 at 13:39.
Launchpad works really great with translations (I know, I've been translating deluge to swedish there), why not use it for artwork as well...

See the 14 comments or propose a solution >>

Help the user understand when closing a window does not close the app  
Written by YannUbuntu the 9 Sep 10 at 10:58. Global category: Accessibility. Needs clarification
When closing a window, it is currently not obvious for the user to know if the app is still running in systray or not.



Developer comments
189
votes
up equal down
Solution #1: When an app goes in systray, temporary highlight its indicator
Written by YannUbuntu the 9 Sep 10 at 10:58.
When the window of the app is closed, its indicator in systray would temporarily (e.g. during 1 second) either :
- change its color
- or change its backgroud color
- or be animated
- ...

so that the user visually knows that the app has been minimized in systray.
388
votes
up equal down
Solution #2: Use same window animation as "Minimize" , but toward the indicator in systray
Written by YannUbuntu the 9 Sep 10 at 11:10.
When you minimize a window, there is an animation (zoom) that gives the feeling that the window is reduced toward the bottom of the screen until its final reduced location in the . This idea is to use the same zoom animation for reduction in systray !

Some applications already use this system for systray reduction : for example in Lucid, Empathy with Telepathy's PPA (ppa:telepathy/ppa) has its indicator in the Notification Zone, and uses this animation. Just try it !

-136
votes
up equal down
Solution #3: Display messages.
Written by Lachu the 12 Sep 10 at 08:38.
- Display information how many windows have application this window belongs to on mouse hover close button.
- Display messages, when window, which don't have focus lastly time disappears(message like "task is complete")
- Tray icon is yet another window
- Watch on x server connections (especially when user interact with window of this application) and show messages, when connection is closed.
-85
votes
up equal down
Solution #4: Use emule's technique: a button for closing, a button for the tray
Written by knocte the 15 Sep 10 at 20:10.
You can see an example of what I mean by seeing this image:

https://bugzillafiles.novell.org/attachment.cgi?id=389828

Of course, still the applications that add this button should add a warning message when the close button is pressed. But this way the user instantly sees there is an extra button that he wants to know about.

And this way it's easy to spot which applications have this functionality and which don't.

Furthermore, this idea could be combined with Solution#2 too to make the user experience even clearer.
-85
votes
up equal down
Solution #5: Use MSN Messenger's technique: solution #2 +display a notification
Written by Glaedr the 20 Sep 10 at 13:19.
Minimize the app to the tray and display a notification such as "The [appname] app is still running in the tray, right-click and select Quit to close it" or similar.
-40
votes
up equal down
Solution #6: Use a different button if closing the window will send the app to tray
Written by fallingleaf the 20 Sep 10 at 20:09.
Instead of the red X the button could be orange or something instead, or some other icon that indicates sending to tray.
-25
votes
up equal down
Solution #7: Make an system tray-program
Written by TooSmart the 4 Oct 10 at 01:05.
This program will give permissions to which apps should be killed and which ones should be in the system tray based on the user's preference.
-28
votes
up equal down
Solution #8: "Cannot be closed" in the taskbar
Written by UbuntuN00b the 7 Oct 10 at 15:55.
When the user want close the window, a message "cannot be close" appear in the taskbar, next to the application icon.
-15
votes
up equal down
Solution #9: Use Mac OS X's technique: closing a window never closes the application
Written by leggy the 3 Nov 10 at 04:03.
List applications in a panel or dock, instead of windows. Applications can be closed from that list.

Then:
* The close button on a window's title bar, control+W, or file->close, closes only the window.
* The close button on the applications list, control+Q, or file->quit closes the application every time.

The Gnome window list can already group windows by application, and when you right click on the group button there is an option to close all the windows. This could close the application explicitly instead.

Clicking the button for an application with no open windows should do something useful, like open a new document.

Unfortunately, this requires altering applications so they can be open with no windows. Several applications that already remain open with no windows must also be changed, so they don't put their (non-notification) icon in the notification area.

In the transition period, you could emulate leaving an application open when its last window is closed from the title bar button by leaving the it in the application list. Closing the fake application removes the list entry. Clicking it starts it again. This isn't ideal, since the emulation could not tell if the application quit because you closed the last document or or asked to quit.
11
votes
up equal down
Solution #10: Create guidelines for consistent behavior
Written by Otus the 9 Nov 10 at 11:29.
For example: Close button should always close the app; minimize may be used for "close to tray" behavior, but must be configurable. Also guide on defaults and the types of apps that should use this behavior.
1
votes
up equal down
Solution #11: Change color of the close button too + #2
Written by Klau3 the 8 Dec 10 at 22:15.
One way – by side of #2 – could be to change the close button color to blue or green. This would indicate that the program would not close when clicking on it (close == red icon, indicator to systray == blue or green).


PS: I was thinking about the described problem a while ago too :)
4
votes
up equal down
Solution #12: Different animations + Indicator
Written by chillyperson23 the 27 Dec 10 at 18:31.
Maybe, there should be an indicator and a different desktop effect for it. IE: Clicking the X button on an application that is closing will make it fade out. But clicking the X button on an application that is just going in the background will fade and zoom towards the indicator applet, and there will be a notification that says "*** is now running in the background" (Kinda like the notification for changing the volume) A notification like this makes things feel smoother and more refined, especially on a mobile OS. And this would work for a desktop system as well.

Another way to accomplish something like this is to have it so that clicking the X button closes the app, but clicking and holding it makes it run in the background. Along with the notification.

In both cases above, there should always be a place to see what apps are running. Currently, on a fresh install, you have to go to System>Administration>System Monitor> Processes tab to see open processes. That is simply too many clicks to see running tasks.

The solution to this is to put a menu item in the Session Indicator Applet that shows running tasks and processes. It should only show apps with a window, or that have been started by the User and not by logging in to reduce clutter.


EDIT: Also do like YannUbuntu said in solution 1 and make the indicator flash/glow.
2
votes
up equal down
Solution #13: Minimize-to-system-tray button in the "X close" button's place (option 3 in img
Written by Voltius the 6 Mar 11 at 09:08.
http://www.chrisnorstrom.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/featured-image.png

=== There are 2 different types of programs ===
Web browsers, email and chat windows, and Photoshop are made to be interacted with and closed when done. But programs like Steam, Skype, uTorrent, instant messenger clients, virus scanners, music players, and others are designed to not be interacted with frequently and instead just allowed to run in the background while you’re working on other things.

=== The Problem ===
Is that both of these types of programs, interactables & forgettables, both use the close “X” button to do two different things. Forgettables just want to run in the background and stay out of your way, but no one bothered to give them their own button to ‘minimize to system tray’ so they use the “X” close button, which is bad because it confuses users and is inconsistent.

Most users just click towards the big red button and assume it will close the window of the program and exit the program itself. They’re probably not going to spend too much time looking at what symbol the big red button has inside of it. Also, users have gotten use to thinking that the button on the outside means close and exit.

== The Solution ==
Keep the "X" close button but scoot it over and in its place put a 'minimize to systray' button. This way everyone's happy. Users by habit will still click on the end red button and minimize the program to systray which is what the developer indented for them to do. Other users can use the "X" close button to exit the program completely.
1
votes
up equal down
Solution #14: #1 + #2
Written by ZebaSz the 14 Mar 11 at 02:24.
Highlighting the indicator helps the user focus on the specific indicator, but might be confused with another app requiring atention.
Using an animation helps understand the app is effectively still running, but the user might have a hard time finding the exact indicator.
I think using a combination of both helps the user understand the app is running on the background, and exactly where to find it again.

See the 3 comments or propose a solution >>

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... Next >>